News
Democratic senator: Jerusalem dispute must stop
Yitzhak Benhorin
Published: 23.04.10, 17:39
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
75 Talkbacks for this article
1. Obama is no friend of Israel and the Jewish people.
Ron B. ,   Lod   (04.23.10)
After President Barack Obama met for the first time with leaders of selected Jewish organizations and leaks from the meeting make one thing very clear. The only free country in the Middle East no longer has a friend in the leader of the free world. Obama is the most hostile sitting American president in the history of the state of Israel. Is Obama a hostile president or is he naive and mistaken ? The answer at : http://xrl.us/be5tt2
2. mr. schumer
(04.23.10)
as a non jew myself, i agree with you profoundly. it is easy for that "against israel" part of your administration to judge netanyahu's decision because they themselves will never have to put up with the consequences of that decision. israel knows what is necessary for its security and future. the americans THINK THEY KNOW BETTER, WHICH IS NOT TRUE AT ALL BECAUSE THEY NEITHER LIVE SURROUNDED BY ISLAMIC ENEMIES AND NEITHER HAVE TO PAY WITH THEIR LIVES IF THAT DECISION DOESN'T WORK OR HOLD WATER IN THE FUTURE. israel is a sovreign country with much more experience of what is necessary to survive amids islamic terror states and those bent on its annihilation. AMERICA DOESN'T. america only saw what israel is living under during 9/11 and it was not a pretty picture, to say the least. only this incidence should tell the present administration to trust israel's present decision on its borders and on its necessities for survival amids the 9/11 perpetrators. the usa has zero right to put pressures on a country whose consequences will never be experiences by the usa by paying for such decisions with usa lives. lay off! let israel TELL YOU WHAT NEEDS TO BE DONE RATHER THAN THE OTHER WAY. THEY KNOW BETTER THAN YOU. THEY LIVED WITH 9/11 FOR MORE THAN 62 YEARS. YOU DIDN'T! if you americans lived there, you have the right to decide. but you don't. so back off and let the jews do what is necessary for their future without meddling in. do not play or use jewish israeli lives for the obama "dream" to put on his resume that he made middle east peace. obama's decisions have nothing to do with what is good for israel and everythin g to do with the furthermment of his legacy around the world. his vision is not pro israel and neither pro jew. the few jews in his administration are window dressing so none of the dumb jews who elected him to office can say he is an anisemite. but surely, he spend the best of 20 years of his life in an anti american antisemitic church and nurtured relationships and friendships with antisemites like farakhan and rashid khalidi. that says a lot more about obama that the jews he surrounds himself with to provide window dressing against accusations of being anti israel. hameed aboughaze, iranian
3. I cannot stand Shumer for his arrogance and even
leo ,   usa   (04.23.10)
stupidity and what his actions do to my beloved USA, but I must admit, he is probably the best candidate to lean on Obama to get off Israel's case. Chuck, you are almost forgiven.
4. mr. schumer
(04.23.10)
the "next step" should have occured to jews such as youjrself in 2008, when you collectively supported a man you knew nothing about or thought you knew or fell for his lies and promises. this is when, in 2008, you jews should have paid more attention to not the empty rhetoric, but to the life this man lead, his friends, his church, his past associations with radicals and left wing nuts and friends and his books, in which, if one read them, one will see this "leader's" agendas, dreams and plans. it is beyond me, as a non jew, how jews have always chosen or made decisions that are not only bad, but can have consequences on their safety as a people. hameed aboughaze, iranian
5. Friends of Israel or friends of the Occupation?
Louis ,   Jerusalem   (04.23.10)
A true friend of Israel will tell the truth: Israel's policy of occupation and repression against Palestinians, be it in settlement building, East Jerusalem, the Wall, torture, putting down dissent is BAD for Israel. Schumer belongs to the old school that thinks it can get political mileage out of blind pseudo-pro-Israelism that is monitored and approved by a very virulent right wing hegemony.
6. Obama will not be moved
oz   (04.23.10)
to do anything but laugh at the temerity of this disloyal pipsqueak. The US will act in it's own interests and supporting the illegal occupation is not in its interest.
7. Fighting for survivial
Madeleine ,   Israel   (04.23.10)
Israel is a country that is fighting for survival and in the eyes of the world has to continually justify its existence. Has any other nation ever had to justify it's existence? America has never had to defend its shores and Its citizens have never come under attack, never had to defend its shores, never had to dive for bomb shelters, never had rationing, don't know the meaning of living under war conditions. Until that time, I think we in Israel understand a lot better than Hussein Obama what it is we can and are willing to do for the sake of peace.
8. Schmer, you're cool
Eyal ,   USA   (04.23.10)
I was proven wrong again. Here I thought all Democrats (Jewish or non-Jewish) were willing to jeopardize the relationship with Israel, in order to stay in power, due to the Obama policies, which proved me wrong again. So Kol Hakavod Schumer for your support and bring it on to Obama. He needs a B@tch slapping.
9. Obama the destroyer
Eyal ,   USA   (04.23.10)
Even though I salute Schumer, Obama the destroyer will soon destroy us as a nation. Obama seems to be the Muslims representative who is on the right path of his and his Muslim brothers destruction. The only obsticle for peace is Obama and the Muslims.
10. For the first time ever, an american senator OPENLY...
ace ,   san francisco, ca   (04.23.10)
support Israel's interest above American interest. We Americans have become hated ALL over the world because of our blind support to an oppressive racist regime- something we have always sang against.. PLEASE Americans, put Americas interest ABOVE ALL INTERESTS.. God bless our PRESIDENT whoever he is...
11. To 10, Completely wrong on all levels...
The Dude   (04.23.10)
This Senator has not openly supported another countries interests above the US's. As this article from Business week written by a Democrat in the committee of aid appropriation clearly shows that US aid to Israel pays handsome dividends, unlike what is paid to the PA: http://www.businessweek.com/news/2010-04-06/israel-aid-pays-u-s-dividends-that-exceed-cost-steve-rothman.html Also need I remind you of this: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KrM0dAFsZ8k The fact is people still hate you with a President who has clearly shown that he hates Israel. It has NOT helped your standing in the world. All it has shown is that you are willing to dump your allies at the chance of appeasing your enemies. The fact is that American support of Israel is very much in it's own interests. Seriously what would you get out of the middle east (excluding Israel)? Oil?... Oil?........Oil? I don't see much else. The fact is that Israel on the other hand is a place where cutting edge research is done daily, and a place where human capital is valued. And for the racism charge, that is simply pathetic. Minorities are better represented in the Knesset and make up a larger proportion of the Knesset, than many European parliaments, definitely the Senate, and I'm almost certain the house. So please, get off your high pony, it isn't what you self-righteously claim it to be...
12. #5 and #6
Ram ,   London   (04.23.10)
I hate to disappoint you but the tide will either turn and BHO will see reason to agree with Israel's view or americans will make him pay for his policy. Regardless of what the outcome will be, Israel is past making concessions tantamount to increased security risks. Neither its leaders nor its population will allow this to happen. Watch the situation slowly ease on Israel in the coming weeks. The Palestinians are being foolish thinking they can sit back and let BHO's administration do the fighting for them. They should engage in an honest and logigal discourse with the Israelis. There will be no Palestinian state if the Palis do not recognise Israel and accept its guaranteed security. The current US administration is wasting its energy huffing and puffing threats at Israel!
13. Israel needs to end the leftist sabotage of media/courts/$
jae ,   Lynn US   (04.23.10)
the left gest voted out but makes a right wing gov become leftwing. Time to end the charade that is as anti democratic as you can get.
14. Mr Schumer
James ,   NY   (04.23.10)
If your loyalty is not to the USA then go and make aliyah to where your opinions belong. US senators should not be agents of foreign governments.
15. "Take it to the next step'?
Mikesailor ,   Miami, FL   (04.23.10)
Who the hell does Shumer think he is? The senator from the state of Israel?
16. The situation is appalling
Mladen Andrijasevic ,   Be'er Sheva, Israel   (04.23.10)
The situation is appalling. We have a President of the US who has decided to do nothing to stop an apocalyptic cult regime get nuclear weapons, but at the same time is doing everything to stop Israel destroy in a preemptive strike the Iranian nuclear facilities and protect itself from an existential threat. In other words, Obama is pushing the world into a nuclear war. This is an obscene policy since it would result in the deaths of millions of Israelis and Iranians. Israel of course will not follow this absurd path and will in defending itself become the new leader of the free world.
17. Mr Hameed-Yr posts are ALWAYS so eloquent and brilliant!
Alan ,   SA   (04.23.10)
They are full of your life experience and wisdom accumulated by you over decades and continents.. Thank you so much for your posts-I always enjoy and appreciate the pure truth in them and the trouble you take to set out that truth you write,Sir!
18. Sen Shumer-How cud you and other American Jews support Rev W
Alan ,   SA   (04.23.10)
disciple to be the President of the US? Was there no better choice in ALL States than this man? Jews,at least, should have known better .At least now you are waking up to what this guy is!
19. About time chuck spoke up!
jason white ,   afula,israel   (04.23.10)
The biggest mistake in the history of the U.S. was the election of b.o. Hopefully in November we will see the tide turn and the dems lose the House. Then it will not be so easy for the jihadist in the White House to try to destroy Israel and the U.S. for his moslim bros.
20. This is shocking!
American ,   USA   (04.23.10)
A Jewish pro-Israel Senator criticizing Obama for trying to be a fair and honest Mideast peace broker (for once)! This is shocking! *rolls eyes*
21. Schumer should make aliyah
James ,   Virginia, USA   (04.23.10)
If Schumer cares so much about Israel, let him make aliyah and move there.
22. Jewish Senators want Obama as puppet
Katherine ,   Australia   (04.23.10)
I guess Schumer is angry that Obama is standing in the way of Israel's ethnic cleansing of E. Jerusalem and settlement expansion of "Judea and Samaria". Too bad Obama won't be an Israeli puppet--he is trying to be fair and actually resolve the conflict unlike his predecessors whose pro-Israel bias caused peace efforts to repeatedly FAIL.
23. # 10 The dude
ace ,   san francisco, ca   (04.23.10)
The articles that you are reffering to were written by "biased" people, ones who like this senator places their political interest above their national interest. All israelis and even if i can say the whole jewish confession puts the interst of Israel above their national interest. You have every right to.. but for American politicians to do so is just plain WRONG.... I am not a hater, but you know as well as I do that Israel is an oppressive, submissive, and racial regime that we support. That is not to say the only such regime that we support.. However when it comes on the expense on our national interest and our image in the world, I personally am against it.. just like Iran opresses the Ahwazi-Arabs- Israel does the same... Just like Syria opresses all other confessions, Israel is doing the same.. YOU HAVE EVERY RIGHT TO DO WHAT IS IN YOUR NATIONAL INTEREST JUST as much as we have the right do so the same...
24. #7 you harvest what you plant
ace ,   san francisco, ca   (04.23.10)
Plant hatred, thats what you harvest.. Throughout history thats what you have been planting and harvesting.. you have been damned throughout history because of your arrogance, its like the whole world owes you.. N.B. Keep waiting for the masiah.. you missed the buss about 2010 years ago
25. shame Obama won't listen to anybody but the muslims
zionist forever   (04.23.10)
In Obamas desperation to advance the so called peace process by just saying Bibi do as your told and Abbas can do whatever he likes Obama does nothing. Bibi suspended construction in Judea & Samaria and then Bibi reached out to Abbas said lets talk. Abbas said its not enough and I am not going to talk until you do more. Obama doesn't go to Abbas and say Bibi made a gesture you reciprocate instead he says Bibi you haven't done enough so do more so Abbas will agree to talk. Except for his nuclear terror summit Obama has had virtually nothing to say on terror worldwide and turns a blind eye to anything the palestinians do because he wants to show them he is their friend. If Obama was serious about actually advancing the peace process he wouldn't be setting deadlines and trying to get Bibi to do things he knows he can't deliver. Instead he would be looking for each side to start with baby steps and those baby steps gradually get larger but the momentum would already be in place before he starts looking for them to make much tougher actions. Obama isn't interested in real peacemaking he just wants a treaty good or bad to be signed before he goes into an election year. That will allow him to campaign on the fact he created a palestinian state and it will buy him alot of votes and thats why Obama is not going to change his policy no matter what any of the Democrat senators or his czars have to say all that matters is his image as friend of the muslim world and his own legacy.
26. The good senator is a politician and a sock puppet,
Erastus CoupeDeVille ,   Ong's Hat, NJ USA   (04.23.10)
he is saying only what his political campaign contributors want him to say... follow the money... it's the gelt, it's always about the gelt! Same as it ever was.
27. #15, Mikesailor - and Schumer
Armchair General ,   Wisconsin, USA   (04.23.10)
Mike, there is a slow boat for China leaving Miami at midnight. Why don't you be on it? Obama's administration is acting as lawyer and gendarme for the "Palestinians." It keeps pushing Israel to do things that defy its security needs. The "Palestinians" and wider Arab world do nothing but push the Americans to push Israel harder. Palestine was never a country so there is no occupation. The small amount of land Israel took was the result of war waged against it. The US state dept. would like to impose its pre-fab Palestinian State plan on Israel if Israel doesn't get there itself. Twice - with Arafat in 2000, and with Abbas&Olmert - the Palestinians were offered everything they said they wanted. They turned down the offers( Abbas: "The gap is too wide.") because it would end the conflict and not later lead to the demise of the State of Israel under "return." Schumer could mean a number of activities by "next step." One is a private meeting between pro-Israel, prominent senators and Obama. Rather like the Republicans who met with Nixon and suggested he resign.Explain to Obama that he is hurting America, hurting Israel, and hurting relations between the US and our valuable ally.And potentially hurting Democrats. Some insider wrote that as an ally Israel was worth 5 CIAs in terms of intel. Another "next step" could be for pro-Israel congresspeople to tell Obama they might not be so quick to get behind Obama's legislative agenda and pet projescts.
28. obama against israel
Henry ,   Stamford, CT   (04.23.10)
when will jewish supporters of obama finally wake up and realize how dangerous he is ? As a Jewish person it hurts too see that the majority of us voted for the democrat in the last election , as we always do. it's time to stop demonizing every republican and blindly voting democratic. obama is not a friend. He demonstrates that over and over again .he is an enemy of the state of isreal . if you care about Israel supporting obama is very foolish. and if you are a non-jew stop believing the anti- semitic rhetoric about israel being the obstacle to peace. the obstacle is that the arabs refuse to live in peace with jews they complain about inequality in israel. in arab countries jews are demonized because of the phony excuse about zionism . they teach their children hatred. if the arabs want peace there will be peace . egypt and jordan have peace treaties with israel. isreal left the gaza strip for the arabs to show that they can live in peace with israel. instead israel got rockets fired at them , starting a war the anit-semitic world then blamed on isreal. wake up american citizens and support your only friend in the mideast-israel. henry
29. #25 Presidet Obama is listening to his conscience...
ace ,   san francisco, ca   (04.23.10)
Something that your dna has missing-- historically ..
30. Israels only threat of existence is Israeli policy itself..
ace ,   san francisco, ca   (04.23.10)
You complained about the Arabs, Europeans, Turks, Christians, Moslems, Russians, Africans and now America??!! Doesnt it seem that something is NOT right here?? PLEASE ISRAEL, WAKE UP AND SMELL THE GUNPOWDER KEG YOU PUT YOURSELVES AND THE WHOLE REGION INTO. Mankind evolved in Africa, it DOES NOT MEAN that mankind has the right to claim Africa as their nation. Doesnt it seem "a little" odd that some south africans are white or some Mouzambiqis are white? They dont belong there just like you dont belong anywhere.. wherever you go you create hatred as if the whole world owes you... We dont owe you sh!t.. By supporting you blindly, our image became tarnished all over the whole world.
Next talkbacks
Back to article