News
Lebanese officer: Border incident won't repeat itself
Roee Nahmias
Published: 13.08.10, 12:46
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
28 Talkbacks for this article
1. Although everybody knows
Johnny ,   Nazareth   (08.13.10)
that the assassination was carried out by Lebanese army, they continue with their ugly lies. This phrase made me laugh : "General Jean Kahwaji clarifies his army has no plans to launch war against Israel"... LOL
2. General Jean Kahwaji
PAL   (08.13.10)
Oh, how very thoughtful of you, wise choice because you will not be a General of an Army, but merely an attendant take tickets at the entrance to the car park you use to call a country.
3. "Hezbollah refuses to hand info over" - hahaha!
mike ,   israel (formerly usa   (08.13.10)
hizbullah won't hand evidence of israel's involvement in hariri's assassination because their info is RUBBISH and they know it! anyone that will objectively examine it will know it's rubbish, and hizbullah knows it! what a gang of incompetent, paranoid losers those fanatical iranian boot-lickers hizbullah are.
4. An road inside israel used by the Lebanese army?
Charles ,   Cleveland   (08.13.10)
Israel should at least set up toll stations to help pay the cost for its defense against Hizbullah.
5. Kahwaji
E1   (08.13.10)
UN already found who is responsible, so take full responsibility instead of telling stories of firing in the air, etc It will help us to believe that such incidents will not repeat, as you are ready to commit
6. for how long will the west be fooled by the arabs? enouth!
dominique ,   paris, france   (08.13.10)
7. It better not
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (08.13.10)
Because if it does, Israel will have a new northern border. We're not interested in playing with Hizbollah or their little toadies, the Lebanese "army."
8. # 6
John ,   Herzliya, Israel   (08.13.10)
As long as the western media will buy and publish whatever lie the Arabs will think of. Just check your media. Whatever they say is published as a pure gold, but the next day when the truth comes out they don't give a shit about it and don't report it.
9. Criminal organization.
Dr D. ,   Jerusalem   (08.13.10)
In all major criminal organization an assassination is a test of "good faith"and submission to the boss. The more difficult the task , the more honor and estime is gained. Killing or trying to kill a Jew is purely an exam . The sniper that killed our officer guaranteed him self a job and a position for life with any Lebanese faction under the protection of the UNIFIL.
10. Israeli hospitality
Serge ,   Antwerp, Belgium   (08.13.10)
This general confirms Israeli hospitality by letting the lebanese, including the Lebanese army to use Israeli roads, however accepting hospitality is not enough for Lebanese, they take propriety of what they use.
11. General Jean
J.K. ,   Brooklyn USA   (08.13.10)
Is this General high on somthing ?,since when does the commander of the Lebanese army decide whether to go to war against Israel or not,such decisions are made far away from Lebanon, by the big brothers the Ayatollas in Iran,and as a loyal vassal of Iran he will obey the orders.
12. What???
M Carr ,   Baltimore   (08.13.10)
"The tree they wanted to trim may be on the Israeli side of the Blue Line, but there is also a road there, which is used by the Lebanese and the army.” I’m confused. Does this mean that a Lebanese road cuts through Israeli territory? What geniuses set that up? If it is true then it needs to be fixed. In light of the deadly border incident, all Lebanese should remain north of the Blue Line! NO exceptions!
13. That's Because If lebanon Does
Brazen   (08.13.10)
The Israeli's are prepared to open a CAN OF WHOOP ASS on hizbullah and they KNOW IT !!!
14. #12 The Blue Line Is Not The Official Border
World Citizen ,   the world   (08.13.10)
It is just a supposedly temporary truce line set up in 1992 by a UN negotiator when Israel withdrew from its occupation of southern Lebanon. There are disputes about where the true border lies. The Shebaa Farms area is one particular area where Israel occupies land definitely claimed by Lebanon. The one important thing about this story is that it notes that Lebanese troops did fire over the heads of the Israeli troops in order to warn them away from the area. It was Israeli troops that returned artillery fire and rockets launched from helicopters that led to the first deaths (Lebanese). The Lebanese then returned fire and that is when the Israeli officer was shot and killed.
15. World Citizen is a liar
Gee ,   Zikron Yaakov   (08.13.10)
The blue-line is the border - the UN already determined that. Who cares what the Arabs claim? Just because they claim something is not a fact. Since Arabs usually lie, that should taken into account. The Lebanese fired and kill an IDF officer and wounded another period. There were no shots fired over anybody's head. Then we returned fire. Those are the facts and your lies will not change those facts. In any case firing over the heads of Israelis in Israel constitutes an act of war. Lebanon DECLARED war in 1948 and is still at a state of war. Our response can be anything we want.
16. Clarify this please?
Josh ,   Montreal, Canada   (08.13.10)
So because the Lebanon has a road near the border, this
17. Clarify this please?
Josh ,   Montreal, Canada   (08.13.10)
To me it's like saying yes we instigated the incident, but it's not our fault because we have a road close by. Forget about the stipulation of not using weapons to attack American allies, does America really want to arm an army who sits back or facilitates terrorist organizations in taking over the capital, well is quick to attack another country because they have a road near by?
18. to #14 World Citizen-correction
Yaakov ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (08.13.10)
1) Shebba farms absolutely does not belong to Lebanon. Even on Lebanese newspaper sites I have read Lebanese admit that and mention no credible Lebanese historian claims that Sheba Farms is Lebanese. 2) Hezbollah created the claim in order to justify its existence which has two objectives: a) Occupation,infiltration, oppression of Lebanon on behalf of Iran and Syria b) Make war with ISrael to destroy it. 3) The Border incident little by little the Lebanese Army admits the truth...before they didn't admit anything and claimes that IDF corssed border/blue line. The Lebanese are still lying about who shot to kill first. The UN admited that LAF fired frirst (NOT IN THE AIR- that is what the IDf does). Another fact that belies the truth is that the Soldier-tree trimer who was closest to the LAF position was not shot at but rather high profile targers i.e. Officers were the ones host by the LAF snipers. Stop being so biased. And how about printing at least your real first name.
19. #14 World Apart
Hal ,   Usa   (08.13.10)
Exactly which world are you a citizen of ?
20. #15 According To You Everyone Lies Except The Israelis
World Citizen ,   the world   (08.13.10)
And your statement "Our response can be anything we want." Well that says it all. You're special. You're Israelis. You are the Chosenites and the Chosenites get to kill anyone because their "god" told them they were better than anyone else. What a f*cked up religion and culture.
21. To World Citizen.
servant3   (08.14.10)
In the Christian Old Testament which is very close to the Jewish Tanakh, God never told the Israelis to kill anyone they want. God told them to kill and destroy a specific group of people at that time. God did not command them to kill anyone they want nor to kill other groups of people aside from the defense of their nation. Actually written both in the Old Testament and Tanahk, God made Babylon and Persia invade Israel to punish them. There were more times when God allowed bad thing to happen to them in the past because of their being stubborn. However, God's promises to them will not change. But, He will not spoil them either. Part of God's discipline on them is allowing the whole world to hate them. All of this is written in the book of prophecies, both in the Bible and in the Tanakh. Things that are happening now has been foretold long time ago. So, I am not surprise with people like you. Being God's chosen people does not mean God will spoil them. They were chosen to spread the good news of God. But, they are not doing that job. That is why God is allowing these things to happen to them. I realize that by writing this note, I could invoke anger from a lot of people. Please stay neutral! Pray to God to reveal to you the truth. And, if you do not believe in Him, tell Him to reveal himself to you if He is real! Do yourself a favor, read the Bible, read the Tanakh, and also read the Koran and other religious books. Compare them. Do not just go with the crowd and echo their voices!
22. "World" Citizen is from Mars
Ivan b. ,   Santa Clara, USA   (08.14.10)
Maybe on that planet up is down and black is white. The UN, which is no friend of Israel, unequivocally stated that the Lebanese army shot and killed the Israeli officer before Israel returned fire. Also on Mars, they must teach writing but not reading!
23. 18 yakov - you are confused.
David ,   USA   (08.14.10)
Yes there is also confusion regarding Shebba Farms weather it is Syrian or Lebanese territory but there is no confusion what so ever it is not Israeli. Israel is using this confusion to hold it but it has never claimed it as its own.
24. # 20 world citizen, reread
Eli ,   Haifa   (08.14.10)
No no, world citizen. When he says we can do whatever we want, he means we can do whatever we want to survive. It was Lebanon and the other Arab states ( not Israel) that declared war in 1948 and who have so far refused to make peace. Would you prefer we lay down our weapons and be eliminated by our savage neighbors? And it has nothing to do with religion or god. I am an atheist, but I love my people and I love my land. I have no problem with anyone else unless they threaten that.
25. #15 and #20
Omri ,   Israel   (08.14.10)
#15 Lebanon was democratic at start they only became a muslim country later on, thats why they wornt even involved in the 6-day war. #20 Not everyone in israel and in the jewish world thinks like him and its especialy not in the zionist ideology to do so. Dont be stupid and take that one guy who is extrem and say all the jews are like that. And notice he had a point at some level. When lebanon is in a state of war with us we can legaly invade them or bomb them or anything like that. Of course this can all end if they would make peace with israel, something some islamic fanatics will never do.
26. Israel made if very clear to lebanon...
RichinBoston ,   Boston USA   (08.14.10)
another incident like this and it will cost labanon's infrastructure three times as much as the last round. 12 Billion dollars feeds a lot of hungry people. That shut em up.
27. Mr. Kahwaji
Maxim Levy ,   USA   (08.14.10)
Border incident won't repeat itself... I agree Mr. kahwaji. Better not for your own good and for the good of the Lebanese people. Your next act of agression against Israel, will change Lebanon for good. On the other hand, Lebanon could use a posotive free change from the evil grip of Iran , Syria, and Hezbollah.
28. omri is right
avi ,   haifa   (08.14.10)
what we call today lebanon is a territory carved out the french mandate of syria to become a christian and french oriented state on our northern border. without any dispute the lebanese attacked israel in 48 and since then they consider themselves to be at war of us. mow lebanon is no christian emclave but a muslim and hesbollah ruled state with a triggerhappy army. israel has no dispute with lebanon. even the UN does not recognize the sheeba farm as lebanese territory. since the UN drew the blue line lebanon has to recognize this line as it's southern border. UN re, 425. the difference to the mandate border is minimal and goes not more -at some places - about 400 m im the one or other direction. if the lebanese don't accept the green line drawn by the UN they are welcome to draw together with the israelis a final border during peactalks.
Back to article