News  Magazine
The Persian prince
Yossi Yehoshua, Reuven Weiss
Published: 16.08.10, 19:11
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
46 Talkbacks for this article
1. The paratroopers reconquered the Temple Mount.
(08.16.10)
The Temple Mount is far more important than one of it's walls. "Har HaBayit B'Yadeinu" - "The Temple Mount is in our hands!" was what was proclaimed.
2. Story needs to be told on Israel's Farsi program
Raymond in DC ,   Washington, USA   (08.16.10)
Israel's Broadcast Authority has a long running program in Farsi with an audience extending beyond Iran's Jews. (They call in via a European phone number.) Yosef's story would certainly resonate among Iran's young listeners. I expect his skills in Farsi could also prove useful to Israeli intelligence.
3. A wonderful story
Eaglebeak ,   Left Coast, USA   (08.16.10)
May God richly bless this man and his family.
4. fake story
borzog ,   usa   (08.16.10)
since iranians don't accept non islamic soldiers.
5. Mazel Tov!
Arthur ,   SF, CA   (08.16.10)
It's a joy to read that another sweet Jewish neshuma managed to escape and come to the Land of Israel. Yashar Koach!!
6. beautiful story
just want to comment ,   israel/usa   (08.16.10)
its a beautiful story!!!!
7. to #4 Borzog- Islamic armies
Yaakov ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (08.16.10)
Specifically regarding Iran I have neither confirmed nor denied. However, it is common knowledge that Islamic Sharia Law demands that non-muslims (who sre still alive) as second class citizens must join the Islamic army.
8. Something fishy,...
split ,   usa   (08.16.10)
Why the remaining 25 000 Jews in Iran didn't immigrate to Israel despite financial incentives like a ($10.000.00 per person) if they have such a hard time living there?
9. Your stupiidity is not fake.It is real!
jason white ,   afula,israel   (08.16.10)
The iranians used force to take in Jewish youngsters into their army during the war with iraq. They will take in anyone to brainwash them. You do not have to worry, you have nothing to wash.
10. #4 if you don't know don't talk BS
LOL   (08.16.10)
Jews are required to serve in the Iranian army and they fulfill their military obligation as required of all Iranians. don't listen anymore to your grnadmother's stories
11. #10 show me one jew serving in iranian army
borzog ,   usa   (08.16.10)
or iranian link which shows that they take jews in iranian army. this story is fabricated.
12. # 4 & # 8 ' prejudice '
David Fakheri ,   los angles   (08.17.10)
13. :: Borzog - #11
Matty Groves ,   Fairport   (08.17.10)
Iranian Jews are, obviously, citizens of Iran and therefore are required to abide by Iranian laws including army conscription (generally 2 years in the army). Many proud Iranian Jews did take part in the Iran/Iraq war as they were Iranian. If you want proof you just have to Google to get see that you are mistaken.
14. I personally know someone
Noach ,   USA   (08.17.10)
There is a difference between the revolutionary guard Corp and the Army. Noone except die-hards are allowed into the guard corps. However, the army is open to non-Muslims. I personally know a Jew that was forced to serve...
15. This shows the kind of faith Iranian Jews have about Israel.
Asher ,   NY USA   (08.17.10)
About 25000 Jews live in Iran and many of them are like Joseph in their beliefs but can not leave Iran because of their age or financial situation or very limited freedom of speech if any and not knowing any other languages and the very hostile situation against Zionism in Iran and the Jews do not dare to show any affection toward Israel and they are forced to participate in oppositions against Israel and chant against Israel. To defend Israel means jail or execution. Israel is aware of the fact that attacking Iranians' nuclear sights will be a great threat toward the lives of many Jews and will put their lives in real danger. That's why the Jewish agencies has to act more efficiently to move the Jew out of Iran otherwise they will be the first human victims of the attack and that's a fact. 25000 Jews in Iran is a huge number and these are innocent and faithful people who live under a brutal regime that have them under total control and keeping them in a situation without any right to show their support toward Israel and kept them as an insurance against any attack from Israel.
16. # 12 - Here ,...
split ,   usa   (08.17.10)
http://www.ynetnews.com/articles/0,7340,L-3462815,00.html
17. Interesting story
Mas ,   UK   (08.17.10)
I have served the compulsory military service in the Iranian armed forces. We had a Christian and a Jewish boy (kalimi we call them) serving. He was allowed to take holidays for every single Jewish holiday plus the Iranian and Islamic holidays which no one else used to take and even though it wasn't fare to others he enjoyed complete freedom to leave for holiday as he wished.He used to pray in the mosque on his own wearing the shawl and the kippa and he used to eat his own food. I believe this guy in your story had a problem being himself and living as a minority in a majority different soceity. Thousands of people live here in the UK who are minorities and have to deal with the same issues, its about personal strenght to deal with realities of life. Good luck to IDF and him.
18. #4
Iranian Jew ,   LA   (08.17.10)
Don't talk about things you are not aware of. I was drafted and I also escaped from Iran illegally. You can pay and not get drafted. Of course, it's illegal. Stop reading this site if you do not like it.
19. #11
Iranian Jew ,   LA   (08.17.10)
You big idiot! You can pay it and not enlist. But you are required to show up and do the service. Read and pay attention to the story.
20. Every Jewish child should aspire to this mans path. Touching
Jae ,   Lynn US   (08.17.10)
and amazing. God bless the Jews of Iran, 2600 years in a land and still spat on and persecuted, may they come home to Zion- the same ZION the Persian emperors Darius and Cyrus allowed the Jews to return to to rebuild the Temple in Jerusalem.
21. #13 iranian army isn't taking jews
borzog ,   usa   (08.17.10)
and is not compulsory for non islamic people due to trust issue. Jews in iran do have some freedom but they are definitely not conscripted into army or any armed forces. They don't want to risk possible intelligence leaks to israel that way. This is a fact. Last thing they would need is having armed jews in iran. Obviously.
22. #4 you are wrong , #8 excatly the point
reza ,   ca   (08.17.10)
#4, infact every male in iran has to go to the army and does not matter what religion he has. And #8 you are right. of couse there is not excess of freedom for jews but so what that is the story for everyone. But they can work, make money , travel and do their regilous custom. By the way one of my close friend in iran was a jewish. and our family visted each other. he emigrated overseas but to go and become a Phsician. a lot of those involved in spying and mercenary in iran are muslem. now you find a jewish one so big deal!
23. Great story!!!!!!!!!!
Frank ,   USA   (08.17.10)
24. Jews in Iran serve in the army
James ,   United States   (08.17.10)
Iran has conscription that covers all iranians even the persecuted Bahai are forced to serve in the army.
25. Nothing to brag about ,...
split ,   USA   (08.17.10)
"a young Jew who instead of joining Iranian army became outstanding IDF soldier who took part in Operation Cast Lead"
26. #11 borzog: What for?
Why ,   Where   (08.17.10)
Why do you want to know that?
27. army
Dan ,   Toronto   (08.17.10)
Jews and Christians are not allowed to serve in the Iranian army. Look it up. This kid is full of crap.
28. to #4 he was Iranian, unless Iranian turned
ghostq   (08.17.10)
to some sort of religion. like judaism and chritianity.
29. Awesome
Ethan ,   Canada   (08.17.10)
30. #27 Seems they do serve
Cynthia ,   USA   (08.17.10)
You, split and borzog don't know what you're talking about. If you have a reliable reference that says Jews are not allowed to serve, post it. Otherwise, just enjoy the story.
Next talkbacks
Back to article