News
Turkish doctor who treated soldiers says more humane
Ynet
Published: 10.06.10, 08:29
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
58 Talkbacks for this article
31. To Dr..Hasan Huseyin Uysal,
Salma ,   Palestine   (06.10.10)
Human always to be a human , or not ! This should be with everyone, not just with the Jews
32. #30 : YOU GOT IT 100% RIGHT!!!
Central ,   Intelligence Agency   (06.10.10)
33. "why would they not just shoot them to death once they had..
Daniel ,   worldwide   (06.10.10)
taken heir guns?" maybe because the entire ship would have been blown out of the water had they shot them??
34. NR. 21.
Arn. ,   SWEDEN.   (06.10.10)
WHEN THE WAR IN THE MIDDLE-EAST COMENSES, YOU WILL SE WHAT EFFORTS IN VAIN, THE AUSTRIAN MILITARY FORCES WILL DO AGAINST THE SERBIANS. Arn.
35. Bravo to "Peace" Campaign
Lya ,   Israel/Finland   (06.10.10)
Turkish own autopsy revealed, 2 of the turks, the oldest and youngest had gunshots not only from front but also from behind from short range to the head - shot by own muslim brothers, to make sure that the propaganda project will be success. So people who come here to educate again, what israelis cannot see - why to bother? This "peace" campaign was success for radical islamist. It is very simple and very easy to understand, that IDF seals got treatment on board for publicity later. This is what islamist are great at, they love to do live stunts on the cost of own brothers, women and children. And all world is crying. They want all world crying, because they keep failing to win the wars in the battle. At least they keep win in media, and they prices will get only higher and higher. Some people have forgot the dancing palestinians in East Jerusalem, celebrating the fall of Twin Towers, lost of the 3000 civilians. Make your own conclusions.
36. to #31 salma there is something called hipocrates
ghostq   (06.10.10)
oath, but as he made it very clear if it was up to him he would never help the soldiers, he just didn't want to lose his job, see how simple it is.
37. Put the 'US Jews' article UP HERE
(06.10.10)
and this non item low down. Change 'em round....oh gee.. it's ynet ...that figures then
38. #31 Salma
Jay3 ,   Israel   (06.10.10)
BUt arent you taught by your Quran that us Jews are from monkeys and pigs?
39. Doctor Feelgood in person!
(06.10.10)
40. The good doctor...
Dan the Jafa ,   Auckland, Aotearoa   (06.10.10)
...is giving us his hypocritical oath. Whether or not he reneged on his Hippocratic oath reamins unknown.
41. #8 you show your real ugly face
Adelle   (06.10.10)
Hatred, hatred, hatred that is what you are all about!
42. To Lara from Australia
Adelle   (06.10.10)
They cold have unloaded everything in Ashdod or go through Egypt! No, their main goal was to reinforce terrorists in Gaza. In case you missed a point - the UN Human Right is infused with subjective, Muslim members. There is NO CHANCE for objective resolution. Just as, sadly, there is no chance for objective reporting. Take Reuters for example! Surely you saw how they cropped knoves and blood from photos.
43. Thank you #16!
Adelle   (06.10.10)
44. So why did they attack the soldiers?
Eyal ,   USA   (06.10.10)
They could have let the soldiers come on board peacefully, but they didn't. They had other plans in their path. The Doctors only treated the soldiers when they had guns pointed at them by other soldiers. The terrorists on board knew what they were doing. If someone came to me with a knife, I would shoot him more than 3 times, in case i missed hehehehe.
45. He's Not a Doctor
emanon ,   USA   (06.10.10)
No doctor would say "stitch". The medical term is "suture". The two words are not interchangeable. This suggests to me the article is bogus.
46.  Stab reached his stomach membrane but not the organ itself.
Alan ,   SA   (06.10.10)
Did he do a Laparoscope that he knew this? He is lying ! He wanted to be sure that they were in good condition to be hostages either on the boat itself or as a companion for Shalit . Im sure the 9 Jihadis died trying to fight off the Israeli Commandos who were trying to break thru to where the 3 were being held in order to free them Why were the 3 taken below ????
47. they wanted to kidnap the soldiers and hand them over to
m ,   israel   (06.10.10)
hamas. ofcourse they wanted to keep them alive.
48. the ole good doc
ygalg ,   israel   (06.10.10)
he is not updated with the recent reports. so he resorts with taqqiya in hoping they buy his bluff.
49. HOSTAGES
MO ,   israel   (06.10.10)
They gave them medical attention to keep them as hostages, alive and in captivity!!! like GILAD SHALIT
50. Israel should release the confiscated video
Rami of Nazareth ,   Israel   (06.10.10)
and show there was nothing to hide...
51. Swiss Dino
David Israel ,   New York, USA   (06.10.10)
What difference does it make. The Mavi Marmara had several hundred passengers. Many of them were not Turkish. About 30 - 40 of the Turkish passengers boarded as a separate group. They were shouting GAZAMIZ MUBAREK OLSUN which means 'may our battle be holly' These are all on tape and published in the Turkish media. Among theose were 3 Turkish celebrities of the Albayrak family. One a journalis an actor and a writer who produced the anti Isareli AYRILIK 'Separation' TV series. They are known anti Isaerl activiosts in Turkey. The definition of peaceful and violent in Turkey is much more different then in Switzerland. Recently the spectators of a peaceful major league football match in Istanbul burned the stadium. Here in the USA this is not a peaceful sports event. Here in the USA attacking soldiers with lethal clubs and even daggers is not considered a peaceful protest. The way the passengers in the Rachel Corrie acted was peaceful protest. You can try to twist the truth as much as you want as you were trying to do with the Kosher slaughtering case a few years back but you can not fool anyone.
52. the passengers dont get the picture
zionist forever   (06.10.10)
These people on the ships either don't understand or don't want to understand the facts. The bulk of the passengers probably intended to be peaceful but there was a small group there who were on that trip just hoping for a showdown. If there were no passengers wanting to make trouble then who are the people beating the soldiers with metal bars? Who thrust knives into the chests of soldiers? The reason they were not shot is because non of the people who were looking for a fight managed to get any of the guns. Also in situations like this its not the intent of the enemy that is what makes a soldier decide to open fire or not. Its does the soldier believe he will be killed if he doesn't defend himself. The only people to blame for all of this is a small group of passengers who came looking for a fight. Everybody else soldiers & inocent passengers were inocent victims of their actions. Israel does need an inepdendent investigation that will listen to both sides just need to make sure its the right people conducting the investigation. No Turks, no arabs, no UN apppointed judge It should be mainly handled by the US and if a foreigner needs to be brought in make it from a country thats traditionally Israel friendly possibly Germany
53. #50 - as soon as France 2 release raw video of Al-Dura
William ,   Israel   (06.10.10)
Otherwise - zip it, hypocrite!
54. Doctor followed his Hippocratic Oath..so what?
William ,   Israel   (06.10.10)
How can the 50+ violent people on board armed with weapons and already guilty of attacking soldiers be considered "innocent" because this doctor did the job he swore to do? In that regard - why not claim Hamas is really a Girl Scout troop, solely based on the actions of this doctor? Let's not forget, Rantisi was also a doctor and he spent more time blowing kids apart than healing them!
55. #14 - Not true, the doctor on board DID have an obligation
William ,   Israel   (06.10.10)
The minute he would shirk that obligation, which he took when he received his physician's license, he would cease to be a doctor. If you think being a physician means adhering to political boundaries then you should have no problem in condemning the ICRC for offering First Aid classes to the Taliban, or future refusal of Israeli doctors to treat even one Arab, no matter how dire. Anyone who thinks a person swinging a metal pipe up over their head and crashing it down into a person wasn't trying to kill them is absolutely deluding themselves. It's more Arab brutality fueled by pure racism...the same that allowed animals to stab reservist soldiers, dip their hands in their bloody entrails, and show them to a sheering crowd in Ramallah!
56. #45-In this case,a stitch in time DIDNT save 9
Alan ,   SA   (06.10.10)
57. disarmed commando in custody INSIDE the ship
observer   (06.11.10)
First of all it’s against logic that these soldiers would not be killed but instead be taken to the medical center if the intention of the activists was to kill them. If people on board were so eager to hurt them, why would they not just shoot them to death once they had taken their guns? Why bother carting them inside for treatment? It just doesn’t add up. One picture speaks volumes
58. He may think he is a doctor
Duchess   (06.12.10)
but since he is a liar he is not true to his profession, what a poor and lame excuse! Does he think we are all dumb or something?
Previous talkbacks
Back to article