News
Israeli student attacked by Palestinians in Italy
Menachem Gantz
Published: 14.11.10, 11:15
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
69 Talkbacks for this article
1. In uk they stand outside shops selling Israeli goods
Like brownshirts   (11.14.10)
2. In the future it won't be safe for jews
Siege of Vienna 1683   (11.14.10)
3. the truth that he is liar
truth ,   everywhere   (11.14.10)
4. the story repeat all over..
Anna M Sedda ,   italy-Rome   (11.14.10)
and people prefer to stay silent that take a stand for a right thing,it is normal for most Italian not to go to the police and "forget about it" or "not getting involved...That's why Mussolin did whatever he wanted and people just bend to his will... Also Italians are afraid of Islamic violence and prefer to bend to Islam that stand for Justice... People can betray for a cup of coffe....
5. sue the Palestinian ,the school for not acting
Anna M Sedda ,   Italy-Rome   (11.14.10)
and get civil compensation for it!!!!!!!!!! do not stay silent even if the Italian Police does nothing...at list you did what it should be done in cases like this ....Do not give up
6. If the Israeli students do not take care of
jason white ,   afula,israel   (11.14.10)
this gazan, then the Mossad should kneecap him. If Israel had any guts, we would bomb a few schools in gaza in response. As for italian cops, they are dullards and not worth spit.
7. wake up
sleepless   (11.14.10)
first it is the jews, then the italians. The Gazan needs to be thrown in jail. What a violent and disgustimg person.
8. Newest movie: "The Ugly Palestinian"
Brian Cohen ,   Judean Peoples Front   (11.14.10)
This is the new documentary about the reality of Palestinian anti-humanism. The Palestinians have been exporting their violent culture for decades: murder, hijackings, attacks against innocent civilians around the world. Is this the true culture of the Palestinians? It certainly looks like it. Is this what they will bring to the family of nations? If so, why does the world need a nation called "Palestine" if it will be so uncivilized, violent and dangerous?
9. 3 you are right Palestine is arafat's lie
(11.14.10)
10. It happened to me in South Africa....
Warren ,   Israel   (11.14.10)
....except it had nothing to do with been a Jew. A group of Africans approached me, screaming to all the others to come and kill the white man. I was in the dorms, which were predominantly black, visiting some other African friends of mine. One attacked me with a carving knife from behind. I managed to avoid the attack and push the assailant away. With the help of my friend we fled the scene. People will always find a reason to hate. I am definitely of the belief that there is much more hate in this world than there is Love. Just watch the people where ever you go. Since coming to Israel , I do not look over my shoulder on the streets.
11. this is how it is, and always will be
danny ,   israel   (11.14.10)
the big bullies will always continue teasing and harassing jews. when jews have had enough, after asking many times to stop, and finally hit back, it is the jew who gets the blame for protecting himself, and then gets chased out/become a target for genocide, because "he's violent". and the cycle continues.
12. facts
Israel Israeli ,   Tel Aviv   (11.14.10)
If 40 Italians threatened a Muslim, the police would have come in with guns blazing to protect the Muslim. But no one will protect the Jew. The only place the Jews have a chance to be safe is in Israel with secure borders. The extreme Left Kadima and Labor, and now even Netanyahu seem to forget this simple fact and after the great successes in Lebanon and Gaza want to surrender Judea and Samaria.
13. it's official......
tiki ,   belgium   (11.14.10)
I'ts legitimed to 'beat up the Jew again, people looking away, won't lift a finger, don't want to get involved. The attackers won't be arrested, the Jew will be blamed for walking in the vicinity of the attacker, showing him the 'evil eye and 'polluting his air/space . It's like the REPLAY of an old movie. The 'Save Haven for the Jews, the State of Israel, is behaving like the Jew in that replay movie..... hush, apaise, don't annoy anyone, not the US / EU / Arabs / UN / NGO's / Left / filmproducers / artists/ singers / writers/ professors, etc., etc., so they "will like us and not harm us". The collective Jew//ISRAEL is at it again, he didn't learn anything, so he must be guilty. The first blow is half the battle, it seems a lesson being forgotten.
14. :: Brian - #8
Matty Groves ,   Fairport   (11.14.10)
"uncivilized, violent and dangerous - attacks against innocent civilians"? Alas such actions are present in all cultures as the following documented clip shows ( http://tiny.cc/65tfu ) however I am curious as to why you single out Palestinians and ignore the same actions committed by your own people?
15. One side of the story
Nour ,   One-State   (11.14.10)
You can rest assured the story was twisted and turned up-side down to make it look like the Palestinian is a killer while the Jew is "innocent". Same story, recycled from old ones.
16. #2 Vienna, Not Surprising
Eran ,   Singapore   (11.14.10)
You seem to forget that Palestinians have immunity from international human rights laws. Palestinians are allowed to target civilians. Their leaders are not threatened with war crimes charges. Their government continues to pay reward money to the families of suicide bombers. Talking of Vienna bring me back souvenirs; I quote; "*You lost Vienna in 1682 to Austria. *You lost Buda in 1686. *Peter the Great trashed you in 1696 in Azov-Crimea. *You capitulated to Austria in1698 in Carlowitz, voivodina *You lost the war against Iran in 1730. *The Russians beat you in 1774- (Kucuk Kaynarca), *Lost Crimea (Kirim for you) in 1783, *Napoleon beat you in Accre..(akko). *You lost WW I like stupid wankers, *Even the arabs beat you out of the middle east. NOT A VERY BRILLIANT RECORD EH? History does not lie.
17. Italy must be put to shame over this.
Tahl ,   Ashdod   (11.14.10)
The worldwide Jewry must utilize its weight and influence, in order to keep this story on on the headlines, and highlight the lame response by the Italian authorities. Let them be learn that their cowardness and capitulation to Arabs would not go so smoothly anymore.
18. Really peaceful trustable people , peace is coming soon!!
olim hadashim ,   tel aviv/israel   (11.14.10)
19. quit
bob ,   can   (11.14.10)
stay home in israel
20. Jews Responsible for their Own Security, No One Will Help
David P. ,   Capitola, CA   (11.14.10)
they never did help us before and they still don't today. outsourcing Israel security to USA guarantees is a dangerous and foolish endeavor
21. this person still go free like nothing is happened
italy   (11.14.10)
22. I'm with Nour And Matty on this one!
Ali' ,   Scotland   (11.14.10)
A kid from Gaza ,I wonder just how scarred this kid is,how many of his family and friends have been killed by Israel? You can be sure he has lost loved ones at the hands of Israel.
23. to #15 the bomb in the 90's on synagouge
ghostq   (11.14.10)
in Italy which killed payers inside was pali involvment, ever since than italian gov guard the place, at that time araft took the responsibility, so I wouldn't excpect any other behavior from palis.
24. In addition to being a student, is Assaf
seadog1946 ,   Shooters Island, NJ   (11.14.10)
an IDF veteran/reservist?
25. Events preceding holocaust repeating
R ,   Israel   (11.14.10)
All over Europe the events that led to the Holocaust are repeating themselves. Instead of the Nazis, this time the Palestinians are the perpetrators. Once again most Europeans stand by and do nothing. This incident illustrates it perfectly.
26. #22, you're right. attempted murder is justified
Aidan   (11.14.10)
If you have a good "reason" for it, right? unfortunately, the real and civilized world works a little differently than that. they call it "a motive".
27. #22 So what?
Line Singer ,   Ã…rhus, Denmark   (11.14.10)
So what if "he has lost loved ones at the hands of Israel"? If that was the case it would indeed be sad but that doesn't give him the right to go around attacking random jews. Same thing happened here in Denmark a couple of years ago when 2 (or 3?) Israelis were shot at (by a Palestinian) in a shopping mall - for no other reason then them being Israeli/jewish. There is NO excuse.
28. That's right, Nour
Tahl ,   Ashdod   (11.14.10)
The Israeli student was actually jeering and picking on the poor Palestinian student, saying that he is a torturer from the Shabak, and sending him to meet his 72 virgins. And the Palestinian didn't really draw a large kitchen knife at him, it was actually an egg-beater. And he didn't say "I will kill you!", he actually said, "I could kill to look as good as you". But wait, it gets better. The Israeli student was picking on all the 40 Muslim students who gathered there and screamed "itbah el yahud", oops, I mean, "you're a cool dude". Oh, and all those female Israeli students whom this charming Palestinian chap supposedly harassed, were just mad at him for ignoring their aggressive come-on attempts at him, and jealous that he picked a Muslim girl over them. So naturally, they all cooked up these silly accusations to get back at him. That's right. The Israeli student was an extension of Israel's vicious, genocidal occupation, while the Palestinian was, as always, a victim...
29. Arab logic
Israeli   (11.14.10)
so since the guy from Gaza is assumed to have victimized or his family suffered in Gaza, it is alright for him to act the way he did according to some of the Arab talkbackers here. Then can my friend whose aunt was killed by a Palestinian decide she is going to kill a random Palestinian on the street? Can the woman I work with whose father was murdered by a Palestinian decide to kill the next Palestinian she sees because she too has suffered? What about my fear of getting on buses because I have been close to a suicide bombing and suffered psychologically, can I now make an innocent Palestinian suffer psychologically because I suffered?
30. Assaf what are you doing there ?
Yossef ,   Toronto/Rehovot   (11.14.10)
come back home, the israeli universities are full of smart people, no need to waste your time in Europe. There is nothing there which is not dying. Life is in middle-east :-) Well, and death too, but that's another story.
Next talkbacks
Back to article