Jewish Scene
Haredi press praises kids' deportation
Kobi Nahshoni
Published: 03.08.10, 07:30
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
52 Talkbacks for this article
31. PERHAPS THE "JEWISH CHARACTER" NEEDS TO CHANGE ...BADLY
jewish doctor ,   NYC USA   (08.03.10)
SHAME ON THOSE WHO USE/HIDE BEHIND THEIR SUPERSTITIOUS NONSENSE TO HURT AND HARM CHILDREN... the whole world sees the shameful treatment by the loonies/heredi. shame shame shame!
32. #1 I agree with you grandpa
israel   (08.03.10)
33. these kids won't burn tires and fight
miri   (08.03.10)
the police like the haridim do AND they will go to the army and contribute something to the country which is more than the haridim do. I'm with Dorothy: I'd rather live next door to them than to a Mea Sharim family with 8 kids.
34. shame on them
Ana ,   Latin America   (08.03.10)
1. If haredim were working probably there was no need to bring foreign workers 2. If these people deported did not have reason to hate Israel, now they have it.
35. TO # 1
DAVID R ,   HERZLIA,ISRAEL   (08.03.10)
do youhave a degree in being racists?, the demographic time bomb is due to the huge amount of haredim doing no work, doing no army service and contributing absolutely a big 0 to this country. That is the time bomb, too many parasites.
36. Common Sense
nr ,   los angeles, ca   (08.03.10)
I live in California and this our debate too - but the illegals will stay because this is a big country that can absorb them. Israel does not have the luxury. Anyone who says the illegals are in Israel because the haredi won't work are pigs - they are there because they work cheap, the same reason they are here. Which means that anyone hiring them is responsible for their living conditions, which sounds like hell on earth. Guess that makes all you bleeding hearts not as ethical as you thought.
37. #16
steven ,   tel aviv   (08.03.10)
In no over western country I have to change my religion to get citizenship,or to be able to live there
38. DISGUSTING BEYOND BELIEF
David ,   Los Angeles   (08.03.10)
This is exactly what Pharaoh said about Bnai Yisroel. And every antisemite throughout history too. And people wonder why people hate the Chareidim, who refuse to do a decent day's work but want to throw out the children of those who do, and justify it on the same grounds Pharaoh persecuted the Children of Israel. Have they no shame at all? I guess we know the answer to that!
39. Wonder When Bunnie Is Moving To Israel?
World Citizen ,   the world   (08.03.10)
His being the most zionist of American Jews i.e. out Jewing even the Abe Foxman (but still living in LA and all that.) He must be in torment all the time. I wonder how much money goes to his psychoanalyst each month?
40. Out with all these intruders!!!!!
Phoenix ,   Israel   (08.03.10)
I am not haredi but I also Praise this action. We do not need these strangers and we do not owe them nothing. They always will be intruders that enter our country ilegaly with the only goal to stay here without no permission what so ever. Israel it's the Land of the Jews!!!!!!! Out with the infiltrators, future corruptors and ennemies in our midsts. Out!
41. Bunnie is well known
David ,   Los Angeles   (08.03.10)
People demonstrate outside his store because of racist signs he displayed. And the Jewish community in LA has condemned him.
42. #39 , we don't need this bunnie here
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (08.03.10)
We have already more than enough of such "people"
43. Inventing the News?
Jake in Jerusalem ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (08.03.10)
Wow. Ynet is reporting on... what a Haredi publication reported... as if this is journalism. The Haredi view noted in your article is mostly level-headed and sensible, even if not worded very well. All countries have immigration regulations and deport illegals of all ages. Israel can do the same. In other news today, it seems that 4,500 Olim are expected from North America this year. Compared to the 20,000 "olim" who will arrive from Somalia, Eritrea and Sudan - almost all of them Muslims - the Jewish aliya is insignificant. Israel's Jewishness is already today noticeably diminished. Ultra-liberal immigration policies only make things worse. Just because a political stance is voiced by Haredim doesn't make it wrong, no matter how secular, liberal or Leftist one may be. Does common sense have any future in Israel?
44. Israel was not created for the goyim!
Jacob ,   New York   (08.04.10)
When did the founders of Israel envision her to be a state where goyim of the world would come and settle. They don't fight our wars, they're not Jewish, they're not educated or highly skilled. Israel is a tiny country with very limited resources, a country that barely has enough of its Jewish population. Naturalizing 250,000 illegals would not only encourage illegal immigration, but also destroy the state of Israel demographically. The Jews of Israel are already facing a dire threat demographically, add more to the ranks of the non-Jews only exacerbates the problem. All the liberals in Israel who have embraced 'Postmodernism', 'Multiculturalism' and 'Transnationalism' know nothing about the Zionism and the seeds that will lead to Israel's destruction. The United States is already crumbling, thanks to the liberals who divide and rule and continually add entitlement programs without paying for them. Am Yisrael Chai!
45. Deporting
Hillis ,   Florida   (08.04.10)
For the sake of Israel I suggest they keep the foreign workers in Israel and deport those ant-Zionist Haredim. Israel has enough problems without those trouble makers.
46. obscene hillul hashem
yakov ,   jer is   (08.04.10)
the audacity to say it even if thats what everybody knew how they felt- is whats so scary- to deport children is a throw-back to nazi era politics where ideology replaces common sense and caring about human life
47. WE want your money- not them
Rachmeil ,   MechburgUSA   (08.04.10)
Maybe they're afraid money that they mooch from everyone else in Israel will go to someone else, other than them?
48. foreign children
gadot ,   herzlia   (08.04.10)
i have had foreign studend in my classes,the speak hebrew,are more israeli then the ultras,the parents work and at 18 go into the army.
49. Illegal incoming
Antonio ,   Spain   (08.04.10)
Look, here in Spain we're suffering something like you in Israel: Moroccans, Romanians, Rusians, etc. are coming, staying and multiplicating here either by tourism or by 'pateras' and any other illegal infiltration. The guilty is only (here and there) of Goverments. It's very easy to prevent, but there isn't decissions at all. Signal now only the kids is a great mistake: the error is maintain their parents. Thus, the kids are only the victims (and the 'hardware' sometimes) of their parents' decissions. And please, take good note that Jews are and had been inmigrants around the world, just like Spanish people and, in fact, people from all the world.
50. A picture speaks a thousand words!
Bob ,   Brooklyn NY, USA   (08.04.10)
Take a look at the woman in this picture [ http://www.ynetnews.com/Images/Thumbnails/magdelet4_English.gif ], top left. It looks like the reason she doesn't have time to get a passport is - forget about the fact that she can't write (to apply for one) - SHE CAN'T READ HEBREW!!!
51. #41 Indeed SHE is...
Sir Humphrey Appleby ,   Whitehall, UK   (08.05.10)
http://la.indymedia.org/news/2005/01/121154_comment.php I wish I had such publicity... Alas, I am just a humbel Civil Servant and obey my masters wishes.
52. haredi press praises the kids deportation
olim hadash ,   tel Aviv-israel   (08.05.10)
Since the founding of the state a cultural war is going on about the character of the state.The ruling classes do all what they can in order to dillute/destroy the jewish character of the state.But as in old Egypt : The more they suffered the more they multiplied.
Previous talkbacks
Back to article