News
Stabbing victim's friends shocked
Roi Mandel
Published: 19.12.10, 21:19
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
40 Talkbacks for this article
1. "who could do such a thing?"
yahudi ,   eretz yisrael   (12.19.10)
thats a rhetorical question, right?
2. :: Give it a few day...
Matty Groves ,   Fairport   (12.19.10)
"They asked me to open the door to her apartment and took out some documents and personal belongings. No one knows the details of the incident" Yeah this will really help track down "two Arabs" who committed a 'terror attack'. Again this is speculation but by all media reports this claim by Wilson that she and a 'friend' were attacked by "two Arabs" sounds very flimsy. What are the bets that in the coming days it will be reported that Wilson and the deceased where 'known' to each other and the Israeli police start to focus on a 'personal motive'?
3. 2 Arabs did it.
Israeli 2   (12.19.10)
4. ISRAELI ARAB issues that are pushed under the carpent wont
John Beasley ,   Wichita US   (12.19.10)
stay there. Deal with it , face it , look into its eyes, stop IGNORING IT. These women are now dead because you IGNORE it. Shame on you Leftist agenda...You think you are helping but your arrogance + ignorance of Arab culture and Islam actually are more dangerous than anything else. Loyalty needs to be had. If for no other reason than to deal JUSTLY with the wretched murderers.
5. no cuts on her hands
eporue ,   europe   (12.19.10)
if it was an attack, then this is understandable, as she was bound on the back, and couldnt defend herself with them... but when someone stabs another person (and e.g. also injures themselves) they often have cuts on their hands, too ?
6. picture of Wilson on the front page; muffled?
observer   (12.19.10)
"I've never seen her friends around – only her and her dog" said Avital who rented an apartment to Wilson. "She had many friends that used to stay with her" said Yosef, the son of her housekeeper. Contradiction could be because the woman worked as spy for the Shin Bet.
7. Out of millions of arabs in Israel all it takes is 2lunatics
Omri ,   Israel   (12.19.10)
with some knives to get this sorta thing coming. It's rather impossible to fight those kind of things...
8. # 6
Birdi ,   Israel   (12.19.10)
Your imagination is working overtime.
9. #6, Shin Bet? Try Jews for Jesus.
Truth Hurts ,   Israel   (12.19.10)
The ultimate in irony, pretend to be Jewish, make Aliyah, wear a star of David, get stabbed by an Arab. Well, you didn't fool everyone, but you did fool the Arabs congrats.
10. Attackers spoke hebrew
Cali Cal ,   Los Angeles, USA   (12.19.10)
I think settlers did this.
11. #2 Matty Groves
Miracle Dog ,   Tel Aviv   (12.19.10)
So you moan about speculation, then speculate in the last paragraph. You hypocritical twonk. Don't you have anything better to do, maybe something nearer to home? Even worse, you disgrace the name of a great band.
12. The housekeeper has an Arab name.
HW ,   Jerusalem   (12.19.10)
13. it is a crime
salma ,   jerusalem   (12.19.10)
search who are the criminals .. to say why .. is it money .i do not think so .the dead one can not say but the alive one may forget some conversation with these criminals .... i do not accept it is for kidnapping or national cause becouse it occured by chance to two women ..only if there is a previose dating
14. :: Post #11
Matty Groves ,   Fairport   (12.20.10)
"Miracle Dog"! Where do these one-time posters come up with such silly names?!
15. To: No. 10
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (12.20.10)
Most Arabs speak Hebrew. They learned it while working in highly lucrative jobs in Israel -- before the PA took over, that is. Now they're unemployed. For your information, oh ignorant one, no self-respecting Settler would touch tref.
16. ISRAEL MUST RESPOND TO THE REGIMES.
BUTSeriously ,   Sydney, Australia   (12.20.10)
Making the same error as US will not cease such sub-human murders. Bush went to the Afghan hills when he should have gone to the terror regime factories. Israel must confront the real murderers who have thus far caused 100's of 1000's of innocent deaths.
17. 'Who could hurt such a gentle woman?'
BH ,   Iowa   (12.20.10)
cowards.
18. Strange Details
Alice in Wonderland ,   Oceanea   (12.20.10)
There are a number of strange details in this case. One is the total lack of any description of the two wanted men. From a different news report. "A senior Palestinian security official in the West Bank said Israeli authorities had told Palestinian forces to take "precautionary measures" So far, there is no indication that the killers moved to the Palestinian territories," the official said, adding that Israel had given no information like ages, names or physical descriptions of the attackers."
19. This act of Muslim-Arab terror is but the latest link of a
Jehudah Ben-Israel ,   Qatzrin, Israel   (12.20.10)
long chain of events which have been part of the war-of-attrition-through-terror by the Muslim-Arab world against the Jewish community of Eretz Israel (Land of Israel); one that commenced in 1920 and is yet to cease. Through the on-going use of knifing, drive-by shooting, explosives - including suicide bombing - and the launching of rockets - the Muslim-Arabs - not Christian-Arabs, not Druze-Arabs, mind you!! - have managed to murder many thousands of innocent Jews - women, men and children of all ages - hoping to dislodge, to uproot the Jewish people from its ancestral homeland. This war has nothing to do with "occupation", "settlements", "Gaza", etc. - all buzz words designed to achieve a political expediency at a given time. This was has been conducted since 1920, some 28 years before the nation-state of the Jewish people, Israel, was proclaimed!! It is high time the US president and his right hand woman realized what we, Jews, have been facing!!
20. who could do such a thing?
moron ,   galut   (12.20.10)
terrorists--'hikers' should lnow the terrain and at least be armed
21. #14, check mate Mattie! Hypocrite! Hypocrite!
Mike   (12.20.10)
22. Hikers
Marilyn ,   USA   (12.20.10)
There are the more adventurous people, who want to go out and see what's out there. They like to go out and explore and find things that are beautiful and breathtaking. However they have to be really careful or they might stumble accross things that are really ugly too.
23. Predators
Marilyn ,   USA   (12.20.10)
Basically predator types are in all societies and they're going to pick situations in which they can be sure of winning and that aren't especially difficult. For example let's say that they have big knifes, are strong, have an element of surprise, a secluded area, and that they were studing the women first. Now you take a look at the women. They're probably laughing and talking not studing their surroundings, probably definitely not in martial arts fighting shape and they might have had something to drink, which slowed their reaction times and their judgement. They don't have weapons (with the knive it was probably used for taking samples of plants or something). In this case, neither one of them should have survived, but something might have spooked the perpetrators to run. And there probably is a lot of cowardliness involved in such acts.
24. Sherlock Holmes
shrinkDave ,   miami usa   (12.20.10)
What fascinating talkbacks by clearly the world's finest investigators possible. These talkbacks should be must reads at all police and investigative schools. Great work. Keep it up.
25. who could do this? and to Matt Groves
David ,   Haifa Israel   (12.20.10)
first who could do this... muslims. terrorist refugees who should be sent home to egypt and jordan. second to matty groves... go to haaretz and post. it is anti semitic and german owned. jew haters like you are most welcome.
26. Groves can't quack like a duck?
Brian Cohen ,   Judean Peoples Front   (12.20.10)
If it looks like a duck, waddles like a duck, quacks like a duck, has feathers and a bill like a duck, well then most of us would surmise that it might indeed be a duck. Not Matty Groves. There appears to have been no theft, no sexual assault, no attempt at ransom. The two were attacked and stabbed and left for dead. Despite years of factual evidence pointing to Palestinian violence against unarmed civilians, Groves thinks it's just a case of mistaken identity, and the two attackers were really English instigators dressed as Arabs. Groves cannot accept the fact that Palestinian policy - both Fatah and Hamas - is to educate and train young Palestinian attackers to go kill Israeli civilians in order to "resist the occupation."
27. OK Matty, I'll take your bet
Tahl ,   Ashdod   (12.20.10)
If your theory proves truthful, I will concede you are right on the money. If however Kaye Susan Wilson's testimony proves truthful, and indeed Arabs have murdered her friend and tried to murder her - then you would admit your crazy speculation was wrong, admit that you cooked it up just to deflect blame from the Arab murderers (being the Arab-apologist that you are), and also apologize to Wilson. Do we have a bet?
28. To sherlock holmes
Marilyn ,   USA   (12.20.10)
As women, we all have to deal with things such as violence and crime against women, to some extent as part of our overall landscape. So agree or disagree, however, not thinking about things, is not an option.
29. "...no self-respecting Settler ..."
A little truth from ,   Sarah b   (12.20.10)
30. :: Brian Cohen - #26
Matty Groves ,   Fairport   (12.20.10)
There is only one claimant who says it was a 'duck' yet yourself and other Ynuts are only to eager to latch onto this claim in the absence of any tangible evidence. I would also point out that there are other posters here who think the whole claim is fishy. Brian you really need to read these posts more carefully, I have clearly stated I think that the claim by Wilson was fabricated - not once did I allude to concept of "mistaken identity".
Next talkbacks
Back to article