News
Goldstone to face libel suit
Attila Somfalvi
Published: 07.04.11, 09:31
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
30 Talkbacks for this article
1. Goldstone
Ralph ,   Caesarea   (04.07.11)
Good initiative to sue him.
2. Self-seeing publicist
VernonMarriott ,   Tel Aviv   (04.07.11)
1) There is no case for libelling a state I believe in common law. 2) American courts don't like dealling with libel (it kind of goes against the "free speech" amendment of their constitution. 3) It's questionable whether the US Courts would hear such a case as they've come out strongly against libel tourism 4) Instead of dealing with something that's in the past, why doesn't Danny Danon deal with some real issues that he can actually do something about - high taxes in Israel, levels of corruption in public office and throughout government, encouragement of trade, disassembling of bureucratic hurdles to life in Israel This is just a publicity stunt and ducks the real issues that those of us in Israel have to put up with on a daily basis,
3. Class action suit! I want in!!!
Brian Cohen ,   Judean Peoples Front   (04.07.11)
This case should be opened to all Israelis who were libeled by Goldstone. And that means all of us.
4. to #2
Monsieur Phepps ,   Netanya   (04.07.11)
I beg to differ.
6. Has potential to backfire spectacularly
Smith ,   TA, Israel   (04.07.11)
Dannon is a loose cannon
7. has this been approved by the government of Israel?
Sally Forth ,   Israel   (04.07.11)
On what basis does a lone member of Knesset decide that he is filing a suit in a foreign court against a foreigner? This action to sue is parallel to Minister Yishai's action to invite Goldstone... and leads me to ask: What on earth is going on with our government officials? and where is P.M. Mr. Netanyahu?
8. Guilty! In advance, Guilty. Lock him up, Guilty.
Bunnie Meyer ,   Los Angeles, CA USA   (04.07.11)
9. G-d bless Dannon! The hateful anti-Semitic
Shmukstone ,   is Goldstone   (04.07.11)
Jews like Goldstone must be brought to justice. It wll be interesting and comical how the anti-Semites come to his rescue.
10. To: #2
Bigizz ,   USA / ISRAEL   (04.07.11)
I understand what you mean by USA courts dont like Libel cases. However, this case is diffrent. This is a case where Goldstone the JUDGE writes a Negative Report against a State of Israel claiming Israel targeted Civilians Thats alot of wieght to say against people...That dosent make people internationally feel good...I say its damaging...That doesnt make people feel good about the State of Israel...It sheds a very bad light. What about all the Countries that stopped trade with Israel because of this report?? Many countries were influenced by the Goldstone Report. Now he reviels the Truth, However the negative impact was done.. He should be sued, you cant make a person or a society a yoyo....Shed bad light internationally and then take it back?? Goldstone Sucks. I cant believe he is a judge. He is hired to take a job to judge a war, and give a fair biased opinions He fudged the report and relied false information and gave a bad report against Israel...Then three later he retracts his harshest judgments against Israel.....That is libel. Where is his fiduciary duty to judge and get the story straight...People have to pay and make for thier mistakes when they screwed up. Goldstone Fix it..Just as quick as you broke it.. Go Lieberman.. Bigizz USA / ISRAEL
11. Danon is GREAT
MZ ,   Israel   (04.07.11)
Probably the (certainly one of) best Israeli politicians and people today. He MUST become the next prime minister. Bravo Danny! We love you.
12. Goldstone Libel
Adam ,   Zichron Y / London   (04.07.11)
If it raises awareness of the distortion of the report then it is worthwhile. Goldstone must have known he was opening a can of worms by writing that article. I think he needs to be given some credit for his honesty.
13. what a jerk
observer   (04.07.11)
If he indeed has a claim against Goldstein, he didn't need to wait for his retraction to file the suit. On the other hand, if he is building his argument on the retraction, Goldstein can retract the retraction ...
14. Dannon
R Fisher ,   London & Tel Aviv   (04.07.11)
Couldn't agree more Smith from Tel Aviv ..we are sometimes our worst enemy. Stupid and very short sighted.
15. Sue him in UK courts
Danny   (04.07.11)
Much stricter libel laws.
16. #2, the soldiers can sue
Danny   (04.07.11)
basically they can bury Goldstone in libel suits. But i agree the US is not the place to do it, sue in the UK.
17. #2
Dooby ,   Israel   (04.07.11)
Right on the nail - besides why does'nt Dannon deal with the symptoms of why that report was made in the first place.
18. Goldstone judged Israelis
Tom   (04.07.11)
like Israel judges judge religious Jews. Clearly measure for measure. You have to be blind not to see it.
19. His fact finding mission
Larry ,   Or Yehuda   (04.07.11)
The problem was that he did not do any fact finding at all. He based most of his work on heresay from people with less than reputable reputations. Even organizations such as Betzalem and Amnesty sprout stuff without checking their validity. But the world will always turn a blind eye. It is about time that all the Arabs went to palestine, today called Jordan.
20. Wait & see
Issac   (04.07.11)
Instead of speculating, people need to see what is actually filed. You do not know what the exact suit will be. He has to serve Goldstone and there is a matter of jurisdiction, etc...
21.  is anybody in charge of Israel?
(04.07.11)
This idea has the potential to backfire stupendously to Israel's detriment. And as for Israel's PR, in general, it is run by amateurs who have no understanding of different cultures. The ideas they come up with sound brilliant to Israelis but utterly daft and retarded to everyone else. Just like this idea....daft. At the moment there is a vague idea out there ,among the very few people in the world who even noticed this story , that Goldstone retracted his report. But he did not actually retract it-- taking the issue to court will force Goldstone to reiterate the fact that most of what he said still stands. And all this after most of the world has forgotten all about the Goldstone report anyway. Israeli politician's understanding of how to do good PR is utterly utterly beyond help. A five year old monkey could do better
22. #21, the time to do it was when the report was released
Danny   (04.07.11)
23. Let Goldstone Run J Street - He's Perfect
Seth ,   Washington, DC   (04.07.11)
24. To # 13
Eli ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (04.07.11)
For calling Danny Danon a jerk you deserve the same treatment. You are the jerk...Danny's libel suit is exactly what is called for in this situation. He is defending our country, our people, our honor and our integrity which has been sorely damaged due to this wackadoo "judge" who by many accounts was both a useful idiot of the Palestinian cause and by other accounts a pompous ass. As to the Judge being able to retract his retraction..tell me Sherlock, how credible will that make him look?
25. arrogant
alexi   (04.07.11)
this pompous arrogant self righteous judge admits that he was nervous when he went to gaza as a jew. Strike 1 if he was apprehensive. Then he picks a groups with some credentials but who made statements in the past that questionned their impartiality. In gathering data, goldstone and his colleagues did not subject witnesses to serious cross examin atiion especially culture where truth and falsehoods are treated equally. After putiing out a report without the israeli side of it because they didn't come to him, he writes an op ed in the washington post saying it would be a different report if he had the data he now has, yet he say yishai was quote inaccurately and that goldstone would not scuttle or ameliorate his report. Any court of law would have disqualified his panel right from the start for partiality. Goldstone will now be subjected to a death of a thousand cuts by civil lawsuits in the US and Israel and while the UN will protect him financially, he will find it unpleasant. Yishai and shas should not be in any responsible position as they have no grip on reality- yishai lunged to beg goldstone and then misinterpreted what he said and goldstone is usually very careful with his language. Yishai upset the israeli government strategy and has shown himself to be like olmert, a rank amateur. Goldstone should work to empty his report of its significance as his UN associates continue to insist on their report. Otherwise, goldstone, knowing that life will be increasingly severe for him with all manner of lawsuits and protests will living in hell just as jews have for over 2000 years for being unfairly tarred with jesus killing when the romans actually were ultimately responsible.What comes around goes around.
26. Bloodlibel is a jewish stereotype....
Alfie Knowkes ,   Golan   (04.07.11)
Getting the lawyers to work for free is another....
27. That's actually a stupid thing to do
William ,   Israel   (04.07.11)
Yes, Goldstone is a putz and 100% guilty, but he retracted his support for the document. The real people you need to go after with a libel suit is the UN!! Rather than hurt Goldstone with a lawsuit, it's best to solicit him to help fight against the UN. Otherwise, you risk future "Goldstones" from coming forth with such regrets if you keep suing them.
28. goldstone
jerome ,   vancouver canada   (04.08.11)
in a world crazed and blighted by rampant uncontrollable inbred ideological anti semitism , an apology from this idiot now will only make things worse. it will no doubt be construed as another devious zionist plot attempting to undo the "good judges'" original findings. Those masses of morons pre- convinced of Israel's guilt will not falter in their ongoing plans to de-ligitimize israel at every turn. This ignoble maladroit perfidious myopic judge should be required to clean the toilets of the palestinian refugees for the remainder of his stay on earth until one day he can go to that hot unbearable dark place down under deep and express gratitude to the devil for doing such an outstanding job for him. will not alter their positions
29. The problem is part of the report is true
Basil ,   Morgantown, USA   (04.09.11)
It would not be a good idea to do this. Some of the statements in there would be highlighted again including from witnesses, quotes from Israeli officials will be repeated and some were horrible, European doctors would be quoted.... From a certain stand point, one could make the claim that war crimes occurred.
30. Libel suit against Goldstone?
Burt goldstein ,   Los Angeles usa   (04.10.11)
Terrific! Can I sue all the ultra orthodox in Israel for what they say about the secular Jews? That we are nit real Jews, etc?. Where is the evidence of malice in Goldstone? This is needed to prove libel. Where is the defamation of a race? The IDF is not a race, is it? The current Israeli leadership that sent them to Gaza is not a race. Where has Goldstone even criticized, let alone defamed, a race? Please give a precise citation...
31. Name calling is juvenile
Burt Goldstein ,   Los Angeles USA   (04.10.11)
Calling Goldstone an anti Semite with offering adhere of evidence is despicable. Whenever I see a lynch mob mentality, I recall how poorly Jews do against mobs. A reckless disregard for the truth is one element of slander. Gold stones report criticizes some actions of the IDF. Show me where he defamed Jews as Jews.
Back to article