News
Protesters interrupt PM's AIPAC speech
Ynetnews
Published: 24.05.11, 07:06
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
57 Talkbacks for this article
31. How dare they ? ;) ,...
split ,   US   (05.24.11)
32.  6. Lenin was by no means a fool ! ,...
split ,   US   (05.24.11)
Obviously, Lenin had Jewish roots, how could he ? ,...
33. # 24
k ,   US   (05.24.11)
It is about appeasement The world is siding with the Palestinians because they want to end the Jewish question once and for all Once the Jews are done then that will take care of that problem People do not care about those other problems because it does not concern them Muslims kill innocent people in western countries when they do not get their way, that is why you see many western countries siding with the Palestinians Do not worry, not everyone will bow down to the Palestinians and their appeasers I strongly support Israel more then anything else in this world
34. #3, what courage did they show?
Danny   (05.24.11)
Now if they were protesting against Hamas in Gaza then they would be brave....
35. Did anyone not notice....
JOHN   (05.24.11)
Did anyone not notice that everything each protestor said was absolutely unoriginal; almost as if it were taken from some anti-Israel website and memorized. The naivety is absolutely incredible.
36. #6 , Jules. "The infant desease of the left" - Lenin.
tanya ,   tel aviv israel   (05.24.11)
37. To #8 We are occupying OUR land,it is
jason white ,   afula,israel   (05.24.11)
the arabs that are trespassing on our JEWISH land. We are not doomed, but you in eurabia are doomed to live as dhimimis under sharia law.
38. Young Jewish pro-Pal Protesters
tiki ,   belgium   (05.24.11)
Wouldn't we all like to have their worries, especially the people in Sderoth, the parents of Gilat Shalit, Israeli's who have to live many days/nights in bombshelters in Kiriat Shmona and other places and all those Israeli's who have lost 'loved ones by these murderers, calling themselves "Palestinians, who use their "brains only to upscale their killing methods of Israeli's/Jews. These are the people who have the sympathy of some ignorant Jewish Idiots, using their 'religion & background to make their point, but don't allow Israel to do the same.
39. Ynet reports on 5 protesters, forgets about Bibi
Rebecca ,   Modi'in   (05.24.11)
How long did this "protest" last? Apart from one small joke, how did Bibi and the audience handle it? Why does Ynet give these insignificant people a voice?
40. lol thought he said that to joke about the standing ovation
Ester   (05.24.11)
41. ONCE AGAIN, EREV RAV AT ITS FINEST
SETTHERECORDSTRAIGHT   (05.24.11)
42. Stupid Jews who have no idea what the reality in Israel is..
Frank ,   USA   (05.24.11)
and they don't care either.
43. To: No. 30
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (05.24.11)
Excuse me, is that how you define "courage?" Putting one's full name on the internet? Like you did? (Frankly, I call it stupid.)
44. To: No. 27
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (05.24.11)
What you think is entirely immaterial.
45. I say to the Apac protesters:
Vicky ,   Ashkelon Israel   (05.24.11)
With a surname like HESS one wonders authenticity of your forebears! A short tale. There was 2 villages one had been there for over 2,000 years, and the people although not perfect, lived a peaceful life, and even welcomed in stranges. Some of the strangers decided to set up their own village nearby. But that is only what they did. They did not tend the land, grow food or help people in need. instead they slammed their doors and were extremely discourteous to the other village and violated their woment and children. When Village 1 had enough they decided to do something about it. Village No.2 stood their own women and children in front of their own bows, slings and spears. Shouting false hoods of foul play. Village No. 1 would not fire on children or women so left Sodom to Gamorra which was destroyed by the hand of G-d. History repeats itself if you let it and we wont let it. We are here to stay, where we belong. you came with the hand of the British who had no right to give it to you. Go back to Egypt. Iran, Iraq and give us back our land which includes Jordan and Lebanon up to Tyre.
46. There are some Jews that support Bin Laden and
Moshe ,   Netanya   (05.24.11)
Al Quade. Their reasoning: killing Americans will bring down capitalism and the Bright socialism will come. Since colapse of the Soviet Union, that all they have now: Bin Laden (and Soros money)
47. Ignorance x 5 = this. JUDAISM mentions ZION 21 times/day
16 yr old murdered ,   Yellow school bus   (05.24.11)
in the daily prayers. This idiot quoting Judaism and then saying he has no ties there is like me talking about baseball statistics and saying they dont used bats in baseball! Moron. The rest dont even try to use anything Judaic, their ignorance wont allow them too. ignorant and ranting is no way to be Jewish. do they stand up for the 16 year old Jewish high school students who was rocketed to death in his yellow school bus? the genocide charter of hamas? any mentions? These people are the kapos of today inmho.
48. igal's point
gary ,   israel   (05.24.11)
excellent point -- is this my friend igal
49. Thank you Sarah B.
Jason Ph.D. ,   Charlotte, USA   (05.24.11)
You are a true defender of Israel and human dignity!
50. Inspiring
Gary Spedding ,   Bethlehem, Palestine   (05.24.11)
The protest of these five people is rather inspiring to say the least! It is good to know that Human Beings are standing up for the rights of other human beings in the world. Them being Jewish or not has little relevance really except for when I see hateful comments by people in this talk back about them because they are Jewish... The thing is that the Palestinian people are being occupied and oppressed and israel needs to be stopped, needs to be protested against. Netanyahu knows that in Gaza peaceful protestors were killed by long range snipers and tank shells.... In Bethlehem the christian community is being destroyed by israel and its policies. Israel is indefensible while it continues its path of destruction against the indigenous people. Palestinians are real they are human beings and nobody can change that fact. They also do have rights!
51. #3 - you mean "hope" for Jews becoming your dhimmis?
William ,   Israel   (05.24.11)
Not a chance, pal. As these protesters have shown, 1) they are adept as mimicking the mis-representations of facts and mis-placing victimhood. Calling your violent protests which happen on a weekly basis and cause much damage as "nonviolent protests for human rights" is a complete farce. Unless you consider (which "Palestinians" do) that terrorism, targeting civilians, and basic racist violence is a "human right". 2) they are married to an ideology that will not allow them to see beyond their own agenda. Hence, they are quick to mention the "demolition of Palestinian homes" and hardly mention how many are used in the act of violence or hiding smuggling tunnels, which negates their protection under Geneva Convention. There is no bravery is spreading falsehoods.
52. #8 - actually, under legal terms, it's not occupied
William ,   Israel   (05.24.11)
That is a term brought forth through the court of public opinion. Legally, based on the previous non-"Palestinian" sovereignty over the land, the terrorist violence that provided the impetus for entering the land by Israel and remaining there, and the act of Jordan giving up their claim on the land, allow the land to revert back to Israel until such time as they release it for a new State for the "Palestinians". UN resolution 242 also stipulated that the land was "disputed" and not occupied. Per Intl Law, "occupied" land must be claimed by a sovereign State and have been taken NOT as a result of defensive war actions. The Intl Community is trying to circumvent this legal obstruction by claiming the "Palestinians" are a unique population and treat them as a "State" in various institutions like the Olympics, where such rights are not afforded other unique groups like Kurds, Basques, or Tamils. If the world was listening, they would have heard loud and clear the intent of Hamas which lends to the argument of Israel on security in the face of constant Arab terrorism. Somehow, that part seems to always get missed by the "world", doesn't it?
53. #29 - probably, based on recent polls
William ,   Israel   (05.24.11)
which placed about 80% of Americans in support of Israel. So if you include children, immigrants who barely speak the language, and elderly who can't function well on their own - yeah, you can get about 55 million (a little less than 20% of the 300mm American population) to support "Palestinians". Maybe I'll see a YouTube video of a flash mob of dancing babies in a geriatric community outside DC.
54. #32 - I thought Lenin was father of Communism...
William ,   Israel   (05.24.11)
not anti-Zionism. So what was your point about his being Jewish?
55. Question
Jamal ,   London U.K.   (05.24.11)
If the Arab world is SO concerned about the Palestinian people, why don't they offer them a homeland themselves? Very simply, they don't want them either.
56. Netanyahu's "joking" comment to protestors
Keren ,   Arlington, VA - USA   (05.25.11)
Yes, indeed they do have these kinds of protests in Gaza - I can share pictures and testimonies to prove it.
57. Comment #9: "Protestors"
MRF ,   Cambridge, MA, USA   (05.26.11)
Abraham Nachmias attacks the people he disagrees with as not knowing anything about Judaism. I'm surprised, therefore, that someone [from Petach Tikva no less] isn't able to accurately cite Jewish sources. What he badly misquotes comes originally from the Talmud: Pirkei Avot [The Chapters of the Fathers] and actually says: "Shimon HaTzadik was from the remnant of the Men of the Great Assembly and he used to say: 'On three things the world stands: on Torah, Avodah [Service to G-d] , and Gemilut Chassadim [Acts of loving Kindliness]'." While "acts of kindness" has always been interpreted as the way we deal with other people - including "Am Yisrael," the *people* of Israel - there is nothing about *eretz Yisrael* [the "state" of Israel." Just an afterthought: reading the vitriol being spewed by many of your commenters I'm amazed at how little "gimilut chasidim" there is out here.
Previous talkbacks
Back to article