News
MK Ganaim calls for Islamic caliphate in Israel
Roee Nahmias
Published: 10.05.10, 13:46
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
62 Talkbacks for this article
31. He should be stripped of citizenship and expelled. Period.
Andy ,   ramat hasharon   (05.10.10)
32. #7 - you are a complete moron.
Andy ,   ramat hasharon   (05.10.10)
33. WAKE THE BLEEP UP Israel!. Incredible just how NAIVE and how
Impeach ,   Timeisticking, Globe   (05.10.10)
much denial there is in Israel. Thus guy is serious. Respect his identity. IT IS WHAT IT IS. Deal with it instead of pretending you dont have serious issues. The US would kick a piublic official out who rpriased the taliban and called for the taliban taking over the US. Israel you must do the same, get REAL. Your behavior is ridiculous. If I were Arab I would laugh at how stupidly you do certain things (other things you are doing well, like a report card with As and Fs)
34. The essence of the Arab Israeli conflict is...
Jehudah Ben-Israel ,   Qatzrin, Israel   (05.10.10)
...that between the Muslim-Arabs and any non-Muslim and non-Arab people that intends to lead an independent political life on any parcel of land in the region they call their own. Israel is just such an entity: a people that is intent on continuing to maintain its independence in part of of its ancestral historic homeland, thus Israel is in conflict with the Muslim-Arab world, local and regional. This is not a "Palestinian" vs. Israel conflict. It is not a question of "state", "refugees", or even "Jerusalem". These issues were not there before 1948, but the Muslim-Arabs initiated a war then. Most of these questions were not before 1967, but the Muslim-Arab world, all of it, supported the Muslim-Arab coalition that initiated the Six Day War intended to wipe Israel off the face of earth. Indeed, the Palestine Liberation Organization (PLO) was set up by the Arab League - not by the local Arabs, mind you! - to "liberate" Palestine. Which part of "Palestine" was it to liberate three full years before the Six Day War...??!!
35. Respect the man and what is in his heart
Jae ,   Lynn US   (05.10.10)
he represents the religious and arabist nationalistic segment, which is over 50%. First respect him and his beliefs, quit pretending it isnt real, it doesnt exist. take your head out of your collective arse, my people...and DO SOMETHINB ABOUT IT instead of paying his salary. Idiots living in Chelm, is that what we are?
36. to #7 hahaha great zionist state did you see
ghostq   (05.10.10)
the size of Israel, hahahaha great zionist ideology, sorry can't stop laughing. god didn't promist all the areas to Israel just Israel, hahahaha you sniffed to much of oil fumes, oh btw oil is limited if you know how it is created that is y people find cheaper less poluting source of energy.
37. jordan is palestine! get the hell out!
jordan is palestine   (05.10.10)
38. have we appointed him to speak in our behalf?
ygalg ,   israel   (05.10.10)
Muslims tend to think they are the spokesmen of the world. what a deluded folks
39. Dream on Baby!
David Hersch ,   Cape Town South Afri   (05.10.10)
What antiquated horse manure!
40. Kach is banned
Kyle ,   Southpark, CO, USA   (05.10.10)
But this shmuck is allowed to occupy a Knesset seat?
41. #7 - Zionist ideology is not Greater Israel
William ,   Israel   (05.10.10)
That's more of a belief of a small group of Jews who believe we should return to the years past of the Jewish empire, but it isn't engrained in Zionist Ideology. Zionism is simply the realization of the Jewish human right of self-determination in the land of their birth and ancestors from which they were illegally expelled. There is no call for a Greater Israel...unless Arabs step out of line again. However, the Islamic ideology of a global caliphate IS very much alive and in the majority among Muslims. Hence, the reason common belief is that Muslims are both racist and bent on replacing other theologies, by manipulation or force, just as they did since the 7th century.
42. #1 - I think he's referring to HIS golden era
William ,   Israel   (05.10.10)
Unfortunately, under Arab rule from 9th century onward - no one was living in a Golden Era unless you count the fat Arab rulers who use Islam as a way to justify their oppressive control, slavery, rape, and theft. Arabs still claim they brought math and navigation to the world...despite all historical references proving that it was stolen from the much more advances Zoroastrians in Persia.
43. He is so emboldened by Left, no reason to lie anymore
William ,   Israel   (05.10.10)
Thanks to the Left in Israel Arabs have no reason to hide their true intentions anymore. A Caliphate, a genocide, a destruction of a sovereign State and a minority to rule over a majority with extreme prejudice. Every day, Arabs voice their most racist thoughts and desires from their heart, knowing that they will be excused by blind Leftists and those opposed will be called racists and attacked by Eurotrash Elitists.
44. Ganaim..
Paul ,   USA   (05.10.10)
needs to visit a psychiatrist. He is delusional.
45. Golden Era?
Dave ,   Detroit, USA   (05.10.10)
Golden Era? Gee, I kinda thought the 190+ Nobel prizes for science Jews have won represent a pretty good era. Where are all those Muslim Nobels for science? There is precisely ONE, and it was awarded to Ahmadi, who acknowledge a prophet AFTER Muhammad. Jews: 190+(looks like 194), pure Mohamedans: ZERO.
46. Where is Rami of Nazareth and his "coexistence" views?
William ,   Israel   (05.10.10)
Rami constantly posts that Israel is racist towards Arabs and believes racist Arabs are in the minority and often ignored. So again - I ask Rami or any other Arab in Israel - exactly WHAT discrimination did you experience at the hands of Israel? Was it having to stand in line with Jews to matriculate in a subsidized university? Was it to be treated by a Jewish doctor in an Israeli health clinic? Was it to travel from your remote village to find work in a population center, as Jews do? Was it because Israel demanded you pay taxes for the service you receive, just as Jews do? Every week we hear of more and more cases of Arabs helping terrorists, of promoting the idea of wiping out the State you are a part of, of even supporting a terrorist group that rained down rockets on Arab towns in 2006. And yet - you seem surprised that Israelis don't trust Israeli Arabs.
47. #44 - common misconception - He's NOT dilusional
William ,   Israel   (05.10.10)
He's not delusional at all. Infact, he's very clear and his comments are reminiscent of the wider Arab mentality of supremacy and oppression. The ones who are delusional are those that believe this kind of thought is rare and by a non-accepted minority. Those who give these people power are the ones who try ti disarm the rest of us by claiming Arabs really want coexistence and the Caliphate is just "radical speak". The truth is - this "radical speak" is more wide spread across the globe and aligned with a true Islamic belief than many would admit to. The ones who are delusional are us in Israel...who not only put up with this racist crap, but give them a platform in order to gain support from the West that would never love us anyway.
48. His excellency , the Sultan...!
joe   (05.10.10)
I think that Mr Ganaim wants to commit suicide. A Caliphate, no less??.Did he get permission from his wife to replenish his harem. I understand that he has ordered a few "pieces" from Victoria Secrets, but isn't that a bit premature ?.I am well aware that among our MK's we have a few adventurous lawmakers But .......!
49. I wonder, what would happen to an MK in an Arab
Steve Kaplan ,   Minneapolis, MN   (05.10.10)
country who only thought out loud of his dream that the Jews would take over the whole region...? But Israel, some claim, is not democratic, indeed an Apartheid state as the infamous former President Carter put it. I wonder, what does Barakah Hussein Obama think?
50. # 46 William
Sagi   (05.10.10)
For your information. Rami from Nazareth is a Christian Arab and has served in the IDF or Border Police. His concern about integration and equality is because he loves this country just as much as you and I and he knows exactly what will happen to us, including himself, if the Muslim Arabs ever get their wish and our demise becomes a reality.
51. #50 - I asked him for 5 months to explain himself
William ,   Israel   (05.10.10)
It would have been easier and acceptable for him to deliver the same message you just gave. I followed his posts for the past 2 years. Until 11 months ago, he was very much pro-Israel and supportive of integration of all cultures in Israel. Recently, he has become a more radical voice and promotes the illusion that Arabs have no rights in Israel. His stance is anathema to your claim of his loyalty to the State. He glosses over the real phenomenon of Arab racism in the region, especially Israel, and forgets the current PM is the one who saved the Plaza of the Annunciation in Nazareth from Muslims who tried to steal the land, sanctity of the site for Islam. By the way - Christian Arabs are NOT required (or allowed, I believe) to serve in the IDF. Only Druze and Bedouins. Though I will assume you are correct in this one instance.
52. # 51 William
Sagi   (05.10.10)
Druze are Druze and do not like to be called "Druze Arabs". Christian Arabs and Muslim Arabs are indeed not required to serve in the military. As far as "allowed" is concerned, they are, and many do, both that is.
53. DEMOCRACY IS THE BEST . PALESTINE WILL BE # 1 DEMOCRATIC....
.ARABIC STATE IN M.E ,   ATİLLA KARAGÖZOĞLU   (05.10.10)
I CHOSED DEMOCRACY FOR PALESTINE. LET THE OTHER ARABS LIVE UNDER THE RELIGIOUS WAY OF THEIR OWN CREATIONS. *** PALESTINE WILL BE FIRST AND BEST DEMOCRATIC ARABIC STATE IN MIDDLE EAST.
54. PALESTINE WILL BE FIRST&BEST DEMOCRATIC ARABIC ...
....STATE IN M.E. ,   ATİLLA KARAGÖZOĞLU   (05.10.10)
BY THE WAY ! TODAY IS MY BIRTHDAY.
55. # 54 Atilla
Sagi   (05.10.10)
Congratulations, but this does not release you from being a total basket case. You are in dire need of help.
56. #55 FRANKENSTINE STATE WILL BE LIKE TURKEY ISLAMIST TO THE
CORE AND BACKWARD... ,   ATİLLA KARAGÖZOĞLU   (05.10.10)
NOW TELL ME AGAIN WHO USES A BASKET TO GO TO THE MARKET
57. #53 - Arabs consider Lebanon to be democratic
William ,   Israel   (05.10.10)
and that's despite the oppression and threats by Hizbullah and Shia thugs against non- Muslims. In this distorted definition, I suppose you might be correct about "Palestine". They already demand an ethnic cleansing of non-Arabs from the State and vow to continue the oppression that is Islamic rule.
58. Just like Islamic movement anywhere..
Rami of Nazareth ,   Israel   (05.10.10)
Finally those radical are showing their tru face. Hope Israeli muslims would wake up and stop voting for them
59. The Golden Era for the Mideast
Ali Babou ,   Ankara   (05.10.10)
Was when the Arabs were back in the desert worshiping the rock in Mecca, picking flies off each other and mating with their cattle.
60. Pity his golden era has long past, never to shine again.
rebecca ,   Modiin   (05.10.10)
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article