News
'Jewish vessel' passenger: Soldier tasered me
Shmulik Hadad
Published: 28.09.10, 21:20
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
80 Talkbacks for this article
31. :: Israelis beat up...
Matty Groves ,   Fairport   (09.29.10)
...fellow Israelis/Jews just because they want to deliver aid to the Palestinians and disagree with Israeli policy in relation to Gaza? There are no reports of violence from these people delivering aid yet it would seem that the IDF were unnecessarily violent. If the IDF can attack and assault their own it is no wonder that they needlessly killed nine non-Jewish civilians in the previous flotilla attack.
32. finally some good news ... taser them again
izzie irgun ,   zion   (09.29.10)
these traitors are the worst self hating jews we got .. they even use the holocaust to describe gaza and help hamas .. someone should tell these losers that those guys would shove them back into an oven .., and suprise, they already have the camps set up, they keep their palestinians brothers in them .. just look at gaza, lebanon, jordan .. home to palestinians camps for 60 years believeing that they will return to israel to claim their land ... and we know that will never happen .. shame on them PS ... i think its terrific that these jerks can't sleep at night
33. I can't sleep
Sleepless   (09.29.10)
at night because my kids wait for the siren to go off, and sleep with me. When they eventually fall asleep I lay awake thinking of Gilad and his parents,who can't sleep either...
34.  A TASER A DAY KEEPS DOCTOR
LAWRENCE RAP ARTISTE ,   SAFED ISRAEL   (09.28.10)
AWAY . Or ,in other words : SPARE THE TASER ,SPOIL THE CHILD.
35. COULD HAVE BEEN WORSE
LAWRENCE RAP ARTISTE ,   SAFED ISRAEL   (09.29.10)
Had these activists messed with the syrians ,they would have had the soles of their feet and palms of their hands beaten and whipped...and far worse . COUNT YOURSELVES BLOODY LUCKY.
36. ***Sarah***at 10,"you can sleep at night"
Chris Rettenmoser ,   Bayerisch Gmain Germ   (09.28.10)
This one was even better than the Marx Brothers...
37. Ruven is liar
Amnon ,   miami   (09.29.10)
I have one word in him mother tonge Romanian IESTI UN MINCINOS,translation he is a liar he is no holocaust surviver i am from the same city in Romania there was no holocaust in tis part of Romania.
38. #31, you are of course assuming these people
Danny   (09.29.10)
didn't simply lie. I remember the "Free Gaza" people saying there was no violence by the "activists" on the Mavi Marama. I even remember watching on the BBC, footage of the soldiers being attacked WHILST the woman was claiming there was no violence. These people have no shame.
39. There is one way to end all this nonsense
Danny   (09.29.10)
reconquer Gaza. 1) Ends the blockade 2) Ends Hamas's rule Ask yourself what times are better - 2000-2002 when the PA ran most of the West Bank or now when the IDF does?
40. tasering the passengers on the boat
Ely benelyahoo ,   great neck, ny   (09.29.10)
They try to break the laws of the country what they want -- red carpet and medal well, don't break - don't get hurt thank you ely 516-652-4753
41. No words to describe? Sounds more like...
Manic Drummer ,   Madison, WI, USA   (09.29.10)
...someone forgot to pack a camcorder to get it all, so they rely on impassioned claims of brutality to sway those who might accept their side of the story at face value without regard to the apparent lack of evidence.
42. to bad. i don't believe her. but if true stop crying.
ralph   (09.29.10)
43. jewish vessel
debbie ,   israel   (09.29.10)
It would be interesting to know if there was actually any "humanitarian" aid on this boat, and how much. I daresay it was one big publicity stunt, as I believe that Gaza residents aren't lacking too much, and whatever they do lack, the tunnel smugglers can bring it in underground (and get rich off it, btw).
44. these useful Jews....
tom ,   tel aviv   (09.29.10)
There's something pathologicaly wrong with our lot. I tend to think it's the alleged Shoa that did it. I can't think of any other group of people (be it a nation or a race-group) who can not grasp what's being done to them and speak with one, united voice. The mythological, moderate muslims never ever staged a protest against the killings done in their sick religion's name. Anyway, not really in a "Big Time" way. Has it been the Hebrews that blew themselves up amongst children and women I grant you half of the Jewish wold-population would've jumped from Azrieli in "protest & disgust"... the rest wouldn't sleep at night. Truly folks: we have to demand more money from the Germans: look what they've done to us , Ma...!
45. Mean, Mean Soldiers
Enoch ,   Canada   (09.29.10)
This is disgusting. No hot chocolate, no cookies.
46. Blind Jews !
Jaacov Baumann   (09.29.10)
If a jew thinks he has to support Gaza, he obviously is mislead ! Gaza is well supplied with everything (no humnitarian crisis at all) and especially, Gaza is an enemy terror base waging war against Israel ! If one cant see that, he either is on the side of the terrorists or he is blind !
47. Let's look at it this way ...
leo ,   usa   (09.29.10)
First, if there is no controversy there is no news. All this money spent to run the "blockade" nobody cares about would be wasted for nothing. So, controversy must be created. Second, if blockade runner does not get punished it does encourage more of the same. I say, if you did not tase them you should've. Additionally, make them jump through every possible burocratic hurtle before they can get their lives back. These guys must leave Israel and never dare to come back.
48. Mamma, I cant sleep, I wet my bed
Jorge ,   Tegucigalpa   (09.29.10)
I suck my finger, people make fun of me, they call me a loser, why are they so mean. He should not sleep thinking of what those "nice" people in Gaza would do to suckers like himself beign a Jew, if they had the power to do it, and the IDF would not be there to protect the likes of him.
49. You are disgusting Yonatan Shapiro!
Cynthia Barmor ,   Modiin Israel   (09.29.10)
You are an embarrassment to our nation and your actions and comments shameful. While you are welcome to your opinion, you do not have to show the world how anti-Israeli (which is interpreted as anti-Jewish) you are. We have enough enemies. Redirect your bravado to defending our country, not bashing it.
50. So where is the video PROOF this time?
CK Tan ,   Singapore, Singapore   (09.29.10)
51. #31 - only testimonies are by activists
William ,   Israel   (09.29.10)
who incidentally got tasered. Of course, their testimony, beefed up a bit for effect, meets your agenda well so it's fully accepted without question. They tried to circumvent law and a military blockade - they are lucky they are alive. Try the same thing in Russia, Iran, China, or the US and see what happens. Deliver aid? Everything that was ever delivered to Askelon made it into Gaza. Disagree with Israeli policy? Go protest in front of the PM's house. But if you go up against the army and try to break Intl Law - you're going to get a spanking. That's it. Score one for "tough love".
52. #31 - BTW - IHH flotilla activists were not civilians
William ,   Israel   (09.29.10)
According to the Geneva Convention, a civilian is one who does not partake in violence or military operations. Based on the video and testimonies, these activists knew very well they were breaking a legal war-time blockade (making them a military operation) and attacked IDF soldiers before they ever hit the deck (making them military operatives). Some were smuggling in envelopes of cash - against circumventing the blockade (making them criminal smugglers). I'd say - this makes them anything BUT civilians. The only civilians on this flotilla were on the other boats!
53. #41- they can just ask for a copy of the IDF's video
William ,   Israel   (09.29.10)
We know they had several angles covered during the whole operation, including top down.
54. Vandalizing the Warsaw Ghetto wall is an act of violence
zelkha ,   Israel   (09.29.10)
55. Boat takeover was violent
Sam ,   Toronto, Canada   (09.29.10)
The activists probably expected the soldiers to bring them flowers, did they not?
56. Liberal Reform Jews are the problem
Mike ,   Atlanta USA   (09.29.10)
57. Cry babies
Sami ,   New York, USA   (09.29.10)
Cry babies. Pathetic.
58. Read The Talkbacks ....See What They Have Become
World Citizen ,   the world   (09.29.10)
Anyone who wants to get a feel of the general Israeli mindset need only to read the posts on this thread. What a sad commentary on the state of your nation.
59. They Bring Aid To Hamas and Israel is Disgusting?
M. Duvduvani ,   Yokneam, Israel   (09.29.10)
They openly bring aid to a terrorist regime and get tasered instead of shot and they are complaining? The Egyptians shoot and kill people trying to sneak across the border into Israel. They should consider themselves lucky they only got tasered. Sad creeps.
60. Sukkot everyone is important
Alexander ,   NJ, USA   (09.29.10)
On Sukkot we are reminded of how everyone is either the ethrog, lulav, hadassim, or aravot. This includes every Jew from the best and sweetest to the worst and tasteless. We all atone for each other and we are all Israel even the ones that live in Diaspora like me :). They are doing it for our sake even if we don't see it that way because they still love us and want to redeem us from things they believe are wrong. I know that we are free thinking people and we have to accept them with all their flaws and also deal with their actions according to the Law.
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article