News
Ireland upgrades PA mission
Ronen Medzini
Published: 25.01.11, 23:22
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
96 Talkbacks for this article
1. Rest easy. Palestine will never see the light of day. TATA.
(01.25.11)
2. It couldn't that important. It wasn't even..
Eli   (01.25.11)
in the top five stories on Galei Tzahal.
3. We're done for.
Michael Steiner ,   Bahrain   (01.25.11)
The intellectual pygmies on here will, of course, lambaste the Irish government and hurl all manner of slurs at the Irish. Those of us with a functioning brain cell or two can see clearly what is going on: The writing is on the wall and it ain't looking good for the chicken-hawks and armchair losers militating for war from their living rooms thousands of miles away. For a long time--since before the establishment of the State--we had the upper hand in every respect, including morally. Gradually and beginning only recently, one by one our arguments for perpetuating a stubborn belligerent stance have slipped away to the point of making us look like a bunch of primitive morons not too many want to have much to do with. The Palestinians don't want to recognize Israel as a Jewish state? Bull. The Palestinians insist on swamping us with millions of refugees? Bull. The Palestinians agitate for huge parts of Jerusalem. Bull. Almost everyone now recognizes that WE are the intransigent side, that WE do not want to attain a peace agreement, that WE are the stumbling block. Since the world can no longer rely on us to do the smart thing of our own accord, these recognitions of the Palestinian state are an attempt to jolt us into the reality. As a proud Jew and fervent Zionist, I say to the Palestinians: CONGRATULATIONS on your state. It is almost fully de iure now; soon it will be de facto, and none will be more pleased than I.
4. Bravo Ireland
Philip K ,   Wexford, Ireland   (01.25.11)
Well as an Irish citizen im glad that Ireland is the first european state to make this move. There is no doubt in my mind that other EU members will follow suit. The Palestinian people have a right to freedom and are entitled to their own state. Im sure there are many pro Israel people that will read this storey and become very angry. Im also sure that their anger will be followed by a slur of insults directed towards Ireland and the Irish (ive seen this behavior on this site before). But to people who want to insult Ireland on here because we've made the right decision know this: We dont care what u have to say, nobody in ireland likes Israel, We believe in a free Palestine, We think that Israel- like the rest of the middle east is just an overcrowded dump, we have a lot more friends around the world than you do, we are satisfied in the knowledge that (whatever insults u may throw at us) that Ireland is by far a nicer, more beautiful, more peaceful, more green, wealthier and more friendly place to live than Israel will ever be. Everbody loves the Irish- who loves Israel?
5. #3 Proud Jew, Fervent Zionist?? NOT !!
(01.25.11)
6. Annex Area B and C
Ralph Levy ,   USA   (01.25.11)
No interim agreements Annex Area B and C when is Israel going to start imposing consequences for these actions. If not the world will roll over us. What is the government doing sitting on it's rear do something to fight against this.
7. A Irish tradition
Michel ,   Jerusalem   (01.25.11)
to help terrorists movments all over the world !
8. What are Israel's Critical Security Needs ? (Video) !!
(01.25.11)
http://emunadate.blogspot.com/2011/01/israels-critical-security-needs-for.html
9. WoW...Hurray,
Salma ,   Palestine   (01.25.11)
we must win and we will. Thank's brothers & sisters in Ireland.
10. Decisions by the current Irish Government are meaningless
A   (01.25.11)
The Irish Government is about to topple due to unprecendented economic woes and this is all they can think of? Pointless. Sorry folks, there'll never be another "palestinian" state. Get used to it.
11. Amusing that Ireland's action preempted by dealt of PA
Eric ,   Tel Aviv & NY   (01.25.11)
On the same day that the PA is self destructing over the leaked internal documents Ireland upgrades them to embassy. Now that is what I call irony.
12. #3 Michael - they are further from a state today than ever
Eric ,   Tel Aviv & NY   (01.25.11)
Your analysis may have been true last week, although I have seen nothing to change the perception that: The Palestinians don't want to recognize Israel as a Jewish state? The Palestinians insist on swamping us with millions of refugees? The Palestinians agitate for huge parts of Jerusalem. None of what came out shows any differently to what we knew before Abbas can not sign a deal and Hamas will not recognize Israel. Palestine self destructed with the Al Jazzer publication of these documents.
13. Terrorist panderers like Ireland !!!!!
Don Rosenberg ,   Palatine USA   (01.25.11)
To all the ignorant, cowardly countries that attempt to recognize the terrorist entity of arabs occupying Israeli land, go to Hell. Jerusalem and Judea/Samaria are Israeli land. These moronic arabs can declare a state and the ass kissing gentile countries can support them, but they will not have a 2nd so-called pales.... they have jordan. Reward racist, fascist, terrorist people, that what good gentiles do !!!!!!
14. to phillip in ireland-regardless of
Barney ,   USA   (01.25.11)
your ignorant views of the middle east situation, to say that Israel is an over crowded dump and ireland is a prosperous country is absurd! didn't ireland just go broke? Israel has one of the strongest economies in the world. you have been in the pub too long. Israel is known for hi tech and ireland is known for well the blarney stone and alcoholics
15. Deluded idiot
John ,   Liverpool   (01.25.11)
"Ireland is by far a nicer, more beautiful, more peaceful, more green, wealthier and more friendly place to live than Israel will ever be" The bomb makers in Ireland are still working hard, and the Irish economy is down the toilet and he says this???
16. #4 please explain
Israel Israeli ,   Tel Aviv   (01.25.11)
Who are these Palestinian people? According to their own definition a Palestinian is not a culture, race, history or anything, it is simply "anyone who calls himself one". And why does this group of people deserve state when there are already 22 Arab Muslim countries? Do I deserve a state on Irish land? I remember you guys did not even want to give the Protestants a state in Ireland, and they were far more deserving than the Arabs. And if these Muslim Arabs deserve a state, do the Kurds? The Basques? The Berbers? The Copts? Why does Ireland not recognize their rights? And by the way, not everybody loves the Irish. I do, but the British hate your guts.
17. All Catholic Countries?
Jonny ,   Cape Town   (01.25.11)
All catholic countries. Given the Vaticans recent stance in blaming Israel for the ethnic cleansing of christians in predominately muslim countries, one wonders what directives were issued by the Vatican, itself an Imperialistic power.
18. Thanks, Ireland!
Brazilian ,   NYC USA   (01.25.11)
Thanks many times. More countries will follow!
19. IRELAND... THE TWO STATE NATION...
stude ham   (01.25.11)
and in the northern irish state they're still killing each other under the pretense of a peace process. ireland is a sick joke.
20. #3 intellectual pygmies?
Ralph Levy ,   USA   (01.25.11)
I guess you were talking about yourself.
21. #9 Since when is "win" in Palestinian vocabulary?
(01.25.11)
22.  Palestinian embassy to open in Ireland
Ilan Haran ,   Beer Sheva   (01.25.11)
Shame on Ireland!
23. #7 and an Open Letter to an Irish with a soul!and a
chris ,   wales   (01.25.11)
Conscience. Yes,and what I would like to ask any fair minded Irish man.woman is the following: First,What have the Israelis done to you Personally,your Nation?anything so evil that you have such blatant contempt towards them?I would have thought that to explain such hostile and vile attitude towards Israel-there must be something that Israel is supposed to have done wrong to you Irish,ANSWER PLEASE! What is it about the Palestinian Culture that the Irish are so in love with?is it the way they treat their own people?is it because they teach their Children to be martyrs by blowing up,or fighting the 'Evil' Zionist??or is it because in their Future State,they will never allow One Jew to live among them-while 1 Million Arabs live in a free democratic state of Israel,even allow to incite hatred agaisnt Israel? and more,Israel is asked to allow 6 Million so called Arab Refugees to flood this Israeli State,while Jews are barred from their State,which is btw,JUDEA AND SAMARIA..Sorry if you can't see the connection of those names to Jewish History and past..really am Sorry for those who don't see Facts,while embracing a culture of death,a People who never had a State in their History,yet are asking the Israelis to not only give them this State,but that Israel itself will be flooded with enough Arabs to desroy the Jewishness of Israel,and make the Arabs a Majority.. I Don't mean to be cruel to anyone here,But it is my Opinion that anyone supporting the Palestinians,as things are now-Abbas's Refusual to Recognize the Jewish State,and wanting every Jew out of Judea and Samaria-hen that person is not thinking clearly,is in fact Insane,is either totally blind to what happening,or self deceived,or is Absolutely Anti-Israel/Anti-Semitic! anti-Semitic because they refuse to recognize the Jewishness of Israel,and care less for Israel's connection with Jerusalem for 3000 YEARS.. SO Irish friends,please think Logic here..I'm not Jewish but my God I would never support these people Who Reject Israel's right to exist,with the same passion the irish are doing..It is an Obsession! how come your supporting Hamas,because if you support this decision today,then you must know hamas rule over Gaza and they have vowed to destroy Israel? anyway,hve said enough,could have said more,but I believe that any Irishman who can read can see clearly their hatred exposed if they think as many Irish people think on this issue!
24. Ireland? No Surprise.
RayS ,   USA   (01.25.11)
Ireland has a long anti-Jewish history. When it was most important, during WW2 ,though technically remaining neutral, Ireland's action (in her vital position) was of great assistance to the Nazi War Effort. Many lives were lost due to merchant shipping sunk (or dangerously deployed) due to Ireland's "neutral"position .Ireland was a harmful drag on the Allied war effort. She has not been helpful to Israel.
25. The so-called "palistinians" can SAY they have a state but
Bunnie Meyer ,   Los Angeles, CA USA   (01.25.11)
there is no "right of return" and no headquarters in the unified city of Jerusalem and no army and no airport and nothing but a wish they were a people. I could declare that I was ruler of the universe and it would have just as much meaning as anything these arabs say.
26. Pal State
Arturo   (01.25.11)
A "palestinian" state will last only until the first time the new nation attacks Israel. Given the history of the "palestinians" that will happen quite quickly. (And "palestine" will will cease to exist)
27. Surprising? Nope..nothing new, nothing to be concerned about
Faruq ,   Ireland   (01.25.11)
Ireland is an impotent country with an anti-semitic past that is still evident - one only has to look at Irelands only jewish politician has been treated. The country is full of ignorance and most people are apathetic when it comes to things like this. Some fringe parties like Sinn Fein (IRA - who sent apologies to germany after they lost the war, helped harbour nazis etc) are nothing short of terrorist supporters. In the midst of economic disaster one can only expect things like this. It's quite amusing - the current Irish government is hated by the people and the Republic of Ireland isn't like much be Europe. It's quite unfortunate as Ireland does have its positives - but Ireland is simply a waste of Israel's time. Terror supporting organisations like the Ireland-Palestine-Solidarity-Campaign are proven liars (eg. recently on their site they have the one month anniversary of the women "killed by israeli gas" - the one that was shown to have been caused by drug overdose of palestinian doctors). IPSC and its members are associated with other extremists organisation and make no mistake - Irish anti-zionism in almost all cases their mask for anti-semitism. In the North of Ireland which is part of Britain there is much less anti-semitism because it is like the bible belt where many love Israel.
28. i don't know about everyone loving
Barney ,   USA   (01.25.11)
the irish,however, i do like shane macgowan. don't know what his political views are and don't care. i have seen that most musicians best stick to music. he is one of ireland's great singer/songwriters with great alcoholic drenched vocals and lyrics. that is one good irish product that and irish whiskey
29. #3 is a great example of typical irish provocation
Faruq   (01.25.11)
there is nothing Jewish, zionist or intelligent about his post. I rest in the knowledge that palestine will never be a lasting reality (existing for a couple of years as an unsustainable pretend state -- under the worst circumstances it could happen -- but there is absolutely no posibility whatsoever that it could be sustained despite leftist delusions - they simply do not understand islam or even arab culture) , readers should too.
30. #25 Bunnie, "ruler of the universe".....
Noodles ,   Coney Island   (01.25.11)
not just as much meaning......more !!
Next talkbacks
Back to article