News
WikiLeaks: Spielberg was blacklisted by Arabs over donation
Yitzhak Benhorin
Published: 18.12.10, 09:35
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
36 Talkbacks for this article
1. What a boring topic: Of Course! So What? !!
tom ,   tel aviv   (12.18.10)
2. Gotta suck to live in Arab League state
Potash Katiftof ,   Tel Aviv, Israel   (12.18.10)
It must not be very fun to live in these arab league states/countries. They loose out on so many quality of life options in their life as part of their own. Would be interesting to hear a survey of how happy people are in these countries.
3. and where is the ark, btw ?
eporue ,   europe   (12.18.10)
any cables ? the characters, cultures or nationality differences in the movies are all overdrawn, a intentionally exaggerated. thats part of the humour. and the arab depiciton was not soooo bad - compared to the germans... maybe it just didnt match the arab humor ? i have a dvd, where the guys who illegally copied it can be heard talking/laughing. (7 nights, 7 days or so, anne hedges, harrison ford). the guys are only heard laughing their a$$ off, when something "happened" to the women. whatever (funny) stupid situation harrison ford got in, there is damning silence on the dvd...
4. don't boycott him for making donations
(12.18.10)
boycott him for making bloody aweful films
5. Thanks for the tip, never again will I watch his works
Nour ,   Palestine   (12.18.10)
Besides, it's not the budget that makes a great movie, and it never was. Repertoire movies I my favorites, you know, the ones based on real life stories that are inspiring.
6. forgot... that dvd was copied in malaysia
eporue ,   europe   (12.18.10)
7. whats your favourite movie, nour ?
eporue ,   europe   (12.18.10)
8. Exodus
Eli and Emily ,   Haifa, Israel   (12.18.10)
Just the excuse he needs to finally make a remake of Exodus. I'm glad he's back on our side after making Munich.
9. #6 Loads of favorites here...
Nour ,   Palestine   (12.18.10)
Bounty (1984) could be the preferred, but again loads of low-budget but great movies...
10. Who gives a Rat's A$$ what nour
David ,   USA/Israel/Egypt   (12.18.10)
or any Pali watches. You watch a movie because you like it not because you want to support a Director. Next thing will be I wont have sex anymore because I can't use a condom, that a Jewish scientist invented when he was having fun in Sweden. All those boycotts are so childish, they border the line of stupidity LOL
11. I have a great respect for Mr. Speilberg because
Rivkah   (12.18.10)
he asked Linda Ronstadt to marry him when her heart was broken from being caught in Africa with then California Governor Jerry Brown who cadishly did not marry her. LInda Ronstadt went to Tucson High School and was not in the same class I was in but was so beautiful in her youth. She did not deserve to be jilted by Jerry Brown, the swine. She never married in her heartbreak and adopted two children and raised them in Tucson. She is worth a thousand Jerry Browns and Steven Speilberg knew that. He knew her to be worthy of his name even if Jerry Brown didn't think as highly of her whom he defiled carnally, the swine. He fooled the voters of California into electing him, but he can't fool me.
12. #3 The Ark is under Al Aqsa ;)
Yossef   (12.18.10)
13. Nour, there are
Yossef   (12.18.10)
philosophical essays and fiction romans. You may like both kind of literature. In movies it is the same, Hollywood movies are more on the side of fiction romans, israeli cinema is more about philosophical/political/life essays. I enjoy both. For example: on israeli side I enjoyed very much אביבה אהובתי and on the Hollywood side Minority Report. Tell me one arab movie I should have seen, I'm curious.
14. Ridiculous
john   (12.18.10)
A comparison to Darfur? let's see: 300,000 dead in the Islamic Republic of the Sudan compared to a war with Hizballah that was initiated after the latter kidnapped and killed soldiers Logical boycott.
15. but egypt did not complain ?
eporue ,   europe   (12.18.10)
as blatantly zahi hawass is copying indy since then...
16. :: David - #10 - Thank you
Matty Groves ,   Fairport   (12.18.10)
Such abstinence will greatly improve the human gene pool.
17. PRETTY COOL
Mark from Georgia ,   USA   (12.18.10)
Why some would want to deprive themselves of great action/adventure films is beyond me. But here in the U.S. you give your money to who you want for the most part. Israel's war with Hezbollah was just another battle of good vs evil. Hezbollah started the war and then proceeded to lie about it in the Media as we see here: http://www.aish.com/v/is/91361839.html This of course is not unusual. Israel as a country seeks and has built its economy on helping the world. As we see here: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I5tDDkvXSI8 While their enemies just try to perfect death. Often bragging about it as an asset. Proud to raise their kids to commit suicide while killing innocent men, women and children. In their warped view this murder and terrorism is "resistance", where G-d will accept you in heaven with 72 virgins. Think about that! Now they want to boycott his films because he gave a million bucks to Israel in time of war. Perverted logic from a deviant culture.
18. 5 nour can watch mohammed bakri's rubbish instead
mike ,   israel (formerly usa   (12.18.10)
nonfactual, self-pitying propaganda that is poorly made - it's about her speed anyway.
19. Donations are still needed for poor Israelis & Carmel fire
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (12.18.10)
20. Why can't our people make quality movies?...alas...
Salma ,   Palestine   (12.18.10)
21. A Jew supporting the only Jewish state? Shocking.
Yaniv ,   Israel   (12.18.10)
22. I'm much more worried about the attitude of Brit Chris Doyle
Esther ,   Netherlands   (12.18.10)
23. #20 Salma
Yossef   (12.18.10)
I am surprised, in the good way, about your self-criticizing remark :) Taking perspective even from what we like the most (our people for example) is a sign a health. And more over, a sign of big strength, and it is constructive (in general). I am happy that in Israel we can support movie makers which look at Israel and the israeli (Jews or not) with a critic sight. We know where are our imperfections, when we are not completely blind, but putting the finger on it, by the way of movies for example, may help to fix them. See the "Syrian Bride" for example, very moving, very critical, but useful. I will be interested about arab movies talking honestly about arab society. It will not harm the arab society, at the contrary. It can even help us to appreciate you even more. I don't elaborate more, you are smart enough :)
24. GOOD!!.. i will buy all his movies now!
David ,   USA   (12.18.10)
YES!!!.. ISRAEL # ! !!!!
25. i'll watch all his works
Marwan ,   Amman, Jordan   (12.18.10)
but as pirated copies downloaded from the internet :D up yours Spielberg.
26. #7. Embarrassing question. Anything with Farfur is his
Harry Wright ,   UK   (12.18.10)
favourite TV series though.
27. Time for speilberg to make a movie about the lies in Arab me
rachel ,   usa   (12.18.10)
media such as Al Dura for an example
28. To nour and salma #5#20
Texan   (12.18.10)
Tell me one palestinia movie i can watch witch have some Love and Passion in at, not only hate ,You and you people never come close to Spielberg movie and to his great mind... You can learn a few things from hem...... Good luck with you hatred go on and do not put you two cents in were are you not belong ....
29. I've seen maybe 6 Israeli made movies
Joe ,   Ohio, USA   (12.18.10)
and have loved each and everyone of them. I have also seen maybe 4 arab made movies. Each one was the most depressing things I have ever seen! Most of them had to be watched in stages over several days just to get through them hoping that they somehow had some redeeming value in them. (They didn't) The acting was always OK in the movies but the script, story, and subject matter was terrible! The arabs can complain about Spielberg's depictions of them as insulting and cartoonish but it's a step ahead of the way they present themselves!
30. To Marwan ..... Jordan
Rachel Openheimer ,   Sde Boker ' Israel   (12.18.10)
Love you, Marwan... You are brave and smart... if all neighbours behaved like you...
Next talkbacks
Back to article