News
'British show demonizes Israel'
Aviel Magnezi
Published: 10.03.11, 00:53
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
177 Talkbacks for this article
61. # 33
Birdi ,   Israel   (03.10.11)
Hey bright spark, everything about Israel concerns Israel. Everything about Jews concerns Israel. Were there disputed territories in the time of the Britsh Mandate?
62. # 17
Birdi ,   Israel   (03.10.11)
I suggest you carefully read # 19. Unfortunately for you, you are in the minority on this forum. I encounter many people with your views on my travels to the great UK. You are all too steeped in fish & chips to ever understand "the reality of life in Israel".Waste of time explaining to you. Lechi kfar !
63. # 2
Birdi ,   Israel   (03.10.11)
Kudos Steve. (Big smile-for you)
64. many British Jewish?
(03.10.11)
I thought I had a good command of English
65. Carol, uk#17 Brit Empire's hands is full of innocent blood
(03.10.11)
Just research your country's heinous crimes and brutality in India and the shedding of innocent blood of men,women and children too in AMRITSER.
66. The Brits were always Anti-Semtic,it's mainly jealousy
Benorr ,   Haifa Israel   (03.10.11)
They hate us because we are successful,we better then them in every way these Pommie Trailer Trash are only good at whining and whinging.They like the Arabs because they feel superior to the Arabs,They feel inferior to Israeli's who are Better looking, better educated,better mannered.
67. The Brits have this Laurance of Arabia Fetish
Benorr ,   Haifa Israel   (03.10.11)
They are waiting for this Arabian stud on his white Arabian stallion to come and ravish them,the men and women have this fantasy.You have to feel sorry for them,they live in little cold and damp island,overtaken by palestinians,who are yanking their chains.Insignificant little people propped up by the US.
68. The promise
Meir ,   London   (03.10.11)
I have seen each episode of it and have always told my family that it was biased now there is proof. I could not believe that something so biased could have been made in the UK. One other weird thing was that Israelis actually participated in making the film!
69. sloppy reporting - did the journo watch it
Vernon Marriott ,   Tel Aviv   (03.10.11)
I don't think the Journalist actually watched the show. The text and comments seem to have been lifted from the London Jewish Chronicle - with some add ons from a quick interview with a diplomat.
70. To those who criticise it - give me an alternative
vernonmarriott ,   tel aviv   (03.10.11)
Actually, it was quite anti-British showing them being hard and cruel on the Jews. But that's besides the point - the main thing is that this film employed 3,000 Israelis over a period of six months. For all those criticising it in a knee-jerk fashion: what's the alternative for those 3,000 people who got food on their tables and money in their accounts. What are YOU doing about that?
71. self-conscious or self-hater Jew?, Jews don't see difference
observer ,   Egypt   (03.10.11)
72. channel 4
Meir ,   London   (03.10.11)
the series was in channel 4 which i noticed is always more pro palestinian
73. should be ''many British Jews'' not ''Jewish''
(03.10.11)
74. Hard to beleive that this tiny little island once ruled the
Benorr ,   Haifa Israel   (03.10.11)
Waves,now they are finding it hard to rule their pissy little country. The Arabs and Muslims have taken them over.They are too scared of the Muslims in their midst.so to suck up to these Muslims they target Israel instead.
75. # 58
Birdi ,   Israel   (03.10.11)
You tell us to relax? why should we relax when the British tv viewers are fed lie after lie about Israel & the Jews. We are trying hard to improve Israel's "impotent" PR here. Give us a break, will you.
76. # 57
Birdi ,   Israel   (03.10.11)
As usual you are sprouting crap.
77. They should worry about their own country.
jh   (03.10.11)
In another 2 generations or so, Britain will be a Moslem state.
78. to all talkbackers pro and anti
john   (03.10.11)
Read to what the Brits did in Amritser India.(Google Amritser massacre)
79. Britainhas turned into morally bankrupt country
Alain Bourchard ,   Paris France   (03.10.11)
It hit the skids,both finance and morally.The EU hates them,and so does the US,miserable backstabbers.The Israel's turned the desert into a paradise,the English turned Britain into a basket case.The English had only a few leaders of note,Churchill,Margaret Thatcher,and Tony Blair,the rest rubbish.
80. #77 will that purge Jews?
observer ,   Egypt   (03.10.11)
81. #74
(03.10.11)
Muslims didn't bring down Britain. Zionists didn't bring down Britain either Britain was destroyed by another European superpower- Germany. It was bankrupted by two wars against a real enemy, not a few skirmishes with middle eastern riff-raff.
82. #75
Mike Carmel ,   Rishon le Zion   (03.10.11)
So don't relax. But you need to understand that Britain as a country should not be the object of your anger. Maybe channel 4 should be.
83. perfect British, Turk, Nazi ideology -- the Jews
jo   (03.10.11)
England's rotten, vicious, pervert, repugnant character in full bloom : relished by 1.4 billion arabs, as rotten, vicious, pervert, repugnant as they are. But, as savvy politicians, diplomats flamboyantly use in their endless get-together " rira bien qui rira le dernier ". With allah, muhammad, imams, sheiks, on 10 Downing st. steps, the biggest surprise or should I say their just reward is yet to come.----- translation -- " laughs best who laughs last "
84. as soon as it said a brit saved jews from the nazis
oferdesade ,   israel   (03.10.11)
one must have understood that this was going to be a lot of apologistic bulls***
85. #58 well said mike. What's with these talkbackers?
Esther ,   Tel Aviv   (03.10.11)
Have the ever even left the USA state they are from? What's also shocking is there are more comments on this story than the one where the university in California had to send in police to protect Jewish students this week, oh wait, Ynet isn't report this. It isn't part of the the propaganda they want to send out to people who can't read the Hebrew site.
86. #15 totally wrong, shariah doesn't prevail Anywhere in UkU
(03.10.11)
What drugs are you on? Can I have some to join you in cuckoo land
87. UK a lot of things but least it doesn have Muslim president
ghostq   (03.10.11)
Like HUSSAIN Obama from Kenya
88. Jews in UK flourishing, growing, talk about talkbs believing
Ronald Zieger ,   London   (03.10.11)
All that they read. It always seems to be Americans, American olim too lazy to learn Hebrew well enough to comment on the Hebrew version of this paper. What does day about American education system? Check it out on jerry springer I guess.
89. THE PROMISE
LAWRENCE ,   SAFED ISRAEL   (03.10.11)
The promise from The ALMIGHTY :" I will bless those who bless Israel and curse those who curse Israel ". It was ,is and will always remain so.
90. the Promise
Adam ,   London / Zichron   (03.10.11)
I watched it's produced by UK company and studio canal, with assistance from the EU. After thinking about it for a few weeks I have come to the conclusion it is hateful television. It is made very well, the director is extremely good at what he does and has created a highly manipulative piece of work. The terrible thing is it gives the impression that all Israelis are living in Ceaserea style houses and the Arabs are living in very bad accommodation, Gaydamak's house was used as the "typical" Israelis house which is a downright misrepresentation. Basically, it's a very clever nasty piece of work against Israel which has been created to manipulate peoples feelings towards Israel and change their perspective on history. Peter Kosimsky should not be proud of this.
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article