News
Salah: Beware of crazy person among us
Sharon Roffe-Ofir
Published: 15.05.10, 00:33
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
37 Talkbacks for this article
1. Raed Salah is advocating transfer.
Jake ,   USA   (05.15.10)
By praising traitors, Raed Salah is showing that he & those who agree with him, are indeed a fifth column.
2. Crazies ? We love them.
Nathan Rai ,   Bangalore   (05.15.10)
The Salah rabble rouser fellow needs to be informed that Israel has a history of successfully dealing with crazies. Just ask Yassin...
3. Thanks Hussein Obama . This is the
Vardina   (05.15.10)
result of your "genius" "peace policy". About time to return the undeserved Nobel prize. Until now Obama's anti Israeli attitude has encouraged terror within Israel from local Arabs. Obama wants to help Arabs get two Palestinian terrorist states: one on the border of Israel and one within the state of Israel. What a peace making genious....
4. Niqab = going backwards
hblaswilson@yahoo.co ,   SF Bay Area   (05.15.10)
To all those who condemn Israel - please start by refusing medical, modern technology in your day-to-day life. Dig a hole in the ground to relieve yourself; refuse all medications that are offered; do not use modern airplanes or ships when traveling -- since you hate Jews and Israel - why use the improvements and inventions that many of us take for granted everyday? Not a trick question.
5. Isn't there a law against attempting to recruit spies?
Zvi   (05.15.10)
I would think that such a law would apply here. Lock him up. Throw away the key. Or deport him.
6. VERY Difficult to Just Sit at that Meeting ..
Christy ,   Boston, US   (05.15.10)
.. and not laugh. Pot & Kettle example here.
7. "nakba", or catastrophe, is what the Muslim-Arabs see in...
Jehudah Ben-Israel ,   Qatzrin, Israel   (05.15.10)
...creation of Israel. The proclamation of a non-Muslim and a non-Arab state, regardless of size, that came into being based on an international decisions and resolutions is a catastrophe in Muslim-Arab eyes. Modern Israel of course came about as a result of the Balfour Declaration , 1917, which was followed by the San Remo Conference, 1920, and then by the League of Nations, 1922, all the way to the United Nations, 1947. This legal chain of events that had been behind Israel's creation, the Jewish people's historic right to the Land, and the ethical right it has based on the universally accepted right of all peoples to national self-determination and independence are yet to convince the Muslim-Arab world of Israel's right to be, to exiist as the nation-state of the Jewish people. Thus, its very existence is a "Nakba", a catastrophe...
8. Misleading Headline
Herut ,   USA   (05.15.10)
The headline is written to infer that this supporter of the demise of Israel is offering a friendly measure of caution, rather than the threat that he actually meant. Sadly, the subtopic headline strongly repeats the anti-Israel lies about settlements---as if it were possible to have an "illegal" settlement in a Jewish nation. (Disagree...take it up with HaShem.)
9. the 1st target is you, brother
Baruch ,   New York USA   (05.15.10)
i hear you and I know what the solution is one country for us only.
10. Yes and they'll all have apartments on TA Seafront
Alan ,   SA   (05.15.10)
11. Well it sounds like you all will be SOL again.
lol arabs ,   bah barbarians!   (05.15.10)
12. F A I L
ben Ish   (05.15.10)
The ENTIRE TRANS-JORDAN was intended for Jews. I suggest you shut up already, before that particular mistake gets rectified. You did not like Israel being reduced to a fraction, and what happened? That's right, YOU LOST. You will lose every time. Always. Do not forget it. If you *don't* like owning the majority of the land, then keep whining about it okay? Israel is fully capable of reducing your land area to zero if that is what you are crying about. Oh, and watch me not care.
13. # 7 Palestinians don't give a damn about these resolutions
Palestinian   (05.15.10)
14. P.S. to post # 7: Note that the "nakba" day is commemorated
Jehudah Ben-Israel ,   Qatzrin, Israel   (05.15.10)
on the 15th of May every year, the day on which Israel came into being, the day on which the "catastrophe" from a Muslim-Arab perspective. (Most of the Arabs who fled their homes and properties at the time did so shortly after the UN Resolution, 181, of 29 November 1947, was voted and not on the 15th of May 1948!!!)
15. Beware of Aharonovitch's broomsticks...
Janice Cohen ,   ירושלים   (05.15.10)
while serving time after your coming trial. Just ask Sheikh Obeid.
16. The joy of the one being the sorrow of another
sik   (05.15.10)
What a talkack! If *you* don't regard having to leave your home and land a catastrophe, you can't blame those to whom it happened for feeling differently. Did you forget the homes your ancestors lost? No. Why should they? Banning mention of a catastrophe will not banish memories of it and grief over it. Ask the people from Gush Katif. Ask the refugees from Nazi Europe, ask those expelled from certain Arab countries. Ask the descendants of those expelled from Spain by the Inquisition in 1492. Ask the deluded loonies who call all Arabs murderers because they are Bnei Yishmael. Did they forget their Greek and Roman Nakbas? How long ago did they happen? BTW, the two men in administrative detention said to be charged for espionage have not yet been tried or sentenced. Their defense against those charges has not yet been heard or investigated. How come you already find them guilty?
17. Please
Yossi ,   Ashkelon   (05.15.10)
Can you boycott also all the social help you are getting from your Jewish enemy state that your are living in? Perhaps you might refuse as well as your monthly israeli salary that is given maybe by a cancer settler ? Perhaps you can ask for palestinian citizenship where you could express your freedom freely !
18. do they really think...
Andrej ,   Jerusalem   (05.15.10)
Do they really think they will ever come back to Israel? Are they out of their minds? The moment they left this country to join the invading armies on the other side was the moment they have finished with Israel and they have nothing to look for here.They are hoping to create international pressure on Israel to let them come back. They can keep hoping. That is all they have. But they will never come back here.
19. Sheikh Raed Salah is a Traitor
ranjan ,   la, USA   (05.15.10)
I do not understand Yisraeli Govt. This guy is openly anti Yisrael and a TRAITOR to the State of Yisrael. His Islamic Movement should be banned he should be put in a jail forever. No country on earth will allow traitor to their country. Bibi what is wrong with you.
20. Nakba
hanzalah naji ,   jerusalem   (05.15.10)
I have to tell all the world, specially the Christians, That the first sector of Arab society that have the big loss from the Nakba is the Christian Arabs, we were about 20% of the Arab society, now hardly we are 2%, and yes Israel either force or encourage Christians to leave, for example my grandfather house was in Qattamon, it still the same there, with no changes, my father born there, they forced to immigrate to east Jerusalem, we never forget that this our house, and my three children born in Misgav Ladakh hospital which located in front of my grandfather house, in 1991 when my oldest son born the secretary told me here is your document, if you don’t have name for baby you can add it later, I asked here to come with me to the entrance of the hospital, I told her there that the name of the boy is George, and he given this name in that house before 50 years, Arab Christians and Muslims will never forget there land, there villages and towns , they wrote books, keeps maps, keys of houses, they pass it from generation to another, and by the way there were people in Palestine, with a civilized cities, culture, and history, Parties like this one its not for reminding, because we remember our homeland and houses, everyday, this party is to show world that we are still here. Hoping that ynet publish our opinion.
21. Who in heavens name do you allow this guy to subvert the sta
Jerome Chiew ,   Singapore   (05.15.10)
To subvert the State of Israel,he needs to be thrown in jail and isolated.
22. Beware of extremists like Salah
Dan ,   CH   (05.15.10)
This person appears to be an ill-concealed or even declared enemy of the state, since he doesn't recognize Israel as a Jewish nation and he incites the Arab masses within the country to attack the institutions. Israel must monitor very closely such extremist forces within her borders and take the appropriate countermeasures by any infrations of the law, such as anti-Israeli incitement, spying and violence. It's absolutely unacceptable that a minority in a country secretly would want to subvert and ultimately eliminate the state itself.
23. Salah- a judicial failure and abuse
DT ,   TA Israel   (05.15.10)
This not DEMOCRACY but an absolute abuse of freedom for which Israelis die to preserve. This man is an enemy and should be treated as such.
24. #13 The Truth at Last!
Logic ,   Israel   (05.15.10)
The world needs to know what you really think of international law.
25. marking "nakba day"?
rachel ,   chutz4now, home soon   (05.15.10)
i would like to know WHEN this "nakba day" marking happened? CERTAINLY it was not marked MAY '49, or '50 or '51.....or '66 or '67 or ?
26. In how many countries this man would be permitted to preach
Steve Kaplan ,   Minneapolis, MN   (05.15.10)
the destruction of the country in which he is a citizen, the political entity that supports him with its social service programs and that pays his salary ?
27. If Saleh were a Jew
Marcel ,   Florida   (05.15.10)
If the Sheikh were a Jew he would have been arrested and imprisoned long ago for incitement. Because Israel is ruled by fearful cowards and retreat experts like Netanyahu and Barak he is given a pass time and time again. The grasshoppers of Israel have already surrendered to this enemy to please their pimp in Washington. Jews have less rights than the enemy within in Israel . Witness the roadblocks to Jews ascending the Temple Mount for one.
28. #7 and the nakba
London man ,   London   (05.15.10)
The nakba was not "the proclamation of a non-Muslim state" but the expulsion of hundreds of thousands of Palestinians. Quite a simple concept really. There was no "nakba" until the hundreds of thousands of Palestinians were booted out and their property and lands stolen. Even the United Nations resolution did not stipulate the illegal transfer of the assets of hundreds of thousands of Palestinians.
29. #18 and flight.
London man ,   London   (05.15.10)
"The moment they left this country to join the invading armies on the other side " Actually, the hundreds of thousands of Palestinians who fled, fled for their lives. They did not flee "to join the invading armies" - unless you believe the invading armies were made up of babes in arms, the elderly and women.
30. Salah would do well to consider.....
Adina kutnicki ,   Israel   (05.15.10)
that the majority of Zionists will beat him and his followers back until they are no longer able to fight us. They are a clear and present danger and a fifth column, and if pushed against the wall our Zionist brothers and sisters won't hesitate to squash them under our shoes. Israel's leaders let them get away with mayhem and murder, but the average Zionist knows how to deal with inciters in our midst. Salah - DON'T dare test us......
Next talkbacks
Back to article