News
Barak backs Jerusalem partition plan
Yitzhak Benhorin
Published: 11.12.10, 10:43
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
67 Talkbacks for this article
31. #21 Nour ARAB property is in ARABia, and that is it! You
Jae ,   Lynn US   (12.11.10)
have ZERO claim to our capital the capital of only one i repeat oneoneoneoneone nation the past 3000 years- the Jews. Rased in your Koran, read in your history books how you have no mention of our capital in your qoran, and never has it been a capital of anyone else----EVEN the occupational Arab Jihad that colonized all of north africa, much of middle africa, and the entire levant. End the Arab Occupation now!
32. Boogey Ayalon Should take over his post...
Trumpeldor ,   incoming eurabyah   (12.11.10)
The quicker the better .
33. Barak's Support for Dividing Jerusalem
Ashirah Dror ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (12.11.10)
Dear Defense Minister ... Your policies in the past lost you the Office of Prime Minister. Your policies at present indicate you haven't learned a thing. It's time to resign!
34. Barak the Jocker !
AlbertoGA ,   St. George, USA   (12.11.10)
He he insane. He has no brain in his head. The Pals in principal is part of this and that of the Arab world. They have no claim at all on Israel. Gaza was major mistake that will self destruct soon. No more fantasy. Barak go home and stop your nonsense Now !
35. we are our own worst enemy
Randi ,   jerusalem   (12.11.10)
now that obama/Hilary have stopped being our worst enemy, with Barak we have returned to being our own worst enemy.
36. to #21 Mount of Olives is a JEWISH
jason white ,   afula,israel   (12.11.10)
cemetery and is the oldest continually used cemetery in the world. There is nothing in our Jerusalem that belongs to arabs! You steal the religious sites of others and claim them as your own. That is all your do and you disrespect the religions of others, because you are jealous of them.
37. Barak, read carefully what # 8 writes
Seppo ,   Finland   (12.11.10)
You follow Clinton's plan. I can assure to you that the Creator of the Universe works efficiently for His people. So far He has given military success when Arabs have attacked. Hashem has also prevented further partition of the land by getting all Arab factions quarrelling with each other so that they cannot agree in anything else but in total capitulation of Israel. Barak, you are fighting against Hashem following your masters American Presidents. Too many of them have tried to divide His land. #8 told what happens. Consequently American economy is already cut into pieces. Europe has been eager to follow Arab dividing plans. European economy is crashing down. Pray mercy from Hashem, maybe He still forgives you.
38. To: No. 26
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (12.11.10)
Don't forget that his disguise as a woman allowed Israel to kill some rabid ersatz "Palestinian" dogs. What excuse do the rabid ersatz "Palestinian" dogs who hide in bunkers have for ACTING like cowardly Arab women, not just dressing like a woman? Huh? What? Face it -- you and Nour have your mutual admiration society and Israel has Jerusalem. Forever. The day Israel decides to kick your sorry asses back to Arabia where you belong, whatever will you do? WHATEVER WILL YOU DO? You're a bunch of sad-assed losers. What have you achieved in sixty-two years? What have you accomplished in sixty-two years? KEEP UP THE REALLY GOOD WORK!
39. These guys don't listen to God
Alexander ,   NJ USA/Israel   (12.11.10)
It's all going to end up the same way as it has been ending with more violence more fighting more bloodshed. Go ahead and sign your little piece of paper and watch how much blood will stain the words on it. These Arabs have not been interested in any sort of peace since day one and have rejected all efforts and attempts at peace.
40. #25 good point
Alexander ,   NJ USA/Israel   (12.11.10)
I guess there's no sense in getting our panties in a bunch over a deal the Pally's will never accept.
41. #15; Israel Israeli; Then Israel....
Mark from Georgia ,   USA   (12.11.10)
Has the right to wage a total war against a country that attacked them. My point is to remove any possible excuse...legally speaking...for 1) The Palestinians to continue terrorism and call it, falsely, "resistance". and 2) Give Israel the absolute legal right to attack with any force they deem necessary...including overwhelming force...the same doctrine used by the coalition forces in Gulf War 1, by General Colin Powell, and not be accused of disproportional force by any International body. Let me be clear, whatever agreement Israel is pressured into signing by the International pressures that are put on Israel. There will in the end be a War, I don't expect the terrorists to honor their peace agreements. So I believe you set it up in such a way, as to when it is violated, that Israel, unrestrained, can do whatever is needed to be done. Leaving those that violated the agreement no legal, or false moral loophole.
42. When?
David ,   America   (12.11.10)
If Barak gets his way, the agreement should be signed on the 9th of Av. Why another day of mourning?
43. # 31 Isn't it time yet
Jim ,   Canada   (12.11.10)
for you (extremists Jews) to stop living 1000 yrs BC and move to the 21st century. As an occasional reader of this site, I find this extremism driving me mor and more to adopt the other point of view. You spread so much false information. Do you think the rest of the world doesn't read . some of you are realy sick.
44. Demilitarized Pipe Dream
Keith Johnson ,   Los Angeles, CA   (12.11.10)
A demilitarized Palestinian state is a pipe dream. Israel could not prevent the smuggling of weapons into Gaza even when it was in control of Gaza. Israel should extend the wall to protect all settlements in Ephraim, Manasseh, Judah and Benjamin. Israel should build in E1 and in the Jordan hills. Building in these areas would provide for security and a united Jerusalem. After securing the borders, the highlands held by the settlers and Jerusalem, Israel can be secure no matter what the Palestinians do and pay no attention to the rapists at the UN. A solution that provides for taking the steps above and then possibly forming a confederation of city states with the Palestinians to include Israeli Arabs in the only just solution to the conflict. Israel Separate and Confederate equals Security and Democracy.
45. No wonder Labor is down to 5- 6 seats in recent polls.
Chaim ,   Israel   (12.11.10)
Barak and Labor represent a negligible proportion of Israelis. Their ludicrous view that Israel should divide our Eternal Capital is symptomatic of a party which has no self respect or reason to exist. No wonder Labor is down to 5-6 seats in recent polls. Labor would serve Israel best by disappearing altogether.
46. Nour , Salma and Sarah B
Ray ,   US   (12.11.10)
It's very entertaining to read how people like Sarah B are so blind or just choose to be about really everything this paper writes regarding the Israeli palestinian issue. You have the World countries saying Palestine. They even got Bibi to say it but people like Sarah B spend there time and effort claiming otherwise absolutely disconnected from any form of reality resorting to personal attacks in all her posts. It would behoove you to remember that the world gave Israel to the Jews And the world is saying today Palestine to the Palestinians. Nour and Salma, what's even more interesting is that people that radical (sarah and her friends) if they ever get their way ( big if) would actualy be working for a one state solution and they don't even know it. It's priceless
47. A better idea, dump Barach!
Wise Saba ,   Eretz Yisrael   (12.11.10)
48. Sarah why are you....
Amy   (12.11.10)
..filled with so much hate? Was it because your German parents did not love you as a child? Is that why you can't love others?
49. To : 43. Welcome to my world
Ray ,   US   (12.11.10)
You have to find the amusement in all these talkbacks You'll see a lot of land claims given from God no less Political solutions: mass transfer of millions People here really believe they will one morning wake up and find the occupied lands empty of it's indigenous people
50. remember this man's election promise?
Golan ,   Modiin   (12.11.10)
in 1999 this putz's campaign sent out a sticker reading Jerusalem: Rabin liberated Barak will keep. What a jackass.
51. to #10
Golan ,   Modiin   (12.11.10)
Barak was a solider, a tactician. He is someone you send out to complete a mission. He is not one who can strategize. This is a man that can play checkers not chess. He is a man who can break into a car, not someone who can buy one.
52. It's Fine - Barak lives in Tel Aviv and Clinton in the USA
ELIEZER ,   JERUSALEM   (12.11.10)
Time Barak was removed from his position - everything he touches gets screwed up - now he is prepared to give away soverignty over Jerusalem - suprise nobody supports his Labour party of Traitors
53. Monstrous, Unforgivable, and Profoundly EVIL
Linda Rivera ,   New York   (12.11.10)
How dare DM Barak refer to the cherished Biblical Jewish Homeland of Judea and Samaria as another nation? Why does he LIE? Holy Hebron is the first Jewish city, and second in holiness after Jerusalem. How dare he even speak of surrendering holy Jerusalem? How can Barak engage in deceit and Islamic propaganda by stating: "Without a peace process, he noted, both Israel and the Palestinians will fall back into a cycle of bloodshed and violence." How dare you slander the Jewish nation, Mr. Barak. Little Israel, victim of global jihad has suffered thousands of rocket attacks, daily rock attacks, etc. and you place equal blame on victim Israel? Mr. Barak, you are devoid of all ethics. You have no loyalty to Jews and Israel. None. Barak is a servant to the US and expansionist, colonizing, conquering Islam. He has sold his soul. Barak betrays every Jew who has ever lived. Why is wicked Barak still Israel's Defense Minister?
54. # 21
Birdi ,   Israel   (12.11.10)
Pure undiluted crap.
55. # 29
Birdi ,   Israel   (12.11.10)
Oopss Nour, do you know what "poking" also means ??????? Your mama didnt teach you right.
56. Barak-the idiot who brought Hizballah
RayS ,   NH, USA   (12.11.10)
This criminal defense minister who single handed brought South Lebanon under the terrorist control and threatened Israel's permanent security on the North (as well as destroying our friends in Lebanon) should be out of the government and expelled from the country.
57. @31
deb ,   UK   (12.11.10)
If your land was so precious to you why did you leave it and not return for 3000 years? The Palestinians never left, they have lived there for over a millenia
58. only one reason Sarah B is so villified
Linichka ,   Gdynia, Poland   (12.11.10)
It is because she is right - and can back up her views.
59. #57 correction
Israel Israeli ,   Tel Aviv   (12.11.10)
The "Palestinians" have not lived in Israel for over a millennium. The Arabs' own definition of "Palestinian" is any Arab who lived in Israel prior to 1948, ask Salma if you like. Thus it includes an Arab who immigrated to Israel in 1947 and went back home when the Arab armies attacked Israel. The fact is that about 95% of the Arabs who call themselves "Palestinians" are immigrants who moved to Israel between 1920 and 1948 during the British occupation. Let's make real peace: a single country where Jews, Druze, Samaritans, Christians, Bedouins, Circassians and any Muslim Arab who can trace his roots to Israel to before the English occupation of 1920 have equal rights. Do you agree?
60. To # 48 Amy & # 11-18-38 Sarah B
Abu Yussef al Yahudi ,   Bue.Aires_Argentina   (12.11.10)
Amy, you are very wrong, Sarah doesn't have any hate, she really has a Great Love to the Holy Land of Israel. Sarah B, we strongly agree with you, and we LOVE your passionate Posts in all the Talbacks of this Website. Go Sarah, Go and keep going AM ISRAEL CHAI Abu Yussef al Yahudi Buenos Aires City - Argentina
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article