News
Convicted soldier: I feel like a war criminal
Tova Dadon
Published: 25.10.10, 15:23
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
29 Talkbacks for this article
1. Disgusted!
Alistair ,   Scotland   (10.25.10)
I don't care what anyone thinks, any soldier from any army who commits crimes like this should be punished.Most moral army in the world, lol
2. At least is honest and admits his many mistakes
christianpalestinian ,   las vegas, nevada   (10.25.10)
Now, it is time for israel to be honest with the world community, admit their many crimes and mistakes, and withdraw from the west bank and east jerusalem.
3. Seen this i dont want my son to go to the army
Francisco Kohn ,   Kibbutz Beit Keshet   (10.25.10)
Looking at this sentence how i will tell my son when he will be 18 years old that he has to go to the army. Soldiers are also human and can make mistakes but first and most they have to protect themselves in enemy territory. Its a shame that the state spend so much resources on persecuting these soldiers instead of persecuting terrorists.
4. No -
rebecca ,   Modiin   (10.25.10)
1. the courts should not have jurisdiction on soldiers fighting a war 2. The courts should not find them guilty - they did not endanger the kids lives. The kids knew which bags to open and which to avoid and the soldiers did not force them to open all the bags, just to show which ones were dangerous. 3. Why should our soldiers protect children who's parents send them out as cannon fodder?
5. #3 - They Are Prosecuting Terrorists.
Doug ,   Rochester, USA   (10.25.10)
IDF Terrorists. Pal terrorism is largely a thing of the distant past. Almost all terrorism in the area these days is Settler terrorism or IDF terrorism.
6. Perhaps you feel like a war criminal...
Mikesailor ,   Miami, FL   (10.25.10)
because you are one.
7. to 3
jorge ,   D.C   (10.25.10)
You are upset that they are held accountable for abusing a 9 year old? you want your son to have freedom to do whatever just because he is in the Army? Are you serious? If you there no rules and morals and ethics then what makes you different from the terrorist . Just think about it (which I doubt that you would)
8. #2
Dom ,   Italy   (10.25.10)
East Jerusalem seriously !! ??
9. he is a war criminal
ivan ,   haifa   (10.25.10)
10. Always playing the victim!
Marcella ,   Israel/Canada   (10.25.10)
Even when convicted of forcing a young child to open bags thought to contain bombs these soldiers still pretend to be the victims and show no remorse for their cowardly deed! What is worse is the Israeli army is trying to protect other soldiers who are guilty of war crimes,, truly sickening to the core.
11. Disgusting!!!
Spencer ,   Israel   (10.25.10)
What is disgusting is the verdict of the Court. These two soldiers were fighting a war. Fighting against terrorists were are doing all in theirs power to kill and maim innocent people and to destroy Israel. What is also disgusting are the replies of Nos. 1, 2,5,6 and 7. These two soldiers are patriots who were fighting to protect their Country. Give them a medal, don't prosecute them. They should know that the large majority of their Country fully supports them.
12. Are these the soldiers
AJ ,   Israel   (10.25.10)
That saw a boy coming towards them with a bag and asked him to open it to show there were no weapons in there? Why are they being persecuted?
13. No. 11
Marcella ,   Israel/Canada   (10.25.10)
You say these soldiers were fighting a war? What they were doing was using a young child to fight the war for them, they failed the Israeli army and failed their country when they used a child to do the job they were meant to do.
14. Know ALL the facts
Yves ,   Haifa Israel   (10.25.10)
Soldiers are subject to so many deadly tricks by terrorists, I wouldn't want to be the judge. I would be carefull about prosecuting these guys in the media. What were the circumstances? what were their perceptions. It is easy to paint a horrible headline. They didn't take the boy out of school and have him check bags for them all over town. Was the boy was carrying them? Was there someone nearby forcing the boy to carry them? Soldiers and security guards in Israel make me and children open our bags all the time and sooner or later they will discover explosives (in someone else's). So why not in war? Facts and circumstances are missing from this story.
15. How strange that Israel asks soldiers to defend their land
Bunnie Meyer ,   Los Angeles, CA USA   (10.25.10)
then allows "peace now" run the court system. They were in a WAR, the prosecutors think the enemy was using fake bullets.
16. doesnt make any sense
pini ,   usa israel   (10.25.10)
no person in his or her right mind would ask someone to check bags for bombs because they would be too close and it could harm them too.
17. Go-al Nefesh
Ussishkin ,   Tel Aviv Israel   (10.25.10)
It is that both they and the illustrious general who spoke for them simpl do not see that what they did was just plain wrong.What they are saying is that that 9 year old boy was "just a Palestinian, so what we made him do was perfectly OK." And then we shout hysterically if anyone questions whether we have the most moral army in the world! If no one in the country can see the immorality of the action of these 2 soldiers, then we are in much deeper trouble than we are already.
18. Heroes Suffer.
Moshe ,   Jerusalem   (10.25.10)
And that's the truth.
19. #11 is right on
tm ,   usa/Israel   (10.25.10)
Disgusting is truly a fitting description of how we treat our "children". Send them to War with their hands tie and all the above do-gooders lefties spouting off how terrible it was to have that youngster open his own bag-when oh when Israel are you going to value the life of you beloved chaiyal over the enemy's. This double standard is only media fodder for those who wish to see an end to Israel.
20. # 5
Birdi ,   Israel   (10.25.10)
WRONG. "Pal terrorism is largely a thing of the distant past". Like hell. Five mortar shells were fired at southern Israel from northern Gaza today. Sunday three mortars were fired at southern Israel from Gaza. Mortar shells were also fired from Gaza at Israel over the weekend.
21. # 2
Birdi ,   Israel   (10.25.10)
sure, when pigs will fly.
22. If..
John ,   Herzliya, Israel   (10.25.10)
If you think that the world will change its opinion on Israel because of such a stupid moves as the persecuting of a soldier is, you are wrong.
23. Bowing Out
A.C.Guard ,   USA   (10.25.10)
When a country sends their young men into battle and then convicts any of them for acting in an war like manner, the country is in trouble. It is happening in the U.S. with regularity and the U.S. is bowing out as a world leader. Bowing out because no one is afraid of a military that does not try to win at all costs and whose leaders punish troops for acting war like.
24. convicted soldier
mike ,   new york,NY   (10.25.10)
Any one who thinks that being a soldier means that you have to be noble and sacrifice yourself, is a fool who has never been in combat. A soldier's first mission is to win the fight and the secind is to survive and return to his family. The enemy be damned.
25. I will not send my children to fight in the IDF. This is mad
David ,   Israel   (10.25.10)
26. The real war criminals are the soldiers' bosses
Cynic #2   (10.25.10)
and the political elite who take the stupid decisions.
27. Convicted Soldiers
Joe ,   Israel   (10.25.10)
There is a very simple solution for soldiers to follow in a combat situation. You have a suspicious object? Blow the damn thing up and finished. The witch hunt being carried out against our soldiers is shameful. What are you trying to do? Send them into combat with their hands tied? In a combat situation, a soldier's first duty is to protect him/herself so that they are able to continue fighting. Why aren't the Arabs that are shooting rockets at innocent civilians in Israel being tried for war crimes? Please, the stupid left is only concerned with "Looking good" in the eyes of the world. They do not realize that the world is only interested in the destruction of Israel.
28. israel bashers
jeremy ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (10.25.10)
I think it is absolutely disgusting to bash and offend our soldiers! Whose side are the israeli people on? The israseli soldiers are pure zaddikim, espescially in caomparison to the barbaric arabs!!! Let's start simging words of praise of our soldiers, they sacrifice they're lives constantly for our benefit!Shame on those who shame our soldiers!!!!!!!!!!!
29. war criminals ??
mike ,   new york, NY   (10.25.10)
It's strange that I have never heard of any russian soldier or officer being tried for war crimes by their country. Or chinese, or North Korean, or North Vietnamese, or any arab country, or any african country or south american republic.
Back to article