Opinion
Hypocrisy’s finest hour
Shaul Rosenfeld
Published: 30.07.10, 00:29
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
59 Talkbacks for this article
31. Semper Fi #5
M. Hartley ,   Atlanta, US   (07.30.10)
Haven't you heard? According to some people, we need to ask the f--tards, if it's OK first and, if we didn't do that to their liking, apologize that we had the nerve to defend ourselves. Our Freedoms were neither won, granted, nor remain freedoms thanks to politicians, but to our - US and IDF - soldiers and from me, thank you for your service! Maybe it's time the IDF, too, adopted one of Patton's "attitudes:" "As I walk through the valley of the Shadow Of Death, I have no fear because I am the meanest mother ****er in the whole valley" - Gen. George S. Patton BTW, late hubby was a US Marine, a Korean vet, and his birthday was Nov. 10th. I can march and sing "From the Halls," at least around the kitcchen table :-).
32. :: Anti-Israel hypocrisy?
Matty Groves ,   Fairport   (07.30.10)
No sane person can deny that the US, UK, Russia, China, Israel, etc have not committed war crimes. *Any* modern country with an army engaged in conflict is bound to commit a war crime at some stage. However the difference between the US, UK, Russia, China, etc and Israel is that these other countries have enough diplomatic clout to stop any international war crimes probe dead in its tracks. Israel on the other hand has no such diplomatic leverage except when the US steps in with its veto power. It should also be noted that none of the aforementioned countries have the gall to claim to be the ‘most moral army in the world’. I would also add that using the authors own logic Israel could well be accused of ‘anti-Iranian hypocrisy’. After all Israel *totally* ignores its own failing, shortcomings and utter lack of regard to international agreements and protocols when it comes to Israel’s clandestine nuclear programme. If hypocrisy was a crime Israel would be found equally guilty. Lastly ‘anti-Israel hypocrisy’ does not lessen or negate the seriousness of Israeli war crimes.
33. hypocrisy
avi ,   haifa   (07.30.10)
may i add a little info about the humane "british emire" by wiki: Diego García is a coral atoll of the British Indian Ocean Territory. In the 1960s, the Chagos archipelago was secretly leased to the United Kingdom and detached from Mauritius with the intention of expelling its entire population and establishing a military base. In 1971 the United Kingdom and United States entered an agreement under which the latter would set up a military base in Diego Garcia] Since then, the United Kingdom enforced the highly controversial depopulation of Diego Garcia, forcing the deportation of all 2,000 inhabitants of the island, who were descendants of African slaves and Hindu labourers brought to the islands by the French in the 18th century, to the surrounding islands, including Mauritius, located 1,200 miles away. In their place, a joint British-American military base was established. hear .hear mr camerom.
34. To #28
M. Hartley ,   Atlanta, US   (07.30.10)
Instead of offering your solutions, you repeat BS peddled ad nauseam by every loser in history. War may not be a good solution, but sometimes it's the only one or have you forgotten 1939 - 1945?? Also, why is it OK for the Palis to threaten to wipe Israel off the map, but it's unjust and illegal for Israel to make sure it won't happen?
35. go4freedom #28 your hypocracy
Gee ,   Zikron Yaakov   (07.30.10)
Your trouble is ignorance. It is our land period. The UN Charter, Covenant of the League of Nations and the San Remo Treaty all state that it our land and cannot be given to another group or government. Why don't you show us a single legal claim by the Arabs for the land? Bet you can't. We are not expanding our lands, the border defined in those lands is all land west of the Jordan River. I eagerly await you challenge to those facts. Go ahead I dare you.
36. hypocrisy
moron ,   animal farm   (07.30.10)
excellent discussion--now let us read how israel tries to appease this way of thinking and how instead it must think and act to win
37. Hypocracy
Yoel ,   Ossining,NY   (07.30.10)
#3 Hartley...Well said.
38. What a p*ss & moan session!
Cameron ,   USA   (07.30.10)
Those who forever hold themselves up as exemplars of a higher morality & virtue must expect to be held to a higher standard of conduct by others.
39. Dr Shaul Rosenfeld - Delusional!
Dino Domingo ,   Vancouver, Canada   (07.30.10)
this can't be put any other way than that, you Dr and many others like you are delusional! to what music do you want the rest of the world to dance to? one day you want the US, Britain, China, Russia and everyone else (not just you but most Jews)..to impose sanctions, support your wild fantasies that Iraq had WMD, fight your battles for you on several different fronts and receive BIG BROTHERS support by using their veto when you decide to arrogantly refuse what the rest of the world considers International Law. NOW you decide to use these examples to your advantage... most of the examples you gave were dealt with on an International level, objective inquiries held (not like your countires inquiries) and show world diplomacy unlike your people! you are an ignorant person Dr. if this is the way the average Jewish person sees life its better they all live in Israel. my only hope is to see one day people like you stop being disrespectful and hopefully countries like Britain, US, Russia, Italy... countries most of you Jews take daily liberties on daily, dont turn their back on you completely! if they ever did (which would be hard considering all the powerful US Jews) you would be serving drinks and washing cars for Muslims today!
40. British politics
British drops   (07.30.10)
for money and business deals,UK drops their knickers very quickly
41. Don't worry so much ...
Robert Renders ,   Belgium   (07.30.10)
Whatever you may see on the news, and whatever you may hear from Europe's leaders, please understand that most people here still love and support Israel, and are impressed by its incredible accomplishments.
42. #20
Dana Rothschild ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (07.30.10)
back off split, you antisemitic maniac! its about usa and britain, not about israel...
43. Put to music by Yedida Freilich
Izzy ,   NYC USA   (07.31.10)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OaGHUZ-8DWw Kol HaKovod to Yedida to quote: Rak Yisrael ayl zachoor lahagen Key m"dam yehudi ha'olam m'talem
44. Solution to the Middle East crises
Alex ,   Toronto, Canada   (07.31.10)
Since the origin of all problems in the middle east is the arbitrary way Brits divided the area I suggest that Britan should take all Palestinian arabs in. Britan is fast becoming a Islamic state anyway. Might as well expedite the process.
45. Enough with bull; accept the facts
Truth Seeker ,   US   (07.31.10)
It is amazing how people ignore simple facts and instead drag whatever they can into a discussion to bend the truth and try to justify wrong-doings: Gaza is an OPEN AIR PRISON!!! Those don't agree, they should put you there for a while for you to get the picture... Flotilla incident was plain old murder; PERIOD!!! The so great IDF in a pre-meditated fashion killed civilians on international waters. Ask yourselves why other methods were not used to stop the flotilla on its tracks such as disabling the propellers of the ships. Ask yourselves why IDF stormed the ship using live ammunition and military weapons against so called slingshots, rods and other make shift weapons. Could they have not resorted to other means of crowd-control?? Shame on you people!!!
46. #39..DINO - DELUSIIONAL RACIST LACKING KNOWLEDGE
ABRAHAM ben JACOB ,   CANADA   (07.31.10)
A BIT OF AN ANTI-SEMITE HERE, AND AN UNDER INFORMED ONE AS WELL. DINO, THE RACIST STATES...... " most of you Jews take daily liberties ". AS A CANADIAN I SUPPORT OUR OWN TROOPS IN CANADA'S WAR IN AFGHANISTAN. BUT DON'T PRETEND THAT ISREAL CAN'T FIGHT IT'S OWN BATTLES. DID YOU JUST WAKE UP ?? ISRAEL HAS BEAT THE ARMIES OF 5 ARAB COUNTRIES...........OR DID YOU SLEEP THROUGH THIS ??
47. I Have lost Respect...
Unbiased ,   Saudi Arabia   (07.31.10)
...fo.r that Scotish O'Bamron
48. cameron delusional
avi ,   haifa   (07.31.10)
maybe somebody should educate mr. cameron that he is not a 19th century british PM, but that britain is today - even to european standards - a second to third class country and that his kneefall before a terrorist group like hamas is noted in Israel as "totally unacceptable".
49. Follow the money
Mahlon Drumgoole ,   Newark NJ USA   (07.31.10)
This British administration and its leader, Cameron, will go down in history as the worst since Chamberlain. They allowed the Lockerbie plane bombing to go free at the urging of the criminal organization named BP Oil. It seems as if there were hundreds of millions dollars for BP if the criminal were releaqsed. The staging of the "medical" findings were a callous attempt to draw attention away from the release of a mass murderer. In essence, BP and the govt spit on each and every parent, relative, and friend of the murdered passengers. Now this cynical and vile antisemitic Prime Minister wants to earn brownie points with Turkey and the other Islamists. Follow the money.
50. #39
fenfen ,   london, UK   (07.31.10)
#39 you are a very scarey man. regrettfully ther are (too) many like you. I wish you peace and happiness
51. Brit politicos..... ugh!
Stephen Goyim ,   Manchester UK   (07.31.10)
Forget Cameron & the rest of these liars. They have no mandate to speak on behalf of the British nation. A bunch of idiots,& so are the people who voted for them.
52. Dana @ 40
split ,   USA   (07.31.10)
Can't live without tagging can we ? No dana it's not about US and the Brits it's about deliberete and unintentional. Last night you killed Hamas dude that was suppose to die couple years ago when you bombed his residence knowing that his wife and his five children are there with him ,... He wasn't there but pregnant mom and her 5 children died that night ,...
53. #52
Israel Israeli ,   Tel Aviv   (08.01.10)
Let's compare. Hamas openly declares it will exterminate the Jews and attacks Israeli civilians with rockets. You say Israel tried to kill a Hamas leader to stop these attacks and accidentally killed his children. On the other hand, no Afghan has ever attacked America and they couldn't attack America even if they wanted. Yet, when the CIA informed Obama that if they attacked Mustafa Abu al-Yazid they would exterminate his family, Obama gave the order. Obama ordered the attack that led to the murder of Yazid's wife, three daughters and INFANT granddaughter. Was there a clear and present danger? For Israel, yes. For the US no. Was every precaution taken to avoid innocent deaths? Israel tried and failed, Obama explicitly ordered the murder to make an example of Yazid. Did Israel have a choice? No. Did the US have a choice? The greatest nation in the world, with endless amounts of money, satellites, UAVs and the CIA certainly could have killed Yazid without murdering the baby. Israel is fighting a war and is innocent of war crimes. The US murdered a baby girl for no reason. Obama is a war criminal.
54. Just protect Israel and let them all stuff it.
B.E. ,   Whangarei, N.Z.   (08.01.10)
55. #54
Dan the Jafa ,   Auckland, Aotearoa   (08.01.10)
Amen to that, brother. I only wish NZ Herald was not so militantly anti-Semi.... er.... of course I mean anti-Zionist.
56. The atrocities of others
Sean ,   Montreal, Quebec   (08.02.10)
Should not be an excuse. Far too often on this site one witnesses the justification for inhumane transgressions by citing the most egregious regimes. This is the never ending echo of the Zionist's cry. Why point us out? There are other bad guys in the world. What a bizarre ethic!
57. #46 - you are a sick human...
Dino Domingo ,   Vancouver, Canada   (08.02.10)
for calling me an anti semite... but thats all people like you do! anytime someone makes a true comment that isn't pro Israel they are an anti semite. you are wrong, I am pro Israel and completely anti Islam...if I am a racist it is againt Islam and not Judaism but I don't have to agree with everything that is Jewish/Israeli...in fact many things bother me about Israeli policies but I am not an anti semite! per you comment about " most of you Jews take daily liberties ".... why is that anti semetic you retard...Jewish people refer to themselves as Jews everyday...just as blacks refer to themselves as n word and so on!
58. #57 Name tagging is wrong but answer this
Settler ,   "Occupied" Territory   (08.02.10)
I agree name-tagging is quite unproductive and just leads to added enmity, but please answer, how will us Israelis be washing Arab cars when we DESTROYED their united forces in 1948, 1956, 1967, 1973, 1982 and so on. I'd like to see Arabs who would dare challenge Israel as a whole without using cowardly, deceitful tactics (What the World Press tactfully calls 'Resistance') and without the two-facedness an on International stage. Answer is: they WOULDN'T! Why? You ask, WHY? they know they are so much STRONGER! Why can't they come out and show us the full mighty power of their 2nd Camelry Division? Answer is; They know that camels, however far they spit, can't defeat ISRAEL. To put it simply: They are afraid of being CREAMED. Erev Tov U'Kol Tuv, David
59. Mr Settler
Dino Domingo ,   Vancouver, Canada   (08.02.10)
it is a well known fact that Israel is a country today with the full support of the US and most of the West, whether you're going to acknowledge this or not is definitely out of my control. The amount of money the US funds Israel along with the weapons it has from the US has given Israel a huge advantage...but even Israel knows Iran, Syria, Jordan and if Turkey helps... Israel can be in a major pickle! Your jokes are humorous to yourself and other people who like to think of Israel as a super power... just as you people say your military men and women are of a higher level than other nations...well, based on what we read daily about all the controversies and the whole GI Joe Flotilla fiasco... the only people who think Israel is untouchable is Israelis...but not all of them... just the geeks like you! a lot of Jewish people are just like you (we dont need anybody attitude)...and then in the very next breath its Obama's fault or Britain are two faced traitors or Germans are this and Turks are that... I hope you are never deserted by your allies but i think for one day it may be ok for people like you to be humbled! Creamed ehh?? so then why couldn't you beat Hezbollah 4 years ago? a piece of crap terrorist organisation shooting missles from holes in the ground and they kicked your ass! Israel was soo embarassed they had to destroy anything and everything in sight because they couldnt stand being exposed by a bunch of thugs organised better than the Israeli military! Creamed??? By the way... talking about cowards... phospherous bombs on a UN site! need I say more?
Previous talkbacks
Back to article