News
Stabbing victim 'found God' in Israel
Roi Mandel
Published: 20.12.10, 14:14
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
111 Talkbacks for this article
91. #54 & #78 both condone Christian missionaries
andy ,   orlando,u.s   (12.21.10)
Both of these 2 people condone proselytizing. The victim in this case did not deserve to die and her family have everybody's condolences. However there can be no excuse for Christian Missionary activity with their deceitful methods trying to convert Jews in Israel.
92. are you kidding me???
human being ,   usa   (12.21.10)
Have any of you looked back and read this chain of your sub-human comments? The evilness spews out from every political side and every geographic location and it makes me want to vomit. You all ought to be ashamed of yourselves and your vile attitudes toward other human beings.
93. Israel must remain the focus
Jonathan ,   New Zealand   (12.21.10)
How sad that christians and Jews alike bicker on this talkback. This murder is terrible and an affront to G-d. Christians must support Israel and not seek to convert Jews where it is not wanted. Jews should not hate christians - no matter how misguided and clumsy they are at times. All I know is G-d wants Israel and the Jewish people to prosper - is not the creation of the state of Israel and its survival enough evidence of this for us stupid humans!. Jonathan (christian)
94. To Solomon in Brooklyn
Christian woman ,   USA   (12.21.10)
Thank you very much for your wise and gentle comments. May you be blessed in all important aspects of your life, and may you have a good influence on all whom you meet. I also respect you for not "taking the bait" from those here who are trying to goad you.
95. Salma no 31
JUDAH THE LION   (12.21.10)
Your allah is pagan god.Go and prey to god of the moon, and the black satan stone in your holy land of mecca,
96. #95 if your point is accurate then y is it that...
(12.21.10)
The Rambam writes that Jews are allowed to pray in Mosques but not in churches?
97. Thank you Alexander # 88 of N.J.
Ginette Golden ,   Toronto, Canada   (12.21.10)
People, please stop the madness! Nobody can convert anyone without their consent, even less the Jews. As for those Christians who love Israel and the Jewish People, I tip my hat to them because they do much more good than bad for MY people. Having said that, let's pray for the soul of the dead woman and her family and let's hope her surviving friend's physical and mental health be restored.
98. Jonathan #93 is right. Sorry andy of Orlando...
Haifa   (12.21.10)
...for saying you were a "warthog"...its just that your comment #30 seemed so tasteless, callous and cold...I know you don't want to see others die by your answer you gave, even if they are what you call "Missionaries". The point was that she is someone's daughter and they are missing her today. Anyway, I don't think Jews should be converted, and God says He will bless those who bless you, so I truly do apologize, you are not a warthog. God loves you as you are.
99. Murder
Marilyn ,   USA   (12.21.10)
No matter what the religious issues or philosophical questions, it's still a murder. You still have a crime scene, the victims and the perpetrators, the families, the police, involvement of governments and so forth. Why is there so much invested in all of this? Because life is ultimately one of the most important things, and someone shouldn't be able to just non-chalantly take that away without hardly a thought. And at the end of the day, it could've been you or me who had the misfortune of coming accross the wrong people at the wrong time instead of them.
100. To the family of Ms. Luken
Christian Hart ,   USA   (12.21.10)
Who is probably deep in mourning, but should they read this, you have my sincerest condolences in your time of sorrow... To the rest of you, shame on you! Is your faith and trust in G-d so weak that you have to slander and abuse the dead while their blood is still fresh on the earth? When G-d talked with Noach did he say that ONLY Jewish blood would need to be accounted for to Him in the judgement? NO, all the blood of the slain in all the earth... Shame on you for your lack of understanding! Shame on you for your support of this woman's murder! Do you think that it will not be held against you too, while you support it, you EVIL speakers, unless you should repent! G-d has given you Israel and you can crow about having His face shine upon you...but He has also appointed terror over you (in case you hadn't noticed), until you stop giving lip service to Torah and begin to practice it! Many of these comments are a hideous perversion and defilement of the word of G-d. A light unto the nations, PLEAZZZZE...
101. The Police and how things are done here
j ,   Jerusalem   (12.22.10)
Makes me be ashamed to be an Israeli.
102. #1- They should perhaps keep people like yourseld-
Juliet ,   Jerusalem   (12.22.10)
away from thsi country that are a prison to freedon of though, and religion. Go away.
103. What was it?
Caleb ,   New York USA   (12.22.10)
A murderous attack by Christian cultist Wilson on a fellow member, who perhaps had expressed doubts, followed by an attempted cover-up. Note Wilson's knife wounds all were superficial with little blood loss according to hospital reports. SELF-INFLICTED????
104. Salma
Frank P. ,   Jerusalem   (12.22.10)
I don't think Salma is an Arab. I think she (or he) is a right wing Jew masquerading as a 'perfectly evil' palestinian agitator. The purpose? to engender strong feelings of revulsion towards the Arabs and therefore strengthen the Jewish perspective. Very smart, very effective.
105. All you Jews here who are saying this about missionaries
yudit ,   Jerusalem   (12.22.10)
in such a time as this, where a woman was stubed. You see what you are writing??? and all your hate to missionaries?you are missionaries yourself. And your hate is equal to the hate of arabs toward Jews because hatred is hatred. And you are a shame to the Jewish race. I better be mistaken as a Christian then being a Jew like you. SHAME ON YOU
106. Kristine Luken
Shoshanah Ephraim ,   Jerusalem   (12.22.10)
Thank you. We have enough enemies let us be grateful for our friends.
107. Well said Yudit, number 105
Scott ,   Haifa   (12.22.10)
Hate is hate. God bless you.
108. @Brian: idiot
Andre ,   Jerusalem   (12.22.10)
I just went to see Kay in the hospital, who is in tremendous pain. I thought compassion was a Jewish trait, but you seem to prefer lashon hara and unfounded slander. You should be ashamed of yourself you moron.
109. Compassion
Andy ,   London   (12.22.10)
Our scripture speak a great deal of G-D's lovingkindness to people. They also say that we are to be a light to the nations. I am saddened by much of what I have read here. Two women were attacked, one murdered, the other wounded. Yet the merchants of hate seem to think this is alright. I prefer to honour the memory of my great-aunt (a Christian) who married my great-uncle and hid him for most of the war from the Nazis. Although sent to Auschwitz he survived and was reunited with his wife after the war. He had far more compassion than many whose comments I have read, despite far more justification for hate. Let us remember that our G-D sees all and only He can forgive us for our sins including hatred.
110. Fake Jews?
Tyler ,   Vancouver, Canada   (12.27.10)
Whether you think he's a false Messiah or not, he was born a Jewish man and all his first followers were Jewish. Why does it have to be any different today? The Jewish people have a 2000 year old right to a piece of land, don't some of us have a right to a 2000 year old Jewish Messiah and his religion?
111. Caleb NY aka @$$hole
Cate ,   Canada   (12.28.10)
Pleassee.. "Christian cultist Kay"".. I knew Kay years ago and she is a very clever, funny Jewish lady. She was an artist in Tel Aviv. Your discriminatory rant is very similar to those that rage against "Jewish domination of the world" and other nonsense. A tourist died and Jewish woman was left for dead ... show some respect.
Previous talkbacks
Back to article