News
Suspicion: Palestinian killed wife because she was carrying girl
Ali Waked
Published: 13.05.10, 14:18
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
44 Talkbacks for this article
1. So kill yourself. It's your sperm. Not her egg.
Suzanne   (05.13.10)
Not even mentioning the silliness to kill yourself because you wanted a son instead of daughter. Gee.
2. Sad.This man is ignorant, he had to kill himself
Salma ,   Palestine   (05.13.10)
because the man determines whether the baby will be a boy or girl.....but our society, like other societies, has some ignorant and insane people:( Personally, I dream in future of beautiful, blessed baby girl
3. I wonder if he'll get more than house arrest
Talula ,   Israel   (05.13.10)
4. women rights vs human rights
sameer ,   jerusalem   (05.13.10)
if they hang him they violate human rights but if they dont hang him they violate women rights. but he must be treated the same as her
5. to #2 can I quot you on that?
ghostq   (05.13.10)
:)
6. Ultrasound, a scienfitic marvel
joe   (05.13.10)
In islamic hands, another deadly weapon in their arsenal. The more boys, the more glorious warriors, mine sweepers, weapon carriers, suicide volunteers ; and of course more boys........ ! what a sad vicious circle.
7. #4 - I think you're unclear of what is human rights
William ,   Israel   (05.13.10)
Being killed for committing a murder is not a violation of human rights. The laws exist that provide that response to his crime - he was aware of it and still made the choice. It would be against his human rights not to honor his choice, however poor, that he made and the punishment that will result. Human rights encompass women's rights as well.
8. He wanted a boy, kids just want a father
William ,   Israel   (05.13.10)
sadly, both of them will not get their wish now.
9. Absolutely Disgusting!
Peter ,   Uk   (05.13.10)
How cruel can this creature be. Not a human action for a normal person.
10. To: No. 4 and No. 7
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (05.13.10)
Please do not confuse "murder" with "execution." The former is extrajudicial; the latter is not.
11. Religion of Peace Honors Wmen . . . NOT!
emanon ,   USA   (05.13.10)
12. @ Salma, no.2
AJ - Raalte   (05.13.10)
Good for you that you do not try to defend this sick and despicable guy, like you usually do with Arab acts, however dumb or evil. Beating his pregnant wife and then killing her over something she has no control over. For that matter, neither does he. In the act leaving his FOUR children without a mother (and a father)! How thoroughly stupid can one be? Poor kids. They do not deserve any of this. Hope the rest of the family will pitch in taking care of them, though I've no idea how a person can get over such a man-made disaster.
13. why is the writing on nationality?
Israeli   (05.13.10)
the guy is insane and should be put in prison for life. But why highlight that he was Palestinian? Do we have headlines "Jew robs bank" or "Jew murders grandchild". This only furthers the racism we already feel. Ynet, I thought you were more responsible than that.
14. Cultural attitudes are a funny thing
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (05.13.10)
I had three boys and dreamt of having a little girl (which, blissfully, on the fourth attempt, I did). I know a great many formerly childless couples who reap the benefit of China's one-child-per-family law. Each of these couples have adopted beautiful baby girls from China that were unwanted. Some have adopted more than one. Your children are what you raise them to be and the dreams which you try to inspire them with. Boy ... girl .... what difference does it make? Your child is your child, no matter what the gender. And, as several people have pointed out, a woman can only contribute the X chromosome. The man can contribute either the X or the Y chromosome. It is NEVER the woman's fault.
15. How very sad - he has 3 sons and 1
miri ,   israel   (05.13.10)
daughter and wasn't happy to welcome another baby girl. Now his children have no mother. What misery
16. To emanon , USA; the smart guy
Ahmad ,   Mother Earth   (05.13.10)
Stupidity, ignorance and hatred have no boundaries; you Sir are such an example. In our society we have ignorants beating and killing their wife's and I admit we as Middle Eastern societies have along way to go with corrupt governments and injustices were the weak don't have many rights. On the other hand Let's check and see how many children rapping rabbis out there and how many Children raping Catholics religious holy men from the advanced western societies, I guess God chosen people after all are not out of this world. Some example with thousands more: Rabbi Israel Kestenbaum .... Convicted of 35 counts of child rape Rabbi Avrohom Mondrowitz, who was accused of molesting children Case of Rabbi Lewis Brenner (Convicted of child molestation Case of Rabbi Yitzchak Cohen (Accused of sexually harassing students at Bar-Ilan University Case of Rabbi Israel Grunwald (Accused of molesting a 15 year old on a 1995 plane flight from Australia to LA Case of the Rabbi at Hillel Torah, Chicago, IL (A teacher at the Chicago school was accused of child molestation
17. #16, yes, let's check how many of them there are
soludo   (05.13.10)
so those truly guilty of this can be brought to justice. And being accused of something doesn't mean the person is guilty. Ever heard of "innocent until proven guilty"? That just happens to be the cornerstone of Western justice systems.
18. multicultural
Don ,   LA   (05.13.10)
Why are you guys mad? I thought that in the West we need to respect others culture.
19. One more thing
Ahmad ,   Mother Earth   (05.13.10)
I have 6 girls and 1 boy and I am Palestinian, Muslim and Arab; very happy with my girls. My best wish that to provide the best education and enlightenment for the girls that I can , because having and educated mother insures educated and descent society
20. Hey, Ahmad
emanon ,   USA   (05.13.10)
I agree no society is perfect. Let me ask you though: 1) Which society says it is OK to mutilate you wife by removing her organ of sexual pleasure, leave her only a container to reproduce? 2) Which society demands that women cannot go out unaccompanied? 3) Which society gives husbands the right to kill their own children or wives? 4) Which society refuses to believes a woman was raped unless there numerous male witnesses? 5) Which society says stoning of women for offenses is an acceptable punishment . . . and still practices it? 6) I am getting tired of typing, but you see my point.
21. Very Cheap
Dan the Man ,   Here   (05.13.10)
this is called defamation and libel with a lot of prrjudice. trying to say these are Palestinians.. no real compassion with the victim and without professionalism in investigating why this sick man killed his wife and mother of 4 children. this is disgusting and inconsidrate not to mention the racism
22. Really
KH ,   USA   (05.13.10)
Everybody is making this into a racist situation, it dont matter if he was american, chinese, arabic, whatever, the point is this sick man murdered his wife because of the gender of his baby and he was the one who made her, women to me are the strong ones in this world, men would be nothing without us and to point out women are the ones that have BABIES BOYS AND GIRLS! It's sad that the world has turned into this. I pray for people who try to be god cause one day they will meet there maker and get everything that they deserve.
23. so now 4 little Arabs have no mother and dad in jail.
sifter ,   Chicago   (05.13.10)
Yep, this is how you build a state. "Spew libel, act tribal." Israel would have an easier time building peace with mad cows.
24. #19
W.R.Monger ,   San Diego Ca. USA   (05.13.10)
Ahmad, if you are who and what you say you are then affect change in your culture. i don't defend my government so i am trying to change it however i can. perhaps if you do the same others may also. it only takes one voice to start a chior. educating your daughters is among the best things you can do. go even futher and protect someone else's daughter or son and don't let the get caught up in... world events...
25. #22
W.R.Monger ,   San Diego Ca.USA   (05.13.10)
KH... he killed 2 that day... a little girl and a woman. i almost lost both my wife and daughter when my little girl was born. life is fragile, more than most know. this less than human who murdered both of these souls needs to die in the most horrible way allowed. i just hope the relatives don't treat the little girl left behind like a slave as usually happens in that culture. the murderer proved that his family sees girls differently by killing her because she wasn't a son.
26. To: No. 21
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (05.13.10)
The victims here are this poor woman and her unborn baby daughter. No one else.
27. To: No. 21
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (05.13.10)
Get real. This "man" murdered his wife because she was carrying HIS baby girll. I don't care what YOU call it. I call it disgusting, primitive, barabaric and .... you know what, Dan? The civilized world agrees with me. Heavy emphasis on "civilized."
28. To: No. 21, redux
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (05.13.10)
Umm, ever hear of vowels?
29. Its the man's sperm that determines the sex!
Win ,   KC USA   (05.13.10)
30. to # 21
me ,   here   (05.13.10)
I do not think that Israeli media is in any way defaming this man by telling the fact that he is Palestinian by origin or living where he lives. I remember a murder case a few years ago, when a Jewish man had killed his 3 years old daughter and then buried her in a wooded area. The body was found thanks to a Palestinian man, who had seen the act and could tip the police. The nationalities of these people were clearly stated, though in that case the murderer was of Jewish origin (not to say that that means he was Jewish...) and the person who helped the police was Palestinian. I do not agree that Israeli media is racist. They just state the facts, as I can see it.
Next talkbacks
Back to article