News
IDF: Settlers beat soldier, hurl stones
Shmulik Grossman
Published: 20.04.10, 21:17
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
24 Talkbacks for this article
1. Zionist Settlers, Not Jews!
(04.20.10)
If these Settlers were Jews they would not resort to violence against soldiers and Palestinians! These settlers are Zionists and Zionists are not Jewish, Zionists dont represent Judaism!
2. #1, since when do you have the right to define who is a Jew?
Faruq   (04.20.10)
What great sage are you? When did all matters of Halakha transfer to your governance?
3. to #2: Actually #1 didn't, the Zionist Settlers just did!
Observer   (04.20.10)
4. #2
beth   (04.20.10)
What's wrong luv, afraid of some clarity? is it a taboo subject coz jews cant decide among themselves? grow up
5. ohh poor baby soldier !! LOL wasn't he carrying a gun?
(04.20.10)
he would have use his gun if they were Palestinians !!! SOB
6. The settlers
Joe   (04.20.10)
If this article is factual, the settlers are becoming another naturei karta. who and when is the Govt. going to enforce the law -- any law. Turmoil in the street of our capital; burning tires, trash cans,smashing cars; segregation in buses; no enforcement on the roads, speed, parking, emptying garbage on roads and fields; gangs, thugs, mafia? having a field day; weapons from our warehouses stolen;drugs at will; missing were the settlers and now we have them. Anyone there ??
7. #6 Joe
Michael Hess aka BS ,   Charlotte, NC   (04.21.10)
You are 100% correct, the country is going to s**t, it is a real shame though that the wingnuts here can't see that.
8. #1 Zionist Settlers not Jews?
Maxime The Zionist ,   ISRAEL/USA   (04.21.10)
Why don't you include your name on your post so we can tell if you are a jew or not...Regardless of who you are. What gives you the right to determine a jew from a none Jew? Who the hell you think you are CABRONE!?
9. Attacking Soldiers Should = Jail
Christy ,   Boston, US   (04.21.10)
Jews, Arabs, Christians, People from Outer Space, etc.. *anyone* who attacks soldiers, in their own country, must be given jail time. If the government is to retain control, respect must be shown to the IDF in Israel. If any soldier is attacked, the attacker should be given some mandatory jail time.
10. In a lawless town everyone is an outlaw
lydia ,   Brisbane   (04.21.10)
Greed begets greed and lawlessness begets lawlessness. Israels willingness to ignore Int. Law have allowed the illegal settlers to morphed into violent law unto their own.
11. Zionist double standards
Noor ,   Palestine   (04.21.10)
Of course, the Zionofascist settler was not shot by the Israeli occupation forces. Why? Because he was a Jew. Imagine if it was a Palestinian Arab who attempted the same. He would have been shot instantly. The law should not be applied on the basis of race or religion. How disgusting.
12. So much bitching about the "settlers" who are simply
Bunnie Meyer ,   Los Angeles, CA USA   (04.21.10)
living in the land G-d gave the Jews over 3000 years ago.
13. THEY HAVE CROSSED THE LINE & BELONG IN JAIL
zionist forever   (04.21.10)
Those same soldiers they are stoning because they are not letting them pass into certain areas are the ones that keep them safe from their hostile neighbors and so they have no business trying to harm them. Lock these guys up and set an example to not only other settlers but all Israelis who may consider attacking soldiers if it suited them.
14. #3 and #4
Faruq   (04.21.10)
Please do not reply to comments you do not understand, all religious Jews are bound by Jewish law and accordingly being a zionist does nothing to affect someones status as a Jew. The claim that zionists are not Jews is made by people who know nothing about Judaism or zionism.
15. Settler thugs attacking soldiers
Avi ,   israel   (04.21.10)
Hardly surprising behvior from these settler thugs where violence has become a way of life for them , after all they have a green light to violence. These so called settlers living on stolen land who have nothing better else to do than provoke the palestinians. Come the day of Palestinian statehood one can only hope this vipers nest known as Yitzhar will be the first to be raised to the ground.
16. #15 who say its stolen?
israel   (04.21.10)
17. Government has GOT to adopt a zero tolerance policy for this
Talula ,   Israel   (04.21.10)
If the settlers think they are beyond the law, then withdraw the soldiers and let them take care of themselves.
18. "IDF" sorry ITF is worth more
Salma ,   Palestine   (04.21.10)
Stones today, guess what tomorrow ?!!!
19. israeli's need to be free to travel everywhere in israel
reki   (04.21.10)
the government and soldiers have no business telling any israeli where they can and cannot go. repression will only lead to more confrontation
20. #12 Who asked you?
Arielush ,   Ramat Ha Golan   (04.21.10)
Bunny, from LA. What right do you have to comment. These settlers are a public nuisance. They endanger our sons, they cause friction. I think they should be jailed as traitors. Or better still maybe they should move to LA.
21. 15 - it isnt stolen land
Yaron ,   Israel   (04.21.10)
Joseph is buried there and it's where Joshua built an alter and blessed the Jewish people shortly after they entered the Land of Israel. Jews have been there for thousands of years. Read the history book or shut up.
22. God gave ME the land
stevieb ,   toronto canada   (04.21.10)
over 5000 years ago. But with your lies I most certainly can see a spot for you here at some point. -Lucifer
23. Which 'history book' is that?
stevieb ,   toronto canada   (04.21.10)
You people are hilarious. But at least you show the world what this conflict is about - psychotically religious fanatics and Jewish supremacy. Wonderful. If history is told truthfully, than there would be no Israel. Just a community of Jews living in peace in an Arab land. Now, thanks to fanatics like you quite soon there won't be ANY Jews in Palestine. Way to go!
24. to 1 - these setterls are not zionists
me   (05.02.10)
these settlers are not jews and nor are they zionists - what they do and believe in does not represent zionism they are simply extremist hooligans thank you
Back to article