News
Obama advisor reveals Jewish roots
Yitzhak Benhorin
Published: 09.03.11, 12:26
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
46 Talkbacks for this article
1. So?
Abraham Nachmias ,   Petach Tikva IL   (03.09.11)
Who cares???? My grand grand father emigrated to Poland in 1680. Who cares????
2. ok, that's nice dear! so now what?
(03.09.11)
3. It doesn't matter too much but she is welcome
Yossef   (03.09.11)
One can be happy and proud to be jewish and want to share with the "family". Nothing wrong with that. I'm waiting the day when Salma will discover that she is of jewish descent too :-))
4. Yeah, right
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (03.09.11)
How convenient. Obama's Jewish support is plummeting like a stone (he can't win without it), his Jewish advisors are leaving in droves (there have been more than just Emanuel and Axelrod, by the way) so comes now Ms. Jarrett with a fictitious story of a fictitious seder and an equally fictitious story of fictitious Jewish roots. Contemplate the likelihood that she did not go into detail about her fictitious Jewish ancestry precisely because it is fictitious -- a clumsy ploy by a desperate Obama who knows that without Jewish support, he's political history. Rabbi Gutlow is a dupe. Fortunately, I doubt very much that very many Jews will be fooled by this transparent ploy by the administration to recoup Jewish support.
5. Jewish roots
Ralph ,   Caesarea   (03.09.11)
Who has not Jewish root ?
6. 1 - My grand grand father emigrated to Poland in 1680.
split ,   US   (03.09.11)
From Khasaria by any means ? ,...
7. How very sad that your great-grandfather was Jewish
(03.09.11)
and married a non-Jewish woman thus losing all his chances of having Jewish descendants unless they convert.
8. Some popes have Jewish blood-So?ND
Ron ,   USA   (03.09.11)
9. Jewish Influence
Jamal from Germany ,   Germany- North Rhine   (03.09.11)
Jewish Influence in the US is very big. I have been born into a Muslim family, but I do not believe that Islam is the right religion. Nor do I believe that any other religion is perfect, but this is another thing (....). What I want to state here is that Jewish people did a marvellous career in the United States, that's quite obvious. And so did many other nationalities and ethnicities: take the Indian people for instance (Hindus from the Indian subcontinent), you will find many successful Chinese or Indian people in the US: look for VIPS in science and economy for example. So, the fact that Jewish people have a good stand there is not due to some sort of conspiration, it is the product of hard work and invaluable contribution to the development and strength of this relatively new state, called the United States of America. What is further eye-striking is, that the Muslim community in the US did not do such a marvellous job so far. Okay, you will find Muslim scientists at American universities and so on, but the overall-weight of Muslim contribution is still very poor, compared to what Jews, Indians, Chinese or European immigrants did. What is the reason for all this ? I think Muslims are still hostage to their own teary and paradoxically arrogant mentality and have still not come out of this self-destructive preload. We shall not forget that for the most part Muslims are still heavily influenced by their religion which teaches them that they are BETTER THAN OTHERS simply by birth and their affiliation to this religion. Islam is a religion that has not undergone any secular bleaching or reform so far, the flowerings of enlightenment are still developing very poorly in the Muslim world, we will have to wait "a while" before muslim societies and their people -the muslims- start to reflect independently of what an 1400-years-old credo teaches them. I think, in the age of world-wide web and the apparent economic superioty of the Western system this is maybe going to happen even faster than we could imagine. Strong indicators for this are the current revolutions in the Islamic world. They all demand Western freedoms and secular rights ! ..... ..... ..... So, lets hope for the good and be prepared for the worst. Your brother Jamal from Germany.
10. Yet another opportunistic claim
Raymond in DC ,   Washington, USA   (03.09.11)
Last week it was Charlie Sheen who claimed to be Jewish, and designer Galiano - fired by Dior for anti-Semitic remarks - now claims to have "Jewish roots". As if that matters now. Now Obama's crony Jarrett, who's never said anything about Jewish roots or herself done anything "Jewish" or on behalf of Jews, now wants to connect to Jews? This claim merits only a clear "So what?"
11. her great-grandfather was Jewish !
Salma ,   Palestine   (03.09.11)
oh really, so what sould we do now? tea party or Shabbat Party ?! #3 Yossef , even so I will remain PROUD Palestinian : ) My friend Yossef, are you in Jerusalem this week ?
12. some of her best friends are jewish, too
mike ,   israel (formerly usa   (03.09.11)
and her bible contains some jewish writings. she's practically frum.
13. My Family May Have Jewish Blood...
Edwin ,   Canada   (03.09.11)
...on their hands. I hope not. Even though we are members of the extended family too, we sons of Esau have done very bad things to our cousins.
14. Jewish roots
Harold ,   USA   (03.09.11)
Why surprised. All Christians have Jewish Root but Baptism convert them to Christianity. Real Jews stayed Jewish because they did not believe in Jesus Christ and Baptism.
15. Only in America
Cynic #2   (03.09.11)
Even if you are not Jewish, it pays to pretend so, in order to get the blessings of the grand masters in America. Otherwise you are on the streets! Can the Muslims say that many of them are of Jewish origins and be blessed by the grand masters?
16. To: Edwin at No. 13
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (03.09.11)
Thank you very much for your post. I really do appreciate it, and I believe most Jewish people appreciate your frankness and honesty as well.
17. Gotta give it to Ynet...Nonsense is better then no news...
Edithann ,   USA   (03.09.11)
So what...what's a Jew doing with a Black woman in the 1850's? Did he stay to start a family? I don't think so.. He was looking for some free or cheap tail, just as they are today with Christian Russian women brought in to satisfy Israli's...hahaha I'm sure the Jew didn't stick around and build a family or there would be more on the subject...The Jew was one of the original 'Carpet Baggers' invading the South for the usual criminal scams they perpetrated all over the South... How many Palestinian women have been impregnated by Isaeli's....we will never know...and for sure they will never tell... TATA
18. If only this mattered at all
Eitan ,   Chicago   (03.09.11)
Maybe she could dignify her distant ancestor with halachic observance. Otherwise, hearing this is no more of a a relief than hearing that "Vatican Assassin warlock" Charlie Sheen's mother is Jewish.
19. I think that it is beter to hire someone for
ghostq   (03.09.11)
he qualification and not by his race other wise you got banana republic.
20. #17
yosef ,   memphis   (03.09.11)
Even though my Rebbe tells me not to read talkbacks I can't help it...your posting made me laugh but also reminded me why I THANK HASHEM I AM NOT A GOY and happy to be Haredi! B"H for the Haredi
21. All of Obama's Jews are self hating
Rosie   (03.09.11)
Great tale...it proves nothing since all of the Jews around Obama are self hating Jews that are helping in delegitimizing the State of Israel. Among them the chief George Soros.
22. so what?
Danny   (03.09.11)
23. #9, Great piece Jamal !
Yossef   (03.09.11)
Welcome Bro :-)
24. A true Jew inherits Abraham's faith in God
Sean Greene ,   Pasadena, USA   (03.09.11)
blood or no she isn't very good for Jews. Even Ahmedinajad has Jewish blood. What makes you a jew is your faith and how that inspires you to act.
25. Obama has the jewish vote wrapped up again
zionist forever   (03.09.11)
My great grandparents were refugees from Russia & Austria wow I bet everybody in Russia & Austria will be so excited when I tell them that. If the jews were impressed by this little fact then the US jews really are idiots. Sadly I think I Obama has the jewish vote in the bag again.
26. Yo Jamal, nice...
Eyal ,   USA   (03.09.11)
27. Ooo - so did Hitler
Haha ,   US   (03.09.11)
Big deal
28. My golden fish grand mother's cousin is Jewish...
Gregg ,   Haifa, IL   (03.09.11)
29. Edithann - Since your fixated on price
BEN JABO ,   ISRAEL   (03.09.11)
what's yours ? You're not doing this as a labor of love
30. to 9 Jamal
sara ,   jerusalem   (03.09.11)
may you have a good luck in this life only to be something it is not related to your religion or nationality but your doing ,but after death there will be judgment it is not about certificate or knowlege it is about faith ... think about this it deserve to think
Next talkbacks
Back to article