News
Boy found to have lied about rape
Yoav Zitun
Published: 30.03.11, 13:36
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
71 Talkbacks for this article
31. #9 - yeah, you wouldnt have been alone on the original repor
eporue ,   europe   (03.30.11)
t in the morning... yoav just found to suppress as he saw fit...
32. Much easier to claim that the boy lied than
Ed   (03.30.11)
to indict Arabs. Were they not Arabs, they'd be sitting in jail for years.
33. VERY dirty indeed
Israeli 2   (03.30.11)
Falsely accusing anybody is dirty indeed. We have to sadly admit the possibility that we have dirty scumbags among us as well. I would like to believe that we are held by higher standards.
34. Where is Ben Jabo, the israeli "dr. justice"
Moise   (03.30.11)
35. #16 R U Serious
babawawa ,   new york, usa   (03.30.11)
What the hell is that last sentence all about? The Israeli police did what real policemen do - they question the suspects and the victim. It turned out these guys didn't do it. Got nothing to do with the right wing of anything.
36. Rape!
Sebastian ,   Isr   (03.30.11)
Its just so easy to blame everything on the Palestinians - its also very easy to cry rape with almost no recourse - perhaps they really should check out this kids story, his family.No smoke without fire,,,even more disturbing is the plea deal made with the twin brothers accused of killing 7 year old Leon Kalantarov. Life has become cheap and nobody really cares anymore.What kind of country have we become?!
37. I agree completely with #7
MD in psychiatry ,   USA   (03.30.11)
This is the BEST answer for this situation. The boy needs to be examined by a competent child psychiatrist and internest. He needs to know that he is safe and has someone to speak to besides his own family.
38. YNET: Stupid stupid people!!!
OMG ,   USA   (03.30.11)
Clearly this poor boy has been the victim of a tragic and tramatic situation. He needs help and protection. Please don't release this boy to his family. He will never recover if you end the story here.
39. #25 - you forgot to mention...
seadog1946 ,   InTransit, USA   (03.30.11)
the Duke University lacrosse team rape incident, the Tawana Brawley rape allegations... you're absolutely right... innocent people are falsely accused all the time.
40. 11 yrs old already lying, israel teaches them well LOL
deutronomy 28 ,   world   (03.30.11)
41. I too agree with #7 - There's something more to this story
Mark ,   USA   (03.30.11)
Police will be glad not to have to prosecute the Arabs, the family is glad it was all a "misunderstanding". Something's wrong here.
42. #7
please   (03.30.11)
You are influential enough to do something about this. if i was, I certainly would. All I can do is urge everyone to read rotter.net where the brother speaks and asks for help. It's in Hebrew which #7 and others shouldn't have a problem with
43. To: No. 39
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (03.30.11)
Okay, add those to the list. Thank you for acknowledging that your "gloating" was quite premature. Isn't it nice that the Israeli police investigators did not treat the case as a slam dunk, but pursued questioning the boy? Don't you wish that would be done more often in the United States?
44. #33 Israeli 2 - You're calling an 11 y.old kid a scumbag?
Mark ,   USA   (03.30.11)
What were you thinking? No kid that age and from that cultural background could have made this up. Someone is guilty, and it's not the child!
45. Isn't there an agency for the protection of children
Mark ,   USA   (03.30.11)
that could intervene and demand further assessment of the situation?
46. in both cases israel looks really bad
deutronomy 28 ,   world   (03.30.11)
if the kid lied, it shows what kind of upbringing israel has for its own kids, learning how to lie about a serious thing as rape and wrongfully accusing an innocent man should be firmly punished and this kid should be tried as an adult, an if he didnt lie and the israeli authorities forced him to, well its sad for that child who will have his life ruined by some arab dumb rapist, but it shows how much israel doesnt care even about its own citizens and would cover up a crime for god knows what reason...
47. Not likely
David M.   (03.30.11)
An enema leaving marks like cigarette burns? That's absurd. I agree with those who think there is a cover up for whatever reason.
48. #10 You poor guy
The big picture   (03.30.11)
but keep on trying to convince yourself...good luck. Poor kid if he lives in your kind of circle. Probably does. My heart crys for him.. and all the others who are 'shut up' by bullies... and worse
49. Shalom Hartman
Me@2011.30.03   (03.30.11)
I agree and I think this mess stinks somewhat. No doubt about it..... the boy is scared out of his wits.
50. #22 believe or not, those neither have connections nor money
observer   (03.30.11)
51. To: No. 28
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (03.30.11)
I invite you to document your sources. The numbers I have are quite different -- both for civil cases and for criminal cases. So I think I know from whence you pulled that 98% number, but I'll give you a chance to back up your statement before I make a complete fool of you. You have 24 hours. You are quite demonstrably not a lawyer. Please refrain from throwing around legal statistics which are outrageously false, and easily proven false. You just set yourself up as a laughingstock.
52. To: No. 50
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (03.30.11)
How can you be so sure? They obviously had enough money to buy their way into Israel (not cheap) and they were not living rough. Someone or something has frightened this boy. Perhaps he feared for his safety, and the safety of his family. Given what happened to the Fogel family, who can blame him?
53. #44: Mark, I said scumbagS
Israeli 2   (03.30.11)
I should have explained better. I am not refering to the boy but by those who coerced him. They are the scumbags. I did not say scumbag. Thank you for your comment.
54. To: No. 40
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (03.30.11)
He did not lie as well as those ersatz "Palestinian" boys who claim they were walking home from the mosque, except the filmed accounts showed them to be busy pelting a moving vehicle with large stones hurled from a sling. He did not lie as well as those ersatz "Palestinian" terrorists who claim that the 13 year old boy was innocently picking flowers for their mother near the perimeter fence between Gaza and Israel when Israeli troops fired upon him -- except before and after photographs clearly demonstrate that the ground on both sides of the border was completely barren; no grass, no flowers. He did not lie as well as those ersatz "Palestinian" terrorists who claim that they were merely collecting scrap metal near the perimeter fence between Gaza and Israel when Israeli troops fired upon them -- except before and after photographs clearly demonstrate that there was no scrap metal. The list goes on and on and on. So which is it? Are the ersatz "Palestinians" pathological liars, or they are so deluded that they actually think that any reasonable person believes their ludicrous claims?
55. #1 Seamongrel
BEN JABO ,   ISRAEL   (03.30.11)
I can hear the Bats ringing the bell in your belfry Just noise, no substance "In transit" to where the moon, or maybe to the Head ?
56. Police are not qualified to made this judgement
Yael ,   Israel   (03.30.11)
PLEASE send the boy for a proper evaluation. He is a double victim.
57. Poor Sarah
Deutronomy 28 ,   World   (03.30.11)
It's not my fault your stuck, it's either the boy lied or the authorities lied, which one ??? Lol one of them is a liar...either the boy is already a bad seed or he is a victim and the israeli authorities are evil and forced him to say that he lied so choose your poison lol
58. #12 Israelit
BEN JABO ,   ISRAEL   (03.30.11)
Children of ages 6 & up, know more about sexual activities than adults of 20 years ago knew Cases in point, reading the online version of the Philadelphia Inquirer just the other day, there have been hundreds of young kids, removed from class for slugging their teachers and performing sexual activities while in class Let's put in this way, when a family lives in cramped quarters, it's rather difficult for the child to avoid seeing intimate activities between adults Then of course, you have the TV, where many sexually exciting things can be seen, just by clicking the channels Look at how young girls wear clothing styles that make them out to be potential hookers Little pishers have big ears & EYES
59. #34 Moise, justice was done
BEN JABO ,   ISRAEL   (03.30.11)
The boy wasn't required to bring four witnesses to prove that he was raped The innocent were set free Now, what are you mumbling, didn't you want your four innocent brothers set free ?
60. #40 neuteronomy
BENJABO ,   ISRAEL   (03.30.11)
Lying for the cause is allowed, when a Muslim does it Read your Koran, you'll learn something
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article