News
A brutal ambush at sea
Ron Ben-Yishai
Published: 31.05.10, 15:44
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
348 Talkbacks for this article
91. #81: yet another bumb Irish?
(05.31.10)
How does it feel to believe every cheap lie the Palestinians throw at you? At least you have this strong belief you know what's going on... oh well..
92. YES WE SAW
STEVE ,   AUSTRALIA   (05.31.10)
WE SAW IDF VIDEO ALSO THE KILLED INNOCENT UNARMORED PEOPLE
93. I CAME FROM SOMALIA
STEVE ,   SYDNEY   (05.31.10)
I CAME FROM SOMALIA MAY I JOIN TO YOU ? IDF
94. Nothing illegal about this in Intl law!
Martin R ,   Jo'burg, SA   (05.31.10)
"According to the San Remo Manual that governs international humanitarian law, it is permissible under rule 67(a) to attack neutral vessels on the high seas when the vessels "are believed on reasonable grounds to be carrying contraband or breaching a blockade, and after prior warning they intentionally and clearly refuse to stop, or intentionally and clearly resist visit, search or capture." Any more doubts about the IDF's legal standing?
95. Good for the IDF
Ana ,   Spain   (05.31.10)
Those people will think twice before going as reinforcements for Hamas.
96. Filth
Juliette ,   Palestine   (05.31.10)
Your soldiers are cowards, and you are liars.
97. translate the video to english!!
.   (05.31.10)
98. The whole world hates Israel
John ,   Austria   (05.31.10)
99. un armed Human right activists ??
Arul   (05.31.10)
We saw the peace loving human right activists with iron bars and knifes attcking the soldiers first. The whole hypocrite world is screaming and crying. How many of them cried when there was killing in Darfur ? Howmany opened their mouths when North Korea sunk a south korean ship with more than 40 soldiers sending them to their watery grave. All these countries are crying for the brutal murderers in Gaza. The whole world is now dancing to the tune of the radicals and Appeasing the radical terrorists is really sickening. Anyway we can see Ezekiel 38 unfolding slowly.
100. Israel: Fight Back in the Press!
Liz Wagner ,   Sleepy Hollow, USA   (05.31.10)
Distribute this article everywhere you can, so people get Israel's side of the story. Demand other news sources report facts found here, too. Then, contact Israeli leaders & get them to FIGHT BACK ferociously with these facts & Israel's just cause.
101. Leftist doublespeak "peace activists"= extremely violent mob
Huntingmoose ,   Sf ca use   (05.31.10)
The only blame israel can get is that they did not follow the latest news from greece, france, spain. Had they, they would have known the true face of "peace" activists who are nothing less then a molotov cocktail throwing , killing and extremely violent group of activists. Clearly the peace they want is not the peace i want. Doublespeak 1984ish.
102. THOSE SHIPS WERE IN INTERNATIONAL WATERS!!!
Vic ,   Lausanne, Suisse   (05.31.10)
Why Israel media omits that simple fact? Cause then all these fairy-commando tales would not mean a thing. Piracy in inetrnational waters thats what it was. And what is the bloody danger to let those 10-15 tonn go through upon inspection?
103. I have to admit that its funny…‎
A.G ,   Israel   (05.31.10)
Some of the responses here are hilarious, some Muslim write here and judge us while ‎Muslims terrorists killed the largest amount of people in history.‎ All the evil in the world comes from Islam, World Trade Center, Afghanistan, Chechnya, ‎thousands and thousands of murdered in Africa, the massacre of the Turks on the ‎Armenians people, and so much more... ‎ So allow me to not get excited when a Moslem Judge me.‎ No one knows the evil that inherent in you as the Jews, I hope the world will come to ‎sense as soon as possible and realize the sick religion he is dealing with…‎
104. Hey John #98
Arul   (05.31.10)
Let the whole wolrd hate Israel. That is how it will happen in the end of days. But we love Israel dearly. May GOD bless Israel and protect her.
105. to#17
Jennie ,   USA   (05.31.10)
Don't you think, that Israel has just received a new lesson and will never ever again treat your bloody brothers with silk gloves...The next vessels wouldn't be able to reach half of their destination- they'll be treated by IDF as enemy combat and destroyed with real weapons....Hope you will be on it too....The law of cause and effect works even on bacilla like you and your ilk....
106. Heartless People! Obama May Have To Shorten Vacation
David H ,   Marietta USA   (05.31.10)
GO TEAM ISRAEL! Good Work, and sink the next round! Let's see how well the Hamas "swimming lessons" worked
107. Matty - a person with weapons is no long "civilian"
William ,   Israel   (05.31.10)
That is - except in the Arab/Leftist mind. And a person between the ages of 16-24 carrying a weapon is no long a "child". Your country tried 12 year olds with adult crimes. You're hardly in a position to throw stones.
108. Better option was to disable the boats
William ,   Israel   (05.31.10)
I don't think anyone would have guessed that the activists were armed to this extent. The leaders claimed it was completely peaceful and wouldn't resist an IDF boarding. And activists were never armed in the past. But then again - violent racist Turks weren't involved in the last flotillas. I would have pulled back from the boats, then targeted their rudders/propeller, and leave them there. Everyone's happy - they can't go to Gaza, and the IDF doesn't need to board.
109. So sad that these soldiers were not authorized/prepared...
David Hartman ,   Raleigh, NC   (05.31.10)
...to properly engage these scum. The fact that soldiers got severely injured before they were authorized to use their (lethal) weapons was a tragic mistake.
110. Are you blind (35)
TAHRIR QUDS ALYAHUDI   (05.31.10)
Yes Mr Polski you are blind.Israel is Jewish Land and the capital of Israel is JERUSALEM,same as Poland is Polish and Warsaw her capital. Go and read your NEW TESTAMENT Mr.BLIND MAN
111. Muslim terrorists with knives and guns were on the ships
David   (05.31.10)
Muslim terrorists with knives and guns were on the ships and attack and opened fire on the soldiers ! It is planned Turkish and radical Islamic groups provocation ! Arabs - Go back to Arabia !
112. :: Lya - #84
Matty Groves ,   Fairport   (05.31.10)
Lya you don’t have to ‘fear’ Obama - you only have to do as he commands.
113. jumping to conclusions
A blessed one ,   trondheim, norway   (05.31.10)
People in Norway are pissed of at Israel now, get that footage out there and please try to convince them the peace activist were not so peaceful after all! Antisemittism is growing by the minute :(
114. Propoganda
Giora Me'ir ,   USA   (05.31.10)
This was just cleared by the military censors, it was written by them.
115. #57 - so do the weapons they had stored on boat
William ,   Israel   (05.31.10)
Seeing all of the weapons they had stored on the boat speak volumes...about the intentions of the so-called "peaceful" activists. I pray Israel plays this footage over and over again ad nauseum for the world to see.
116. #48 - have you even played paintball before?
William ,   Israel   (05.31.10)
I have and know the equipment well. Those "guns" the soldiers had are paintball shooters. You can see that when during the video a soldier fires it, resulting in a big "puff" sound. Again, a Leftist hateful comment with no real knowledge about what they talk about emanates from the land of potatoes and leprechauns.
117. No comments from Libya
TAHRIR QUDS ALYAHUDI   (05.31.10)
Your god allah is pagan,god of the moon.Islam is bloodthirsty religion and even your prophet was blood thirsty by your islam sword. How many people Islam killed by the sword and to force people to convert into your religion.
118. @88: Don't be so naive...
Roee ,   Israel   (05.31.10)
Yes, it was international water. No, that's no justification. Israel made it clear that the ships couldn't directly go to Gaza, due to many reasons, the least of them to make sure no armaments were on board. Plenty of alternatives were offered, including docking in the Ashdod port and checking the ships and whatever it was they contained, and then letting them pass on to Gaza if all was well. Additionally, a group of people from the ships would have been allowed to go on with the ships afterward. But, no. They wouldn't settle for it. They cared NOTHING for the welfare of the people in Gaza, otherwise they would have agreed and tried to do things in a more reasonable way. They wanted PUBLICITY. They wanted to hit the main stories. They wanted to provoke Israel and delegitimize it. The people on board the ship weren't just "defending" themselves... They were actively attacking the soldiers that came on board... Trying to disable and destroy the helicopters that were in the action... Trying to snatch guns, to harm the soldiers... Knifing them... That's not self-defense... That ship could have been a threat to Israel's security, had it carried missiles that could be used by Hamas. Hamas keeps launching missiles on a DAILY basis towards Israeli civilians and cities... the Gaza strip is only ~80 kilometers from Tel Aviv, the largest area of population in Israel, so don't tell me there's no threat in a ship heading to an area that bombards us. We need to make sure there's no threat. And please do tell me what everyone knows the IDF does... I fail to see what you're trying to say... The IDF is one of the more humanitarian armies out there. Just look at what Russia did to Armenia not too long ago... The world didn't care much... The world soon forgot... But us? Because we don't want to be bombarded and to check foreign ships who IGNORE explicit orders not to cross into the waters and be searched for weaponry, which if they contained only food and supplies, why should they care being searched? I really hope you'll actually read what I've written. Yes, this was carried in a bad way. We should have just neutralized their engines and then carry them off to Turkey and be done with it. Thing is, we didn't think they would be so VIOLENT, them being for peace and all...
119. Recap: Israel is gradually losing it
Ihab ,   Lebanon   (05.31.10)
A small recap: - in 2006, Israel lost the Lebanese war. The pow were not delivered, hizbullah rather reinforced it's arsenal, Israel lost it's deterrence -cast lead was barbaric: politically it discredited strong allies for Israel, strengthened hamas position in the Arab peoples and goldstone condemned Israel -ayalon , the genius, with the bouncer liebermann pissed off turkey through a childish act. Result: Israelis had to apologize, created tension with turkey and simply got them farther -the testosterone of yr idf simply made nasrallah impose a new deterrence equation : airport, ports, electric plants, etc... Are the new targets. Immediately Israel started sending messages assuring it is not intending to launch war -progress on the Iranian nuclear ? U know it - the flotilla today? As a Lebanese, Yr leaders have become yr burden. Israel ' countdown started. Go back to Poland, Russia, USA... Is it worth yr brother, son, dad or friend to die in Palestine. When peace is considered as a luxury, there will be the moment when it will become a must for you. Hopefully, we will not grant it for you
120. The raid was incredibly stupid
Giora Me'ir ,   USA   (05.31.10)
There was no reason for it, and it's a political and diplomatic disaster for Israel.
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article