News
Ultra-Orthodox Jews make rare visit to Gaza
Associated Press
Published: 01.01.10, 15:38
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
50 Talkbacks for this article
31. Neturei Karta is also Zionist, but Passive Zionists
Tayfun_Turkey ,   Istanbul   (01.01.10)
Rather than they are in true path of Mosses IMO, any Jewish religious sect who denies 10 commandements or takes some of them defunct and unapplicable is not in the path of Moses, Neturei Karta also denies or find unapplicable a commandement. which is crucial to distinguish zionism from true path of old Jewry Whatever, it is your religiou take care.
32. Some explanations and questions for Mahmoud (# 28)
flyingdoc57 ,   Florida, U.S.A.   (01.01.10)
"isn,t killing is a contradictory to the holy!!!commandment that says thou shall not kill?!so why the masahia in waiting plans to "machine gun kelly" the human race,why can,t he slap us on the hand , and then we all sing halaujha lyrics,why do religious people always pray for great floods and plaques and not for humanism?" [mahmoud] While "Thou shalt not murder" is one of the 10 commandments, there are plenty of references in the bible which allow (even obligate) Jews to kill in self-defense. Notice that there is no Jewish commandment which reads "Thou shalt allow yourself to be killed by anyone seeking to kill you": But, I digress. The point made regarding Neturei Karta (i.e. Moshiach coming and killing all the non-Jews so that Israel can be given back to the Jews) is limited to that off-the-wall sect which numbers just several hundred out of a world population of some 7.5 million Jews. They are, indeed, insignificant to anyone except the media and Hamas. And now, my question to you, my Muslim friend. To use some of your words in analogy, why do your people not simply "slap us on the hand, and then we all sing Hallelujah" rather than use all four corners of the world to engage in Jihad consisting of "Allah Hu'achbar.....Ka'Boooooom!!!!!!"? Our (Jewish) nutjobs number in hundreds, whereas your Muslim nutjobs number in the millions. Furthermore, our nutjobs (e.g. Neturei Karta) don't kill or hurt anyone, whereas your nutjobs chop people's heads/limbs off, throw people off of roofs, and yell "We love death more than you love life". See the difference? Just exactly what is with your people, Mahmoud?
33. We also believe that our Messiah Jesus and
Yaakov Sullivan ,   NYC   (01.01.10)
his follower Muhammed PBUH wikk both rule the world from Al Quds.
34. The twins; naturei carta / islam
Jojo ,   PRT WASH NY   (01.01.10)
naturei karta, the croquemort of modern judaism, the guardians of the city who, according to their beliefs and islam's, feel that Jerusalem should have remained the " pigsty " that it was 70 years ago. They should have waited for the messiah or some other divine sanitation angels to do the clean-up. Then, the city was not part of the " green zone ", but according to modern scriptures i.e.,a dictionary, it was a bonified SLUM. For better or for worse, I am a free thinker, but I will have to thank the almighty for helping in making the city what it is today, without the grotesque sombrero men in black "helping hand"
35. Trade them for Gilad Shalit
George Steinbrenner ,   NY, USA   (01.02.10)
I'd trade them for Gilad Shalit, with cash considerations, and a couple draft picks thrown in.
36. you are disgusting and a disgrace to all Jews
outraged in Israel ,   Tel Aviv, Israel   (01.02.10)
You should be thrown out of Israel and put on a listed banning them re-entry. If you are citizens your citizenship stripped from you. Go live in Iran. If you don't believe in the existence of Israel then don't live here and take our money and all the benefits. You contribute NOTHING. Don't visit here. Don't live here. WE DON'T WANT YOU!!!
37. #25 Marco el puerco and jew hater thinks he is an expert on
rachel ,   usa   (01.02.10)
judaism
38. These parasites should move to ...
Pullo ,   Rome   (01.02.10)
Iran and Gaza and wait there for their Messiah who undoubtedly will buy them first class airplane tickets to move back to Israel when he arrives. They are an embarrassment to the rest of the Jews in the world.
39. Neturei Karta are arabs in Jewish clothing, nothing more.
Bunnie Meyer ,   Los Angeles, CA USA   (01.02.10)
40. NK
Bill   (01.02.10)
Of course the "tragedy" is not in the name of Judaism. It's in the name of the failed Pan Arab state.
41. Mahmoud in USA (#28)
Ginette Golden ,   Toronto, Canada   (01.02.10)
You seem like a decent person and I enjoy reading your postings. So when you ask: "Why do religious people always pray for great floods and plaques and not for humanism?" I feel compelled to educate you a little. Very simple my humanitarian friend, it's because most Arab countries and People abroad only wish for the destruction of Israel and the Jews, that's why we think and feel the way we do. No I am not orthodox but rather your regular "run of the mill Jew" that happens to keep a kosher home and believe in the coming of the Messiah who will help us get rid of all the undesirables, mainly the anti-Israel and anti-Jews (I don't say anti-Semite on purpose because Arabs are not only our cousins but are Semite People also). And trust me when I say to you that Jews are much more humans than Arabs living in neighboring countries. We welcome and allow them to receive treatment in Israeli hospitals (the reverse is unheard of in countries like Jordan, Libya, Egypt, etc…); also we do not use places of worship and hospitals to store arsenal or hide behind (sometimes willing) women and children during battle. There is nothing human about the look in the eyes of a Palestinian. I saw a documentary of Hamas kids in training (some as young as 7) with only one goal in their twisted mind is to pour Jewish blood on the streets and that my friend is the true face of terror. Shalom/Salam!
42. #35
Dorothy Friend ,   Tel Aviv   (01.02.10)
Totally. If they want to be there so much, let them stay.
43. please keep them there
Avi ,   Israel   (01.02.10)
Talk about taking out the garbage !
44. Real Jews/Non Zionist .. Bless them
RJBH ,   Methil   (01.02.10)
45. No. 38 Pullo
NYC Girl   (01.02.10)
The good news is that they don't come from Israel. These putrid fanatics come from the USA and Canada, so the Israelis don't even have to deal with them.
46. Neture Shikra
J.K. ,   Brooklyn USA   (01.02.10)
Do the Neture Shikra (false Guardians) have palestinian partners in Gaza, who share their ideology,concerning the establishment of a palestinian state ?.
47. 13
Rosie   (01.02.10)
Me too.
48. 29
Rosie   (01.02.10)
They are NOT from Israel. They are from US and Canada.
49. # 41 Ginette Golden
J.K. ,   Brookllyn USA   (01.02.10)
Ginnete ! you are wrong,theArabs are not our cousins,the Arabs are not decendants of Abraham and Yishmael,because ,at the time of Abraham and Yishmael,the Arabian peninsula was already inhabited with Arabs,so,how can a people predate their founding fathers ?,it is true, Arabic,Hebrew,and Aramaic are sister languages,and have 1 origin,going back 20-30 000 years,the teory that Arabs are decendants of Abraham and Yishmael has no historic base.
50. Antisemites that's what they are
Rose ,   NY   (12.25.18)
These people are Holocaust deniers who have no shame. They hate Jews and lm surprised they are trying to portray a picture of loving Palestinians. All I know is that they're are just haters.
Previous talkbacks
Back to article