News
Israel observes 5 minutes for Gilad Shalit
Ahiya Raved
Published: 15.03.11, 11:02
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
23 Talkbacks for this article
1. Gilad Schalit suffers for all Israel. Let
Robert Haymond ,   Israel/Canada   (03.15.11)
us cease providing Gaza with electricity, gas, clothes and food until he is safely returned. Let us stop all family visits all Red Cross visits, all legal visits, all television, radio, internet and educational services for those prisoners who are members of Hamas or associated terrorist entities.
2.  And Then What ?
Salma ,   Palestine   (03.15.11)
Pressure your government to do something........urge your government to release our brothers, sisters and Shalit immediately.
3. Yes, Salma, let us release all Arab
Robert Haymond ,   Israel/Canada   (03.15.11)
terrorists so that they can continue to create more mayhem like your people did in Itamar. You don't seem to understand the meaning of justice, Salma; typical of the Arab Salafist mentality.
4. #1 - robert: gilad must be freed, but to punish a whole...
eporue ,   europe   (03.15.11)
people for that ? ...let us cease providing BIBI with electricity, gas, clothes, food until gilad is safeley returned... => could be more effective ?
5. to salma
gomez   (03.15.11)
urge your 20 state arab regimes to end hostility with the one jewish state . while you are at it tell them thatnot only israel s/b expected to compromise. the arabs have to compromise too. so far israel has ceded land after land &v got nothing in return.
6. #3
Palestine ,   Palestine   (03.15.11)
What if the Murderer in Itamar was not a Palestinian ? Would you apologize for saying that all Arabs are Murderers? Just for you to know I agree about one thing with you that what has happened in Itamar was a very inhumane thing to do, it is dispicable and I wish it never has happened. Please Do not let politics rule your life.
7. Palestinian
Daniela   (03.15.11)
are you saying that e jew killed the family at Itamar? yes of course like that jew who put the shark in the sea of sharm el sheikh ! don't you see how ridicolus you are?
8. #6
Reuven ,   Petach Tikvah   (03.15.11)
Wishful thinking............Of course not that all murders and terrorists are Arabs. However today most acts of terrorism and political murder in the world are committed by Arabs in the name of Islam. What other religious society in the world can claim such a vile program as Jihad when you send a teenager to his or her death with bomb strapped to his body. You are right politics should not rule your life, but in the Arab world politics are a way of life - or death.
9. On Gilad
Joanne   (03.15.11)
It is unfathomable that Israel takes such good care of the terrorists in her jails. These murdering monsters do not deserve visits from their families, they do not deserve cell phones, newspapers, books, a college education and good food. Israel is crazy to allow this! They should rot in a dungeon or be hung for murder. And when released they go home fat, degreed and ready for more blood.
10. "palestinian"
...ana   (03.15.11)
Daniella! Or like the eagle on espionage. That was a funny one.
11. Bibi - Immediate 24/7 blackout on all Hamas prisoners
Brian ,   Judean Peoples Front   (03.15.11)
Stop the stupidity of giving Hamas prisoners full rights as if they robbed a candy store. Bibi should immediately declare a complete blackout on all Hamas and Jihad prisoners: -solitary confinement 24/7 -zero visitors, calls, letters, lawyers - no exceptions -immediately move all hamas prisoners to secret facilities. No more family visits. No more anything. A total imposition of the exact same conditions that Hamas imposes on Gilad Shalit. And Bibi should appear on TV and address the families of the Pal prisoners and tell them the lights are off forever and will only go on when the Red Cross is allowed to visit Shalit as is demanded by international law. DO IT BIBI!!!
12. Idiots giving aid and comfort to nation's enemies
Raymond in DC ,   Washington, USA   (03.15.11)
Whatever happened to Israeli common sense? It is not Israel holding Shalit. By piling on the pressure to "bring him home" these fools are the "useful idiots" of Hamas. It is they who are encouraging those holding him to stand fast against doing a deal, even to raise the price. I won't even ask if any of those who blocked traffic were arrested as the answer is obvious. But how ridiculous must Peres have looked stopping his speech for five minutes in mid-stream. And has anyone asked how a nation that stands in memory for those lost in the Shoah or in defense of their country get TWO minutes of silence while Shalit gets FIVE? When a nation has so lost its sense of proportion it is no wonder the enemy looks to kidnap more.
13. Still praying for Gilad
Neil Turner ,   Watford, UK   (03.15.11)
Five years ago when gilad was kidnapped the Lord reminded me to pray for him. I have prayed every day Since then for his safety, welfare and release I believe the Lord God of Israel is with him and will rescue him
14. #3 "Arab Salafist mentality"
Salma ,   Palestine   (03.15.11)
Robert , do me a favour and explain it for me? Thank you in advance, Typical Jewish Guy ; )
15. Teshuvah
Keren ,   IL-BR   (03.15.11)
Perhaps Noam Shalit should follow Rabbis and publicly read Psalms( 56 for instance)along with all Israel? Perhaps he should also publicly put Tefilim every morning? For a man who has tried all that is in human hands and hasn't find the answer,probably he will find it in the G-d of Israel. If I would be Noam,I would try. Perhaps a sincere and humble Teshuvah will bring Gilad back home. Noam should humblely try and serve as an example to all Israel. Gilad deserves it as do his family.
16. INITIATIVE IN ISRAELI LEADERSHIP IS LACKING !
Orao. ,   Srbia.   (03.15.11)
WHY IS THERE NO VISION IN THE ISRAELI GOVERNMENT TO SOLV THIS MATTER ? SEAL ALL BORDERS WITH GAZA SO NO ONE CAN COME IN OR OUT. THEN REALISE ALL PALESTINIANS FROM ISRAELI JAILS TO GAZA PUBLICLY AND IN THE FACE OF THE WORLD OPINION. THEN COME WITH THE ULTIMATUM TO HAMAS IN THE FACE OF THE WORLD - RELEASE SHALIT SAFE AND SOUND, WITHOUT ANY FURTHER DEMANDS AND DELAYS, OR WE WILL COME FOR YOU. LET ISRAEL THEN SE THE REACTION ON THE WORLD OPINION AND ON HAMAS. Orao.Srbia.
17. u Salma Idiot
salmita # 2 ,   il   (03.15.11)
yr brothers and sisters are playing games they had a huge list to release terrorists and the worst scum that society or zoos can imagine- we were ready for the exchange- and your leaders as always played games - and were not happy with the offer- it's no good to celebrate you dirty & tricky creations- you dont want piece and are holding into Gilad for all instances where blackmail is required-
18. Why block the roads?
g.e.   (03.15.11)
Stop the electricity and water to Gaza, every day for 15 minutes. How will blocking the roads in Israel for 5 minutes help?, It only creates anarchy. Maybe that's the hidden agenda. We might have more of a chance we block the roads to the Red Cross, close the Gaza crossings even to hospital patients, but blocking the roads in Israel?
19. #6 pali,pali You are Full Of HUDDA
Brazen   (03.15.11)
you say it was a despicable act, yet you would do the same if it ment no jewish presence in Israel. May Hashem send his sentence down to the people responsible for this UNCALLED for SENSELESS act of HATRED. My Thoughts And Prayers to the Fogel Family.
20. # 2
Birdi ,   Israel   (03.15.11)
salami, Gilad Shalit is being held by Hamas, in Gaza, not in Israel, by Israel. Wake up!
21. to Salma-2
john Darren ,   cairns-Australia   (03.16.11)
Read your silly inaccurate comment again-and while you're at it do not lie again that you are from "Palestine"
22. to 20 Birdi
john Darren ,   cairns-Australia   (03.16.11)
Salma is totally exhausted from telling lies,gathering rocks for the kid to throw and for the biggest lie of all-that she is a"Palestinian".She really needs help-her brain suffers from intellect-perhaps some rest home in Gaza would be appropriate.
23. FREE GILAD SHALIT
JoAnn Dolberg ,   Council Bluffs, U.S.   (03.28.11)
This young Israeli soldier has been sacrificed....and for what? Israel NEEDS to do something that will terrorize the terrorists! Shut off their electricity. If they fire missiles at you, fire back, with deadly accuracy and take them down! And quit giving comfort to the enemy in your prisons. The hell with world opinion; they aren't the ones who are suffering, and they are not important!
Back to article