Travel
Renovating David's Tomb
Shachar Poni
Published: 25.01.10, 15:05
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
8 Talkbacks for this article
1. Continuing the Myth !
Avraham ,   Jerusalem   (01.26.10)
Why refer to it as the room of the Last Supper when it was only built 800 years ago. How we always fall into the trap of fighting on there terms not ours. If we only did some research and woke up.
2. Last historically documented Jewish owner…
Paqid Yirmeyahu ,   Ra'anana, Israel   (01.26.10)
Until the Roman Hellenists expelled Jews from Yerushalayim: the lower room was a Netzarim Beit K'nesset (see Biblical Archaeology Review, 90.05-06, XVI.3, p. 16ff). Interesting that Jews believe to be the tomb of Dawid ha-Melekh was brought to this location from its earlier locations (originally, archeologists think, in Ir Dawid). (The "upper room," in which Xns think Jzeus did "communion," was added during Crusade times.) Some of the stones used in its construction archeologists believe to have been salvaged from the Beit ha-Miqdash (2nd). Paqid Yirmeyahu Paqid 16, The Netzarim, Ra'anana, Israel Israeli Torah-reverer (& Orthodox Jew) Advocate for Logic as Hermeneutic Halakhic Authority Welcoming All Torah-reverers (Jews & non-Jews)
3. When I visited King David's tomb, it was as it I were near
Rivkah   (01.26.10)
Ariel Sharon's hospital room at Sheba-Chaim Medical Center. The genetics of King David is so similar to the genetics of Ariel Sharon, it was astonishing. I have to wonder if Ariel Sharon is the Wandering Jew, also called Joseph of Arimathea, Johannes Gutenberg, Leonardo DaVinci who are all the same person who passes through a gate of heaven in Jerusalem in old age to become young again after a faked funeral. Rabbi Yeshua said there would be people still alive when he comes as the Lion of Judah who were alive when he was on earth over 2000 years ago. Who was Joseph of Arimathea? He was the brother of Miriam, the mother of Rabbi Yeshua who adopted Yeshua after Joseph the Carpenter died. Joseph of Arimathea had the throne seat on the Sanhedrin. The Bible said the Throne of Judah would not pass away before the Lion of Judah comes and takes the throne forever. Joseph of Arimathea was the religious, genetic King of Judah while King Herod was a usurper appointed by the Romans. Why are there no photos of Ariel Sharon as he looks now? Is it because he is no longer an old man but is young again? Whoever Ariel Sharon is I would swear he is the same person or 99 per cent similar to King David as is Rabbi Yeshua and Joseph of Arimathea.
4. I remember when I was on the Diaspora Yeshiva in 1979 with
Steven Wilson ,   Anchorage, Alaska   (01.27.10)
Tom who had flaming curly red hair like the comedian Carrot Top. We used to chip away at the walls and pull pottery out of the walls to put in our rooms. Who knows how old the pottery was. I left all of my tools for my ten speed up above one of the walls, or doorways, up high on the same side as the bathroom in the living quarters area. They might be still up above rusting. Box knifes and tools in a bag and sitting up above. The tower above Davids Tomb was a favorite place to hang out at night with friends. The stone stairs winding all the way up. I remember the Church of the Dormitions bells waking us up every morning vibrating through the walls and shaking us awake every morning. Tom might still be on the Yeshiva for all I know. We both were at Kibbutz Haogen when we decided to go live on the Yeshiva. If anyone finds some of my tools overhead in the living area.....give me a holler on Y-net. The Arab laborers were remodeling the rooms in 1979 with new stone floors. I remember the work they were doing and it was very good. I was always fascinated by how little they were making. I told some of them they could have made exceptional money in the United States for the same work. Mount Zion is a wonderful place to see. I still wonder where the pottery went to, that we dug out of the walls.
5. guesthouse of renovation?
Tom ,   China   (01.28.10)
I never to David's Tomb(but I know David is a great man in Israeli history, David star in the flag) I just read this article,and saw the picture (guestroom), is it open to the visitors in the future?
6. Just an eye opener
Dajani Family ,   Jerusalem   (02.08.10)
I would like to draw everyone's attention that the whole of the Nabi Daoud compund belongs to the Dajani family and was stolen from them in 1948. The Dajani family are the custodians of David's tomb since hundreds of years.
7. David's Tomb Renovations
Hugo Schroeder ,   Liverpool, USA   (02.10.10)
It seems to me that many years ago there was an article in BAR magazine which reported the discovery of inscriptions on the interior walls of this building raising the possibility that it had been the site of a very early Christian Church. Has any more investigation taken place about this? I'd be interested in hearing.
8. Ownership
Ilan Bar ,   Rishon Lezion   (02.14.10)
The Dajani family claims ownership "since hundreds of years..." . ? .Why don't people, instead of feeking sorry for the victims of theft, go a bit into the history of the different "stolen sites". And by the way, what about all the property of Jews that was stolen by Jordanians and other Arabs/Palestinians, who bemoans their loss? The story has two sides to it ! The complex holding The Tomb of David as well as The Upper Room, was the original home of the Franciscan Order, till the 16th (or 15th) century when they were expelled by the Moslems, as were many other sites and taken oveer by the Moslems. So sorry, Dajani family, "he who steals from a thief is pardoned..." (hagonev meganav, patur). Not only were the Arabs "victimized.
Back to article