News
IDF, Shin Bet foiled soldier abduction in December
Hanan Greenberg
Published: 11.02.10, 14:29
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
10 Talkbacks for this article
1. No big deal..
Avi Cohen ,   Tel Aviv   (02.11.10)
..they'll be returned to Hamas soon enough.
2. ari shavit and security
alexi   (02.11.10)
ari shavit has just written an article in haaretz on deligitimization of israel and lieberman. He advocates for bibi to get rid of lieberman as he has damaged israel in arab eyes and the world of EU and USA. Lets examine this closer: One million israelis in the south now have a life in part to bibi and lieberman's missile for missile and verbal attack for verbal attack approach. second, shavit's man olmert who he criticized for a picking an ignoramus as defense minster, now turns on olmert for that mistake. Yet olmert did everything shavit wanted to get in their good books: he put flags on his dinner table for president abbas and called him your exellency. He sympahtized with the nakba.he offered assad everything. He offered abbas essentially 100% withdrawal with land swaps and jeruslalem. ye t he was mocked and derided and shot at with missiles and tractors. And shavits' implied choice for foreign minnister who he considers worthy,w hat did she do?-she helped author UN resolutins on lebanon and gaza that did little to stop smuggling.She recently voted no tax breaks for israel golanerss because she did not want to upset mofaz. She sat with olmert and took orders under him after she told him to resign. Am I missing something here??? Olmert was a coward of historic proportions, livni is not far behind. Shjavit is dreaming in delusions and chamberlain. Arabs made a deal with begin and no one else. Figure it out. This is unbelievable.Shavit, ginsberg, what does it matter, a collection of cowards and beilinists that led to gas chambers. lieberman has put some spine in israel and is doing so far a good job as is bibi and yaalon. oslo, olmert, barak as Pm and peres have been disasters for israel. And not to leave haber out of ths, rabin, was wrong on oslo, was reluctant about the whole thing concocted by gutless beilin and peres, and reflected this doubt on his face. He was wrong.
3. Resisting occupation by all means is legitimate
Philistin   (02.11.10)
israel controls Gaza's airspace, territorial waters and does not allow the movement of people or goods in or out of Gaza by air or sea. The blockade, israel controls the flow of goods going into Gaza, including electricity and water. This is the only thing we can see at the moment as long as the brutal occupation is surrounding us with its devesation & destruction. Until we see hope waving in the horizon carrying honor & degnity to all Palestinian, we will keep those green flags along with Palestine's flag waving and any other legitimate means as well that makes the dream of freedom to come true.
4. someone forgot to tell them
ghostq   (02.11.10)
that this method doesn't work, Gilad is still in Gaza, and their terrorists still In Israel. they just wanted to kill Israel and they will ever miss a chanse for terror.
5. Hamas and Hizballa are traders in human flesh: live, dead,
Eitan ,   Qatzrin, Israel   (02.11.10)
body parts and information about those parts are all for sale. I wonder what the international community thinks of it, or perhaps trading in Jewish flesh - yes, we are human beings too - is acceptable and the world may go on doing its business, e.g. issuing more Goldstones (both reports and rockets).
6. alon ben meir
marcel   (02.11.10)
ben meir today wrote in hurriyet a piece on returning the golan to syria, that golan and west bank rule are the causes of hamas and hezbollah and that israel needs to make gestures to make peace with syria. And that syria after peace will detach from iran and hamas and hezbollah will wither on the vine. This is all wishful thinking, does not accord with reality, and explains why 6 millions jews died inovens. Ben meir, shavit and the rest of the gang spout rubbish and weakneed policies. Golan and west bank are due to arab aggression and israel has made enough concessions by your front man olmert. Ben meir runs the syrian israel friendship society and is trying to justify his existence. like olso, return of the golan is null and dead. Until israelis liberate themselves physically from the dominant jewish trait of submission and concession, israeli will not know peace and respect. Arabs are afraid of lieberman who does not cower as olmert did in sderot in reaction to israeli protesters. Besides, if someone punches me in the fact, he 'll get it back. What kid of man says no, don't hit back, give him some money and lets hope he goes away. The list of such jews is large led by beilin and others and olmert and livni. All israelis have to go to martial arts and idf training.
7. #3
Rusty ,   USA   (02.11.10)
it is obvious palestinians are better served without freedom. palestinians have become the perpetual victims in the world. it used to be the jews. now we are strong. palestinians are the pawns of the syrians and iranians. realize that kidnapping and murdering jews, israelis will not get you what you want. what you want is the extermination of the jewish people and the jewish home. this will not happen. of that, you can be certain.
8. a country
Ilana   (02.11.10)
that got its independence based by means lies, theft, murder, terror, whining excuses for all those sins doesn't sound like a nice place to live in.
9. To #8 Ilana
Pedro ,   Brazil   (02.11.10)
What country are you talking about? Syria,Jordan,Iraq?US,Canada,Australia?
10. #3 philistin
(02.12.10)
are your philistin brothers free in egypt? free in iraq? free in jordan? free in syria? free in lebanon? free in saudi arabia? free in quwait? free in any arab muslim country? NO! your philistin brothers live in all arab nations with no citizenship, no civil rights to work, to have medical care, to vote, to have national benefits and without any civil rights. yes, philistine, your palestinian brothers live stateless and oppressed and murdered and executed, and tortured and without any dignity and any wealth and any work and any rights IN CONCENTRATION CAMPS CALLED REFUGEE CAMPS FOR 61 YEARS....ALL DONE BY ALL MUSLIM ARAB COUNTRIES, ALL DONE BY MUSLIM ARAB TOTALITARIAN LEADERS, ALL DONE IN THE NAME OF "WE ARABS ARE HELPING THE PALESTINIANS". so, how are your arab brothers helping you, philistin? what have your arab brothers done for you, philistin? remember the slaughter of 20,000 palestinians by kinf hussein of jordan in black september? remember the slaughter of 30,000 palestinians by hafes al assad in hama, syria? remember the above???? when all these arab leaders were "looking out for you" so much that they slaughtered you in day light...almost 50,000 of your brothers and sisters were murdered by both syria and jordan. how nice of your brothers that always wanted the "best for you". indeed, with friends like these who needs enemies? right? NOW, LET'S TALK ABOUT REAL OCCUPATION HERE.... between 1948-1967 both egypt and jordan owned and annexed gaza and west bank, including east jerusalem into their countries. the palestinians were living in gaza and in the west bank. yet!!!! not once did the kingdom of jordan and egypt EVER EVER EVER GIVE YOU A STATE OF YOUR OWN. NOT ONCE DID ANY OF THESE TWO COUNTRIES EVER INTENDED TO HIVE YOU A PALESTINIAN STATE OF YOUR OWN. did you complain to them then? did you ask for a state of your own between 1948-1967? NO! WHY NOT?????? if egypt and jordan demands a stae of your own so very much, why WERE THEY NOT WILLING TO CREATE A STATE OF PALESTINE WHEN THEY BOTH RULED OVER GAZA AND WEST BANK??? why did they continue to put you in depraved dirty and demeaning concentration camps between 1948-1967? there was no israeli occupation then, remember???? no israeli occupation. YET, NO ONE GAVE YOU A STATE THEN AND YOU NEVER ASKED FOR ONE EITHER. WHY NOT? why did all arab countries not give you a state when the land in gaza and west bank was under their rule? why not? why didn't you scream at them, occupation!!!, occupation!!!! between 1948-1967. why did they continue to force you to live as degenerates in refugee camps, to torture you, to deny you dignity and fairness, to imprison you in dirt and squalor without education, without infrastructure...to use and abuse you to become terrorists filled with hate against israel even before the israeli "occupation".. because arab leaders knew they can't defeat israel militarily, so they forced you into camps, fed you hate and propaganda everyday and used you to do the dirty terror work for them. you were used and abused not by israel, but by those arab rulers that you never point a finger against them. why not? THEY HAVE DONE TO YOU MUCH WORSE THAN ISRAEL COULD EVER HAVE DONE. hameed aboughaze, iranian
Back to article