News
No peace in NY: Fayyad-Ayalon meeting ends on sour note
Yitzhak Benhorin
Published: 21.09.10, 21:30
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
76 Talkbacks for this article
31. The ugly truth has been thesame if I recall from>
Enraged American ,   NY   (09.22.10)
From time immemorial.Nothing new here and never will be. Besides as another responder said There are already two states. == i.e Jordan and Gaza .The latter given to those terrorists free of charge by Sharon,who was not in his right mindwhen he decided to uproot the Gush Katif settlers (that had been encouraged by succesive Govt's) Who made the desert bloom,left all the infrastructures, plus the Hot Houses for those barbarians who could have used them. Instead destroyed the Synagogues and everything in sight turning the place for qassams.Good let them enjoy their life.Same applies to the Fat-ah number two terrorists who hide their desire annihilating Israel surrupticiously. They forget Jews were not born yesterday, (I mean in the INTELLIGENCE and know how department).And most certainly not only since 1948.,but have been in the present land looong... before there such A CULTIC belief called Islam. Methinks this will end in another CAST LEAD that really,really will finish them all never to achieve a so-called state never deserved,nor needed anyway. Isn't 22 Arab states enough for the greedy Arabs? And think by firing the rockets Israel will not retaliate. Their mindset as you say ( and most people know) is: Not peace,but all they wanted.still want is:piece by piece of Holy and Jewish Israel. Peace will not come in our time,nor at any time assuredly. Has water and oil ever mixed? Oh I have tried just for fun--without success. There is such an unreachable GAP that it reminds me of the TALE of Sisyphus pushing the heavy bolder up a steep hill. Their situation will be the same,or worse than Sisyphus . That Fayyad sure is a clown...Better listen to Danny Ayalon or else YOU IDIOT Fayyad ,you ain't gonna steal Jewish Israel. But hey,Arab Muslim pals can try till doomsday,but since the land is not Arab,but Jewish they can stay exactly where they are in their intransigence of wanting --something that was never theirs,but belonging to another who's claim is genuine,and yours. One is a Holocaust denier, facilitatator of the Munich Masssacre of Israeli Olympians,a chum of the RAT-IFAT, boss of the al-aksa-m-brigade. As for this fayyad who thinks he is a prime minister...Prime minister? No state yet and one calls himself its president,and fayyad a pm? Gee these people tend to think Waaayyy above themselves don't they ha? INTO THE BOX YOU ENTER . ISRAEL WILL NOT LET USURPERS THIEVES INTO THEIR LAND.
32. #3 Gee from Zichron...
Lobo ,   USA   (09.22.10)
Man, I hope you are right. Enough of this "peace process" B.S.
33. #8 ...ex-Federal Reserve Banker???
Mark ,   Lodz, Poland   (09.22.10)
Well that explains a lot then and it doesn't necessarily cut in his favour, Mark...hobnobbing with the the people who control the USA and proponents of the New World Order. Extremely dodgy, in my opinion. See Aaron Russo full interview on youtube and his view of the FR. Well done Danny Ayalon for calling Fayyad's bluff
34. #29 We call it Israel because of our own history.
Roman ,   Lod, Israel   (09.22.10)
The original kingdom of the Hebrews in this land was Israel. It later split into Israel and Judah, with the former being overrun and destroyed, and latter conquered over the centuries on numerous occasions. We Jews have our modern-day name from Judah, but historically it is also only a small part of the larger kingdom of Israel. So when we got back here, we connected to our roots. To Israel. Simple, right? Though my guess is that as a Palestinian, you wouldn't quite understand. After all, you guys have been revising history and denying our very existence in these parts for decades.
35. #21 Yes, it was Ayalon that refused and..
Mark ,   Lodz, Poland   (09.22.10)
..Fayyad got angry...so? He's been rumbled. Ayalon is right for demanding a less abstract sumary. It's like... if you don't intend to cheat someone you should have no problem putting your agreement down on paper. You're emanating naivety at best...
36. To Mark of Lewiston (#8)
David Segal ,   Philadelphia, USA   (09.22.10)
"...Ayalon must have tried real hard to provoke him. But then apparently Ayalon wanted this reaction. " Yeah. We can always count on you to tell us, "A Jew made me do it". FYI, the Palestinians may want a land without Jews, and Israel may be satisfied to have 20% of her population to be non-Jews. But it's absurd for you to complain if Israel is uncomfortable to see her demography increase beyond those parameters. Just what is so offensive to equate the "Arab State of Palestine" with the "Jewish State of Israel"?
37. #13
Yallah Yallah ,   Eurabia   (09.22.10)
"Don't let this Israeli bully push you around...just like he did to Turkey's ambassador when he badly humiliated him. Good for Fayyad to stand up for himself and Palestine." Err Joe, seems like your hero was unmasked and had to leave in a hurry....
38. To Israel: Take Out Hamas/Hez Now
Dav Lev ,   Burbank. CAUSA   (09.22.10)
Ahmad said yesterday that the Zionist racist county will never be recognized, that 1.4m refugees will be created (peace talks), that only a few Zionists have successfully pressured Obama, that Hillary is now Obamas rubber stamp, and THAT THE TALKS WILL FAIL. Syria is getting a variety of missiles and Migs. It has given Hez ScudDs. Hamas/Hez will never recognize the Jewish state. Abbas wont recognize the state as Jewish (1.4m Muslms live there). Abbas isnt' giving in on the refugee question., with million relocating to israel. Iran has 2 nukes now..and potential for dozens more. Ahmad said the US gave Israel nukes. What! Abba will walk out if the freeze lifted, blaming the Jewish state. And on and on and on. To Israel: take out Abbas, arrest Fayyad. Blow Hez and Hamas off the planet NOW. if Abbas walks out. Then let the chips fall..it doesnt matter anyone..,sooner or later, the Arabs will launch the final Jihad, the mother of all battles.
39. Hitler is Smiling
Dav Lev ,   Burbank. CAUSA   (09.22.10)
To Israel: you have the high ground, use it. Take advantage of your position. If Abbas walks out and blames Israel, annex parts of the W. k. and start building. 1m Jews are ready to relocate to Israel to help. I am one. I am armed. I will defend myself. If Hez/Hamas fire one rockets..bomb them 24-7. use phosphorous and clusters..use daisy cutters..you erred previously whenh you had them on the ropes and got Goldstone, the traitorous Jew and now Turkel flotilla, while Iran tortures in its jails and will murder an Iranian women with stones ( deny it Ahmad). BTW, Ahmad has threatened every supporter of Israel with extermination. Hitler is smiling.
40. And the Truth shall set you free! Arabs dont want Jewish
Jae ,   Lynn US   (09.22.10)
hoemland restored to the Jews, thats why they walk out of meetings at the mere mention of it. The goal has always been the same- disregard, ignore, hide, or lie about the Jewish historic homeland, and set the ground for either military, terrorist, demographics, or world pressure to destroy the 1 Jewish nation on earth swimming in a sea of 57 muslim and 22 arab nations. The hypcorisy and naivety and ignorancr rarely dissapoint among leftist Jewish leaders and western leaders towards the arab and fakestinian peoples view of the sovereign Jewish state
41. It was a mistake to involve Ayalon
Ted   (09.22.10)
i am surprised that Israel has not learnt. Ayalon's arrogance will make peace impossible with anyone. Look at what happened with Turkey. Bibi, i am sorry, that even though you and Palestinians may be ready for peace to progress, your ministers are not. It's a pity.
42. 33 Mark of Lodz - Bush Pushed His Appointment
Mark of Lewiston ,   Lewiston USA   (09.22.10)
43. #35 - because Israel learned from Oslo Accords
William ,   Israel   (09.22.10)
That peace accord, under Arafat, was a convoluted mess and should never have been signed. In it's basic implementation it gave the PLO the right to launch terrorist attacks if Israel failed to deliver horse vaccinations in a timely fashion. So desperate were Rabin and his ilk that they just signed anything and this is what we got. This time, the goals are clear - an absolute end to fighting, an end to claims, and the original intention of the Balfour Declaration and UN 1947 vote.
44. #29 - well, first there are plenty of Islamic States already
William ,   Israel   (09.22.10)
and only one Jewish State, which is how Israel is often referred to in the world media. Second, non-Jews within Israel are working hard to destroy both the Jewish character and the rule of law, from which Israel was originally founded anyway. These same people are not shy about calling themselves "Palestinians" but refuse to join you in Ramallah. There are plenty of Arab States that define themselves as "Arab Republic" or "Islamic State" and no one seems to have a problem with it. So...what the hell??? You can call your State whatever you wish, but the end game demands that Arabs end their claims on Israeli land and demands that minority Arabs rule the majority.
45. 21 You mean like the UN242 peace agreement Israel signed
lydia ,   Brisbane   (09.22.10)
Or Israel declaration of Independence, UN181. Didn't stop Israel reneging on any of these. The Palestinians will not recognize the 'Jewish State' outside the borders of UN181 until ALL aspects of 242 is completed
46. No Peace
Gary Glaser ,   Hutchinson, MN, USA   (09.22.10)
If the Clintons, Obama, and some of their cohorts weren't living in fantacyland, they would have seen this coming long ago. If they aren't talking about two states for two peoples, there's nothing to talk about.
47. Do we have to draw a picture
Mark from Georgia ,   USA   (09.22.10)
The Palestinians want one state to be a Palestinian state, only for Arabs. The Second state they (the Palestinians) want defined as a Bi-National state, this, leaving the door open for a flood of Arab refugees. The hope is all the Arab refugees would return to Israel, then using Israel's democracy (one man, one vote) to demographically take control of Israel. I believe the Arabs have a higher birth rate. So if all the people who identify themselves as Arab refugees return. In ten or twenty years, with the higher birth rate, the Arabs would make up the majority in Israel. Then using Israel's democracy take over the government, and turn it into an Islamic state. So the "two state's for two people's" is important. In addition there will be no "right of return" for Arabs living outside of Israel. They will return to their Arab state of Palestine. Really that is as it should be. There really is no right of return anyway. It seems silly that an Arab who lived in one part of Israel moving to another part of Israel (that becomes the new Palestine) be considered a refugee anyway. There will have to be some kind of trade-off with the Jewish people who became refugees, and the Arabs who became refugees. The numbers were about the same, except that Israel took in all the Jewish refugees from all the Arab countries. While the Arab countries abandoned or denied true absorption (i.e. denying citizenship, property ownership, voting rights etc.) for the Arab refugees from Israeli/ Arab wars. Who's fault was that? Certainly not Israel's.
48. Ayalon is a prince sent to appease knaves
Roland ,   miami beach, USA   (09.22.10)
i'll be happy if the PLO decides to finally tell somebody where Bin-Laden is, among others... Gilad Shalit is still a captive. They have not changed their stripes. What exactly do they expect us to do with our own?
49. fayyad: "what's mine is mine; what's yours is ours"
dante ,   uk   (09.22.10)
puts the lie to the American fantasy, shared by some Israelis, that the p.a. wants peace, in the way that that word is normally understood. the p.a. wants a "peace" that will allow it to establish its state and, at the same time, to continue a campaign to subvert the Jewish State.
50. #30 Trust me Mark, I read very well.
Tahl ,   Ashdod   (09.22.10)
"Ayalon must have tried real hard to provoke him" - did you not write this? Do these words come out of my imagination? Well, using my splendid American English (which you scorn for some unimaginable reason), I believe I've addressed your 'provocation' claim quite well, and in doing so, exposed the Palestinians' true intentions, as well as your extreme bias while defending them. And aside for some rants about my English and irrelevant factoids to evade the subject, you could provide nothing to counter.
51. Does this mean only Blair supported sanity?
Paul ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (09.22.10)
Both US special envoy to the Middle East George Mitchell and Quartet envoy Tony Blair participated in the earlier part of the meeting. Blair supported the Israeli stance.
52. That's right M.Duvduvani ..GAME SET AND MATCH!
Enraged American ,   NY   (09.22.10)
The Arab pals think are clever by their continuous "pallywood" exercise that israel has been innured and expect it. No such people called Arab Palestinians EVER.Some people should open the BOOKS and read the reality of a these people who belong to in any arab country and most certainly not in the holy land of JEWS. But these lot have not stopped being deluded,their choice and let them live exactly where they are By that I mean the DESERT...being just bunch of tribes like the rest of all the arab countries that surround Israel.
53. No lewiston it is your wrong interpretations that serves you
Stephen ,   USA   (09.22.10)
That serves your true hateful feelings typical aof a troll. Who the hell cares what you think. Look into your backyard before talking BULL SHIT. Ayalon's english may even better then yours,but then your assumptions perhaps are skewed. I bet you he can speak even better english than you'll ever know,or EVER WILL.Get thee to the troubles in the USA before you embark on Iasraeli afairs Mr nobody called lewiston. would recommend you go and read the Jewish historicity before making a gigger fool than you already are.
54. #29. The jewish people are both a people (a nation), & relig
Jae ,   Lynn US   (09.22.10)
religion. we also share common history. much of that includes 2000 years of persecution murder rape forced conversion 24/7 humiliation racis/anti semtisim gas chambers pogroms inquisitions blood libels job discrimination military discrimination political discrimination civil discrimination. we are , en masse (weve always been in Israel) in our 4000 yr old historic homeland. we dont want to be taken over from within. Its time you recognize the Jewish historic homeland and the Jewish state. Yes non Jews can live there with full and equal rights, but a new nation cant be created from within it by demographics or any other way. GOT IT? youre hatred will never let you comprehend...
55. ayalon
Ari   (09.22.10)
? On the topic though, this totally exposes the farce that is the "peace process," as there is clearly only one side that wants peace - and it's not the one that storms out in a tantrum at the most reasonable (and basic) of suggestions...
56. 29. Jewish country Nader, to reman a Jewish state
Jae ,   Lynn US   (09.22.10)
not be taken over fakastinians and 8 kids per family who dont pay taxes and dont serve the country bash their country side with terrorists like hamas . However you dont need to be Jewish at all, just loyal to the country. . Thats your issue
57. David, Tahl & Stephen - You Guys Almost Make This Fun
Mark of Lewiston ,   Lewiston USA   (09.22.10)
The problem is that Ayalon's reputation and tactics precede him. Or maybe you don't recall why a Turkish Ambassador post is still open in Israel. I spent more than two decades putting the fine print into contracts. If it is not there, it was not intended to be there. Ayalon is nothing but calculating like any professional diplomat. He understands exactly what he was doing, just like he did when he had the legs shortened on the sofa and then bragged to the press about how clever he is. And Stephen, is that a Mountain Troll? Like the Norwegian ones that wanted to defend the honor of the Kings daughter after Charlemagne's emissary had at her? And David, Fayyad has said he wants to allow Jews to remain in Palestine. But, he has a real problem with armed Israelis remaining, especially of the organized militia or army kind.
58. NR 26 - HAS HIT THE MARK HERE -
Arn. ,   Sweden.   (09.22.10)
Netanyahu says over and over that the Palestinians must recognize Israel as the "Jewish state." Now Ayalon says the Palestinians must acknowledge "two states for two peoples." They are both saying the same thing. They are both playing the same trump card. They have discovered a simple, effective way to unmask the Palestinian "peace negotiators", and thereby expose the "peace process" as a cynical sham. Critics of this ploy will claim that it's actually Netanyahu and Ayalon who don't want peace, and have found a reliable way to make it impossible for the Palestinians to conclude a peace deal. But it's really the Palestinian leaders and negotiators who are letting themselves be exposed for the complete frauds they are. Netanyahu and Ayalon are playing them like a violin. Septimus (09.21.10) - RIGHT ON THE SPOT !!!. Arn.
59. Fayyad to Ayalon : not with Haman, O Pharaoh!
Salma ,   Palestine   (09.22.10)
It's a popular myth Meaning that the Palestinians must remain Vigilant against "Israeli" ploys : ) bravo Dr. Fayyad .
60. #43 William - Hear hear!
Mark ,   Lodz, Poland   (09.22.10)
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article