Jewish Scene
For the love of God (and country)
Akiva Novick
Published: 04.10.10, 14:57
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
38 Talkbacks for this article
1. female heroïnes
peter ,   a'dam NL   (10.04.10)
Judith killed Holofernes for the good cause...maybe there are also men who do it to enemy women...though Joseph refused Potifar's wife.
2. Too bad the this wasn't very well thought out...
Nick Sporek ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (10.04.10)
LOL - "The latter, Shvat argues, ruled that sexual intercourse with a gentile for the sake of a national cause is not only sanctioned, but is a highly important mitzvah." and the rabbis are worried about intermarriage and assimilation??? It's way easier to convert to Islam or Christianity than it is with the mess out rabbis have made of Jewish conversion. It only takes a movement to convert to Islam and no matter how religious you become you will never be universally accepted in Judaism. Mainly because there are way too many opinions on everything. I don't think the rabbis that sanctioned this considered that this strategy works both ways. This will totally back fire on them. How many Jews are going to go out shtuping for the "king(GOD) and country" because of this study/article. LOL I'd much prefer this way of "conquering" than the convention endless fighting though. May the best lovers win, because love conquers all!!!
3. valantine operatives
yousef ,   Palestine - west-ban   (10.04.10)
O feel dizzy and sick about this . Adultery is Adultery whether it is for the sake of god or country or satan
4. Trust the Jews to kosher any activity that serves their caus
very creative   (10.04.10)
5. .Be fruitful & 'X'...Children will be Jewish.
Roland Seener ,   London England   (10.04.10)
6. I sleep every Jewish girl I can that comes here on holiday
argentine guy- ,   B.A.   (10.04.10)
They love having the goy toy boyfriend while they are away from their hovering Jewish parents. I tell them I have an important security job. They think they are doing great mitzvah. LOL.
7. valentine honeytraps
moron ,   galut   (10.04.10)
women of other nations can be heroic in the same way --it's just that most dont question the propriety of their conduct in as great detail do the jews
8. sex with the enemy is kosher?
dan Gur ,   brisbane australia   (10.04.10)
SWEEET... I'm going on a mitzvah world tour. All I have to do is convince the middle eastern girls that sex with jews is halal and its awwnn.
9. to #3 you don't know the history of the place
ghostq   (10.04.10)
but it happened 3500 years ago in Israel, if you were lokal you probably know that, and she wasn't even Israelite, but probably good looking, who knew milk can be lethal.
10. Seducing the enemy
NYC Girl   (10.04.10)
Does anybody think that female Israeli spies really care what the rabbis say? These women are doing important and dangerous work, and whether or not their activities are considered kosher is totally irrelevant.
11. argentine guy #6, great job!
observer   (10.04.10)
12. Jewish law perverted
Besalel ,   Great Neck, NY   (10.04.10)
Esther was taken against her will. While the general rule is that any law of the Torah may be violated for the sake of saving a Jewish life, there are three notable exceptions; one of which is adultery.
13. #7
David ,   USA, exile   (10.04.10)
Now I understand why you chose the name "moron."
14. What Vanunu told me about his 'honey trap'
eileenfleming ,   clermont, USA   (10.04.10)
Legend has it that Vanunu flew to Rome from London with Cindy/Cheryl, to have sex, but the opportunity for that already existed in London. In March 2006, I brought up the topic and asked Vanunu, "What were you thinking?" He immediately replied, "No, it wasn't like THAT. A tabloid paper published a story with some of the photos of the Dimona I had taken. They never contacted me for my side of the story but they published my photo with a bad report; lots of lies. I knew I was in danger and I wasn't sure if the Times would still print my story. I thought I would just leave London with her for a few days." eileen fleming, Producer of "30 Minutes with Vanunu" and "13 Minutes with Vanunu" and the author of "BEYOND NUCLEAR: Mordechai Vanunu's FREEDOM of SPEECH Trial and My Life as a Muckraker" WeAreWideAwake.org
15. USING DIRTY SEX
ALLEN ,   ISRAEL   (10.04.10)
BS'D PLEASE BE INFORMED THAT THE SO CALLED 'RABBI' DOES NOT KNOW WHAT HE IS TALKING ABOUT HE IS WRONG ON ALL FRONTS --HALACHICLY AND OTHERWISE BUT THIS IS HOW LOW A PERSON CALLING HIMSELF A RABBI CAN SINK JUST TO MAKE A SPLASH AND TO SHOW OFF (his ignorance)
16. Ynet's officially off the deep end
Talula ,   Israel   (10.04.10)
I mean honestly!!!! What an absolutely ridiculous article?!?! You have definitely lot have lost the plot! I would think that there are ZERO Haredi woman Mossad agents banging the enemy to protect our country! If you don't stop with stupid articles and lose that annoying banner - I shall take my vulgar comments over to Ha'aretz and the Jerusalem Post!!!!
17. Oh-la-la !
Salma ,   Palestine   (10.04.10)
Where are the "Israeli" men? ummmm....Hiding behind the bodies of their women !
18. what do we call them??
Shariff ,   UAE   (10.04.10)
WHORES!!! as simple as that...
19. smells like jihadism
mike ,   israel (formerly usa   (10.04.10)
islam has taqiyyah, sanctioned deceit for "higher" purpose or ends, so why can't the rabbis bend the moral structure if it benefits a supposed more sacred principle? there is already plenty of precedent for this, like the recent uproar about permissibility of jews to "eliminate" innocent gentiles in time of war if perceived necessity dictates. so lying, stealing, murder, sex, are all ok if done in service of a higher principle, right? and if islam is any indication of how these moral-twisting dispensations end up, this should turn out oh-so well for judaism and israel. i guess if you can't beat 'em, join 'em.
20. Ynet the Joke!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Phoenix ,   Israel   (10.04.10)
Why Ynet love to publish such a bunch of stupid and ilogic articles. This News site it's a bloody Joke... Only garbage!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
21. Heroins welcome
Michel ,   Doha, Qatar   (10.04.10)
I can suddently feel those nasty violent thoughts peeping up again, lots and lots of dark images and this urge to shed innocent blood + I have lots of secrets I would not want to share with anybody at any cost. Now to the detail of the business: please avoid the blonde-with-big-boobs ploy; I really go for well brought-up brunettes, curly black hair if possible; not too fat, not too slim; taste for classical music would be nice. Not married if possible; i would feel guilty. Thanks.
22. That's only if the woman can cut their heads off
(10.04.10)
23. Seculars have finally found a "mitzvah" they want to observe
(10.04.10)
Like animals, that's the only thing in life that interests them... How lowly and despicable!
24. What can I do to become a target. Please Advise.
Ali ,   Washington, DC   (10.04.10)
25. religionism
observer   (10.04.10)
do the religious Mossad women taste better than the secular ones?
26. #6
Yonatan ,   USA   (10.04.10)
Your post is pathetic. Men like you have to brag about their sexual exploits because of their extreme low self esteem. This is what you need to feel like more of a man? It's just sad. By the way, what exactly do you think Israeli men visiting your country are doing with your countrymens' sisters, daughters, mothers, girlfriends, and wives? I assure you they aren't having intellectual discussions on politics and philosophy. I know. I've spoken to a few about their visits. Oooops...I'm sorry. I hope I didn't bring down your fragile self esteem. Seriously find something real to brag about.
27. Halacha is for neither. Cult spying harms the both.
Josh   (10.04.10)
Don't be fooled, they just want to use this rule for themselves to support one of the main staples of protexia and oppression. All cults use spying to brainwash and punish memebers. Native or not. YOU ARE BEING OPPRESSED! Let my people go. Hebrews are not cult sheep nor cowards afraid to stand against evil mind control attempts. Did G-d say sleep around? Devarim 4:2 NO ADDING. Another Rabbinical chet additions. Time to take the Rabbis to court and convict them for misleading the nation into sin. We cannot add to Torah! It is not the Rabbis place to set rules for female spies. Religious secrets are a give away of cults. Torah is a light to all nations-nothing to hide.
28. #19 Jewish taqiyya
observer   (10.04.10)
Taqiyya is is believed by a very small minority of Muslims - under severe threat of death. However, none of them believe to change their religion to fool the oppressors or the majority of non-Muslims society they live in. However, posing as a Christians (in Spain under Crusaders 1492-1534 CE) tens of thousands of Jews converted to Christianity while practicing their Jewish religion in hiding. Same the hypocrite Jews did under Ottomon Empire, pretending to be Muslims. Even, now these filthy creeps can be found in the US - pretending to be Christians or Evangelists - eating the Christian societies within. I wonder, now if I have to explain the meaning of a Crypto-Jew - to this HASBRA Jew?
29. I've thought about it, sign me up :^)
Nick Sporek ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (10.04.10)
30. Bullshit and sick!!!!
Avner ,   Ashdod   (10.04.10)
Next talkbacks
Back to article