News
Netanyahu: Conflict is about 1948, not 1967
Attila Somfalvi
Published: 16.05.11, 19:41
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
60 Talkbacks for this article
31. chutzpah
alexi   (05.16.11)
livni along with olmert led to hamastan courtesy of the gaza unilatreal withdrawal and convergence concepts drawn up by the twin lawyers- one a crook going to jail and who did not serve in combat, the other a dumbell extraordinaire who babysat apartments in Paris. they ushered in hamastan and 8000 rockets and death. It is beyond sanity that livni mouths empty slogans for peace. How did she get into law school? peace cannot be had by offering concessions to the arabs or by running to the peace table as peres suggested. israel is being humiliated by peres, livni and barak and this lousy trio should be rejected thoroughly by the voters.
32. Stop Delaying!
Ussishkin ,   Tel Aviv Israel   (05.16.11)
Start negotiating.
33. Bibi spoke the truth..
Jennie ,   Israel/US   (05.16.11)
And the conclusion of his speach is obviously corect. The current facts about the terror groups organizing into a new terror state with a clear aim to intimidate and innihilate Israel, leaves no doubt, that if a so-called palestiian state will be established or even if not, they always try for our innihilation...What the heck is livni barking about? Did anybody learn a lesson from the events of the recent days?Recent month, years, decades for that matter ? The enemy doesn't sleep, they love it when our government is not getting along...If we are to win and survive,Israel must unite, roll up sleeves and stand up with a resolve to clean up house, seal borders, prepare to fight for real peace....Right and Left together...It is time to learn a new rule of ingagement....
34. one israel- together we'll make it!!!!!!
unite the nation   (05.16.11)
together we'll fear no evil. mohamad cannot win us if we're united for israel
35. Who's occupying?
Daniel ,   Edison, USA   (05.17.11)
Jews lived in Israel long before the Palestinians arrived. Their historic and religious sites predate Islamic sites by at least 1000 years. They were expelled by the Romans in 70 AD, but they never relinquished their right to their county. When they returned, they allowed the Arabs the opportunity to live alongside them, but the Arabs either revolted or fled. Now they want to return to wipe out the only Democracy in the middle east and replace it with a jihadist theocracy. where is the Jewish Occupation?
36. #5, you think you can occupy Israel forever? WRONG
Jake ,   USA   (05.17.11)
No foreigh occupation in the land of Israel lasted forever. While Arab occupation has been in Israel for several centuries now (though too long), it will be dismantled and uprooted.
37. LIVNI
LONIA ,   MTL CAN   (05.17.11)
NEED BABY SEATER
38. 5# 35# Duh...and Puh...
Alex ,   USA   (05.17.11)
39. re: #2 and YNet please clarify
John ,   Alaska   (05.17.11)
The YNet article reads in English: "... We also agree that our people must retain the settlement blocks. Finally I insist that Jerusalem remain the State of Israel's capital." Post #2 says: "UNDIVIDED Yerushalayim capital!!! I worry it wasn't a slip. (End)" I don't yet read Hebrew well enough to follow news in Hebrew; I depend on an English-language translation to understand what is going on in the Jewish nation. My question: did the Prime Minister say "UNDIVIDED Yerushalayim capital"? This matters because one could say he was willing to settle for Jerusalem being the national capital for both states, each with their own divided part. But it the Prime Minister's translation is more correctly "an undivided Yerushalayam as the capital of Israel", this is a very different, and most laudable, position.
40. netanyahu.
justice for all ,   world/planet earth   (05.17.11)
netanyahu has never blamed himself, he always blames others even he is wrong himself!
41. To N 7, Jehuda
Luiz Felipe Haddad ,   Niteroi, Brazil   (05.17.11)
Dear Jehuda Ben-Israel. Your words are excellent. Your State needs to be firm, but, also, patient. Rigid positions are so inconsistent as the ones that endanger Her security. I think, as a friend, that all Israelian political parties must be united about a definitive peace's agreement. Remember Churchill-Attlee(Tory-Labor) Coalition's British Cabinet in II World's War. Y salute you.
42. Livni has gone down in history as:
Harry Wright ,   UK   (05.17.11)
(a) grovelling for a ceasefire agreement in the second Lebanon war when Hizbullah was on the verge of surrendering. Between her and the weeping Fouad Siniora, I don't know which one was worse. For some unknown reason, she did not want to crush Hezbullah; (b) Stopping Cast Lead (along with Olmert) before crushing Hamas, when they were at the point of surrendering. She could have caused absolute ruction with Olmert in favour of continuing the war but instead, just made some feeble statements that the war should go on, only because she did not want to be blamed a second time; (c) Getting more votes than anybody else but not being able to garner enough support to form a coalition government...thank God for that; (d) Unable to show unity and patriotism in her brand of politics in the most trying and critical time for Israel. She put herself and her own vindictiveness first, before national interests - just like it was in her political interest for her to be obedient and keep in the good books of the US politicians during the two wars; (e) Consistently acting against Israel's interest blurting out statements that only make people despise her more; (f) Refusing to go home and take care of her debilitating delusions of grandeur, preferring instead to cling on, much to everyone's annoyance; (g) So very willing to give away land for peace and the whole store too, that Erekat and Abbas have found her to be the best and most gullible and generous negotiator ever, only because they gain and Israel looses. Recognition of Israel was never a priority for her, only concession after concession.
43. Knesset IS a Circus: Livni is a MONSTER!
EZ ,   US   (05.17.11)
Shame on this ignorant, arrogant fool Livni who never misses an opportunity to BASH ANYONE for her own sake but dies she know bow animalistic and stupid she looks!? That she reveals she is a cruel egomaniac!? Indeed, Netanyahu has ruined many opportunities and has not "led" anything but a parade of silence and WEAKNESS! He MUST GO! But because the Knesset is full of "clowns" (as the speaker so idiotically threatened to make out of hecklers) who the heck does Israel have left to lead it!? There is an ENORMOUS AND DANGEROUS VACCUUM IN THE POLITICAL LEADERSHIP OF ISRAEL. Choices must be made and bold ones at that! But by WHO!? Can any of my fellow Israelis point to 1-2 LEADERS in Israel? Are there ANY left? What has happened to us!? Should we vote in the nearest humus store clerk? The field is barren, there is no one. Except...most importantly...the dead silent Israeli population itself. WHERE ARE THEY when our nation is slipping into oblivion and the world HATES us as represented by the UN!? Where are the "brave" Israeli citizens? Probably smoking a hookah at a dance club in Tel Aviv pretending nothing is wrong and shirking any and all responsiblity to their nation. I refuse to believe this but that is what everyone is saying. Where was the Israeli public when the pals demonstrated at the borders, WB, Gaza? ASLEEP? Are we LAZY losers who refuse to do the right thing and COUNTER PROTEST ENMASS AT EVERY OPPORTUNITY!? There should have been tens of thousands of flag waving JEWS at the borders, ready to confront these animals who yearn to kill us and our children! But like Europe, 1938...we are complacent, optimistic and turning a blind eye to reality. Perhaps that IS how stupid we are. And just read the talk backs on this post: you'll se just how quickly these issues and I will be bashed, ridiculed, made fun of and rationalized. It's what almost always happens: a normal occurrence. What are we gonna do? Confront the enemy with massive protests and CREATE OUR FUTURE BY DEMANDING THE CHANGES THAT NEED TO MAKE, THEREBY BECOMING THE TRUE LEADERS OF ISRAEL AS A PEOPLE...or shall we lie down in our graves and die? Choice is ours but this time make you choice loud and clear so we can all hear it...just so we can be sure. Can you do that much...or are you truly a complete loser?
44. Israel has lost it's edge: Israelis apathetic
EZ ,   US   (05.17.11)
No leaders, everything is about start ups and money, partying and pretending everything is hunky-dorey while the Arabs run all over us, the UN, EU, ME hates us...and we sit around with a loser "parliamentary democrazy" leading us to hell in a handbasket. I'm guessing 2,000 yrs in exile and the Shoah wasn't enough to smarten us up. What a freakin shame.
45. it's 1917 bibi, as well as 1948.
sweeter than honey ,   far away   (05.17.11)
remember the balfour declaration? and the first british high commissioner in palestine herbert samual, a jew? and how the british taught jews (via jewsh agency) to run post offices, transport systems, public services etc.. that is fulfilling the promise of nation building. cabinet papers from the 1920's also reveal that britain was going to transfer the arabs of palestine to the east bank and partition the land. similar was done in ireland, india, china, africa, america, australia. in the 1920's it would have been quite normative. the arabs are not to be underestimated. they saw 15 years of british help to jewish nation building, and when hitler came to power they made their alliances with britain's enemies. appeasement to the arabs led to jewish terrorism vis a vis imigration to palestine. a very great irony such was the sympathy and effort the british had put in for 15 years. However; the notion of the british to transfer the arab population of the west bank of the jordan in palestine to the eastern bank once the jewish nation was able to be independent has in the past 90 years fallen out of fashion. one could probably not get away with it now. i wonder why.
46. how disgusting the politicians world
ego trip ,   ISRAEL   (05.17.11)
how disgusting that they give even the chance to talk to that livni- she will take any opportunity to attack whatever is said- to show that's she is there- for sure she's not pro Israel- she's pro Tzipi- in a total ego trip
47. Thank you Tzipi Livni
Ibrahim el Awal ,   Dearborn, Michigan   (05.17.11)
I want to thank you Zipi for doing a good job for Hamas. Since you are a woman we cannot have a Haflah for you in Jenin, with good Humus, Shashlik. Why did you not say "Allahu akbar!" at the end of your speech?
48.  Conflict is about 1948
ovadyah ,   Hales   (05.17.11)
this is abosolutly true ... the mere fact that israel exist is the focas of the islamic anger...
49. #5
Ovadyah ,   Hales   (05.17.11)
there will be a season of 1000 years where the jewish messiah will rule from Jerusalem which is now eminant....according to scripture.
50. I finally agree with Bibi
StevieT ,   USA   (05.17.11)
As a longtime supporter of the seculoar middle (if there is one), I have been quite contemptuous of the current governments clumsy machinations. Things have changed in this 'Arab Spring', their leaders are under pressure and it has forced them to show their hands prematurely. The cards are on the table, they are face up, and their 'bottom line' is exposed to all. 1948 is a good way to put it. Livni should reconsider, unity is essential in the face of this new reality. If a cozy, comfortable, moderate schmuck like me can see it, she should be able to also.
51. I cant stand Livni
Susan ,   Kfar Saba   (05.17.11)
Ok, she is the opposition, I get it. But she finds every opportunity to slam Bibi to the point of sounding ridiculous. When Bibi was in the opp he mostly kept his mouth shut. During the Gaza war he publically supported the govt. Does she not get it that she turns off a lot of people with her rants?
52. Netenyahu is right, we have only ourselves to blame.
Salma ,   Palestine   (05.17.11)
As an "occupied" people, why do anything for ourselves, when others will do it for us?
53. The PA can't go through with their plans...
Sandra ,   NYC   (05.17.11)
...without "cooperation" from Israel. Fayyad has admitted this. So why does Israel cooperate with such horrendous enemies? The Oslo Accords are dead and it's time to stop cooperating with these people (especially when it comes to passing tax revenues on to them). They're forming a government with the people who fired an anti-tank missile at a school bus in Israel. This is more than enough of a justification to stop all cooperation with the PA. The PA can't function without Israel and stopping their functioning is the best idea at this point.
54. Netanyahu and dates
Michael ,   Haifa   (05.17.11)
If Netanyahu wants to improve his idiotic spin, he should have phrased it "not 1967, not 1948 but rather 70 AD" . Maybe he can also employ another advisor in the Prime Minister's Office to verify the date on which Abraham cleared out of Ur.
55. haval
birdi ,   israel   (05.17.11)
this blind livni only wants bibi's chair. if she really loved israel she would join ranks with bibi to form a stronger united israel. this woman should not be in our knesset.
56. 17
birdi ,   israel   (05.17.11)
nope, sorry, no can do. we need to face our problems here and now. its no use telling us what we should do, ''if'' bibi knows what we need to do, try supporting him instead of back-stabbing him. read post 13 please.
57. 19
birdi ,   israel & proud of it   (05.17.11)
thank you for your blessings. we are NOT going to fall in september. am Israel chai,
58. I said it
CC   (05.17.11)
and say it again. Kadima and Livni are traitors. Nothing else. Why is this concept so hard for middle Israelis to realize? She is a wretched traitor, just like her party.
59. THIS CONFLICT REVERTS BACK TO THE FIGHTING IN THE WOMB
GLENN ,   YUCAIPA,USA   (05.17.11)
BETWEEN JACOB(ISRAEL) AND ESAU(ARABS) IN REBEKKA'S WOMB IN GENESIS.ESAU(ARABS) GAVE-UP HIS BIRTHRIGHT AND JACOB(ISRAEL) RECIEVED THE BLESSING FROM YHVH AND WILL ALWAYS RULE THE MIDDLE EAST THROUGH JUDAH(JEWS).
60. Bibi is the world's only great leader
Emily ,   Seattle, WA   (05.19.11)
Does anyone realize that Mr. N is the world's only great statesman left? This man has it all! He has outsmarted the entire US contingent of State Dept. wizards by appealing to Congress, outclassed the president when he tried to diss him at dinner, gotten around the UN, pulled the wool over the 'Palestinians' eyes repeatedly in the piece process and now shown that he's a much better person than the lowlife Livni, who even in her country's direst moment of crisis cannot put down her childish self-concern for the common good! Bibi writes speeches and books that are brilliant and moving, he loves his country and if you don't like the way he does things, we'd LOVE to trade you!!
Previous talkbacks
Back to article