News
Arab victim 'stabbed 10 times by haredim'
Hassan Shaalan
Published: 20.03.11, 17:51
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
53 Talkbacks for this article
1. The clothes could be a disguise.
ORA ,   JERUSALEM   (03.20.11)
2. This is not the way of the Jewish people
Dov ,   Yerushalayim   (03.20.11)
Shame on those who attacked this innocent man. Those with information should step forward and be punished to the full extent of the law.
3. animals!!
Salma ,   Palestine   (03.20.11)
4. DISGRACEFUL!!! NO EXCUSE FOR THIS!!
andy ,   orlando   (03.20.11)
5. disgraceful
mike ,   uk   (03.20.11)
Haredim attacking seculars, haredim attacking arabs. These people are out of control, with no values other than Torah, living in a bubble, no taxes , no work, zero contribution - these maniacs shouldn't be roaming the streets.I have yet to read or hear one good thing about these people.
6. #5 mike Don't Believe Everything You
Brazen   (03.20.11)
Read. Wait until the facts are published, most orthodox Jewish Men are NON-VIOLENT where I come from most are what we call SHEGGIES, nonathletic , studious and wouldnt hurt a fly. Very Hard To Believe.
7. Racist, Extremist Jews
Katherine ,   Canada   (03.20.11)
This is disgusting. What has become of Israel? And why are the police so impotent when it comes to Jewish fanatics and extremists who attack innocent Arabs like this? As usual, since the victim was an "Arab" no one will be punished--Israel doesn't believe in punishing Jews who harm Arabs. God bless the few brave remaining Christians like this man who have the courage to live in such a hateful racist place.
8. Maybe it was his Muslim girlfriend's brothers
This story ,   is bogus   (03.20.11)
9. False Flag all over it
k ,   US   (03.20.11)
Jews do not do something like this, I have no doubt it was "Muslims" posing as Jews
10. #2 Ummm, apparently it is.....
Alfie Knowkes ,   Golan   (03.20.11)
11. Why accuse Orthodox Jews?
Yoni ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (03.20.11)
He admits they wore masks. How on earth would he know they were Orthodox Jews? They could have been anybody; Sefardic punks, Russians or blacks. Since when are Hassidic Jews violent and running around around in jeeps and wearing masks, carrying guns and knives? I've never in my life heard of such a thing! Orthodox Jews are meek, peace-loving people that would never provoke a non-Jew unless he provoked them first. This story stinks and I don't buy any of it!
12. Terrible regardless of the identity of the assailants
Brooklynjon ,   Brooklyn, NY, USA   (03.20.11)
I agree that it seems odd that his attackers would be Haredi Jews, but that shouldn't detract from sympathy for the victim of this disgraceful attack. And certainly the anti-Arab sentiment implied in the attack is not present in all, or even in most, Jews. It's time we ALL live together in peace. And Jews, being a light unto the nations, should lead by example.
13. Very fishy!
Chaim ,   Haarom, Israel   (03.20.11)
Look at the pictures. Is that someone who was just stabbed 10 times?
14. #5 mike in uk never read one good thing about haredim
Kyle ,   Southpark, CO, USA   (03.20.11)
http://www.ynetnews.com/articles/0,7340,L-4043178,00.html
15. Where are the wounds?
bob96, Tel Aviv, Israel ,   Tel Aviv, Israel   (03.20.11)
According to that little punk, he was stabbed "in the head, the neck and the leg", yet he can show only ONE stab. Where are the other nine? I see nothing there. Do you think he would be shy to show them and to embarass the jews? I don't think so. So, let's not take all the palestinian's stories at face value.
16. Where is the proof?
Mitchell ,   Jerusalem   (03.21.11)
He looks in good shape for someone who has been stabbed in the head. Could it be that he was stabbed by a rival arab clan?
17. Virulent Anti-Arab Racists Here
Michael ,   Canada   (03.21.11)
I see the Anti-Arab racists have made their way here...this man is even a Christian which shows that their hatred is purely aimed at non-Jewish Arabs no matter their religion. Some of the racists claim the story is fake and others simply denigrate the victim because he is an "Arab". Its disgusting. For those who had any doubt about the level of incitement and hatefulness in Israeli society today, look no further than the talkbackers here.
18. Haredim picking on wrong people
Sam ,   USA   (03.21.11)
Why pick on harmless Arab Christians? They should be after the real stated enemies of Israel the Islamic Arabs!!!
19. Stabbed in the head
Kyle ,   Southpark, CO, USA   (03.21.11)
And he shows a picture of his... head.
20. #12 They Led By Example In The
Brazen   (03.20.11)
1940's and LOOK WHAT HAPPENED, They Walked Into OVENS, but not before the ss pulled out the gold fillings? NEVER AGAIN !!!
21. This why I read Ynet
IRAN#1   (03.20.11)
It gives me a good understanding to typical jewish conduct. Thank you!
22. 7 Katherine
Rachel   (03.20.11)
Did you feel the same way when the Arab or Arabs stabbed the newborn Jewish baby in the heart last week after murdering her family? And the innocent Arab residents of Gaza celebrated?
23. To Naive Iranian, and other easy influenced readers.
Anna ,   Montreal Canada   (03.21.11)
"we knew from their accent and their clothes that they were ultra-Orthodox" I can't believe how this guy could recognize by the accent that his assailants were ultra-orthodox. Did they speak Yiddish to him? If those masked ultra-orthodox men were covering only their faces, and the alleged victim recognized them by their huge fury hats, short trousers and long socks, he could got easy away because in their cloths it is very difficult to fight. Their shoes don't look as the most comfortable ether. By the way, the orthodox Jews were celebrating Purim on Saturday night. Ultra-orthodox Jews, I doubt, won't choose a Nissan jeep for the very simple reason: it's not practical. These consumers are interested in minivans, vans, bases because of the need in a big size. Jeep is a wrong model. The stabbings in Alber Halul's head and neck look very impressive and believable. Try again. Why there is no medical report attached to his claims?
24. to Michael, # 17. I don't see what you see
Anna ,   Montreal, Canada   (03.21.11)
If you would read the article more careful, if you would know what it means being ultra-orthodox Jew you would never believe the guy who is sitting on his hospital bed and giving interview while having the knife stabs in his head and neck. Please, be reasonable.
25. Islamists told him to blame the Jews are they'd return
GWN ,   Canada   (03.21.11)
Islamists told him to blame the Jews are they'd return and kill him.
26. Remember Baruch Goldstein?
Dovit   (03.21.11)
Of course Jews do things like this. They do and they did.
27. #23 rachel
Deutronomy 28 ,   World   (03.21.11)
That family was on Arab land ...
28. 10 stabs all over
Dean ,   USA   (03.21.11)
and one shown. His head -face, arms do not show stabs, He knew they were Orthodox from their accents ? ..as in Lithuanian or Yemen, or US accented Hebrew? Sounds like a Jenin hoax. Where are his friends and girlfriend to substantiate this 'story' ???
29. No 17. Remember Gorge Habash
Eran ,   Singapore   (03.21.11)
You write; "..this man is even a Christian.. ". Habash was a Christian too. He murdered many Israelis. Michael, stop your demented accusations.
30. Probably the truth of the matter, #8
Cameron ,   USA   (03.21.11)
Next talkbacks
Back to article