News
Israel flying Sudanese infiltrators back to Africa
Ynet reporters
Published: 14.12.10, 00:48
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
45 Talkbacks for this article
1. Pay countries to take them?
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (12.13.10)
Oh, I think not. The United Nations has a massive budget dedicated exclusively to refugees. It is high time they used it on something other than no-show jobs for their relatives and friends and the ersatz "Palestinians," who aren't even refugees to begin with, but rather displaced persons.
2. Get rid of them before they get rid of you
Al   (12.13.10)
No self respecting country allows itself to be usurped by strangers. The USA has long ago lost its self respect, witness the fact that it is imploding. Israel was not founded to be a refugee camp for the worlds poor..It was founded as the long lost home of the Jews. As to those who tell of Jews being denied sanctuary in Europe in WWII, and so Israel should welcome all those who come...I have news for you....it was only after Jews were brutally murdered by their host countries in WWII that the State of Israel was founded. In short we lost 6 million before we grew a set and stated we werent going to take it anymore. Ben Gurion had no intention of declaring the State..It was only after Begin stated that he would, then BG got the brainwave to declare the state. If you didnt know that, then I would suggest you open a book, read history.
3. NOT OUR PROBLEM
SETTHERECORDSTRAIGHT   (12.13.10)
LET THEM TRY EGYPT, JORDAN, LEBANON OR SYRIA.
4. Error in translation of headline....
(12.13.10)
voluntary departure isn't deportation!
5. look at us
simon ,   tel aviv   (12.13.10)
what has happened to this country, our moral values and our future. It was only a generation ago that we were refugees with the world turning their backs on us. The deportation of the refugees turns my stomach. Bibi and his racist mates (yishai, lieberman, ayalon) need to take a step back and look at the dangerous path they are leading us down.
6. why are we paying money for them to leave?
Jon ,   Israel   (12.13.10)
This is absolutely absurd. They are NOT our rafugees. They are not our problem. And worst of all, they are from an enemy state. Kick them out and be done with it.
7. Al - your comment stinks...
Gregg ,   Haifa, IL   (12.13.10)
8. Illegal border crossers from Egypt should be sent to Egypt
Dr. L. Brnd ,   San Diego, USA   (12.13.10)
Regardless of nationality, all persons who cross into Israel illegally from Sinai should be send back to Egypt, where they came from. That is what Jordan and Egypt do when foreign tourists enter from israel without proper clearance. If they were in Egypt legally, they are Egypt's problem. If they were in Egypt's Sinai illegally, then Egypt was violating the peace treaty with Israel by allowing them to cross the territory, and they are still Egypt's problem. Israel should be demanding that Egypt pay the cost of its violations, or demand that the US deduct the cost from Egypt's aid package, and give it to Israel as reimbursement. No African border crashers OR Iranian rockets crossed Sinai into Israel when Israel controlled the territory - NONE; this is an Egyptian responsibility, they could easily stop it if they wanted. All human and weapons contraband traffic enters Sinai's interior through five (5) roads across the Suez canal, Reef-surrounded Sinai has no "ports" where African or Iranian ships can dock
9. 150 is NOT ENOUGH ! They are here for money and make trouble
David   (12.13.10)
10. WHY TO PAY FOR ILLEGALS ?! WE MUST KICK THEM OUT !
(12.13.10)
11. send to america
bern ,   phil usa   (12.13.10)
plenty of room here congress will give ok if asked.
12. Not Enough
Tony ,   Brooklyn,USA   (12.13.10)
Deadly force must be authorized at the border. This can't be allowed to continue.
13. Refugees
David ,   Israel   (12.13.10)
I agree that the refugees shouldnt get money, since its going to follow a precedent to other refugees that they will also get money. Israel is supposed to grow with their economy, not be weakened.
14. To: No. 5
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (12.13.10)
Are you serious? Israel is a Jewish state. Don't you want to preserve its identity as such? How long do you think that will last if all the illegal aliens who have entered Israel are permitted to stay? Our moral values and our future stem directly from our identity as a Jewish state. Moreover, the African illegals are a huge drain on the resources of the State -- resources which should go for the benefit of Israelis (whether Jewish, Moslem, Christian, Druze or anything else). I put their welfare ahead of the welfare of illegal aliens; they are the bailiwick of the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees. Let them do their job.
15. Sudan in Arab League. Arab League should pay for their reset
Jae ,   Lynn US   (12.13.10)
resettlement. 1) they should not be sent where they will be in danger 2) arab league needs to be pressured to be involved. after all sudan is a member of the 22 nation arab league! Like the EU have a say on all countries within it.
16. Al, 2#, I liked your comment
Judah ,   Golan Heights,ISRAEL   (12.13.10)
We need to kick them out or better yet finish the fence so they cannot enter in the first place. Al, there is 2 meters of snow at Mount Hermon and a half a meter of snow at my house in the Northern Golan Its just like Canada!
17. Now time for Arabs to return to Arabia!
Tony ,   UK   (12.13.10)
Now time for Arabs to return to Arabia!
18. #14
(12.13.10)
Your comments in 1933. Are you serious? The United States is a Christian state. Don't you want to preserve its identity as such? How long do you think that will last if all the illegal aliens who have entered the US are permitted to stay? Our moral values and our future stem directly from our identity as an Christian state. Moreover, the Jewish illegals are a huge drain on the resources of the State -- resources which should go for the benefit of Americans.
19. All of them should be put out!
Phoenix ,   Israel   (12.13.10)
150 it's nothing!!! Thousands are living ilegaly in our land. Hundreads enter Israel every day. The money of our taxes should not be use to maintain all these African Muslim intruders. Why should we pay millions for people that have nothing to do with us. Just put them out send them back to their real countries.
20. Israel is not the dumpster of Egypt
bruno ,   Portugal   (12.13.10)
I can understand that Israel has compassion for these mainly economic refugees. Life is hard in Africa everywhere. Independance was given to elites who have no regard for their own nation. But one thing I can assure all you guys, is that Egypt is using these refugees as a weapon against Israel and on top of that, the border is wide open. Remember that Fidel Castro did the same from Cuba to Florida. Morocco is doing the same with Europe. Yes, today refugees can turn out to be the worst weapon possible. Look at the third generation of maghrebins in Paris. And if most are muslims, then you are in for troubles... Please be realistic ! Israel is the land of Zion, not the dumpster of Egypt.
21. Because of Israel's history...
Kyle ,   Southpark, CO, USA   (12.13.10)
They are obligated to take in every refugee? Area of Africa: 30065000 sq km Area of Israel: 20770 sq km Does this make sense?
22. The civil rights groups must ensure the rights they are
Harry Wright ,   UK   (12.14.10)
promoting for the illegals by: providing them with food, clothing and shelter for them. That is more meaningful than their empty rhetoric. These people have no shame. They should get off their a**es and provide for the illegals they are championing. Put your money where your mouth is!
23. Any chance they could take Eli Yishai with them
Avi ,   Israel   (12.14.10)
Just wondering..
24. The Government
David ,   Israel   (12.14.10)
Why does the government see fit to go against the oecd's wishes and go higher into a deficiet? How much do you think they give to the Sudanese people on the way back? Right now its 150 ppl.......tommorrow more? When is it ok to say "NO, You cant come in.....beware that we will send you back if you try. If you want to come in legally, come in with the right channels. Not through empty borders and tunnels. I am sure everyone know how much these people are suffering, but there has to be a different way to go about it. Israel it seems is the only country that will take them in......
25. To: No. 18
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (12.14.10)
"The United States is a Christian state." Wrong. The United States does not have an established religion, and is constitutionally precluded from adopting one. "Our moral values and our future stem directly from our identity as an Christian state." And where from precisely do you think Christianity took its moral values? Christianity did not spring up whole. It grew out of another religion. Care to guess which one? "Moreover, the Jewish illegals are a huge drain on the resources of the State" What "Jewish illegals?" What "drain on the resources?" Perhaps you are unaware that over 80% of Jews living in the United States are in the top taxpaying percentile? Perhaps the Christians living in double-wide trailers, cooking methamphetine and receiving public assistance and disability should stop living off Jewish tax dollars! You are a pluperfect idiot. javascript:%20save()
26. sudaneeese
pini ,   usrael   (12.14.10)
go back to africa, pick up gun, and fight for your right to live in your nation. You are of muslim decent, find muslim countries to help you since the muslim world always says Israel is so inhumane. LEAVE US ALONE
27. #21
pini ,   usrael   (12.14.10)
whoa, theres a kyle in southpark, co? lol thats funny Yes this is crazy, im sorry sudan is sufferring but Israel does not have the ability to help, they need to ask the UN or learn to fight. Why would Israel want a 1000 plus muslims to illegally enter its country every month? They need to do what America does, put them on a bus and send them back over the border, Egypt can deal with them. I get it life sucks, but thats life..it sucks sometimes.
28. Political correctness and reversed racism
Alexander ,   Tel Aviv, Israel   (12.14.10)
Had they been "refugees" from Europe the Israeli "human rights" organizations would have said nothing. It's because of the color of the skin that they are hysterical about the deportation - a kind of reversed racism. Because they belong to a certain ethnic group they are holy cows - eternal victims - declared to be children unable to take care of themselves. So Left Wing Liberals are reducing them to children and at the same time Africans are exempt from any responsibility due to the color of their skin. That's racism of the highest order. Generosity towards other ethnic groups depends on their needs and how many resources you have in your possession. If say you are a huge nation where foreigners are merely 1-5% and the infiltrators are few - one can be generous. If one is a small nation with 15-20% foreigners (Arabs in Israel) plus being surrounded by 300 million hostile anti-Semitic Arabs ONE CANNOT SHOW ANY GENEROSITY. Extreme altruism which means sacrifying one's life for others well being is alien to Judaism and to all moral thought. If the Africans want a better life then I suggest they solve their own problems back home. Escaping from their own problems will not make the problems go away and only results in their problems continuing to exist and expanding into our land. So instead of killing the problem, the problem grows and their problems also becomes our problem. These African infiltrators should be seen for what they are: cynical, egoistic, opportunistic wealth seekers that don't give a damn about Israel and the Jews and they don't give a damn about the Jews' need to live in a JEWISH nation. So my solution is simple: finish the fence along the Egyptian border as soon as possible and shoot at anything that moves along the border. If they infiltrate Israel, the police and the IDF must hunt them down and expel them. And whatever the Israeli "human rights" organizations might say about "racism" and no matter how "desperate" these African "refugees" may seem, the answer is LO, NO, NEIN, NJET. Enough talk!!
29. Any chance we could stick some Mexicans aboard?
Cameron ,   USA   (12.14.10)
30. At least Israel is dealing with them less harshly than
Harry Wright ,   UK   (12.14.10)
the EU which pays Qaddafi about 4billion to prevent them from arriving in Europe. They are beaten, tortured and even raped in Libya. Anyone thinks the Europeans care? Those civil rights people are out to prove they are more civil than everybody else?
Next talkbacks
Back to article