Jewish Scene
Palestinians seek new partner: US Jews
Associated Press
Published: 29.06.10, 13:14
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
35 Talkbacks for this article
1. The Obama team put him up to this.
Terry ,   Eilat - Israel   (06.29.10)
And, while I couldn't offer proof, I'd bet any money that Israeli Leftists or Kadima or Ehud Barak had something to do with this, that they offer tactical advice to our enemies for their own political advantage. Never under-estimate the degree of sleeze from Israeli politicians.
2. US Jews and Abbas can talk as much as they like...
Menachem ,   Israel   (06.29.10)
but the facts remain that only Israel decides her own future. Since Israel and not J-Street is the neighbour of Abbas, it would be a good idea to talk directly with Jerusalem if interested in a genuine peace.
3. "went a long way with the audience. "
Harry ,   Jerusalem   (06.29.10)
Exactly how far of a way. The total blindness of these people. Talk is so cheap, they are giving it away free. "condemnations of violence " WHO ARE YOU KIDDING!!! What are you smoking or drinking. Are you people for REAL. Has Lies taken the place of TRUTH
4. The Jewish American dinner party game :)
Salma ,   Palestine   (06.29.10)
In Ramallah will be the Palestinian luncheon party game :) Abu Mazen is sincere he is talking in one language, and this is something I respect about this man who should resign
5. Robert Wexler in top 5 of Obama supporters
Rod ,   Fargo N.Dakota   (06.29.10)
I figured he's be up to something since he decided not run for Congress again.
6. Stupis American
(06.29.10)
7. The Disgraced Sandy Berger ws There
DAVID ,   ISRAEL   (06.29.10)
Sandy Berger caught with his pants full of top secret documents re the CLinton Scandal is among our "Jewish Leaders" Oi Veh are we in trouble ! American Jews's Brains Have Turned to Mush !!
8. Isn't this the same Abbas who wrote
m   (06.29.10)
his dissertation as Holocaust denial? Or isn't this the same Abbas who financed the murder of the Israelis in Munchen olympics? I have the feeling that these "important" Jews would have fetted Hitler if he was despondent enough.
9. You can't fool all of the people all of the time.
AJ ,   Washington, DC   (06.29.10)
Abraham Lincoln said it best. Abas is not going to convince a room full of American Jews that he wants peace and compromise, unless his actions match his words. AIPAC and the ADL were there, after all. These are not Obama bleating sheep. Meet with the Israeli government face to face or STFU.
10. If he had spoken on the record in Arabic
Zvi   (06.29.10)
it would have been more convincing.
11. Pals sweet talk Jews for territory without accepting Israel
Sam ,   Canada   (06.29.10)
The Palestinians and other Arabs are trying to sweet talk Jews and the West into getting Israel to relinquish territory without the Arabs having to accept a Jewish majority Israel. For the moment this is a better option for them than violence.
12. What he says in English vs what he says in Arabic
Raymond in DC ,   Washington, USA   (06.29.10)
Says Abbas, "I talked to them in the same language that I speak on the Palestinian street." Uh, no he didn't. It's unfortunate that hardly a person among those US Jews speaks Arabic, as they could have challenged him on the particulars. Even where the same word is used, they have different meaning in the two contexts - "justice" and "innocent civilian", for example. Ironic too that he can claim to oppose holocaust denial, given his own contribution to the practice.
13. Abbass police murdered Israel police&citizens=violence
sam ,   USA   (06.29.10)
14. Neture Karta in Iran only reversed
Golan ,   Modiin   (06.29.10)
Instead of Neture Karta in Iran these Jews invite a Holocaust denier. I guess they voted Obama.
15. Stupid American Jews are so gullible its unbelievable!
Abbas=TERRORIST ,   with a suit!   (06.29.10)
16. Bang heads together....The solution is not nuclear science
Sammy ,   Newcastle   (06.29.10)
A Mid East Roller Coaster Ride - riding up sky high with optimism then going rock bottom - up down up down - So near - yet so far! Palestinians and I include the majority of Gazans as well as the majority Israelis silently watch opportunity after opportunity passes them by
17. Abbas and the Jewish peaceniks
Barbara ,   Haifa Israel   (06.29.10)
Fools. If you believe Abbas, then now I know how Obama got to be president. If anyone of you come to the West Bank for a lunch party - be forewarned - you might be the next kidnapped victim.
18. Does the Jewish people as a people have the RIGHT to...
Jehudah Ben-Israel ,   Qatzrin, Israel   (06.29.10)
...national self-determination and independence? If not, why not? And if yes, why don't you, Mr. Abbas, accept Israel's RIGHT - not only FACT - to be, to exist as the nation-state of the Jewish people. You have persistently and consistently refused to accept Israel's right to be, to exist as the nation-state of the Jewish people. Indeed, your right-hand man, Mr. Erekat, stated clearly that there is no such thing as a Jewish people (Nov. 2007, Annapolis). Also, why have you refused consistently and persistently to accept a peace deal with Israel as the "end of the conflict"? These two refusal - right to exist and end of conflict - surely indicate that your intent is NOT to live peacefully with the nation-state of the Jewish people but rather to ensure that the conflict is not over until the state in whose right to be you don't believe is eliminated in stages.
19. The people who decide for Israel are Israeli citizens, not
Steve Caplan ,   Minneapolis, MN   (06.29.10)
naive and Obama supporters of the U.S., and with Israelis, Mr. Abbas refuses to talk because they know a thing or two about him and his intentions that Jews abroad don't and/or they are motivated by the the new messiah, Barakah Hussein Obama whose hostility to Israel has been proven many times.
20. No. 8
NYC Girl   (06.29.10)
The fact that Mahmoud Abbas was the bag man for the massacre of the Olympic athletes always seems to bring to mind Al Gore's book on global warming..."An Inconvenient Truth".
21. Rod from Fargo N. Dakota
David Israel ,   New York, USA   (06.29.10)
Wexler is being considered to be the US Ambassador to Israel. He hasn't decided to take the job yet but we will know soon. He was the head of the Turkish friendship commission in the house. President Obama believes that he is capable to improve the Turkish / Israeli relations.
22. Why?
Ariel ,   São Paulo - Brazil   (06.29.10)
Why they receive a person that have a thesis of denial the holocaust ????? http://www.pmw.org.il/holocaust.htm
23. sure, make an agreement with US jews
mike ,   israel (formerly usa   (06.29.10)
i'm sure US jews will be happy to accept palestinian refugees to america.
24. Simple wedge politics
BH ,   Iowa   (06.29.10)
Nothing more than an attempt to drive a wedge between Jews and the Jewish Homeland. Disgusting.
25. Salma
Yossef ,   Rehovot, Israel   (06.30.10)
Well, this is my offer : 1) Separate Gaza from Israel and the so-called Palestine. That is make Gaza a free independent republic or attach Gaza to Egypt. 2) Split Israel into Arab/Jewish/Druze/Beduin cantons with a full autonomy (including Police) for every canton (details must be negotiated). The Arab cantons could be attached to Jordan as a master state (militarized) or to the Jewish State. The Druze/Jewish/Beduin would be attached to the Jewish State. 3) Between the three masters States : Egypt/Israel/Jordan and the cantons, a confederation could be created to manage all the interactions : water/roads/trains/energy etc... Now, what do you offer Salma ? I am impatient to read you. (I will see if you are really serious.) BTW Did you noticed how everybody take care of you on this talkback? You are becoming our Palestinian Passionaria :)
26. his actions speak louder than any
Barney ,   USA   (06.30.10)
bs that he throws out. He should have been jailed for his past crimes. He has done nothing but incite against Jews and Israel and get fat off of his corrupt aid thefts. He learned from the best at that-arafat.
27. #25 Yossef, Rehovot
Said ,   Amman, Jordan   (06.30.10)
Although what you propose is intriguing, at a closer look, it is merely a rehashing of the idea that Gaza be given to Egypt and WB to Jordan. Are you suggesting that each canton has autonomy (laws, police, taxes, resources etc.) yet is federated with a parent country (sounds better than "master" country)? Essentially what you are alluding to is some sort of a Swiss system. There are many questions that I'm interested in hearing your answers for: Jewish settlements, resources, economic ties (movement of goods, border crossings etc.), military/police strength of each canton, elections. Please discuss.
28. Yossef,Although U ignored my Q. yesterday, but I will not do
Salma ,   Palestine   (06.30.10)
I'm sorry, Yossef..... I'll tell you a weighty Word In my humble opinion, i don't see any solution to the conflict between us, always there will be Palestinians and Jews who are not satisfied or convinced that this is the endpoint ! Will impose solutions, maybe! There will be quiet?maybe too, but a final solution, there is no :( I think it eternal struggle This is not my wish, I'm looking forward to lasting peace, but the bad guys in all the world will not let this region to be calm, you will remember my words, without a doubt in the future Palestinian Passionaria !!!!!!!!!!!!!
29. Said & Salma
Yossef ,   Israel   (06.30.10)
I am on my way to a trip in Europe now. I'll be happy to continue this discussion a little bit later. שבת שלום
30. I don't think
Yossef ,   Israel   (06.30.10)
that you are racist Salma, may be a little bit patronizing. Pay attention, a human being deserves respect and protection, may he be Arab, Jew, Druze or Beduin or whatever else. Have a nice evening.
Next talkbacks
Back to article