News  Magazine
Report: Hamas torturing 250 Eritreans in Egypt
Menachem Gantz
Published: 28.12.10, 20:00
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
45 Talkbacks for this article
31. i wonder who was caught in europe last month ?
zooz ,   gaza   (12.29.10)
wasnt that an israeli gang and doctors doing the human organs harvestings ??? even i russia !! anyway its simply a stupid claims , Islam forbids such actions and any moslim will till you its forbidden , if someone is harvesting them in Sinai it would be the israeli gangs and not palestenian groups
32. 6
zionist forever   (12.29.10)
If you were not looking for a donkey & wife you might have seen things like this going on. The noble palestinians have no problem blowing up civilians riding on busses or in a hotel celebrating a passover meal. They were celebrating in the streets on 9/11 as the World Trade Cetre came down. Sorry to burst your little bubble about palestinians being an angelic people. Palestinians have no morrals and you are certainly not above doing this. Hope you get many years of plessure from the wife & donkey.
33. Salma: looks like yr poeple are cruel MOST of the time
STEPHAN ,   YAFFO   (12.29.10)
but as long as they keep paying you to spread hamas propaganda, you can keep post your lies with the blessing of our democracy, you do not fool anyopne here. go post your junk to the guardian in UK
34. HISTORY: the Arabs were and still are the SLAVE TRADERS of
Dr. Sergio HaDaR ,   Augusta Taurinorum   (12.29.10)
the planet. It has been like that FOR CENTURIES. NOT BY CHANCE, in the Neghev even the Beuduins call the black Beduins 'abda and 'abed (slave, f. and m. nouns)
35. @ #6 Rashid
Chana ,   Israel/USA   (12.29.10)
I think I love you and your donkey, Sullah. I want to be wife #4. Meet me on the Egypt side of the tunnel tonight.
36. to #16 so spread the word
ghostq   (12.29.10)
finally someone resonable in Norway, btw that book is mega kool, who knew norwigians faught the Nazis.
37. zooz @ 31, if I am to believe Muslim claims Islam forbids
leo ,   usa   (12.29.10)
many atrocious things, yet it has never stopped your gang from committing them. Weak argument, my friend, very weak.
38. And probably part of them are turn into spy for Hamas
Elie Cohen ,   Israel   (12.29.10)
39. This is a cruel lie: adds insult to injury
Daniel Abraham ,   Eritrean   (12.29.10)
First of all, since Israel accpets Eritrean refugees, every African migrant is hiding behind Eritrean identity to get acceptance (hence the ballooned 250 number). Secondly, we know Isreal does not love Hamas, so this is yet another thinly-veiled chance at blackmail. LIE, LIES and LIES.
40. If this is true, Hamas proves it again
Eran ,   Singapore   (12.29.10)
that they behave like beasts, no human rights, arbitrary killings , slavery. Where are the human right NGO's? Asleep.
41. # 9 Ian
J.K. ,   Brooklyn USA   (12.29.10)
Ian ! Rashid is right,Hamastin is the best country on earth,unlike the Norvigie man, who can't own even his own wife,the man in Hamastin owns 7 wives, and everybody in Hamastin is very happy most of all the 7 wives of the Hamastinian man,because the owner of the 7 wives is poor and can't afford to hire a helper to help him in the beating up of his 7 wives,therefore,less beatings for each wife,the Norvegies are sending a delegation to Hamastin to study the secret of their happiness and adopt their system.
42. I'm curious
Helder Vieira ,   Porto, Portugal   (12.30.10)
This is a quite interesting story, so I went to the NGO's site trying to know some more on the subject. Well, a few days ago, it seemed that bedouin traffickers were responsible for this crime. A few days later Hamas becomes the culprit... Now I'm curious.
43. Hell to Hamas
Levine ,   Dubia , UAE   (01.01.11)
I was jsust about to cry when i read, that " four have gone missing – allegedly being the subject of human organ harvesting and trafficking". That is the worst thing you can expect from a Human being. It is shame that this people are fighting for religion, because let alone a religion, just the consciene of an educated human being would not allow such attrocities to be done to person on earth. " I hope the worst things in life happen to Hammas and Palestinians, Go to hell you renegades "
44. Yes it is true!
Rahwa ,   Brussels   (01.02.11)
Dear Rashid, I am afraid it is indeed true. I am an Eritrean by origin and I recently received the sad news that one of my close cousins is amongst the kidnapped. A few days back, this cousin of mine talked to his sister, who lives in the EU, on the phone - of course demanding $8000! He informed his sister that he and many others have been kept under severe in humane conditions for over two months, and said they were regularly beaten up so heavily that some of them died on the spot! They were made to lie down on their belly and beaten up using steel rods. So please, please stop covering up, the world needs to hear the truth so that these poor young people can be saved asap.
45. ...
Winta ,   SF, California   (01.11.11)
You sound so stupid. Eritrea gaining it's independence has nothing to do with it. These people were obviously not happy in their home so they're in search for a better life. People flee countries for many different reasons. Focus on the issue of topic.
Previous talkbacks
Back to article