News
Academia denounces rightist 'threat letter'
Ilana Curiel
Published: 17.08.10, 23:56
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
27 Talkbacks for this article
1. finally, push back for radical left
izzie irgun ,   zion   (08.18.10)
I love these guys .. finally some push back to all the university professors who sit there bashing Israel day in and dy out, writing editorials in the LA times telling the world to boycott israel .. and that includes Hazan at the New Israel Fund who finances Jewish NGOs that are Israeli bashers ... well we are sick of all of you and its time someone stepped up and set these people straight ... professors kicking students out of class for wearing an IDF uniform is unacceptable and disgusting ... these professors ought to get down and kiss that soldier's ass and then thank hashem for sending them
2. All Israel bashing academics should be promptly fired.
Chaim ,   Israel   (08.18.10)
Enough is enough! It's way past time to allow pseudo intellectual academic traitors to collect generous salaries, from Israeli taxpayers, while bashing Israel and promoting anti-Israel boycotts. All anti-Israel academics should be promptly fired. The worst ones should be investigated and tried for treason.
3. Just shows how desperate the rightist are
Avi ,   israel   (08.18.10)
As usual their actions are in the form of threats, which just goes to show how desperate these people are to force their so called morals on others.
4. The Emperor has no clothes...the radical Left, though 5% of
Jae ,   Lynn US   (08.18.10)
population, if that...represent over 80% of political science acacemia! 9 of the 11 professors of political science belong to far left groups, 6 called forJews boycotting the army , and several called for the world to boycott the one Jewish homeland. The priase belongs to Im Tirtzu which called a spade a spade. They only reported the numbers, the organization, the politics. There is no subjectivity in saying BGU's hiring of 9 of 11 professors with avowedly far left philosophies is not congruent with a university that offers multiple ideas for its students to learn about. If BGU wants this remedied, than toss gordon and his ilk and open some positions for the right wing, the sephardim, the Black Ethiopians, the religious. Enough of this ashkenasi take over.
5. "since when does academia..capitulate to...extremists..."?
William ,   Israel   (08.18.10)
...and insane ultimatum from a movement like this one?" For a long time, Yair Green. The crap coming out of academic institutions actually follows quite closely the insane ultimatums and extremists of groups like, Peace Now, B'tselem, ACRI, etc. Infact, wasn't it a few professors from Ben Gurion that joined anti-Israel movements and protests in Sheik Jarrah despite a fair court ruling? Infact, I remember one Ben Gurion professor who actively protested against Israel and gave up his citizenship for a "Palestinian" one. Maybe Green is correct. Academia doesn't capitulate to extremists...they aid them.
6. misunderstanding of academia
Orly ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (08.18.10)
The fundamental failure to understand that academia is a place for those intellectuals far removed from the harsh realities of life in practice led this group to forget that academia is the ghetto of the delusional left. Be they right or wrong in practice, the inhabitants of this ghetto are neither prepared nor equipped to be thrown into the real world, and the rest of us should content ourselves with the knowledge and relief that they have electively secluded themselves within the confines of the bastions of "academia."
7. I for one would never ever support a Ben Gurion University
Al   (08.18.10)
It is a sham of a school that produces self hating imbeciles who like to pretend they are 'educated'. I for one will never ever support them and I'm not your poor shnook waiting for a handout. Amongst my friends, the only schools in Israel worthy of support are some Yeshivas, and some high tech schools. The others are wannabee nothings who in many cases produce some of the worst anti--semites in the Jewish world today. Till such time you clean up your act and become a proud institution of real higher learning, you cant expect support from those of us who know the difference.
8. wrong, you are wrong. dismiss leftist profs
ralph   (08.18.10)
9. Prof. Hazan. is a RADICAL ATHEIST LEFTIST!
Jean ,   Paris   (08.18.10)
10. If Ben-Gurion was alive he would put a bullet in these
leftists head!   (08.18.10)
Ben-Gurion was more right wing then todays rightists!
11. I was going to go
Israeli student ,   Israel   (08.18.10)
I was planning on joining Ben-Gurion University soon. But after reading all this and seeing how non-diverse the University is, I think I will go elsewhere to get an even and balanced education.
12. Leftists brainwash public!
Oren Greenberg ,   Lod, Israel   (08.18.10)
Bolshevik 'academia' jealously protects it's turf. No 'rightists' are allowed. Students are brainwashed. 'Research' is one-sided. Academic papers look like they've approved by a KGB.
13. Liars!
Tony   (08.18.10)
"No university in Israel needs to prove its faculty's love of the homeland," Really? And we are supposed to be buying into this? BGU is a hotbed of Arabism and anti-Zionism. It's good somebody is speaking out about this and about their choices of faculty which are based on political orientation. Most universities wouldn't give an academic post to a member of KKK. Then why does BGU gets away with giving academic position to anti-Zionist antisemites?
14. This article is a collection of propaganda.
Terry ,   Eilat - Israel   (08.18.10)
This article quotes only those interested in covering up the reality of what is being taught to our students. No one quoted was telling the truth. The real truth is in the details. The reality of the discussion is in the details. But, of course, if they went professor by professor, gave examples & quotes of what is being taught, if this was common knowledge, exposed for what it is, it would cause an uproar. They are hiding behind rhetoric, quite Orwellian actually to obfuscate the truth. Anyone who has read in detail about what is being taught, or rather, the brainwashing being given our students, would be scandalized, outraged.
15. Good for Im Tirtzu
DT ,   TA Israel   (08.18.10)
The Left always scream "unfair" except when they are doing their uselss and subversive bits
16. Braverman Misunderstands and is Unaware
R. ,   Goldrich   (08.18.10)
Despite what Dr. Braverman says, the Herzeliya Interdisciplinary Center (IDC) is far more Zionist than BGU. Perhaps this is because they *define* themselves as a Zionist university. Ben Gurion University is funded by the very state which so many of its lecturers undermine. Academic freedom may allow radical lecturers to do this, but let them do this without the support of the taxpayers or the state. Form another institution of higher, errr... learning. The problem is that they cannot. If you took all of the anti-Israel-teaching lecturers in all of the country, they would never get a university started because no one wants them. Well, in Israel, anyways. Maybe they would find work in Iran.
17. What Academia?
DAVID ,   JUDEA   (08.18.10)
There is hardly such thing here and for sure most universities are run by a bunch of loud mouth Anarchistic Socialist defeatist losers.For the past several years I have been able to convince some wealthy donors from my old country to donate to instututions of learning and not to institutions of incitiment and stupidity like Ben Gourion, Tel Aviv and Haifa Universities. Meanwhile we the taxpayers get fleeced to pay the salaries of outspoken self loathers pretending to be intulectuals.
18. anti Israel
colin   (08.18.10)
Finally a small spark brings to light the rotten state of higher education in Israel Unfortunately it is no longer higher education but political anti Israel preaching Hazan and her so called professers(Doughtfill) forget that Israel does not need rubbish in our midst. START PREPARING THE YOUNGSTERS FOR THE FUTURE Stop this anti Israel lies,falsehoods and twisted untruths by Beer Sheva university
19. bravo Im Tirzu, well done
ghostq   (08.18.10)
show the extreme lefties a sain education system.
20. BGU should indeed fire a professor or two
Brian Cohen ,   Judean Peoples Front   (08.18.10)
Does "academic freedom" include the right to call for the denial of academic freedom for your colleagues? No. Because that's simply Stalinism in the guise of academia. Academics do not have any "right" to demand that academic freedom for an entire country be denied. There is no "freedom" involved in silencing academic freedom. Any professor who calls for an academic boycott of Israel is telling the world that they do not support academic freedom and they demand that the academic freedom of themselves and their colleagues be cancelled. This is grounds for their dismissal.
21. What is undemocratic about giving information?
michael redbourn ,   Arad - Israel   (08.18.10)
The bottom line is that Im Tirtzu is threatening to give donors, and would be donors information about the faculty staff and its political leanings. What is so undemocratic about that? Michael
22. Academia
Ricardo Macher ,   Karnei Shomron IL   (08.18.10)
Between the leftist elite, to be considered a member of the academia is the prove of being more important than "common" people. Hazan, Braverman and some of your talk-backers are what is left of the Ashkenazi/Communist elite that directed Mapam in the creation of this country. It's really hard for them to accept that they are history and that they represent nobody. Freedom of expression is important, but Israel is MUCH more important! We should kick all of this arrogant elitists out so they will be able to say that we don't like them, just ask around, read the talk backs and you will see.
23. to #21 no Im tirzu just want to give true data
ghostq   (08.18.10)
about the head of university activities, since many of donares r zionists, seems like the head of university do that because they like to keep the money and the idiology is not much important to them, but truth always come to light thanks to Im tirzue. further more the head of university should resign and prosecuted in court for giving investers fals info, which I hope it's the next step.
24. "EXTREEMIST" is dictionary defination of New Israel Fund.
Bunnie Meyer ,   Los Angeles, CA USA   (08.18.10)
25. Steven Plaut wrote an essay on
Robert Haymond ,   Israel/Canada   (08.18.10)
self-hating Jews many of whom could be found, present and past, in Israeli universities. Must reading if you wish to know about the virulent garbage they spew out in the name of academic freedom. Go to isracampus.org.il.
26. Leftist Domination Hot Subject in U.S.
David Aarons ,   Jerusalem Israel   (08.18.10)
After many years of intimidating students with other than extreme anti authoritarian views students in America are rebelling and demanding change as well. This is hardly an isolated Israeli rightest cause. It should be a cause all should support .No student or teacher should be intimidated because of their polictical views.
27. Why do those lunatic hippies always get to be
Omri ,   israel   (08.18.10)
heads of univercitys? It seems that in history those places where always lefti propaganda balloons.
Back to article