News
Israel Prize laureates protest for Palestinian state
Yoav Zitun
Published: 21.04.11, 15:12
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
90 Talkbacks for this article
1. There are still some decent Israelis
Cynic #2   (04.21.11)
who are worthy of being called good neighbors of the Palestinians. Alas, they are being drowned in a sea of fascism and apartheid.
2. How many "Palestinians" have accepted Israel's right to be,
Jehudah Ben-Israel ,   Qatzrin, Israel   (04.21.11)
to exist as the nation-state of the Jewish people...?? None!! When the Arabs, Muslim-Arabs to be more accurate, after so many attempts to wipe Israel off the face of earth and with it it all traces of Jewish life, accept Israel's right to be, to exist as the nation-state of the Jewish people, we shall accept the setting up of an independent Arab state in our homeland, not before!!
3. With fools like this, who needs peace talks?
Brian Cohen ,   Judean Peoples Front   (04.21.11)
Sure, just leave it to the leftist and rightist activists to declare what it is that will be reality. No need for that silly little concept known as "international law" to get in the way of a Palestinian state. Why did we even bother with all those money-wasting peace talks and peace conferences? And far be it from these leftist do-gooders to pay attention to Israeli public opinion. They obviously are oblivious to the facts that: a) the majority of Israelis favor a 2-state solution and b) the majority of Israelis favor a 2-state solution that is determined in negotiations between the two sides, and not by some arbitrary declaration by the Pals (or the leftists) who are bypassing the peace talks. These leftists are the few remaining activists from the "peace camp", that dead but still much-flogged concept that is almost extinct from the Knesset.......for the exact same reasons mentioned above.
4. Reeks of the mid-nineties
HaifaGuy   (04.21.11)
In those days i would vote sheeple like them into power, Meretz and the likes. Thank god, i have unglued my eyes and ears since then and restarted my brain. thank god, there are less and less self-hating jews like these half-mummyfied dinosaurs. Please, my fellow Jews, keep popping those eyes and ears open, keep restarting your brains. Dont give up on the only hope we have to survive as individuals and as a nation- the State of Israel. Let them dinosaurs die out - just like 67 million years ago.
5. Freud once explained that kind of
Chris Rettenmoser ,   Bayerisch Gmain Germ   (04.21.11)
behaviour...it is simply a death wish...
6. THESE LAUREATES PROBABLY CHEERED THE GAZA PULLOUT
stude ham   (04.21.11)
how easily fooled these laureates.
7. Total idiocy
sk ,   USA   (04.21.11)
ok I'm neither Jewish or Israeli but these leftwingers are dead wrong! They must live in a make believe state of mind incapable of comprehending historical reality, Arab aggressiveness, Isalmic philosophy, and geographical vulnerabilities. It's not about land, Arabs already have over 99.96% of middle east land already. These leftwing idiots just don't get it!
8. Boring
Joe Schmoe ,   Israel   (04.21.11)
Since when were a few dozen nutcases worthy of international media attention. Heck, all she has for fame is that she can imitate other people for a living.
9. left wing activists....
Jennie ,   US/ISrael   (04.21.11)
This is the most shameful act of betrayal by the home grown traitors...This is Democracy at its ugliest . These people should be tried for treason and thrown out of Israel forever ! 1967 borders ? After 66 years of daily acts of war on our sovereign soil, they want Israel to commit suicide ? They must all be expelled to gaza ! Let the chamas,the fattah, etc...show them the same welcome they showed to the their friend who was executed only last week...
10. the leftist self-hateful Jews want to destroy Israel
frank ,   usa   (04.21.11)
11. Leftism is a crippling virus. It must be bleached out
Dan ,   USA   (04.21.11)
12. The combination of two extremist groups-
Anonymous ,   Israel   (04.21.11)
Won't create us, the citizens of Israel, a positive matter,in this case, even though it might entertain us. As long as both groups counter each other, their words will only carry nullity. Left wing protesters won't reach a Palestinian state through exploiting the declaration, and right wing protesters won't be able to suppress the others through blunt harassment.
13. What a bunch of silly, naive morons.
Noodles ,   Coney Island   (04.21.11)
14. "Intellectuals are't the nation's brains, they are it's sh.t
tanya ,   tel aviv israel   (04.21.11)
Lenin wrote to Gorky.
15. What palestinian state?
Jake   (04.21.11)
Where does Israel's Declaration of Independence mention a "Palestinian State" or "Palestinians"? In 1947, the UN General Assembly passed a non-binding resolution, 181 (II), recommending the partition of Mandate Palestine into 2 states, Jewish and Arab. The Jews accepted the partition plan, the Arabs rejected it and went to war to prevent its implementation. The British refused to implement partition over Arab objections. If partition had been accepted by all parties, a transitional period under United Nations auspices was to begin with the adoption of the resolution, and lasting until the establishment of the two states. However, war broke out and the partition plan was never implemented by the Security Council. On March 5, 1948, the United Nations Security Council reached an impasse when it refused to pass a resolution which would have accepted the partition plan as a basis for Security Council action. However, the Security Council voted to send the matter back to the General Assembly for further deliberation. The General Assembly decided to appoint a Mediator, and relieved the Palestine Commission from any further exercise of responsibility under resolution 181 (II) of 29 November 1947. The principle of partition is legally dead. Nothing since then has superceded the legal entitlements of the Jewish National Home in international law established at San Remo in 1921. Their continued validity is guaranteed by Article 80 the UN Charter. Resolutions 242 and 338, which were accepted by all parties as the basis of Middle East peace negociations, make no mention whatsoever of the establish of any "Palestinian state".
16. #1, Cynic
DR ,   Florida, USA   (04.21.11)
Yeah Israel is the roblem in this situation. As per usual you forget to mentino one reason for which the Palestinians deserve their own state. Is it the terror, the brainwshing of oung kids to want to kill jews, is it he hatred and oppression of anything other than radical Islam? Why in the world should they have their own state???
17. Leftists "Protests" against Israel
Edward ,   Savannah, USA   (04.21.11)
The ONLY way for these "leftist" people to "get it" is to dump them in the middle of Syria, Egypt, Lebenon, or Iran, and let's see how much those "people" recipitate the same "love and concern" these idiots are expressing to those that HATE them and want to see ALL Jews D.E.A.D.!!! Abbas has already openly STATED that there will be NO Jews in the NEW Pali State, so who's the one practising "aparthied and racism"!!!??? These people have a mental disorder that they refuse to see REALITY!!! Be careful what you wish for, you just might get it!!!
18. these were never peace activists
Golan ,   Modiin   (04.21.11)
they are traitors who brought the PLO and Hamas into our cafes, buses, and rockets on our heads. The fifth column has exposed itself as being anti-Israel and not peace activists.
19. those retards can go to gaza to live or the west bank if the
(04.21.11)
think this will help the cause
20. Change them for Shallit.Them acept ???
Rosenvald ,   Brasil   (04.21.11)
21. to#2
Jennie ,   US/ISrae   (04.21.11)
Great point, Jehuda ! The so-called and self proclaimed palestinian people are the living proof of a known fact: a lie repeated often enough, eventually becomes the truth...And by now we know why are the palis there and what is their mission...If there is one thing they don't want, it is a state of their own...They have proven it time and again...Tracing the history of these people's actions towards the Jewish State, the only conclusion to be made to this day is, that it is only another radical islamic state instead, not next to Israel, they would ever settle for and are striving for...Don't we know who is backing them and orchestrating the game ?
22. Israel
Jorge ,   Israel/USA/Argentina   (04.21.11)
We want freedom from all dictators around the world oppresing all Jews. We want freedom from all the quasi nations that target Israel from any point of view We want freedom from all the rockects that every day land in the country. We want freedom from all club of hypocrats that with petrodollars direct the world. We want freedom from all those that never heard or seen a Jew but balme on us. We want freedom from all the puppets goverment from "Third World Country" that follow the entinties that want to destroy us.
23. Left = Equality, Right = Apartheid >>> Left will prevail.
Michael ,   California, USA   (04.21.11)
24. "Israel Prize laureates protest for Palestinian state..."
(04.21.11)
and who says there are no good Jews?
25. And when things go wrong?
Jonny ,   South Africa   (04.21.11)
If the so called "borders' are implemented- and things go wrong (experience of Islamic colonialism here tells us they will) then I hope that everyone of these actvists will be as active in manning the barricades. and not allowed to run away to foreign countries. I am sure that they all have stand by plans at foreign universities.
26. When Palestinians Love Their Children More Than...
Ari ,   Israel   (04.21.11)
they hate Israel then they could have a state. When Muslim Arab women living in the "west bank" have the same rights as they do living in Israel then the Palestinians could have a state. When Palestinian gays are no longer being oppressed, tortured, and killed then the palestinians could have a state.
27. #1, You are an imposter just like these cowards
Cynic ,   USA   (04.21.11)
28. I am sure they are all packing for move to their new state
Cynic ,   USA   (04.21.11)
29. These left wing,naive morons make me...
Malone ,   Hfx   (04.21.11)
..want to throw up!
30. Rightwingers make a lot of noise
Rika Chaval   (04.21.11)
But since when has noise, hatred of intellectuals and shameless namecalling been proof of wisdom? The fact is, 17 Israel prize winners do have 17.000.000 times more brains than a bunch of attarded Kahanists. They know that Israel can't just sit back and wait for peace to unfold. Israel has to take action at long last. A majority of Israelis does want the 2 states solution. Simply because it is the ONLY way to secure Israels existence as a democratic state, national home of the jewish nation. Kahanists and their likes are exalted, violent, destructive of the state of Israel, hamas-like. Follow them, it is the way to destruction of Israel.
Next talkbacks
Back to article