News
Soldiers deliver, save Palestinian baby
Hanan Greenberg
Published: 07.02.11, 14:21
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
36 Talkbacks for this article
1. Not on Al Jazeera
Jew from Brasil ,   Rio de Janeiro   (02.07.11)
I will bet a million dollars that this news will not appear in any other news site beside Israel and I will be 100 million dollars that will not appear on Al Jazeera
2. Great news.
SAM ,   ME   (02.07.11)
3. Miracle
Jorge el judio ,   Israel/USA/Argentina   (02.07.11)
Is anybody reading this article? This is an example of love, kindness and courage from the IDF. They received stabbing from the enemies and they deliver babies and bring love. Good work IDF, showinmg compassion without any distintion. Please all the people against, remember that this is an army defending a country. In your country is your army acting like this?
4. IDF deliver & save Palestinian Boy
JUDAH THE LION   (02.07.11)
BRAVO IDF.YOU SAVED LIFE. No comments from our enemies anti Israel Broadcaster, such as,BBC,CNN,SKY,ALJAZEERA,ALARBIYA, If it was bad news,they will not stop broadcasting the news.
5. Great news!
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (02.07.11)
I think she should name the baby "Israel."
6. Let the word go forth
Alex ,   RSA   (02.07.11)
Let the word go forth from this time and place, to friend and foe alike......
7. L. Colonel Shalom Eisner, thank you.
Salma ,   Palestine   (02.07.11)
You are beautiful exception in "IDF"........I think the mother sould name the baby Salam which means Shalom : )
8. Salma, you have no idea
Golani ,   Vineland, USA   (02.07.11)
Salma, you have no idea, but I really believe that the majority of IDF soldiers would have done the same and I do not think that this was an exception. One day you may realize this. I too was once in a position where we were being bombarded with rocks, bricks and bottles and a little Palestinian girl was trying to cross the street and was hit with a rock. Without having to even think about it, I jumped up, ran and jumped on top of her and saved her although I was hit with rocks. Everyone of my soldiers was about to do the same, but I reacted first. Would I do that again? Yes Would you do that if the situation were reversed, I don't know, but I would hope so.
9. Salma #7
Texan   (02.07.11)
Salma The I.D.F the most moral army i wondering if this happen to the Jewish women and the Jewish baby ???? you going to help ????? G-d Bless Israel the I.D.F. and this baby to have a normal loving life ...
10. #7 SALMA
edu ,   KH, IL   (02.07.11)
Mistake, he is not the exception!!!! He is an IDF soldier. May be the baby must be named SHALOM.
11. So proud of the IDF
Lioness ,   Israel   (02.07.11)
Sky News are you reporting this?
12. Had the baby died, we (Israel) and
Robert Haymond ,   Israel/Canada   (02.07.11)
particularly the IDF would have been blamed. The crappy comment about the IDF by Salma is indicative. Simple appreciation--never!
13. Saving lives
citizen   (02.07.11)
Every good deed brings its own reward. Saving lives is probably the highest form of charity. In years to come, may the baby be told of the kindness shown to him and his mother - and may they both thrive and be happy.
14. Where's Salma ? And the the other..
Paul ,   USA   (02.07.11)
miscreants, who routinely complain about the evil Joos ? How will these hypocrites respond to this story ? By not commenting..
15. To: No. 7
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (02.07.11)
Anyone ever tell you what a complete idiot you are? Why do you always have to politicize everything? This baby could have died, and he didn't because a team of Jewish soldiers saved his life. I'm sorry that offends you. I wonder what the fate of a Jewish woman in an Arab country in a like circumstance would have been. Contemplate that one for a while.
16. Not on Haaretz or al Jazeera
Arie ,   BaGolan   (02.07.11)
Not surprising - if they did print this, it would obfuscate all the Jew hatred they promote
17. Condemnation
Arie ,   BaGolan   (02.07.11)
One way or the other, the lefties and other Anti-Jews will find a way to condemn this save.
18. Quotes
Yossef   (02.07.11)
IDF not "IDF" ISRAEL not "ISRAEL" BTW how are you doing? ;-)
19. you guys chill out on salma
pini   (02.07.11)
20. kolhakavod!
oz   (02.07.11)
one who saves one life , it is as if he/she saved the entire world. yeshar koach! the question remains, will the arab mother be greatful or continue in her jihad mentality about the el yahoud?
21. share this on your facebook accounts -let the world know
Galut ,   selah   (02.07.11)
22. proves once again,leftis'm is a mental disease
chaim.s ,   brooklyn ny   (02.07.11)
and is suicidal,the criminaly insane leftist's,just saved another potential and future suicide bomber
23. #22: how vile can you get?
Miri ,   Ashdod   (02.07.11)
What a cruel thing to say...just typical of the far right. Shame on you!
24. To # 22
Abu Yussef al Yahudi ,   Bs._Aires_Argentina   (02.07.11)
As a Jew, I'm ashamed by your disgusting post. Do you know the teachings of our Torah regarding the "Pikuach Nefesh" issue? Well, it applies to both the Jews and Non -Jews people. Shame on you for your inhumane post ! ! I'm happy that an overwhelming majority of the posts here, praise the action of our beloved IDF. AM ISRAEL CHAI
25. EISNER vs. EICHLER
Michael ,   California, USA   (02.07.11)
Coloner Eisner, Seargant Nesher and others at IDF and Israel: you are my heroes. It is too bad that your exemplary work gets mixed up by some with expressions like those of the recently reinstated MK Eichler who only gives negative image to Israel based on his religious and racist ideas. Being honest, honorable human beings is above religion, above nationality, above race. It is wonderful that people like you, Seargant Nesher and Colonel Eisner, are growing in numbers and influence, while the Eichlers of this world are just discombobulating like hell. We will beat the confusion, worry not.
26. #22
Texan   (02.07.11)
Chaim you are sick , Shame on you...
27. To 23 and 24
Chaim.s ,   Brooklyn. Ny   (02.07.11)
You are tipical delusional bleeding heart idiotic leftist!s,don,t you realize by now that every single Arab nazi living in Israel is ready to slit your and your children throat on a moments notice,if only he was sure he can get away with it,any other normal country would have thrown out these vicious snakes,only stupid suicidal Jews like you would tolerate this murderers
28. CHAIM s., I AM NAUSEATED, #22,27
Michael ,   California, USA   (02.08.11)
You can add me to the list of those who "leftists who don't understand." Your white foam is showing around your convoluted mouth. You are angry, insulting, probably treated for some aberrations. We have forgiven the Germans of the present generation, haven't we? And not only for the shilumim. At the Beit Avot where my father lived, the German volunteers were called "Our Angels" by the staff. There was no task those German volunteers wouldn't do, even when some time the paid workers refused. A day will come this newborn PA child may be a volunteer, or rather paid worker in an Israeli Beit Avot. Or this child may help build houses in Israel or work on a farm somewhere. If you buy Kosher food in Brooklyn imported from Israel, there is probably a part in it from Israeli Arab work. You disgust me to a nausea buddy, but do me a favor, stay here in the USA.
29. answer to 23 and 24
(02.08.11)
scientists have found the gene that responsible for being a left wing.. its maybe funny, but true.. so with a specific perspective, you can say that being a left wing is mental or genetic desease. and that regardless of my political views.
30. To # 27
Abu Yussef al Yahudi ,   Bs._Aires_Argentina   (02.08.11)
You are totally wrong, I'm not a leftist, I'm first a HUMAN BEING, and then an Argentinian Citizen, of Jewish Sephardic origin. My Parents and my Rabbis have taught me that the Jewish Faith, first of all, must defend the LIFE over all. Regarding you, it seems that you have RACIST ideas. People like you are the SHAME of the Mankind-PERIOD
Next talkbacks
Back to article