News
Barak: US will supply Israel with bunker busters
Attila Somfalvi
Published: 20.09.10, 07:12
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
29 Talkbacks for this article
1. new weapons FOR PEACE!!!!!!!!!!
Salma ,   Palestine   (09.20.10)
ha !
2. To Salma #!
Nigel ,   Israel   (09.20.10)
Yes, weapons of peace. Unfortunately with our belligerent neighbors seeking to destroy us, a strong deterrent is necessary.
3. Does anything Ehud Barak says have credibility?
Terry ,   Eilat - Israel   (09.20.10)
If past performance is any judge, the answer is a resounding NO. Statements by Mr Barak are always self-serving & have little or nothing to do with either reality or the country's interests. Allowing a man with Ehud Barak's history of blunders & strategic failures to be in charge of Israel's security is the height of irresponsibility.
4. @#1: but you have no problem with missiles sold to Syria
Bat Zion ,   Centre, Israel   (09.20.10)
5. @1: One a civilised nation is surrounded
Tom C ,   No palestine!   (09.20.10)
By "peace loving" neighbours, such as yourself, then concetrating as much "metal" as possible is the only solution. Besides, ket all arabs disarm and then maybe Israel follows...
6. #1 Salma, Peace means Israel loses land
Nour ,   Palestine   (09.20.10)
..and declares its own borders. Will happen...when popsicles are sold in hell. Israel has no incentive to make peace or normalize relations with the neighborhood, dropping its fortification walls, etc. For more on this reality, read TIME magazine issue from last week. Who would have imagined that we would read the trashy TIME for unbiased reporting on the genocide of Palestinians?
7. Salma
TAHRIR QUDS ALYAHUDI   (09.20.10)
What about Syria new weapon from USSR.AH? WE all can see the peace treaty with EGYPT & JORDAN.HOw many times MUBARAK have visited ISRAEL.THe answer is once for few hours for funeral of RABIN.
8. #1 If no one of your persuasion lied, cheated or stole, no
B.E. ,   Whangarei, N.Z.   (09.20.10)
one of our pursuasion would have to arm or to prepare for your peaceful takeover of the world!
9. Barak is too impatient.
rom ,   israel   (09.20.10)
He will not get anything from Washington at this time. He should have waited until Obummer becomes a lame duck. Won't be long now.
10. Genocide, Nour? Your indulging in
Robert Haymond ,   Israel/Canada   (09.20.10)
tyoical overdramatic and distorted Arab propaganda. Try adding something of value and credibility.
11. With neighbours like Hezbollah and Hamas,
Robert Haymond ,   Israel/Canada   (09.20.10)
and the Muslim Brotherhood, Salma and Nour, whose main principles are to destroy the state of Israel, I really think blaming and critiquing Israel for not attempting even more gestures for the sake of peaceful relations is beyond comprehension. The distorted mindset of Palestinian Arabs and their faux liberal politically correct associates may pass muster in the world of Israeli bashing but it doesn't even get you a minimum of cognitive credibility in the objective world of political science studies. That's another way of stating how ignorant you are.
12. #6
Omri ,   Israel   (09.20.10)
If that is true why did Israel make so much work to get peace with Jordan and Egypt? We had all sini with all its oil and we gave it for peace, how about that? You had ALL the west bank but then wanted war and guess what, losers in war lose land! Thats how it always been and that's how it will always be. Make another war and you would lose even more land. You're statement that Israel doesn't want peace is only an excuse for you to make war.u
13. There would be no weapons needed if arab terrorists stopped
Bunnie Meyer ,   Los Angeles, CA USA   (09.20.10)
killing Jews. The more advanced weapons Israel has, the less likely are the arabs to attack and that makes for PEACE.
14. Nobel peace prize
Israel Israeli ,   Tel Aviv   (09.20.10)
It is clear that Obama never deserved the Nobel peace prize. Amongst all his other failings, Obama will be remembered as the president who tried to save the US economy by flooding the world with weapons leading to the deaths of thousands, if not more, innocents.
15. Nour
TAHRIR QUDS ALYAHUDI   (09.20.10)
Nour,Time magazine always been anti Israel.Arabs have no claim whatsoever to the land of Israel.This land was promised & given by the ALMIGHTY in Heaven to the nation of Israel (BNEI ISRAIL).Your quran says so.Islam should obey and respect the ALMIGHTY wishes. .NO one can go against the Almighty Do for yourself a favour go to Arabia the land of Arabs.
16. There wont be any cruise missiles coming to Israel
zionist forever   (09.20.10)
Both Clinton & Bush refused to sell Israel Tomohawks because the US has strict laws on the range a missile can travel if its going to be exported. Obama suspended the delivery of bunker busters on route to Israel and short of the F35 since Obama came along Israel has had no major purchases for arms. Barak is dreaming if he thinks the Obama adminisration will ever sell Israel any offensive missiles. If Clinton refused to sell prime minister Barak cruise missiles as part of the package for making peace with Syria there is no way I can see Obma selling Israel cruise missiles. Assuming that Obama did agree to a sale of cruise missiles what would be his political price from Israel. Obama never does or gives anything to Israel no strings attached. Israel has already developed its own cruise missiles because of the US rejections for Tomohawks in the past. Better to continue domestic development rather than grovel to our enemy in the White House who would like nothing better than to see Israel destroyed and every inch of the country given to the arabs.
17. Why does everybody answer back to Salma?
Ryan ,   Netanya   (09.20.10)
Every day she is writing nonsense to get us worked up. She is entitled to her opinion, but honestly who cares what she thinks. She is almost always the first to respond to many articles which. She obviously has nothing to do all day but to be glued to Ynet, and try to annoy everyone. We are all spending the better part of our days making Israel a great country, so don't stoop to her level. I'm sure she is not going to go away, so just ignore her.
18. #6, Israel offered it over and over
Danny   (09.20.10)
and the Palestinians always rejected because deep down you'd rather be "victims" than be a state. After all why bring an end to the world welfare of billions a year - which makes up most of the Palestinian GDP - and work for a living?
19. As always, it comes down to the Yanks
Cameron ,   USA   (09.20.10)
Hard to make a call on this request for cruise missiles & bunker busters. Even odds on a either "yes" or a "no".
20. Is there such a thing as a secret ?"Shtum"!
Roland Seener ,   London England   (09.20.10)
21. barak's weapons ineffective
moron ,   galut   (09.20.10)
because he talks too much..israel needs protection from its defense minister..and from its press!
22. no.2
hebrew prophet ,   israel   (09.20.10)
Poor Salma the stupid Palestinian who doesn,t seem to understand the conce pt of peace ; there,ll be real peace when Islamofascism puts down it,s weapons (Hezbollah,Hamas,Al-Sheba ab etc.) and decides to be civilised in it,s dealings with the Jewish state ,not before?
23. Sure, US will ask China for more money for Israeli arms
Bloodyscot ,   Dallas, Texas   (09.20.10)
Why does Israel need more offense weapons any way? I can see the need for defensive ones, like anti-rockets systems and aircraft. Peace is a better solution than a continuing arms race, even if US largely footing the bill.
24. To: No. 1
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (09.20.10)
Enough with the melodrama. They're not for use against you (yet); they're earmarked for use in Iran.
25. 23
zionist forever   (09.20.10)
US tax payers get a good deal from military aid. This money must be spent on Made in America. We don't get a cash hand out and say buy what you want from who you want. Recipients of military aid are obligated to spend around 70% of any weapons they plan to buy on top of military aid on US weapons. We can't buy a couple of F16s with aid and spend the rest of the military budget in Europe. So we have to spend our own money in the US. Israel spends between $5-$10 billion on the military around $2.5 billion and around 70% of its own money Israel is spending must be spent in the US. Military aid also gives the US so much political muscle over Israel. Either we tow the line or no more toys. The US gives military aid in some form to around 30-40 countries. Its real purpose is to subsidize the US arms industry which needs government investment to stay ahead of the competition. The government is not allowed to give cash handouts to these private sector companies so in the budget money is granted to various countries in the form of military aid which creates a loophole to subsidize the industry. It also helps keeping production lines open for aging designs like F15 & F16. They are not top of the best anymore compared to the newer competition made by foreigners but if you can get an F16 on aid or a superior $80 million Eurofighter Typhoon for hard cash what will you buy? As for why Israel needs more offensive weapons .. nobody ever won a war by sitting around letting the other guy fire all the shots while you just defended yourself. The best defense throughout military history has been a good offense.
26. re25: agree to a point but these weapons game changing
Bloodyscot ,   Dallas, Texas   (09.20.10)
Agree on the subsidizing the US war industry but not on jet and tank fuel that is part of the aid. The long range cruise missiles and bunker busters bombs are a bit more than just offensive, they can change the play field strongly in Israel favor, which is likely why Israel wants them. Israel wants a military solution for Iran along with other countries latter without having to rely on US.
27. Nour your persuasion kill each other in Arab capitals
(09.21.10)
28. 1 what did they teach you in the cultural centre?
(09.21.10)
29. us sells advanced weapons to Saudi's
norman west ,   nyc,ny   (08.22.11)
us tipped the balance months ago when it sold jets to saudi arabia that are more advanced than Israeli jets....too many jew haters in obami's gov't...
Back to article