News
NYT columnist: Israel lost contact with reality
Yitzhak Benhorin
Published: 14.03.10, 13:18
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
95 Talkbacks for this article
31. Israel lost contact with reality???
jerry rogers ,   usa   (03.14.10)
Ummm...excuse me but the obama administration has no clue what reality is. they try and push a crap health care system when people in this country say no. they (obamites) try and tell Israel to give up more land for peace and when land is given? the attacks increase. these democrats have cut their own throats and they know it.obama is a one term president and he knows it. if hes not impeached first. glad to hear Mr. Netanyahu is no longer listening to obama. no one in america is. why should he? iran has a bomb pointed at Israel and hillary says "lets sanction them". obama tells Israel..."dont attack them". if iran was threatening the united states in that matter iran would have been bombed back to the stone age. dont attack iran? who's out of contact with reality? not Israel.
32. All the ANTI IL posters dont want "justice" for Pals-just
Alan ,   SA   (03.14.10)
destruction of Israel.Of course they are Anti semites as well.Who they bluffing? Not me! Israel doesnt need USA to invade ANY country for it .Its never asked US to do this and never will.Im sure Israel can look after itself . This whole HOO HAA is just to soften up Israel for the onslaught Obama promised his sponsors. I think he is making the mistake . IMAY BE WRONG ,but the US Voters that count are not impressed with his stewardship . Also so much for your Nooo York Senator with the Gefilte Fish Bobbe maiser and Yiddishe son in law to be.! Prez Clinton tried also to shaft Israel,but didnt get it right. Israel take a page out of Iran book and stand up to Obama Administration . The great people of US are just waiting to turf Obama out in 2012-thats why he has rock bottom poll ratings
33. Friedman,Katie Curic,NYT,CBS all the same Soynes Yisroel
Alan ,   SA   (03.14.10)
34. No, you call us when you understand Jerusalem is ours
Meir   (03.14.10)
Theat these are not settlement, but that Jewis people returned to our ancestral homeland. Besides a veto at the UN and some arms sales America is more in line wth of Arabs and Iran, no reason to trust President Barack Husein Obama.
35. Under a cover of friendship
USA   (03.14.10)
The majority of American people are friends of Israel. American foreign policy is pro Arab, always had been therefore American foreign plicy is Realy anti Zionist.
36. building policy
BM ,   T/A Israel   (03.14.10)
The timing of the announcement could not have been worse nor more crass and more amateurish. We are dealing with the worlds super power and whilst there is no friend in Obama for Israel we have few if any options but to ensure we keep our wits about us and not insult anybody. We apparently have a Government where the left hand has no idea about the right. Yishai knew what he was doing and he should be dismissed for his actions,to ask him to stand down would be a waste of breath,on the otherhand to ask BB to actually do anything would be equally unrewarding. It appears that we are doomed never to learn BM
37. Obama's Dislike for Bibi
Rich ,   Miami, USA   (03.14.10)
Seems that so many people are delighting in the Ramat Shlomo fiasco. Obama has never had sincere and kind words for Israel since being elected. Hilary does all the dirty work and lacks sincerity. While the timing was awful the reaction was even worse for it shows ignorance on the part of the administration as to how far Israel is willing to go for peace. Hands of Jerusalem. Remember Masada? Well Jerusalem is 1000 times more important than Masada so unless and until the world figures this out- there is no chance for peace. And by the way- Israel should take risks for peace because Obama can be counted on. Bull.
38. Jerusalem is more ours than DC is theirs
Raphael ,   Montreal   (03.14.10)
Time to tell the President of the Occupied United States that "This land is our land". Mr Obama, before you accuse us of land stealing, review your Jewish History and give back USA to the original owners.
39. idiot "israels only true allie" india's a way better allie
(03.14.10)
india doesnt make us so thing like self destruck ie building freeze fuck him
40. Reality??
Jeff   (03.14.10)
Hey Thomas... I'd much rather loose touch with your kind of reality then have inocent pepole get blown up in kindergatens and pizza shops. What reality??? The kind where the Jews give up Hebron and get suacide bombers for it? Or giving up bethelem and get buses with children blown up?or giving the PLO gaza and get missles shot at us? Or is it giving up what you call west bank and we giving arms to the palsteinin police only to have "them" shoot at us with those wepons? Or is it Thomas... The reality of talking with one part of the PLO while the other part creates havoc for us by bombing us and killing us? You know what stick with your reality and we will stick with ours.
41. Obama poisoned the peace process, now wants to blame Israel
Sara   (03.14.10)
Obama is a politician trying to shift the blame to Israel to divert attention from the fact that he single-handedly destroyed the "peace process" by creating Arab expectations that he would deliver Israel's head to them on on a silver platter. Rather than accepting responsibility for his own incompetence and ignorance, Obama is trying to intimidate Israel into committing suicide, because nothing less will entice the Arabs to enter "peace" negotiations. It's also obvious that Thomas Friedman has sacrificed his own credibility on the Altar of Obama.
42. A tempest in a teacup
Aron ,   Bet Shemesh, Israel   (03.14.10)
If the Obama administration would be genuinely motivated to work with Israel instead of dictating, they would accept the apology realizing that Netanyahu was also ambushed in this situation. That isn't the case because the Obama Administration is genuinely arrogant and immature. Furthermore having been totally stymied at home trying to force an unwanted agenda down the electorate's throat, the White House is acting like the neighborhood bully who just got drubbed by a bigger bully, look for someone smaller to pick on. The Obama Administration has from day one acted improperly to the single democracy in the Middle East, instead the President deems it fit to bow to despotic Saudi princes.
43. Friedman lost contact with reality
tiki ,   belgium   (03.14.10)
Mr. Friedman must have been under influence of 'something while writing his article. *"America's most depended ally thinks it can push Obama around".....wake up call!!!! Everybody pushes Obama around . *"Israel undermined the TRUST in the Peace Proces and US Interest".........wake up call!!!!! There IS no peace proces and it's about ISRAEL's interest, not the US interests. *"Obama and Clinton feel 'betrayed and insulted" (not by Iran/Russia/Korea/Arabs/Pals/) , but by Israel over some houses......... wake up call!!!! If a US PRESIDENT is 'so insulted by BIBI over this, than he's not up to the job. This only shows the poor and hopeless state HE is in. You don't GET respect, you have to EARN it. *"He doesn't have relations with Foreign Leaders"......of course not, THEY see him as he is, an "empty balloon with a teleprompter". Wake up and get sober mr. Frieman........."your president ain't impressing very much".
44. Jews need houses, too
Rafael ,   Yerushalayim Israel   (03.14.10)
Jews need houses, too. Where are we supposed to live? In caves? Friedman is an idiot.
45. Big brother.
tanya ,   tel aviv israel   (03.14.10)
Mr. Friedman! Stop acting like big brother. You have your president and your fellow american jewish democrats. Give them advice. They need help! Leave Israel alone . Me, like most of the immigrants from the former Soviet Union ( today25% of the Israei population ) know very well how to resist mind control.
46. israel is more in touch with its reality than ever before
jason ,   israel   (03.14.10)
in its long and vaulted history, when for hundreds and thousands of years jews lived amongst the nations, thinking in a dream like state it could thrive as a people in mutual tolerance and respect for its host nations. we are moving full circle to the process of becoming a sovereign nation again, with the empires of the world crying foul, with historic memory of being able to kick the jews around failing them... the only thing we have ever wished to do is come back to and re-build our homeland, buying (or winning) back our own land first from the ottomans, then the british, now the arabs. we will continue to build with determination, regardless of the arrogance of the world. our respect for our arab neighbors and willingness to live in harmony will also remain, despite the ways of their leaders. i know many arabs in the west bank of israel would just like their jobs back, but that reality is less interesting.
47. Another separation fence needed
berlonski ,   berlin   (03.14.10)
It seems that Israel has to build one more "separation fence". The one against these islamist palis already exists. Fine. Now it is time to build an even much higher one against these "leftist" politicians from the US (and "Eurabia"). If then finally everything is closed around Israel nobody will be threatened any more by different (=annoying) opinions. With all these walls around there will be just a focused and pure view to the nice blue sky. Great outlook, no?
48. US is more generous than Israel in what to give up for peace
Sam ,   Canada   (03.14.10)
The US is simply more willing for Israel to make generous concessions for peace than Israel is. The US wants to get away from oil and terrorism threats by the Muslims and wants to push Israel in the direction of satisfying the Arabs (and other Muslims). Left unsaid is that the Americans support Jewish and Palestinian states but have not pressed the Palestinians to openly express the same. There is little motivation for Israel to make the concessions that the US is urging them to make. The Palestinians, meanwhile, are waiting for everything to be handed to them on a silver platter. If Fayyad and Abbas are more willing to make peace than other Palestinian leaders, Jews certainly haven't heard it. They just look more western because they wear suits and ties.
49. #44 My children need houses, too
berlonski ,   berlin   (03.14.10)
My children (without religion, well educated) need houses, too. Where are they supposed to live? Can I send them to build in your garden? And if you protest then, can I call you an idiot then, too?
50. ROBERT L. FRIEDMAN
GABRIEL ,   NEW YORK   (03.14.10)
MR. FRIEDMAN, JUST A REMINDER, THAT ISRAEL DOES NOT NEED TO DANCE TO EVERY U.S. TUNE. I THINK IF VP BIDEN GOT ON THE PLANE AND WENT BACK TO D.C., IT WOULD HAVE BEEN EVEN MORE STUPID AND CHILDISH. FROM A MAN IN YOUR STATURE WHO I HAVE BEEN READING FOR YEARS, YOUR IDEA SOUND LIKE KIDS IN A WHO DISAGREE ABOUT SOMETHING AND ONE LEAVES BECAUSE HE OR SHE IS UPSET. ISRAEL CAN AND SHOULD RELEASE ANY NEWS WITHOUT HAVING TO ASK FOR PERMISSION AND DO SO REGARDLESS OF WHO IS VISITING. THE DAYS OF THE OBAMA ADMINISTRATION ARE NUMBERED ANYWAY, SO AT THIS POINT THEY WILL SAY WHATEVER THE WANT. THEY ARE SITTING DUCKS MR. FRIEDMAN AND ITS TIME FOR ALL THE LEFT WINGERS TO BACK THEIR BAGS AND GET OUT OF WASHINGTON.
51. Right wingers howling like wounded coyotes!
Rambam ,   California   (03.14.10)
Keep on howling, your boy really screwed it up this time. Go ahead, kick America's President in the gonads again. Maybe the Saudis will defend you against Iran, ya think? Bonehead Bibi is a Likudnik first and a Republican second - serving the republican party is a dead end for Israeli diplomacy.
52. Row
Marilyn ,   USA   (03.14.10)
I view a lot of the fighting as being over land, so it is not surprising or shaming to the US if our government cannot stop it. After all it's been going on for a long time. Not only that, but even I wouldn't go along with some of the ideas of our government, so it's not like expecting everyone else to. In relation to Obama, we were counting on opposition because with Bush everyone just kind of went along with him. Not healthy. So no surprises.
53. Obama is really the one who has lost face.
Fred ,   Greenwood USA   (03.14.10)
Since Barack Hussein Obama has become the President of USA he has relentlessly demanded concessions from Israel. Does anyone remember one concession demanded on the PA side? In the US Obama is trying to force unwanted bills down Americans throats. Suffering defeat upon defeat in elections, yet he is still demanding his socialist agenda be placed on an unwilling nation. If he is bruised the liberal media demands apologies on his behalf. Stand your ground Israel, Obama's only interest is being recognized for being the great leader that he is not. He has no interest in Israel, only his ego, because he, only he knows best. If you Israel listen to Obama you will lose. You Israel had better become your own leader, and it sounds like Bibi, is doing just that. Go Bibi, wish we had such a leader in America.
54. Israel acting against peace
David ,   USA   (03.14.10)
If Israel wants to continue acting against peace by building settlements in the West Bank and in E. Jerusalem rather than engaging in serious peace talks...then there must be repercussions. The US, EU, and UN should stop just condemning Israel for this behavior, but should look at SANCTIONS INSTEAD.
55. Let Palestinians build inside Israel
American ,   USA   (03.14.10)
For those of you calling this non-sense "racism against Jews": If "Jew should be allowed to build anywhere they want"...even across the border in the West Bank territories...then Palestinians should have the same right. So let the Palestinians cross the border into Israel and build homes wherever they want. Fair is fair.
56. joe biden is NO james baker
one EYE jack   (03.14.10)
the fear of reelection is at stake for Obama,baker and shamir fiasco over the loan guarantees ended george bush senior second term chances,clinton,s camp david peace process!launched at the end of his second term,fear was not on bill clintons mind but failure was an option,obama likes to be two term president ,unless he can find moses staff!
57. Blaming Israel unfairly
Shalom Freedman ,   Jerusalem Israel   (03.14.10)
The way the Obama Administration has puffed this crisis up leads to suspicion of an ulterior motive. The truth is the Obama policy has been a total failure. It's one-sided pressure on Israel got it nowhere. Not it is blaming Israel again. A true friend would realize a mistake in timing had been made and let it go by. But the Administration needs a scapegoat for its failure to move the Arabs even a centimeter. By the way the way they fail to point out the true nature of Palestinian actions in incitement, in illegal building in everything shows what 'fairness' means to them.
58. I love what it says under Obama's picture
Golan ,   modiin   (03.14.10)
so funny. He does not have Chemistry? After stabbing Bush in the back after their private meeting world leaders saw that the first RED American president cannot be trusted. After the slap in the face of Britain (insulting gifts and slight to the Queen) and the attack against Israel (during his speech in Egypt) everyone sees that Obama will betray US allies and kiss up to its enemies. Obama betrayed Poland and the Czechs, he turned his back on the Jews, and gave Iran a green light to go hot with its nuclear ambitions. So if his communist allies and anti-Israel PLO supporters like Friedman don't like us who cares? As Yasser once said about 100 times in the same sentence "let him drink Gaza water!"
59. #55 - Arabs do have houses inside Israel
Shira ,   Israel   (03.14.10)
It was ignorant for you to assume that Arabs aren't allowed to build homes inside Israel. Arabs do legally (not only illegally) build homes and many have luxury villas in Arab villages inside Israel, as well as in major Israeli cities, including Jerusalem. Only Arabs are demanding that Jews are not allowed to live in terroritory they claim is their own (which isn't only Judea and Samaria, by the way, despite what is told to Western audiences, because it's still constantly reinforced in Arabic schoolbooks and preached in mosques that they claim ALL of Israel). Assuming you weren't intentionally supporting Arab apartheid, you really shouldn't make assumptions.
60. Mr. Friedman ( ghetto Jew).. Did you know
carlos ,   San Diego U.S.A.   (03.14.10)
the one about bout the two Jews that were about to be executed by a firing squad of European soldiers and the sargent asked one of the Jews: Do you have a final wish? and the Jew answered , yes a cigarette, Then his companion told him please don't bother the gentleman? Hey Mr. Friedman (court Jew) did you know the other joke about......
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article