Opinion
America speaks Arabic
Moshe Elad
Published: 18.11.09, 11:55
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
39 Talkbacks for this article
1. wot came 1st?
oferdesade ,   israel   (11.18.09)
the declaration to expand gilo or the american warning against? who was the rectal orfice who decided that the US needed another slap in the face? does anybody out there realize that only in hebrew is the term dafka awarded that honorary status of being a legitimate word? in other places it is translated as "to spite", ie an agressive act. only in israel can a verbal argument remain one ("hold me back, i'll kill him..."); in other places, people often speak softly (without being accused of it being a sign of weakness), carry a big stick (sometimes as a warning)and often use it (especially when they've been slapped once too many times).
2. "Palestinian name"?!
Stan ,   Jerusalem   (11.18.09)
Actually, Mr. Elad, the entire world refers--and has always referred--to Jewish construction across the Green Line by the term "settlements." Only some in Israel, like yourself, refuse to acknowledge this. Palestinians, by the way, use a different term: colonies.
3. It is time WE refer to Har ha-Bait as such and not as the
Eitan ,   Qatzrin, Israel   (11.18.09)
Temple Mount!!! It is time WE refer to our homeland as Eretz Israel and not Land of Israel or Palestine. It is time WE learn more about the history of our Jewish civilization, its most important language, Hebrew, and the depth to which historically we have maintained our affinity to our people, to our country and to the learning of texts produced by our people for nearly 4,000 years. Shall we commit ourselves to the above?
4. By the same standard every US city is a settlement
Truth Hertz ,   UK   (11.18.09)
But what is different in Israel is that the 'settlements' are often named after their real original names from before the Islamic occupation of the land of Israel. eg Beit El
5. Salam Aleikum
(11.18.09)
Every tree eventually will get old make peace now USA won't be forever...
6. I am with you, Eitan.
Ronit ,   Usha, Israel   (11.18.09)
7. Refuse to talk with the arabs of the U.S.
jason white ,   afula,israel   (11.18.09)
government till they call all places in the Jewish capitol of Yerushalim by the proper Hebrew only names. Let mitchell tell hussein and hitlery clinton to refer to Yerushalim as the total Jewish capitol of the Jewish state of Israel! Nothing to do with illegal arab trespassers on our Zionist holy land.
8. Israel IS a banana republic
m   (11.18.09)
Get some backbone and start behaving like you own the country, not America or the world. The "poritz' decreed, gosh, every word he says we get tied into a knot.
9. Agree with #8.
rebecca ,   Modiin   (11.18.09)
The only way to deal with the Obama administration is to work with him when it suits us and to quietly get on with doing what we think is necessary and let them rant and rave on the side. The only way they will treat us as a nation is if we behave as one. And we are a successful nation. We have proved this in the 60 years of our life. Lets keep going forward.
10. The old #9 bus provides a lesson in contiguity
Raymond in DC ,   Washington, USA   (11.18.09)
In 1971 I lived in the old student barracks on Mount Scopus, though studying on the Givat Ram campus. Most don't know, or have forgotten, that Mount Scopus was the original site of the Hebrew University. (It's also the site of the ancient Jewish cemeteries overlooking the Old City.) But after the the War of Independence, Mt. Scopus became an island, held by Israel but separated from West Jerusalem by land held by Jordan, and linked to West Jerusalem only by a secret tunnel. Hebrew U thus had no choice but to relocate. After 1967, Scopus was linked to the rest of the city by new roads and that #9 bus that passed through (wait for it) the new neighborhoods of Ramat Eshkol and French Hill. Hebrew U was then able to expand the Scopus campus. If Mitchell expects Israel ever to give up those neighborhoods, returning Scopus back to "island" status, he really has hummus for brains.
11. #4
Ilana   (11.18.09)
I am with you
12. My deepest sympathies to the people surprised by this
Nick Sporek ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (11.18.09)
especially all the Jews that voted for Obama.
13. Send Mitchell packing & tell America to go to hell.
Wise Saba ,   Netivot   (11.18.09)
14. :: Cut off all aid to Israel
Matty Groves ,   Fairport   (11.18.09)
It is time for America to cut off all financial aid to Israel. After all what is the point in America paying for a puppet state if that state won't follow orders. It is also time for Obama to state quite categorically that America will never recognize Jerusalem as Israel's capital as long as Israel continues to build illegal settlements (like Gilo) on Palestinian land. The Arabs didn't drive a wedge between America and Israel; Israel managed to do this all by itself. It is time Israel stops blaming everyone else for its own failures. If Israel wants to be an outcast then so be it, likes treat Israel as such.
15. Palestine is also Israel
eddie ,   london UK   (11.18.09)
These lands called palestine are Israelite lands. Te invaders are the arabs, who came from elsewhere. "west bank, east Jerusalme" are meaningless. The Torah is what defines the land, and it is the Israelite nation who a) are related to in the Torah, and b) owners of this land. Arabs have plenty of land in Arabia, and no shortage of states.
16. Matti Groves, I don't see you advocate to cut aid to Arabs.
AK   (11.18.09)
Arab terrorists murder Americans abroad and at home; Jews don't. and yet you don't advocate cutting aid to the Arabs (a/k/a as 'Palestinians' ) even though one of their own just murdered 14 and wounded dozens of Americans. What is it with you and the Jews? You're kkk or something?
17. #5, No one is offering Israel peace, only 'peace', get it?
Jake   (11.18.09)
18. #14 Matty - cut off aid
Thomas ,   USA   (11.18.09)
Reminder to all of your kind of mindless radicals who are dwelling on Jewish forums 24/7 that your GOD, the Messiah, Hussein O. is below 50% approval by the American people so he can only pound sand and you too. The congress supported Israel by 400+ votes so please go to the desert and howl at you moon-god, pray to Allah and your Islamofascist-Marxist coterie. Inshallah, you fool.
19. Ynet, stop f***ing censoring my posts, already
Jake   (11.18.09)
You censor my posts, then you had better censor all the anti-Israel, anti-Zionist, and anti-Jewish posts, to whom I am responding with facts, not with opinions or insults. If not, then you, like Haaretz, are guilty of bias and should bear the mark of Cain.
20. #14, Gilo is not on Palestinian land
Jake   (11.18.09)
There is no law in the world, as in a legally binding law and not just a kangaroo court ruling or a UN vote by the automatic majority, that states that Gilo is Palestinian land. It is built on state land, with no recognized sovereign, in Israeli-administered territory. Legally, Israel has exactly the same rights in that territory as India has in Indian-administered Kashmir, and Pakistan in Pakistan-administered-Kashmir, both of which 'occupy territory' with no recognized sovereign and over which there is a dispute.
21. To Eitan #3
Jake   (11.18.09)
It would be good progress if the world were to refer to the Temple Mount as Temple Mount, and not as 'Haram al-Sharif'.
22. Matty Groves the US outlawed buying and selling of people
Gee ,   Zikron Yaakov   (11.18.09)
You might want to look up that law sometime. Aid does not give anybody the right to dictate to us.
23. :: AK - #16
Matty Groves ,   Fairport   (11.18.09)
That is correct, the 'Arabs' are not impeding the peace process like Israel. < Arab terrorists murder Americans abroad and at home; Jews don't.> Well I assume you have never heard of 'Murder Incorporated' (Jewish-American organized crime). Firstly 13 were killed, not 14. Secondly Hasan was 'one of us', he was an America Muslim, whose Palestinian parents emigrated to America from the West Bank (no doubt to escape Israeli occupation and oppression), to date there has been no proof that Hasan was in anyway affiliated with any 'terrorist group'. < You're kkk or something?> Of course I'm not. If you recall you will have never seen me at any clan meetings.
24. :: Thomas - #18
Matty Groves ,   Fairport   (11.18.09)
If you are going to be childish and insulting don't expect much of a reply. Obama's approval ratings have no impact on matters, he is still the man in charge. Secondly what goes around comes around. Don't expect Israel to get the usual blank check/blind support anytime soon.
25. # 3 History of Jewish civilization
Carmen ,   NYC   (11.19.09)
you may want to read up a bit http://www.worldagesarchive.com/Reference_Links/False_Testament_(Harpers).htm
26. Hmmm
thundercloudokc ,   Oklahoma City USA   (11.19.09)
I really don't care what the Israeli's do or do not do, but a growing majority of my people object to our nation being tied to a country that obviously does not want to have peace with its neighbors. The USA was once at war with the UK, Mexico, Spain, Germany, Italy and Japan. Somehow we managed to find peace. Why can't Israel find it in its heart to try to do the same?
27. ISRAEL you have the backing of congress, BUT the more you
Jae ,   Lynn US   (11.19.09)
act like 2nd class country in servitude to the worlds opinions to you, and specifically Obamas, the less congress will stick itys neck out for you. no one not even congress respects a gelatinous Israeli government that doesnt stand up for itself. people like winners not losers. Be men, not slaves. "Today we are enslaved, tomorrow may we be free men"
28. 26 thundercloud. Dont believe everything the white man tells
jae ,   Lynn US   (11.19.09)
you.... Israel has been the homeland of the Jewish people for 4000 years. we are not like the white man that came and occupied native american land. we ARE the natives going 4000 years back. the arabs have 23 countries, the jews have their 1, the only one that is theirs and that they want.
29. yes it is
majd ,   jerusalem   (11.19.09)
salam aleekom but where is waaleekom elsalam ???????????????
30. to 8
fakhr ,   jerusalem   (11.19.09)
one israili said it is falafel republic ... i think he was right
Next talkbacks
Back to article