News
Clashes in J'lem, West Bank follow Havat Gilad razing
Omri Efraim, Yair Altman
Published: 28.02.11, 22:10
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
51 Talkbacks for this article
1. These are the real Human Right group
Chaim   (02.28.11)
clashing with Leftists Destroyers of Israel.
2. Time for patriotic uprising in Israel.
Chaim ,   Israel   (02.28.11)
Israel votes resoundingly for patriotic right wing parties yet gets stuck with far left Labor/Meretz policies. Leftist courts almost invariably take the side of Israel's enemies. They place the convenience of enemy civilians over the lives of Jews. Israel is a center right country which strongly voted against racist building freezes and the evil Two State Final Solution. Yet we're still stuck with these sick policies. It could be time for a patriotic uprising in Israel.
3. Disgusting!!!
Shlomo ,   Jerusalem   (02.28.11)
WORLD- These crazies do not represent Israel. We Israeli's are ashamed of them. You are all blind and disgraceful!!!
4. right wing idiots
Line Singer ,   Århus, Denmark   (02.28.11)
They should be ASHAMED of themselves talking about "the pogroms at Havat Gilad". They clearly have no idea what pogroms are and have no respect for other people or themselves. Threatening with price-tag actions is despicable. Shameful!
5. The Government vs Jewish Settlers
Elad ,   Netanya   (02.28.11)
I am furious, frustrated and ready to explode at the blind stupidity of this government. Who is the real enemy here? Jews? Who is the police "shooting" at? Jews???? Why cannot Jews build in Judea and Samaria? Why is the government so afraid of its shadow? Has fear proved to be a useful weapon in our war of survival? If the government doesn't grow a little brainpower, quiet, non-violent, lawful people like myself are going to take to the streets too and turn things around.
6. LET MY PEOPLE GO
Ricardo Macher ,   Karnei Shomron IL   (02.28.11)
Let's go people. Let's follow the example of our brethern in Egypt, Tunisia an Libya. Let's overthrow this corrupt Government and let's fulfill our aspirations of a big nation. A big Israel. Time has arrived to show that jewish blood run in our veins. Let's conquer the land once and for all.
7. # 5 THE LAND I NOT YOURS
Ricardo Macher ,   Karnei Shomron IL   (02.28.11)
The land is not yours. The whole world knows it. And half israel knows it. It means 6.5 billion people against 1 million fanatical Jews. Let's keep what we have and give up the rest. I am ready to leave Samaria if it is for the good of Zionism and Israel. The people of israel shall survive within the Green Line.
8. parliamentary committee to investigate funding
Michael ,   Haifa   (02.28.11)
I wonder who funds these criminal hooligans
9. YOU'LL LOSE EVERYTHING
Uri Mitzpeh ,   Mitzpeh Ramon   (02.28.11)
Settlers, you are destroying Israel. All the good the country has produced until today is within the Green line. Technology, arts, future for our kids. All the bad is beyond the Green Line: fanaticism. wars, conflicts, bacwardness. You have not enough representation in the Knesset. You have no support in the world. Americans are getting fed up of Israel because of you settlers. The law and moral are against you, indecent settlers You are violent, have no moral standards, no education no values whatsoever. You dont speak on behalf of 7 million decent Israelis. You are just a bunch of criminals that are destroying Zionism and the future of my country.
10. The Bolshevik Leftist racists control the country and
Israel is not ,   a democracy!   (02.28.11)
elections mean nothing!
11. Netanyahu and Barak
David ,   On this planet   (02.28.11)
Are pushing for a civil war like the ones in the Arab countries Their wish will come true. Keep it up losers
12. "One of the rooms in the house was burned"
Rafi ,   Hertzliya   (02.28.11)
How have you guys missed that these fanatic settlers could have killed people, I dont understand how they can call themselves religious. That being said i am here only talking about the fanatic settlers, most, while maybe to extreme in their midset, aren't actually members of this 'price-tag' group, but i still feel that the mainstream settler groups must speak out more against them.
13. My crime: Born in Judea!
Itamar ,   Judea   (02.28.11)
Because I am Jewish I cannot build a home where I am born. The Israeli government hates Jews in Judea and discrimantes them. We are the only one in Israel still living under military jurisdiction.
14. Funny Thing; Jews who dont want to be 8 miles wide called
Yaawqove ,   Israel   (02.28.11)
" right wing" and "extermist" Its the idiot left that wants to be 8 miles wide and copw tow to the EU and UN who are the extremists. They are extremely insane and short sighted.
15. The youth has it...
päivikki ,   finland   (02.28.11)
I can clearly see from the protesters,that they seem to be mostly young israelis how fully understands to how the land of israel belongs to.It´s great to see brave israelis.
16. Where's Ivette?
Rachel ,   US   (02.28.11)
17. #9 Uri in the Crater.
Joseph ,   Israel   (02.28.11)
You couldnt be more wrong. zThe Jews living in Judea are the pioneers and real zionists. you think 8 miles wide will work. man someone must be putting drugs in the drinking water. 8 miles wide is insane. I bet you think sderot is doing better since 2005 when we follishly pulled out. we got 10x the missiles after pullout. you trust hamas? you think abas and fatah have power? you think fatah wont revert to PLO if the support of the arab street demands it. what then? it would too late. it is you who has lost your sense of direction. people like you eating cake while rome burns. I support the Jews in Judea and Samaria and so do MILLIONS of Jews and Christians in and outside Israel. Israel is in a bind because it has a schizophrenic government that has little backbone and doesnt put out that Jordan is palestine
18. Mitzpe has already lost it all...
Claudia ,   Green Liner   (02.28.11)
Mitzpeh, you are destroying Israel. All the good the country has produced until today is because of our connection with our heritage. Much of the problem is withinl the the Green Line: failure to join the IDF, low morals, hedonism. You have no representation among the elite who truly care about the country. You have support in a world that would be happy if it were Judenrein. When you are prepared to stand up and be a proud Je, the world will take notice. I refuse to call you indecent but it is a shame that you are a bunch of pleasure seekers that have long forgotten what Zionism and this country is all about. Come back and connect to your roots.
19. Chanukah Story
nr ,   los angeles, usa   (02.28.11)
The Helenists are back - and they're still secular. Imagine if Mattisyahu Cohen Gadol was trying to do today what he did then - he'd be hit with paintballs! Hello, the world wants Israel destroyed. And they don't want settlements. So you listen to the settlement part to appease them. They will not be appeased because they see weakness. Wake up. These settlers are right.
20. #6 a problem
Israel Israeli ,   Tel Aviv   (02.28.11)
The Left want a civil war in Israel because then the Arabs will win. The only hope is to remind Netanyahu that soon the Arab armies will attack Israel. If we lose, he will be remembered as one of the leaders who betrayed Israel and helped the genocide. His sons will disown him and all the money in the world won't help him.
21. this land is for jews only
Ruth ,   jerusalem   (02.28.11)
all the left wing sobbers and weepers for the poor arabs are free to go running into the sunset with their lovers and have a gay parade in teheran.and dont come back. we are jews, god gave us this land and that is it. and everyone else get the hell out of my land. it is disgraceful the way they treat jews like a enemy. horrible disgusting. revolting to please the goyim who want us all dead.
22. GO FOR IT!
Dina ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (02.28.11)
We need our own Day of Rage by Jews who are fed up with the abuse of patriotic right-wing Jews! And Ehud Barak has got to go, one way or another!
23. # 17 Joseph, go back to your hole
Uri Mitzpeh ,   mitzpeh Ramon   (02.28.11)
First, Zionists agreed with the Partition, that means the West Bank was not ours since 1948. So you are wrong. Real Zionists were and are within the Green Line. I am decent. You are indecent if you live beyond the Green Line. Second, Sderot is not doing better. And so what? Is it Hebron? Try to take your foreign guests to visit it on weekend. Besides, just imagine if the US had to occupy Mexico to bring protection to LA from drugs thugs. You are wrong here too. Third. Fatah is now backed by the world community. Who would say an American president would spend one hour imploring a Palestinian leader and the guy simply refuse? Who would say Fatah people would protect israelis citizens lost in the West Bank roads and deliver them back safe to Israel? Fatah is not Hamas and if you dont know that you are ignorant. You lost here too. Next Fourth: Only those who don't know the reality of Judea and Samaria support Jews there. Not even us Israelis have a consensus in that let alone those rednecks in southern USA. As soon as they know the settlers' caracter and immoral attitude they will start fighting you as Europeans do. It is just a question of time, dude, dont worry. Wrong you are here again. Next. Fifth: Jordan is Jordan. Israel is Israel and Palestine is Palestine. Any attempt to throw your problems on the other side of the border have failed. Nobody buys this lie anymore. i am a decent Israeli who served the Army, who pays high taxes and who believes in the moral values of Zionism. You are a immoral person that probably live on the States' expenses and whose only ambitio is to grab land of poor Palestinian people with the excuse of religion. I will win because my moral is superior to yours. You'll have to come back to the Green Line and will have to find a job and to work as a normal human being. Sorry, you will not manage to destroy my country. Sliha, matok.
24. Israel"s future belongs
olim hadashim ,   tel aviv/israel   (02.28.11)
to the jewish people foremost .They are haredim,settlers and national-religious and traditional jews.Enough with domination of a small assimilationist elite .
25. A serious debate is URGENT between ...
ORA ,   JERUSALEM   (03.01.11)
the leaders and the settlers.Bibi invite the head of the settlers ,listen to them,and than only tell them what you think is realist and why.Have a real dialogue with them.They are not our ennemies.We are all from the same Jewish family.We need unity.
26. # 18 THE SAME TO CLAUDIA AND...
URi Mitzpeh ,   mitzpeh Ramon   (02.28.11)
More some clarification more: Our heritage is reflected in our culture standards within the Green Line. Not in fanatical religious people like you. Try to get a bus in Measherim and let's debate where civilization is. We are a bunch of pleasure seekers, yes, we celebrate life and that's judaism. We create science and arts. And that is judaism. We fight for the future of our children This is judaism. You attack Palestinian old people, destroy trees, create separate roads, disregard human life based on religion divide. You appeal to violence and pracitce progroms. Everything i teach to my kids about wrongdoings they watch you doing in the TV. And you try to defend all this in the name of Judaims. Shame on you. Come back to the Green Line, repent of your sins and help us put israel among the greatest nations of the world.
27. Israel' future
Matt   (03.01.11)
And here in the Talkbacks you can clearly see Israels future . Torn apart from the inside in twenty years because of weak ineffective leaders now.
28. Well done our brave heros from the security forces
Avi ,   Israel   (03.01.11)
In case they havent heard there is a system of law in this country and they are occupying stolen land. Arrest them and jail their leaders. They had better start getting used to it as they are fighting a lost cause.
29. Settlers can't see the forest for the trees
Marcella   (03.01.11)
They go into furious rage at the demolition of homes and police brutality. Rightfully so. But what they don't want to address is the fact that their government is in the process of giving their land away. What good is it for them to build, when they'll have to abandon the land once the PA declares independence and the Israeli government withdraws all presence from the area? The government already instructed the "right wing" MKs - the same Likud that professes to be on your side - to vote against the National Union proposal for annexation on February 23. Did settlers feel enough indignation at this betrayal to confront their MKs? That vote delegitimized their ownership of the land, but there was no public reaction. Therefore, the government has interpreted this indifference to signify that the path is open for partition of the land.
30. #1 Rcardo Macher
BEN JABO ,   ISRAEL   (03.01.11)
You forgot all about Gaza, which was returned, resulting in increased violence against Israel Since you want to give the lands to Arabs who never owned it in the first place, answer these simple questios to prove they'yre entitled to it You live in Karne Shomron, I think you sat on one of the Horns Have a go at the following When was the country of Palestine founded and by whom? Where did the Palestinian people originate from? What were Palestine's borders? Who were its neighbours? What language did the Palestinians speak? What writing did they use? What manuscripts or records did they leave whether written or engraved? What was their religion? Where are their temples? What monuments attest to their existence? What was the name of their capital? Name its other major cities. What was their currency called? Greenline, that was the same Greenline they ignored before, what makes you think they won't ignore it again ?
Next talkbacks
Back to article