News
Kahane supporters: We'll destroy 'Ishmael state'
Yair Altman
Published: 27.10.10, 00:28
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
90 Talkbacks for this article
1. Don't hurry God's plan
Palestinian   (10.27.10)
2. Parade in their heads
Paul Freedman ,   Falls Church, USA   (10.27.10)
Everyone wants to dance to the fine hora playing between their two ears in their own noggins. But the yitzra hara is playing the fiddle and heartbreak fills the broken morning when the party's over.
3. Finally, the real Israel speaks
Joseph ,   West Bank   (10.27.10)
These Kahane supporters represent the real Israel...the one that successfully hides its face from the World. I am happy this event was held, let the World see Israel's true fascist and racist face.
4. why is this man called a terrorist?
THE GREAT KHAN ,   Kandahar,Afghanistan   (10.27.10)
My dear Jewish bros and Sisters why do u call this man a terrorist?He seem somewhat modest and very rightwing thats agoodthing.The arab jarab want to destroy you so why not return the favor?eye for an eye is good.If i was in Israel i would support this man and his group they seem very devoted to Israels future just like Eliezar Maccabee the great warrior.You all should learn from the past and march forward very strong and unafraid.Khudai Hafiz
5. Every day it becomes more obvious Kahane was right.
Chaim ,   Israel   (10.27.10)
The first rational criticism of Kahane's ideology has yet to be heard. I wouldn't hold my breath waiting for it even now, twenty years after Kahane's murder. The only thing we ever hear from Kahane's critics are insults and mudslinging. Never factual rebuttals. Every day it becomes more obvious Kahane was right. All the events he predicted decades ago are coming true. Kahane's solution is the only real one.
6. Kahne and his rascist followers the ugly side of jewdism
Avi ,   israel   (10.27.10)
The only cause for celbration is that Kahne the rascist was assisaniated. Mk Michael Ben Ari should be arrested the group was declred illegal, he brings shame to the office he was elected to.
7. Strident But Sad
Dav Lev ,   Burbank CAUSA   (10.27.10)
Read the rabbis books and you will learn how right he was. He predicted the deaths of 1,000 plus Jews during the 2nd Intifada and worse. Michael Orens book, The Sic Day War, foretold what would happen if the Arabs won in 67. Jordans destruction of everything Jewish in 48 and afterwards was a presursor. The final jihad..no Jews left alive..dont believe anything else. No Jew will survive the 1m Arab invasion, preceded by 100,000 rockets ( see Hez/Hamas/Iran/Syria). This is the bottom line: while I am against deporting or harming Arabs..Israel does not have to commit suicide either. The disengagement..give Abbas the Galilee..for the settlement land. Annex parts of the W. Bk needed for security. Stop pandering to the world..it harms you Israel. I met the rabbi in Brooklyn once. He was a formidable person. I listened to him speak. He was strident but sad.
8. Kahane was persecuted by the left & shot by an Arab
Yaniv ,   Israel   (10.27.10)
That he was shot by an Arab was expected, but the betrayal by the Jewish left is the biggest disappointment. The Jewish left is the bigger enemy, because it is because of them that we can't get a decisive victory. Without the left, there would be nothing to stand in Israel's way to eliminate our enemies.
9. Only Ynetnews:
Josh ,   USA   (10.27.10)
How can a news service convict someone?! you would never convict an arab- saying "the wife of the arab terrorist" he is a SUSPECTED terrorist, and he denies it.
10. we knothat we are decendents of Ishmael, however
Son of Yaffa ,   Palestine   (10.27.10)
we also know that most of you not decedents of Isaac. you are outsiders.
11. we all realize by now Kahane was right
CHAIM.S ,   BROOKLYN NY   (10.27.10)
THEY MUST GO
12. To the author: Yair Altman
Israeli 2   (10.27.10)
Please do not EVER call the honorable Messiah ben Yosef AKA Rabbi Meir Kahane an activist. He is merely expressing the true Jewish soul. Thank you.
13. Chillul Hashem these people still support Meir Kahane Y"S.
David ,   Los Angeles CA   (10.27.10)
14. Bless the memory of the honest Jew Kahane, truth teller to
Bunnie Meyer ,   Los Angeles, CA USA   (10.27.10)
Israel. The leftist crazies wanted him silenced but his words live on. Bless the Jews who keep Kahane's memory.
15. To quote Rabbi Kahane,
ilyse ,   usa/israel   (10.27.10)
"NEVER AGAIN" He talked the talked and walked the walked. Not enough Rabbi's like him.
16. Legacy and teachings of Kahane live on.
Arthur ,   SF, CA   (10.27.10)
May the memory of a tzadik be a blessing to the young generation of the Torah loving Jews
17. If Arab ...A freedom fighter !
Roland Seener ,   London England   (10.27.10)
18. iam not a muslim
(10.27.10)
yet i believe what is said in it , and that is every jew will be slaugtered , even the trees will tell when a jew is hiding behind it ...
19. Rabbi Kahane
Robert Haymond ,   Israel/Canada   (10.27.10)
While he was living, I didn't know much. I was a liberal who had no understanding of Israel and the mideast. I was convinced that the Rabbi was not only an extremist but a volatile and and unreasonable man. Now I am increasingly convinced of how wrong I was. The Rabbi taught Jews to stand up, proudly, for themselves, not to make excuses for merely existing. He said we had a righteous place right here on this earth. He was like those Jewish partisans during WWII who refused to go unyieldingly to the ovens. The Rabbi knew that our lives were precious and that we had a right, as one of the Creator's special creatures, to survive and multiply. We all needed to hear that. Our brother, Franz Kafka, wrote stories about anonymous people who not only did not believe in themselves but did not believe that they had a right to exist. Only a poor Jew could have expressed those feelings, the "stain" of being a Jew. Rabbi Kahane sought to alter all that. Our problem, Fellow Jews, is that we think we have to explain ourselves, that we have to excuse ourselves for surviving. This Jewish disease is not only true in the diaspora but within Israel as well. In Israel, we are in a weakened condition because we do not believe in ourselves, because we are ashamed of who we are. We are pitiful. We will only survive our challenges when, and if, we understand that we have a godgiven right to exist here on this earth.
20. Jewish Terrorist?!!!
Jehoshaphat ,   Judea   (10.27.10)
You are still slandering him with that title after the courts ordered him to be freed for total lack of evidence?!! Shame on you!
21. Rabbi Kroizer, I have a question a bout G-D, plz
Salma ,   Palestine   (10.27.10)
Can you please tell me where was God during the Holocaust ?! in holiday ?!!!!!!!!!!! Why did God NOT protect His chosen people ?! Are you sure this time from 'God's plan' ?! Thanks in advance ;)
22. #3 #21
Mahmoud Abdullah   (10.27.10)
Joseph look whose talking... Read me a story from one of your school books about the Jews, then talk to us about racism. Kahane was "slightly" insane, but ironically his language is not too different from many of your political and religious leaders, they certainly do not hide it whatsoever. With their constant calls for throwing Jews into the sea you have to wonder... The Mufti is a perfect text book case of an Arab racist that existed long before 1948 "nakba" or second "nakba" 1967, so what "injustices" by Jews were his excuse? At worst your lieing about Jews, and at best your simply a kettle calling the pot black. In any event, you guys were serving the Persians in ancient times, and in more modern times you were serving the Turks, those guys had no patience for your cries of "racism" and there was no united nations then either. You guys were law abiding citizens then, other wise Persian/Turkish steel ensured you behaved. How sad that Jews give you better freedoms than you ever experienced at the hands of the other two, yet you still take any opportunity to criticize Jews... Lets not forget your co-brothers the other "arabs" i.e. Arabicized Phonecians, Assyrians, etc... They sure do a lot for you guys... Tell us, does the Koran say it is better to be treated badly by Muslims, than being treated good by Jews? Then again, you're all such good friends your mighty unified ummah stands till today... It scares me how delusional people in the ME can truly be. Sad your leaders pull the wool over you time and time again, all the while screaming Al Yahood. Easier to believe in a boogey man than to see the real monster next to (your leadership). Anyways, keep being blind and unconditionally pointing fingers at Israel and Jews. I got a scary truth for you, even if Israel and the Jews disappeared tomorrow, all your problems would not go away, perhaps they may even amplify ;)
23. No. 3 Joseph
NYC Girl   (10.27.10)
Since you've chosen to extrapolate from a small group of people that this is the representation of an entire country (which is total b.s. if I've ever heard it), I assume you also believe that the terrorist thugs and suicide bombers are the true face of every racist and fascist Arab country. Not only that, but I'm saying this as somebody who's an avowed atheist, so I'm not usually in the business of supporting right-wing rabbis (although I have to admit I did get a certain satisfaction every time I heard about the ass-kicking being handed out to one of the little Jew-baiting racists in my old neighborhood, by members of Kahane's JDL).
24. It is written in the Torah that
Yossef ,   Toronto/Rehovot   (10.27.10)
Ishmael AND Izchak escorted Avraham, their father, to its final resting place. Nothing is written in the Torah uselessly. Arabs are our brothers, I am fed up with these racist Ashkenazim!
25. forget one state or two states, we need a state for crazies
Israeli   (10.27.10)
I think all the Palestinians and Israelis who believe God gave them this land exclusively for their group and have to fight for its redemption should have their own state- together. That will leave the majority of Israelis and Palestinians to live in our own normal state where we just want to llive and not be obsessed with how to fight the enemy.
26. Response to Salma- where was God
C ,   Israel   (10.27.10)
I am an aetheist so these are not my thoughts but some religious say that the Jews began to leave the religion in Europe or dilute it with non-orthodox ways in the 1800s and the Holocaust was God's punishment for turning their back on God. Just like the destruction of the temples in Jerusalem and the expulsions from their land (586BC, 70AD) this too was punishment for turning away from God. I, of course, think that is a sick interpretation for the murder of millions of innocents.
27. Jewish Wacko Fest
Nour ,   One-State   (10.27.10)
Wow, with gatherings like these who needs zoos?
28. #21 Powerful state rises from the ashes
Avi ,   Israel   (10.27.10)
Whoever heard of such a thing? What has Allah done for you lately?
29. Don"t hurry G Ds plan to no 1
JUDAH THE LION   (10.27.10)
your pagan called allah.
30. Son of Yaffa no 10
JUDAH THE LION   (10.27.10)
Of course Jews are decedents of Abraham,Ishak,and Jacob.The LORD have changed the name from Jacob to Israel.You Arabs have no claim whatsoever to our land including West Bank and our HOLY PLACE CALLED JERUSALEM.Read your Quran.You can stay in our land and obey our RULE,or get out and go to your ho,y place called Mecca or Medina
Next talkbacks
Back to article