News
Video: 11-year-old Palestinian stone-thrower arrested
Elior Levy
Published: 27.02.11, 16:46
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
137 Talkbacks for this article
1. rock throwers are criminals
Golan ,   Modiin   (02.27.11)
2. wat is the deal ?/
carlos ,   5000   (02.27.11)
if I trow a stone to police .in every place in the world I get arested as well ??so ! wat is the big deal .and if it was my son.. he was NOT walking and trowing stones to police .B.T selem it is time to go to the parants and have a nice talk to this people
3. Well these little CHILDREN
Shmuel ,   Maale Adumim   (02.27.11)
should stop acting like criminals!
4. I can't feel any sorrow for Child or Parents
BEN JABO ,   ISRAEL   (02.27.11)
Parents should have kept an eye on him to prevent his participation in riots Rest assured, this tyke did this before and will do worse in the future, if he's given the opportunity All those that piss and moan about how "They're only children", must realize that stones thrown by this little bastard can be as deadly as stones thrown by their bigger brothers The "child" shouldn't have been allowed to go home, he belongs in a reformatory !! "The boy's father, Salah al-Tamimit told Ynet, "They took him without a chaperone, and by the time we arrived at the police station he was already being interrogated." Parents should have "Chaperoned" him in the first place, they didn't
5. Listen to the Footage Carefully
Nate ,   New York   (02.27.11)
The officers CLEARLY and SEVERAL TIMES say to the woman approaching the police van, "Bo'ey Ta'ali La'Oto" which means, come get into the car. The officers had no problem with a chaperone coming along with the boy...
6. So? He got a well deserved scare
ben yaacov ,   herzliya il   (02.27.11)
Maybe not old enough for criminal responsibility. Old enough to know you can't throw rocks.
7. wow
wow   (02.27.11)
where were the parent to make sure he wasnt in the street? where were the parent??? in america they would have areested the parents for aba
8. If a kids throws a stone at NYPD car he also gets arrested
Joe Black ,   NYC   (02.27.11)
They should of arrested the others as well who were interfering with the arrest. Kid should have been sent to juvenile center or foster care!! What is this crap that he gets released!!! They arrested 12 yr old jewish girls for weeks in prison during the Gaza pullout and she didn't even assault anyone!
9. Stupid policemen falled into "Bezelem"'s trap.
pure camera show   (02.27.11)
10. I listened to the tape
BEN JABO ,   ISRAEL   (02.27.11)
The loud mouthed woman was told she could escort the criminal In ANY Arab country, anyone interfering with an authority performing his sworn duty, would have gotten a swift whack in the head or a fist in the mouth, if they were lucky, they could very well have been shot for interfering with an officer One thing makes me wonder, why is it the women who seem to have the baytzim, while their men stay hidden ?
11. ynet becoming like haaretz
david ,   uk/rsa   (02.27.11)
12. Arrest the parents.
Rebecca ,   Modi'in   (02.27.11)
13. rock throwers
jason ,   ra'anana israel   (02.27.11)
Y net loves scandels! sorry ynet you r 5 years old and throw rocks at police anywhere they arrest parents and kid... kid id lucky! big enough to pick up rocks and throw it he should go to juvi jail for a few months
14. Any more VITOS Mr. Obama ???
(02.27.11)
15. Shame Shame Shame.
Salma ,   Palestine   (02.27.11)
do not ask anymore why do our children hate you !
16. Stone Thrower
Nili   (02.27.11)
I find it interesting that they are there with the camera as the police are chasing him--why did they not stop him from throwing the stones in the first place? What a bunch of hypocrites. Sending children to throw stones because they know that they won't be charged. As for B'Tselem, they should all be shipped to Gaza.
17. B'etselem
Ricardo Macher ,   Karnei Shomron IL   (02.27.11)
They should not ne investigated, just prohibited and jailed. They are the enemy!!!!
18. #15 Salma, the shame is YOURS
BEN JABO ,   ISRAEL   (02.27.11)
You should have taught your brats some manners The young criminal just hated getting caught, he thought he was going to get away with committing a crime, he didn't !! What he really needs is a stay in a reformaatory, upon release to be outfitted with an Oregon Boot, this will hinder him from running away at warp speed when he attempts to commit another crime
19. Rocks can -- and have -- killed
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (02.27.11)
If this juvenile delinquent threw rocks, he IS a dangerous criminal. It will only get worse as he gets older. Lock him up and throw away the key. He is not rehabitable. And take a good, long look at the parents -- they haven't been doing their job.
20. Salma, rocks don't hurt !
BEN JABO ,   ISRAEL   (02.27.11)
Try banging one upside your skull, maybe it will knock some sense into you
21. Did the writer of the article actually watched the video ?
Daniel ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (02.27.11)
The mother was asked to escort the child in the police car and she didn't get in. What is the fuss about? you will get arrested at any country in the world for throwing rocks at a police car.
22. Justified
moriah ,   sacramento usa   (02.27.11)
These parents send their children out into the streets to throw rocks while they just happen to be out in the street filming? They're hoping for another pedestrian launch so they can prosecute Israel for daring to protect themselves. They should have taken the "parents" to jail too!
23. #9 You hit the nail on the head
BEN JABO ,   ISRAEL   (02.27.11)
Cameraman was part of a conspiracy which instigated the Childs' rock throwing so that it could be filmed, he was already there set-up to film Therefore, the cameraman should have been arrested and charged for instigating and inciting the Childs crime There was more than enough space in the van for both the child and the cameraman and you could have thrown a couple of the women who were interfering with the police from doing their jobs SALMA, you should have been there, they would have given you a ride in a nice Israeli Police car, you could have comforted the brat
24. To: No. 15
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (02.27.11)
And do you suppose that eleven-year-old rock-throwing juvenile delinquents might affect the way WE feel about YOU? Think about it, bubbeleh. For once in your sorry life, contemplate the fact that the ersatz "Palestinians" might -- JUST MIGHT-- be responsible for SOMETHING? Why are you congenitally incapable of taking responsibility for your bad and stupid acts? The faster we get you despicable lot out of OUR country, the better. You've worn out your welcome a long, long time ago.
25. Hollywood
Ed ,   kh   (02.27.11)
Just a big show. Islamic hipocresy.
26. Lying parents and B'etselem, good thing video
Yosi ,   Gilo   (02.27.11)
shows the officer telling her to get in the car. B'etselem forgot to edit the video before sending it out. #12 is right, arrest the parents, they seemed to be present for the whole thing and are probably instigating cowards.
27. I didn't hear his parents screaming when he threw stone
Me   (02.27.11)
on the police, only when they came out for him. His parents should be arresting for letting the kind do it while they standing aside and filming. And pay attention to the lies "Poor sick kid" - he doesn't look like that "9 years old kid" - he is 11
28. To: No. 14
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (02.27.11)
"Vito" is an Italian male's name. "Vetoes" is doubtless what your illiterate self meant to say, and the answer is "Yes." Lots and lots. Israel is all the United States has left in the Middle East. You people are for the dung heap of history.
29. Madness
Noel ,   Cork, Ireland   (02.27.11)
What ridiculous crap arguements raised by "Human right" groups - you are all a big joke. If anyone plays with fire, kids or adults, be expected to get burnt and bear the consequences for your actions. No sympathy from me! Parents should bring up their kids to behave in a civilised manner and not get involved in stone throwing excercises!
30. peace is still far away
stop the humilation ,   israel   (02.27.11)
iam just wondering , palestinian boy is arrested for throwing stone, when israeli settler shot palestinin and kill him, his punishment is home custody for refrishment, and to calm down for new crime,
Next talkbacks
Back to article