News
UN calls for impartial probe of flotilla clashes
Associated Press
Published: 01.06.10, 09:34
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
57 Talkbacks for this article
1. :: 'What kind of peace activists use knives, clubs...
Matty Groves ,   Fairport   (06.01.10)
and other weapons to attack soldiers?' Obviously those who are trying to protect themselves and prevent the hijacking of their ship in international waters. Where do people get the idea that ‘peace activists’ are defenceless and incapable of protecting themselves and giving the IDF a good ass-kicking? None of this would have happened if the IDF hadn’t tried to hijack the ship. “If indeed it were a humanitarian mission it (the humanitarian aid) would have accepted, weeks ago, during the planning stages, the offer by the Israeli authorities to transfer the aid (to Gaza)”. If Israel is so willing to transfer aid to Gaza so readily why is there a blockade in the first place? Either way Israel has managed, by the sheer incompetence IDF to put the issue of the Israeli siege of Gaza squarely back on the world agenda.
2. :: More ships en route...
Matty Groves ,   Fairport   (06.01.10)
The MV Rachel Corrie and at least two other ships carrying humanitarian aid are still en route to Gaza. Because of weather conditions it is hard to predict when they will arrive. It will be interesting to see how Israel deals with these ships. Needless to say the IDF will be using kid-gloves.
3. IS THE UN COMPETENT TO INVESTIGATE THE PLOT OF ...
BENJAMIN ,   SINGAPORE   (06.01.10)
ERDOGAN AND TURKISH ISLAMIC BROTHERHOOD UNDERGROUND MOVEMENT ?
4. UN Sending Goldstone again?
rebecca ,   Modiin   (06.01.10)
5. How does one condemns first and probe later...??
Jehudah Ben-Israel ,   Qatzrin, Israel   (06.01.10)
Only the UN and its agencies, e.g. UN Human Rights Council can apply such a logic: Blame the nation-state of the Jewish people first, and ask the relevant questions - or don't ask them at all - later. What a cynical world!!!
6. "Israel" is not the only guilty,Thus
Salma ,   Palestine   (06.01.10)
We need an impartial probe with the United Nations, because it is the responsible number one on "Israel's" belief that it is above the law
7. UN - Report
Miriam Woelke ,   Tel Aviv   (06.01.10)
The UN should appoint GOLDSTONE for a new "reliable" investigation !
8. The noble ones who erected UN
(06.01.10)
are turning themselves in their graves!
9. "proper, reliable, independent, and transparent"
mike ,   israel (formerly usa   (06.01.10)
it says quite a lot that the UN has to make that clarification.
10. Translation:
ben Ish   (06.01.10)
When the UN says "proper, reliable, independent, and transparent" probe", they mean: "conducted by Syria, Iran, Saudi Arabia, Yemen, and the entire Arab League, with special footnotes by Noam Chomsky and special guest liar Barak Usama, oops I mean Ubama.
11. "UNITED NOTHING"
Rotem   (06.01.10)
Reliable investigation my ass. Do the pictures not enough for you, or maybe this was a military 'production' as well? UN are bunch of anit-Israeli idiots, whom ignore the facts in a methodical way, as they always did: Why you never hear about "emergency meeting" for Iran, Tibet, China, Georgia etc. Well, am I not surprised - There's Nothing new under the sun.
12. Comment
Mohammad ,   Jordan   (06.01.10)
An investigation is needed, this is for sure before we start condemning one party or the other. A very important question that need to be answered: Who attacked first? I think its safe to assume that a soldier with a machine gun in his/her hand, would pull the trigger if someone coming at him/her with an axe in his hand. Israel deserves condemnation for one thing even before investigation starts, that the confrontation was in international waters.
13. Goldstone would be fair to Israel in this matter also
Jazz   (06.01.10)
14. Oooh
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (06.01.10)
15. Hypocritical "probe"
The Doc ,   Travelling the USA   (06.01.10)
Nobody probes the Russian invasion of Georgia, including the thousands of civiliand murdered in the process. Nobody probes the atrocities done by China in Tibet. Nobody probes the tens of thousands murdered by China in the Uyghur Muslim region. Nobody probes the thousands of Ba'hai and Sunni murdered by the Jihadist regime in Iran. Nobody probes the thousands of civilians killed in Afghanistan by US and NATO troops. Nobody probes the nuclear infestation of the Pacific Ocean by the French colonialism. Nobody probes the thousands of whales murdered by the Norwegians. But everybody blames and demonizes Israel for defending itself and its natural and legal rights against the provocation of terrorist organizations and the Turkish Act of War. So how can anybody regard the UN, its Human Rights bodies and its Security Council as credible, dependable, balanced and organization representing what is good in mankind? Ever since the US opened its arms to thirld world dictatorships and terrorist organizations, it lost its purpose and its leadership status. Today, the UN is nothing but a gang of corrupt and racist puppets, led by the worst tyrannies in the world whose decisions are dictated by the most bloodthirsty dictators and human rights offenders. It is not only Israel who suffers from this situation - it is the entire (remaining) Free World. Those who participate and approve of the hypocritical US demonization of Israel are nothing but suicidal collaborators with evil - unless they happen to be Muslim, in which case, the UN is even better than the Arab League, where the mutual tribal and religious hatred, and Dark Ages style bickering and violence prevents them to rach any common decision that would bring Islam out of its poverty, misery, backwardness and cruelty into the modern age. I despise the UN and what it represents today and I ignore its "resolutions" and racist and vicious and biased "probes".
16. LOL
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (06.01.10)
The United Nations calling for impartial ANYTHING is just a huge joke. Israel should tell them to go pound sand. Impartial, anything -- indeed. What are we, fools? I think not.
17. Morals and legality.
Ron B. ,   Lod   (06.01.10)
The rules of international law governing the use of force by victims of aggression are embarrassingly unjust and would never be tolerated by any domestic criminal law system. They give the advantage to unlawful aggressors and thereby undermine international justice, security and stability. Article 51 of the U.N. Charter forbids all use of force except that for "self-defense if an armed attack occurs. Israel's raid on Uganda's Entebbe Airport in 1976—to rescue the victims of an airplane hijacking by Palestinian terrorists—was also illegal under Article 51. More at: http://xrl.us/bfq4r7
18. matty people protecte themselves in their own home
ghostq   (06.01.10)
not when they r in someone elses home and carry knives, the next thing you will tell me that burglars got the right to go to other people houses with knives and the house residences should not defed it self, you got some backward logic especially when you support jihad.
19. #6 Of course. Turkey and "Palestine" are the guilty parts!
The Doc ,   Travelling the USA   (06.01.10)
And of course, all those who don't know geography and think that "Palestine" is a country. As a matter of fact, the real "Palestinians" are the Jews. The Land of Israel has been named "Palestine" by the Romans rapers and, at that time, I don't remember reading anywhere about you or any of your squatter ancestors doing anything on these lands. Heck, you can't even pronounce "P" because there is no "P" in Arabic! The "palestinian ethos" is a 20th century Muslim fabrication. There aren't even historical, religious and ethnical connection between Gaza and the West Bank. That's why you hate each other so much. Gazans are basically Egyptians and you, my "palestinian" friend, are coming from the Arabian deserts, Iraq or even further away! Even "Syria", "Jordan" and "Lebanon:" are not real countries - they never existed before the French and the British colonialism. The only documented country in this area (if we count Egypt and Persia out) is ISRAEL AKA "PALESTINE", populated, built and treasured by the Jews. Jerusalem was built by the Jews and raped by Romans, Greeks, Persians, Crusaders and yes, Muslim predators. So spare us of your "palestinian" drivel. You have no rights on these lands and you know it, and I don't care how many of your grandfathers you remember. Ours are written in the Bible. Even your Quran says that this is Jewish land so clamp your hole and either behave, or leave my living room!
20. UN = ARAB LEAGUE 2
UN = terrorist ,   organization   (06.01.10)
21. Abolish the U.N.
Michael Steiner ,   Bahrain   (06.01.10)
So, nine (not 19, as the usual tom-tom hyperbole had everyone believe) "activists" getting killed after attacking soldiers in one of the most conflict-ridden areas on the planet warrants an emergency session of the U.N. At the same time, nine THOUSAND people die in various conflicts the world over every single day, and the U.N. hardly ever even discusses that, let alone issues demands. 'Nuff said. Throw the U.N. into the trashcan of history.
22. We demand a probe of Turkey's role
Cynthia ,   USA   (06.01.10)
Turkey showed malicious intent by sending armed "activists" with terror ties across international waters to provoke an incident with Israel. Not only was there a lack of cooperation by the Turkish ship, but armed "activists" attacked IDF soldiers upon their arrival to inspect the ship. This harassment of Israel by another UN member state must be investigated and not ignored by the UN.
23. :: Eitan - #5
Matty Groves ,   Fairport   (06.01.10)
In case you haven’t noticed, or do not wish to acknowledge Israel has done exactly the same thing. Ie: “...they are not peace activists; they are not messengers of good will. They cynically use a humanitarian platform to send a message of hate and to implement violence." (Dan Carmon) The Israeli Gov and media have spent the last 24 hours condemning the participants in this flotilla for their ‘hostile actions’/etc. In short the Israel Gov have already put these people on media trial and found them guilty, even before the ships docked. Don’t start whining about a ‘cynical world’ when Israel is part and parcel of such a world.
24. learn International Law!
gene ,   tlv   (06.01.10)
the Left and their Jihadist allies always yell about Israel's alleged violation of international although they have no idea what International law is! Israel has every right to intercept vessels in international waters that have declared their intention to violate area which under the Geneva conventions, are under Israeli jurisprudence- ie Gaza and its coast. After these floating terrorists declared their intention of running the blockade they declared themselves no longer neutral and israel had every right to intercept them. On another note, these Islamic Turkish terrorists were anything but peace activists, they were sent by the Turkish government to provoke Israel and they did so through PURE violence. Gandhi and Martin Luther King Jr would never have acted the way these Jihadist brutes!
25. Extreme overreaction by the hypocrite world
Tahl ,   Ashdod   (06.01.10)
I don't recall there was ONE-TENTH of this backlash, when the North Koreans intentionally sunk a South Korean ship recently - no doubt a much graver crime. The world is such a hypocrite, and a stage to militant Islam. What else is new.
26. to #16 they hesitate cause from one side they know
ghostq   (06.01.10)
it can happend to them and the immigrants allready protest around europe, but since jews r the first victims to any evil behavior on earth, it's only time until the Muslims will hurt lokal chritian people whom they don't like, like geert and othe rparliament, they will riot they will send death threats oh yeah arab immigrant behavior, that is y the voters turned right in Europ the leadership have no idea if their voters r fully switched to right wing opinion.
27. to #6 no turkey is she is the president of the security
ghostq   (06.01.10)
in the UN today and she is getting close to Iran. you do the math, Israel is not the issue. for death of 9 people you don't make international probe, just for the emphasis in the sucide in pass over when a woman blow herself in otel in north Israel 30 innocent people got murdered.
28. to #2 weather is hard??? sound like you read
ghostq   (06.01.10)
the wrong weather channel again it's not UK and this is the end of spring, lol you better land on earth. cause you live in a world of your own.
29. "drenched in blood"
Zvi   (06.01.10)
The only "barbarism" was that committed by the crew of the ship - and their hands alone are drenched in the blood that they wished spilled.
30. release of the flotilla's passengers=FREEDOM 4 GILAD SHALIT!
P   (06.01.10)
Next talkbacks
Back to article