Opinion
Crime and punishment
Smadar Shir
Published: 22.02.11, 17:54
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
10 Talkbacks for this article
1. To: Smadar Shir
Israeli 2   (02.22.11)
Is the justice system in Israel perfect? Is it even close to perfect? If it is, please respond. If it is not, then he may yet be innocent for as far as we know. Pharao = Katzav???? Doesn't Lashon Hara feel good?
2. Crime ????
Ralph ,   Caesarea   (02.22.11)
Lies and racism, what we heard from Ashkenasi nomenklatura!
3. I hope he shares a call with Olmert both for a long time
zionist forever   (02.22.11)
Both have damaged and humiliated this country. Both as corrupt as hell Both deserve to spend a long time in jail.
4. Crime
Michael Pielet ,   Boca raton, fl.   (02.22.11)
Yes a crime was committed by the Israeli courts and media against a man who committed no crime, except the fact the he is Jewish, sephardic and religious. There is not one scintilla of corroborative evidence that a rape ever occurred. This is further proof that israel is a racist country that persecutes innocent people for crimes they did not commit. As a jew i am personally disgusted. I am reminded of the Salem witches trial where young women were falsely convicted of witchcraft. The trial and court's decision reminds me of the Spanish inquisition and trials against innocent Jews. KATSAV IS INNOCENT!
5. # 4 Michael tottaly clueless
Avi ,   Israel not Florida   (02.22.11)
gee what a clear view of events here in Israel you have from florida. Oh you really dont belive that do you, even his lawyers admit he is guilty. Sorry the race card just dosent cut it, he is a serial sex offender which has been proved beyond all reasonable doubt in a court of law, even his lawyers admit he is guilty.
6. Torah class and the president
Talula ,   Israel   (02.23.11)
How sad for Smadar Shir that she has to compare an Egyptian King whizzing in the river to a sex-starved lying cheating president. Such comparisons show that she is utterly out of touch with the real world – stop living and comparing events to those in the past – think modern day – it delivers a more intelligent punch. This man does not need to be compared to anyone. By his own merits, he abused his position, he couldn’t keep his manhood zipped up around anything with a skirt - he cheated on his wife and made a complete fool out of her - AND he has brought disgrace on our country. He’s nothing but a disgusting little degenerate who should NOT be given any more state handouts – strip him of everything and send him to prison, just like any other sex offender.
7. #1
A Jerusalemite ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (02.24.11)
The man has been convicted. He must be punished as are all convicted criminals. If he is innocent - I don't believe it - then he can appeal or he may receive a pardon. No country in the world has a 'perfect' justice system. Israel's justice system however is very, very good - one of the best in the world.
8. Michael Pielet Boca Ratan Florida
Micktheknife   (02.23.11)
This guy is absolutely clueless. I can only assume he is a very close and "dear" friend of Katsav if not a relative. Pielet is sick in the head. Was he drunk when he said katsav is innocent? he must have been.
9. To #7!
Israeli 2   (02.24.11)
Lump it. Tell it to your grandma. She MAY believe you. The judges are only human and they err alot....in this case they had NO solid evidence except for heresay. If they are NOT "mushchatim" and fear God and do as the Torah dictates, they may be fine....these judges are neither. They pride themselves in being as Goyish as possible. PATHETIC STATE of mind.
10. Patriotism and the Mizrahim
(02.24.11)
Patriotism used to be the last refuge of the scoundrel. Today it is democracy. People want transparency when it comes to funding the left wing, the left wing calls it "undemocratic." When you hear the word "democracy," think "scoundrels." When the ethnic card is pulled out and you hear the word "Mizrahim," you can be sure it is the last line of defense for someone whose acts cannot be defended. I steal and get caught? It isn't my fault I'm not an Ashkenazi. I rape and get caught? Naturally, they hate me because I am not Ashkenazi. Katsav is a rodent. He not only took took criminally unfair advantage of subordinates, he betrayed his wife, his country and the office he held. And now his supporters are whining that it's because he isn't Ashkenazi. Grow up!
Back to article