Opinion
The anti-Israel Jews
Giulio Meotti
Published: 05.04.11, 18:14
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
106 Talkbacks for this article
1. They are not supporters of Israel
Rachel ,   US   (04.05.11)
So stop trying to appease them or give their view more validity than they deserve. Treat them like the enemies they are. These stooges would have been against King David.
2. Chomsky
Not sure   (04.05.11)
My belief is that chomsky was once for the two states with minor border modifications seven percent would be moderate and limited right of return for refugees to israel who could build villages in Palestine. So chomsky is as often is out of reality . The arab peoples want palestine back and the jews back out.
3. unfortunately nothing new
Tuvea ,   Chicago, Il   (04.05.11)
Jewish self-haters have been around for as long as Judaism herself has existed. The difference is, of course, these particular anti-Israel bigots are rewarded by their non-Jewish peers with "respect". Many also are given huge amounts of cash by academic institutions to spew their hatred in the name of "Social Justice". Just as the Kapo's of Shoah groveled to extend their putrid extistence, so too do these creatures. The truly funny thing is that behind their backs their so-called "friends" laugh and make jokes about those "dirty Jew assholes" who server them. These peoples are traitors and are treated as such not only by pious, moral Jews but also by their "friends". No doubt the Eternal One will have something to say to them when, as all mortals do, they finally are no longer of this earth. --- Am Yisroel Chai!
4. Just like Neturei Karta
Kyle ,   Southpark, CO, USA   (04.05.11)
But without the frisbee hats
5. The anti-Israel Jews
robert ,   italy   (04.05.11)
They need world approvations and they dont care the killing, the abuse, the negation of basic right of their brothers that are fighting to be considered human being in these world..... Once the name of these kind of Jews were : JUDENRAT
6. I really question if they are even Jews at all or not.
(04.05.11)
7. Am Yisrael Chai!
Paul ,   SA   (04.05.11)
8. Ken Loach
Geoff ,   London (UK)   (04.05.11)
I believe that Ken Loach has a Jewish son-in-law but I don't think that Loach himself is Jewish.
9. lets not forget George Soros
Eran ,   Toronto   (04.05.11)
10. This is a matter for serious clinical, pathological study
tom ,   tel aviv   (04.05.11)
that world's leading (non Jewish) psychiatrist and psychologist should undertake. Really: in all seriousness! I can think of no other race/nation so preoccupied with self-loathing as us, Jews. Well: "chosen people" or what ??
11. Faithful remnant
David N. ,   Haifa, Israel   (04.05.11)
Only a remnant... In each generation of Israel, only a remnent remain faithful. Ever has it been so.
12. Self-hating Jews. Nothing new... Israel will outlast them
Efi ,   Tel Aviv, Israel   (04.05.11)
Self-hating Jews who will do and say anything to please their anti-Semitic overlords have been sniping at Israel for years. It's nothing new, nothing to get too excited about. It's revolting, sure, but that's about it. Don't give these hate-filled lunatics, who despite the Jewish masses, and fear the reality of Jewish sovereignty, any more fuel for their enormous egos.
13. They will be forgotten in the dustbin of history
Moish ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (04.05.11)
These Jews are the Eruv Rav, the mix multitude that built the Egel Zahav/Golden Calf. We all now where that got us.
14. the anti Jewish-Jew.....
tiki ,   belgium   (04.05.11)
Like today there are the 'anti Israel Jews (always good for establishing ones name), but it realy is not a new fenomen. Throughout history Jews ALWAYS have been their own worst enemy. There always have been Jewish traitors, willing to send their brothers/sisters into the gas ovens. The anti Israel Jews of to day probably are their descendants.
15. Idiots
Roey   (04.05.11)
They think they're making a difference with their beliefs...all they're doing is serving as PR points for the cause of those who want to see dead Jews.
16. anti Zionist Jews
yonatan silverman ,   tel aviv israel   (04.05.11)
Don't exaggerate. So what if there are traitor Jews in the world. They are loud mouth fanatics and nothing they say matters one bit. The only problem Israel faces is from governments who may call for Israel's disappearance like Iran. To deal with Iran is a different kettle of fish than dealing with Finkelstein and company. There is no reason to do anything at all against Finkelstein. He will self destruct
17. Delegitimizing Yeretz Yisrael
PNJohnson ,   Winnipeg, Canada   (04.05.11)
This is blatant nonsense: "Now, we are again in an era where the Jews are once more sentenced to solitary confinement on the moral high ground." The greatest 'delegitimizer of the Jewish State' is the Jewish State, particularly the Government of Bibi and his fundamentalist political masters. Israel is becoming what it hates, and is now devouring its own children, at least rhetorically, through items like this one from Ynetnews. It makes me very sad. The voices of the propets are once again being silenced. Shema, Yisrael!
18. Traitors
George Brown ,   New York   (04.05.11)
Traitorous Jews should be treated with the same respect other countries treat their traitors: in the US they lock them up. In muslim countries they decapitate them. Either works for me.
19. Jews Against Israel
Andrea Moriah ,   Israel   (04.05.11)
Not to panic. These kinds of Jews have always existed. They are the manifestation of all the self-doubt inherent in being a people apart. They simply don't have the guts for it. There are, thank God, enough of us who always have, do now and always will.
20. These jews are Cowards
David ,   USA   (04.05.11)
Complete Cowards!!! Zero Spine or soul. These far left wing scum bags are not worthy of anything. Their opinions are irrelevant and so are they. We in the USA have many are self. The modern JEW must be like the ancient warriors of King David not the wimpy European jew.
21. These jews as bad as...
David   (04.05.11)
These far left wing hating JEWS Are as bad as the terrorist Arabs. They are weak, pathetic, ignorant people. They would be the last ones to fight back in a real life situation as they have no heart or soul.
22. Now They Have Their Own Club - J Street
Seth ,   Washington, DC   (04.05.11)
23. Simple Reason: They know NO Torah!!!
Israeli 2   (04.05.11)
24. There's a hope with Jews like them ,...
split ,   US   (04.05.11)
25. Look They Hate Themselves, Too
Terry Feld ,   Houston, Texas   (04.05.11)
These are the definition of Self-Hating Jews. Treat them as you would any other mentally challenged, mentally deficient, mentally deranged, fool. Look at history. When Jews are defenseless they are always forced to disappear, die, or cower in fear. Not anymore. Now the Christian world latches on the their "Judeo" side. And the other segments have learned to fear/ respect the long arm of Israel. God Bless Israel. Am Yisrael Chai!
26. its the vogue for liberals to prove that they are
Larry ,   Los Angeles   (04.05.11)
real liberals have to hate Israel, its the in thing, the more they can demonstrate that they love our enemies, the more they feel great liberals. ah, what a sickness,
27. May HaShem bless these so-called self-hating Jews
cynic #2   (04.05.11)
For they know that what they are doing is right. As for the others, may Hashem forgive them for they know not what they are doing!javascript:%20save()
28. They love socialism and one world government more !
nero ,   nyc   (04.05.11)
These miscreant who hate their Jewish roots and Israel are addicted to the socialist ideal of one world government and would readily sacrifice Israel for that ideal. They also make pretty good money lecturing around the world with Saudi money.
29. If Albert Einstein would have been alive today...
Ben Alofs ,   Bangor, UK   (04.05.11)
he would have been on the list of what people on this Talkback call "traitors", "self haters", "idiots". The only stereotype I have not heard yet is "kapo". In earnest I have nothing but admiration for people like Noam Chomsky, Ilan Pappe, Michael Lerner, Marek Edelman, Yeshayahu Leibowitz, Stephen and Hillary Rose, Harold Pinter and Hannah Arendt, who have the courage of their convictions. Here are a few more Jewish heroines, who I admire and respect. Would they have been alive today, they would no doubt have been on the above list: Rosa Luxembourg and Emma Goldman, What all these people in my opinion share is that they are a "light unto the nations".
30. #3 the eternal one has already spoken
deutronomy 28 ,   world   (04.05.11)
read deutronomy 28 you will learn something, remember the eternel one doesnt approve violence and killing nor nationalism from wherever it comes
Next talkbacks
Back to article