News
'Iranian nuke scientist seeks asylum in Israel'
Roni Sofer
Published: 24.04.10, 18:55
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
27 Talkbacks for this article
1. may this be the first of many!
tom ,   toronto, canada   (04.24.10)
the best solution to the iranian nuclear programme is to neutralize their scientific and technical experts - let the mullahs try to build a bomb! it is, however, surprising that the scientist needed to contact an israeli civilian, rather than the mossad initiating contacts with anybody and everybody who might want to flee the regime in tehran. they should be advertising "group rates" and a toll-free number!
2. Smart man to seek asylum outside of Iran.
Rivkah   (04.24.10)
Staying in Elam, the Bible name for Western Iran is to die or be forced to migrate after that area is destroyed in a judgment fully described in the Bible. Elam was a son of Shem who was a son of Noah. Elam is South of ancient Assyria andEast of Presia Proper which is now Western Iran. Jeremiah 49:36-39 describes what Y'hovah will do to Elam. Jeremiah 49:36-39 in the Hebraic Roots Version Bible says, "And I (Y'hovah) will bring against Elam the four winds from the four quarters of heaven, and will scatter them toward all those winds; and there shall beno nation where the dispersed of Elam shall not come. And I will cause Elam to be dismayed before their enemies, and before them that seek their life; and I will bring evil upon then, even My fiece anger, says YHWH; and I will send the sword after them, tillI have consumed them; And I will set my throne in Elam, and will destory from thence king and princes, says, YHWH. But it shall come to pass in the end of days, that I will bring back the captivity of Elam, says YHWH." That means the people of Elam will become slaves in other lands (captivity).
3. A nuclear exchange ??
joe   (04.24.10)
I think that our Govt. should make a deal with Iran,. We will send them 1000 or more naturei karta citizens in exchange for only a dz, of their nuclear scientists --- 2000 ?, no problem. They enjoyed ahmadino's hospitality very much
4. Iranian Nuke Scientists
Bonnie ,   ny   (04.24.10)
You, israelis, are so funny! What whoppers! You stick a story up to see the reactions of the Public, and if it doesn't fly, you make up another one. You, israelis, never give up do you? But don't worry, we, non-jews- are on to ya!
5. Mahmood? Persian Kitty Kat?
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (04.24.10)
Come out, come out, wherever you are. Read it and weep.
6. 68,000 bombs?
S. Butler   (04.24.10)
By all accounts Israel has over 400 nuclear bombs or one for each 100,000 Israeli Jews. To achieve parity with Israel, Iran should have 69,000 nuclear bombs and the other countries of the world should have 6,800,000 nuclear bombs. Fair is fair you know.
7. Very dubious information
Gordon Wagner ,   San Diego CA USA   (04.24.10)
I believe the Europeans have a gesture of gently tugging down one's lower eyelid to display... suspicion and disbelief. Is this the best you can do? Yesterday's Mossad came up with far more robust headlines.
8. SarahB. I do remember you jumping up and down when you heard
Alex ,   Stockholm-Sweden   (04.24.10)
Of the assassination of another iranian scientist. months ago that is. Thinking it was the job of your own people?? Well we all heard what that turned out to be(for your information,he was killed by the government itself). Now you tell me,how could we even consider taking you serious?? If you call your self an intellectual,then I wonder...
9. Bonnie
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (04.24.10)
Go back on your meds. Now, really, do you want those electrodes firing into your poor excuse for a brain yet again? A lobotomy is next, and you won't find that much fun at all. (Actually, you won't be able to spell your name afterwards, dear -- hey, perhaps not a half bad idea.) Don't know why they let patients in Bellevue have access to a computer .... tsk, tsk. I'm a taxpayer. Bellevue is a public hospital. I'll find out. Trust me.
10. No.9, Sarah!!!!!!
Chris Rettenmoser ,   Bayerisch Gmain Germ   (04.25.10)
comments like Yours make the talkbacks worth reading and me Your fan No.1!!!... come on, I nearly fell from chair...
11. LIARS DAMN LIES
Stendec ,   Palestine   (04.24.10)
LIES! Sure the man jumped fence kind reminds me of the old cold war era....lol
12. #8 Wealth of misinformation
Cynthia ,   USA   (04.25.10)
Ali Larijani blamed the US and Israel for the assassination. If you have information that it was an islamic regime job, please post the link. It certainly would make sense given the professor's support of the green movement and his encouragement of students to participate in protests.
13. More info please . .
michael mazur ,   brunswick australia   (04.25.10)
. . otherwise there is no reason to believe the story. More seriously, you guys want ww3 between America and Russia through starting it over Iran once Iran is nuked. Why do you think you yourselves won't get nuked by either or both America and Russia, or if that doesn't happen, why would you survive the inevitable nuclear winter to follow ?
14. #6 - Butler
Gabriel ,   Brazil   (04.25.10)
On the other hand, every other major religion/race already have a bomb: Protestants, Chatolics, Muslims, Hindus, Chinese... So Israel does need nuclear weapons at it's disposal.
15. #6 Uh?
Ed ,   canada   (04.25.10)
With enemies like you, the Jews don't have anything to worry about. Keep up writing your talkbacks!
16. 9 Sarah: Bonnie is wrong, but your making fun of people
Rivkah   (04.25.10)
with lobotomies or who have been electroshocked in mental hospitals until the can't remember to flush a toilet is uncalled for. Your husband is a physician, so he would know what doctors do to people to keep them coming back for assured income. My oldest sister had a nervous breakdown and the Arizona State Hospital made sure she would never get well by electro-shocking her brain and sedating her so she could be raped by staff and other patients and sent to California many times (1960's) for abortions from being raped and no one protected her. That is not a place to go to get well. I have never met anyone who went to a mental hospital who came out better. The come out sedated and subdued and raped, but not better. A former school teacher named Patsy Willis died two years ago in a lockdown facility in Merced, California, because no one treated her breast cancer. Governor Terminator's answer to health care costs: execute people in hospitals. Patsy said she was being raped in the anus because when she woke up, white stringy semen came out of her anus when she went to the bathroom. No one cared or believed her, just like no one cared or believed my sister. Patsy was put into lockdown for saying swear words since she had Tourette's syndrome and would say swear words when she forgot her medicine. To you that is funny what happens to people in mental hospitals. With socialism taking over America, Bill Ayers from whose home President O. started his campaign for President, said 25 million people need to be killed for socialism to take hold in America. Wait until you are rounded up and find out what happens to the intellectuals in the brutish system the President wants America to be. Then you will find out how cruel your words are, words you would never say even to someone you disagree with if you knew the full horror of what that means: lobotomy and electric brain shocks. My sister was despised by doctors and the government that destroyed her. She was nothing but an income source from the government for treating her like an animal. She was despised by her mother who put her into lockdown just as Patsy's mother did the same to her. But God blessed my sister with grandchildren inspite of all the evil she suffered in her life. At least the physicians have not destroyed her daughter or grandchildren...yet. I don't think the souls of many doctors go to heaven or that the bodies of many doctors are resurrected to eternal life. They are murderers and charlatans and swine of the first order except for a rare few.
17. #12 There was no word from larijani on this one..
Alex ,   Stockholm-Sweden   (04.25.10)
And even if there was,you shouldn't believe everything you hear,right? You have a brain. Make use of it. Not hard. PS : There were reports on the internet of a hezbollah agent being seen on the assassination scene and also the guy who got killed was opposition member. That enough??and oh,the opposition blamed the regime for his death. PPS: looks like you don't remember things too much or are too misinformed and should not comment on anything.
18. I feel bad for this guy!
Adam ,   San Francisco   (04.25.10)
Israel will treat him like a potential spy more than a guy seeking protection. His life will be hell and once they prove he is not a spy they will treat him like a traitor who didn't protect his mother country
19. #17 Hezbollah Agent
Cynthia ,   USA   (04.25.10)
Please post link to internet report on Hezbollah agent connection to assassination.
20. #5 Sarah
Cameron ,   USA   (04.25.10)
I wondered that myself. YNET postings like these just aren't complete without the Outraged Arab Warrior & the Persian Darpet Dealer slinking through the door.
21. #19..whats the matter?cant handle the truth??
Alex ,   Stockholm-Sweden   (04.25.10)
Its obvious by the way you talk,that you have nothing new to offer and decided to label me as hezbollah agent.
22. To: No. 16
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (04.25.10)
Rivkah, please. Chill. I was not making fun of anyone. Although it is becoming increasingly tempting to make a whole hell of a lot of fun of you. Chill. Please. For your sake.
23. HI SARAH,KEEP THE DEFECTOR.....#5
MAHMOOD ,   LONDON-UK   (04.26.10)
Although I have not read in any other media report,even if true,do you really think we should worry about it.Oh no,Sarah,we don't do that.Iranians are not that stupid to risk sharing confidential information of their Nuclear programme and let an individual know beyond his limit.We have done away with quite a number since Shah fled Iran.Sporadic cases of departure is norm we are totally used to.How useful have the past defectors have been and how this one will be is what counts,doesn't it?Well,let us see how this guy shares the information that could be useful to you,yah?
24. To: No. 23
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (04.26.10)
The problem you have, as I see it, is that all of your top scientists have either defected or met with unfortunate accidents. Tee hee. Iran will have a nuclear weapon on the very same day that pigs fly. Get used to the idea.
25. HAHAH!!!!
IRAN#1   (04.26.10)
This is really getting funny now!!! The "west" tells Iran "we have informants inside your nuke network". Iran says OK, we will plant some more for you. In Jersey they call this dis-informattion :)
26. #23 & 25
Hal ,   USA   (04.27.10)
The problem for you two cartoon characters is that your house of cards is buckling. For some ungodly reason the both of you actually believe Iran will get away with this. Sorry for you clowns but, no! Not even the prople of Iran are for any of this Tin Horn crack-pot nonsense. The coming months will be a huge disappointment for you. Watch as the air comes out of you're collective balloon. Pity I can't watch Mahmood doing his angry dance. Post it on You-Tube Mahboob. Hope Peter is watching as well.
27. OH!! NO!! SARAH,NOT AT ALL...#24
MAHMOOD ,   LONDON-UK   (04.27.10)
We have enough resources in Iran,much to your dissappointment.As mentioned,so far,what have you managed to do.Guess work even with so-called defectors.Just compile all the articles on Iranian Nuclear programme and see for yourself the contradictions by your own clowns.
Back to article