News
Abbas: No Israeli presence in future state
Roee Nahmias
Published: 25.12.10, 15:40
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
70 Talkbacks for this article
1. No Palestine between Jordan River and the Sea
Paul Freedman ,   Falls Church, USA   (12.25.10)
It is high time that Israel recognizes the current PLO has no intention of recognizing Israel or finally withdrawing its claim to be the sole state, in stages, between the Jordan River and the Mediterranean. Israel must advance a parallel claim and end its approval of a two-state solution.
2. here are their true intentions...
bruno ,   Portugal   (12.25.10)
Do to others what you wouldn't want them to do to you. This is the real motto of the PA dream. They don't want jewish settlers but they want the present israeli arabs + the so called arab refugees in pre 1967 Israel. How can you discuss peace with such guys ? I have a Road Map for Bibi, send this PA gang across the Jordan river and then deal directly with Hamas on a language that they know well, called war, since they are begging for a whip... Is there any other solution to this conflict ?
3. LOL!
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (12.25.10)
Translation: No Jews. Well, that just confirms what we've known all along -- the so-called "Palestinian" state will exist either exclusively in the minds of the ersatz "Palestinians," or they assert themselves in Jordan. Judea and Samaria -- forget it. That's Israel's. Soon to be annexed, and its Arab interlopers repatriated to Jordan, country of their citizenship. Mark my words. The time for games is over. Abbas is about to learn a hard, cold reality -- what happens to a vanquished people who fail to take advantage of every single opportunity ever presented to them and who resort to terror on an unparalleled scale. Well -- no one can say that the ersatz "Palestinians" haven't had their chances. They've had far more than they deserve. And blown each and every one. Not our fault. Good to know that they will no longer be our problem. They've been a pox upon the House of Israel long enough.
4. Oh yeah? We want the same terms. Unilateral, it's called.
Bat Zion ,   Central Israel   (12.25.10)
5. Abbas- be warned...
Laura   (12.25.10)
so it is ok if Israel throws out all Arabs and Palestinians right now? what is good for the goose.....
6. True racism!
~~Lengualima~~ ,   I   (12.25.10)
Mr. Abbas "If a Palestinian state is established with Jerusalem as its capital, we will object to the presence of even one Israeli in its territory. This is our position," he said. Where are? those who dedicate their lives calling racist at Israel , segregationist, ethnocentrism, and the whole dictionary of the antisemitism. Read many times, Europeans, Americans, whose are the true racists, whose only dreams are, clean the Middle East of Jews.
7. Abbas calls for racist country
Eric ,   Tel Aviv & NY   (12.25.10)
Abbas refuses to have Jews in the new Palestine while expecting Israel to keep "Palestinian" Arabs living in Israel. Truly a racist division.
8. #3 What mushrooms are you eating?
Nour ,   Palestine   (12.25.10)
Sweetheart, you can wake up every day, day after day, believing the Sun rises from the West, or that the Earth is flat. Just as you can believe Palestinians will be "repatriated" to Jordan, in your true colonialist, genocidal mentality. Reality sits on the other side of the fence, along with daily recognitions of the State of Palestine. It is actually your own squatters from Russia and Brooklyn who will soon be repatriated, Sharon style, out of Palestine back to their former countries! Mark my word - darling.
9. An Apartheid Palestinian State, Anyone?
Michael ,   Eilat, Israel   (12.25.10)
Very little hue and cry over the PA's insistense on a Judenrein entity. No UN condemnations, no Human Rights groups ever speak out about this long standing policy... It is a shame that Abbas is what we have to deal with as a "moderate" leader as he is incapable of not uttering inherently racists statements as matters of future Palestinian policy. Why does no one ever notice this?
10. now there will be a REAL apartheid state around here
mike ,   israel (formerly usa   (12.25.10)
i look forward to that because everything israel has ever done that they complain about will absolutely pale in comparison to what these losers will do when they get their own state. that, AND they won't be able to blame the "brutal" "occupation" for their disgusting actions.
11. There is NO Israeli presence in Jordan
Chris Rettenmoser ,   Bayerisch Gmain Germ   (12.25.10)
and Judea and Samaria are and will always be an integral part of Israel...so where is your problem Mr. Abbas...lolll
12. Palestinian state : Sad, pathetic joke...
Noodles ,   Coney Island   (12.25.10)
that will never see it's fruition. At least not in Judea and Samaria.
13. there are no israelis in jordan
moron ,   galut   (12.25.10)
jordan is palestine...however there are still arabs in israel--who is 'occupying' whom? see map...
14. Will Israel accept Nazi soldiers operating in Israel?
Observer ,   USA   (12.25.10)
To all talk backers: You all seem to forget that the IDF has been arresting Palestinians, evicting Palestinians and making life miserable for Palestinians. If the shoe were in the other foot, would you wear it?
15. HOW STUPID CAN YOU BE
jim   (12.25.10)
IN 1933 JUDEA DECLARED WAR ON GERMANY FROM NEW YORK (REF NYT). HISTORY TELLS US THE RESULTS OF THAT JEWISH WARMONGERING. FOR TWO HUNDRED YEARS PALESTINE & JERUSALEM WAS RULED BY THE CHRISTIAN SWORD. HISTORY TELLS US WHAT HAPPENED AFTERWARDS. PALESTINIAN ARABS HELD TO THEIR LAND THEN AND THEY ALWAYS WILL. TAKE HELEN THOMAS ADVISE.
16. Peace
Marty ,   L.A. USA   (12.25.10)
OK, no IDF forces & no Israeli's in the new State, fine then NOT ONE PALESTINIAN SETS FOOT IN ISRAEL for work. NO imports, no exports & every Palestinian now living in Israel leaves & never comes back into Israel, that is fair. If Abbas wants his cake, he can't eat it as well...
17. Abbas: No Israeli presence in future state
A ,   Belgium   (12.25.10)
I hope that also includes no Israeli electricity, no Israeli water,no Israeli gas, no trade with Israel, no working in Israel, no Israeli medical care, no Israeli technology and no arabs in Israel! They can all go to their "future state".
18. What's really sad...
john   (12.25.10)
Is that Abbas does not even have true legitimacy to strike a deal. Sadly Hamas technically has that power and in a YNET article they just stated, "Israel will 'cease to exist and we will have Palestine." And the world wonders why Israel's security is so important?
19. Sarah B. - They let you out again?
The assylum   (12.25.10)
Enjoy your christmass vacation, we care about you.
20. Pales...what ?
Gabe Yakmore ,   Canada   (12.25.10)
Abbas has nothing left to negotiate about even if he had a valid mandate to do so.
21. to #14, Israelis cannot be on the border of their own state!
Mike ,   Atlanta USA   (12.25.10)
Get real.
22. What's your problem?
Edithann ,   USA   (12.25.10)
No Israeli military bordering Palestine unless the Palestinians are armed to the same degree? What part of that don't you understand...let's try making it clearer.... Palestine is not to be armed, but Israel will be armed to the teeth and deployed at Palestinian borders...Hahahah What are you all smoking? TATA
23. "Compomise", #8, #14, #15
Solomon ,   Bklyn   (12.25.10)
There are no negotiations, yet the "Palestinians" have given the US their Final Terms. So much for negotiation. I don't think they know the meaning of the word "compromise". #8- You have a point in that most "Palestinians" didn't come from Jordan but from Syria, Egypt, etc in the early 1900's because of the good economic situation, improved by a large wave of Jews who came in the late 1800's. Jordan didn't exist at that time. It is, however, over 72% of what was then "Palestine". Salami tactics? #14- Fine. Israelis will not be stationed in the 'Palestinian' Jordan valley. The valley will remain a part of Israel. #15- I understand that you call declaring war on Germany and the Nazis, warmongering, as you supported them and lost. Don't forget that Islam conquered Arabia, including the Land of Israel, by the sword. Double standard?
24. #15 How Stupid Can YOU Be????
Chaya ,   Tel Aviv   (12.25.10)
There is no such thing as a palestinian people. The only people who has the right to live here - historically and legally - is the Jewish people!
25. #15 Jim
Lippy ,   Proud Israeli   (12.25.10)
I'll take Helen Thomas' advice at face value.........
26. #3
Palestinian   (12.25.10)
Dear Sarah, I'm sorry to tell you this. But not everything your government(s) tell(s) you about is correct. Palestinians will never leave their land. You may do stupid thing and annex west bank, but you have to deal with the Palestinians there. And one more thing, you are (Israelis) really arrogant. This will make your fall even much bitter. I'll leave you now, kind regards, Palestinian
27. #9 it's NO Lebensraum in the future state
observer   (12.25.10)
28. That could explain it
jim ,   uk   (12.25.10)
an advanced case of the pox attacking the brain cells. would explain your mindless drivel
29. Ynet! Abass said: "Jewish presence..", not
tanya ,   tel aviv israel   (12.25.10)
"Israeli presence..".
30. you never ever know the Arab mentality
observer   (12.25.10)
Abbas has just accepted the idea of a pure international force along the borders of the future Palestinian state.
Next talkbacks
Back to article