News
German judge sets 'Uri Brodsky' free on bail
Associated Press
Published: 13.08.10, 16:01
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
30 Talkbacks for this article
1. doesnt dubai want him
ali ,   dubai   (08.13.10)
what about the uae and interpole isnt he wanted by them he was involved in a murder or is he a victim
2. Dahi Al-khalafan will not accept this farcical :(
Salma ,   Palestine   (08.13.10)
3. Germany is NOW crime accomplice in Dubai Killing
Tayfun_Turkey ,   Istanbul   (08.13.10)
4. Some good news from Germany...
Chris Rettenmoser ,   Bayerisch Gmain Germ   (08.13.10)
Sorry for all of you hypocrites...who wanted Mr. Brodsky to be arrested...
5. Look at the picture
William ,   Israel   (08.13.10)
See him hiding his face? If he was innocent why would he hide his face?
6. revealing his face, even if innocent, will ruin his life.
A   (08.13.10)
7. #5 He hides his face because
b. David ,   usa   (08.13.10)
He is a Mossad agent you fool. Do you think Israel and the Mossad wants the face of one of their agents spread across the world? If that were to happen the Mossad would certainly have to dispose of him.
8. to #1,#2,#3
Roman ,   Brooklyn   (08.13.10)
He isn't wanted for murder, he's wanted for helping to take out the trash. Trash being the Hamas murderer that you had freely roaming around Dubai. Germany knows it has no moral high ground in this matter, or any other.....for a while. God bless Mossad, god bless Israel and the Jewish people. Brodsky is another faceless hero who will never be thanked for all the sacrifices he makes for his nation.
9. #1: killing a terrorist is not "murder"
david ,   new york   (08.13.10)
a simple "thank you" to israel would have sufficed. god willing america does the same to osama bin laden and his crew.
10. Brodsky
i love Israel ,   Germany   (08.13.10)
Good decision by German Justice to free a man who was involved in hunting down a real criminal.
11. Thank you Germany! Israel's best friend.
Israguy ,   Tel Aviv   (08.13.10)
12. Thank you Germany. Now arrest Turkish Chemical War Criminals
Tayfun_Turkey ,   Istanbul   (08.13.10)
13. #5 You don't sound like our William
Mark ,   Lodz, Poland   (08.13.10)
14. DON'T ANTICIPATE VERDICT
Ian ,   Newcastle upon Tyne,   (08.13.10)
So far Brodski hasn't been found guilty of anything.Evidence that can stand up to scrutiny has to be produced,not Dubai allegations. He may be found not guilty for all we know.German justice is not political. THREE CHEERS FOR ISRAEL!!!
15. He should just leave the country...
Mark from Georgia ,   USA   (08.13.10)
And disappear. If he was involved with the hit, that's fine with me. At worst, he's guilty of killing a weapons smuggle, murderer, and a planner of murders. So who really cares? Except terrorists and their supporters here on these boards.
16. He should leave Germany and never go back.
Rivkah   (08.13.10)
Courts in America have a habit of reniging on agreements like with Jonathan Pollard who signed a plea bargain that was afterwards revoked and he was sent to prison for what seems to be a life sentence for giving information to Israel that former Defense Secretary Caspar Weinberger said was inconsequential. He was shocked at the indefinite imprisonment of Pollard,.
17. Thank you Germany
Brad   (08.13.10)
The number 1 ally of Israel.
18. #5 William
Seth ,   Washington, DC   (08.13.10)
That's perhaps the dumbest talkback I've ever read on YNET and that's saying something
19. To 12- imposter:Tayfun_Turkey is distinctive in dedication
Tayfun_Turkey ,   Istanbul   (08.13.10)
to facts Turkey never use Chemical weapons Turkish army has no chemical weapon inventories However Israel, USA and Nato use chemicals against muslim also depleted uranium
20. @19 Tayfun
Sunshine ,   Germany   (08.13.10)
Ups, you are critizing Germany for releasing a man just charged for passport fraud. Wasn't it Turkey which just released 6 men charged for raping a female German tourist 2 weeks ago? I wonder which crime is more worse. I'm grateful that the German justice works in this case and hope Uri will have a safe return to Israel.
21. #19; Tayfun_Turkey; I know it is tough...
Mark from Georgia ,   USA   (08.13.10)
Sometimes to accept the facts, especially when they hurt your feelings. I mean that sincerely, not sarcastically. I believe all people want to be proud of their country, some people refer to it as "patriotism". And there is nothing wrong with that. But the fact is this, your country has committed this crime against humanity. Doctor's and people who specialize in these kinds of crimes don't make these kinds of charges lightly. It is easy through observation and tissue testing to determine exactly what was used and how long ago it took place and a myriad of other facts. I'm sorry for you, but that doesn't extend to excuse your country and its new trend. Some would say not new at all...when you look at the Kurds and Armenians. Your country, at least the government, is sleeping with the devil. When you dance with Devil, you don't change the Devil, the Devil changes you!
22. Now arrest #19 for committing identity theft and being Jihad
Tayfun_Turkey ,   Istanbul   (08.13.10)
Real Turks are not Arabs, but #12 is. Adopting filthy murderous Islam is against Turkish soul.
23. To Sunshine and Imposter-Do not compare Turkey with else
Tayfun_Turkey ,   Istanbul   (08.13.10)
It CANNOT be true Turkey will release any rape crime suspect. It is quite sensitive issue and any rape crime will not be tolerated neither against Germans or anybody else Even Prisons in Turkey is not good place for Rape criminals, they are mostly killed in prison as Prisoners refuse to stay in the same place with Rape criminals. As for imposter;I am not arab, no relation with arabs except for ruling them for a few centuries You are more closer to arabs in anything including bloodlines.
24. URI THE SPY
MARIO ,   USA   (08.13.10)
Germany needs to have fairness in dealing with criminals like Uri and his accomplices. They should keep Uri, put him through an open and fair court of justice. The head of the Mossad should also be tried and jailed. Thanks.
25. Israel + Germany = Allies !!!
kornblumenblau ,   Münsterland/Germany   (08.13.10)
26. # 24 MARIO THE JUDGE
Dorothea Killus ,   Germany   (08.14.10)
I am proud that Germany acted as it did.
27. not proud..
go4freedom ,   germany   (08.14.10)
i am deeply ashamed of what happened here in europe. "brodsky" was assisting in a murder. germany wanted to put him on trial for forgery AND "spying". why did the polish court demand germany to drop the "spying" charge? "brodksy" could have also been charged with assisting in a murder here. this has nothing to do with justice. i am deeply ashamed that this could happen.. mossad is committing crimes!!
28. German #1 allies? What about Poland?
Justine   (08.15.10)
Germany released him, but why did they issue the warrant in the first place? Maybe they changed their mind, but don't forget that the Polish court only agreed to extradite him on lesser charges which limited the power of the German court.
29. WHEN WILL GERMANY EXTRADITE MAHMOUD ABBAS?
Ian ,   Newcastle upon Tyne,   (08.15.10)
By his OWN admission Abbas was the paymaster of the terrorists who carried out the 1972 Olympics Massacre of Israelis in Munich,and that place is in GERMANY.Yet Abbas swans in and out of Europe without a murmur from anybody. Brodsky's alleged offences pale into insignificance compared to Abbas's. There's one rule for terrorist-in-suits politicians and another for Israelis subjected to insinuations from Dubai. THREE CHEERS FOR ISRAEL!!!
30. #29 You're right...
Soeren ,   Cologne/Germany   (08.15.10)
... the more as there is – according to German law – no limitation of time when it comes to murder (a consequence from the crimes of the Third Reich)... On the other side – there is "realpolitik".
Back to article